For the Fans Part 2 - A Poor Four Fic (Patreon)

I've made you wait long enough. Here it is, the much awaited, next installment of the poor four's foray into the polyverse. This is unedited/unbeta'd and could potentially suck but I'm praying it doesn't. If you haven't read part one I linked it below.

IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE IDEA OF ARSEN/EVER/LEVI/SHILOH PLEASE SKIP THIS AND DON'T GET MAD IN THE COMMENTS. ITS OKAY TO SKIP A STORY IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT.

You can find part one here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/for-fans-poor-143291075?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=postshare_creator&utm_content=join_link

Shiloh

The masks came off the moment the red light died, showing they were finally offline. For a moment, they all just sat there, none of them sure just what came next. Shiloh had a whole swarm of butterflies in his stomach and his cock was tenting his shorts. The room suddenly felt too warm, too small, thick with adrenaline and lingering tension. There was this…tension between the four. Not uncomfortable, just…anticipatory. 

They were standing at the edge of something that would change everything once they crossed it. Still, no matter what happened tonight, it was a long time coming.

Levi’s hands were all over him, but Shiloh gripped Ever’s hands tightly, making heavy eye contact, hoping they could read each other’s minds like they always did. Ever’s pupils looked blown wide, his lips kiss swollen and pink beneath the remnants of his gloss. Without hesitation, he surged forward, licking his way into Shiloh’s mouth in a way that made him dizzy. 

It was so different from Levi’s kisses.

Levi’s kisses were always hungry, forceful, a little violent in the best way. Ever kissed with a quiet desperation, little sounds of pleasure escaping. Every soft whine and shaky breath seemed to go straight to Shiloh’s cock. When Levi and Arsen tried to separate them, Ever made a noise of complaint and grabby hands as they parted.

“Let’s take this into the bedroom,” Levi said, tongue trailing over the shell of Shiloh’s sensitive ear. “Where we can all be more comfortable.”

The words alone sent another rush of heat through Shiloh’s body. Bedroom. Comfortable. Like this was actually happening.

Arsen picked Ever up, eliciting a squeal of delight as he hauled them in the direction of their bedroom. Ever immediately wrapped his legs around Arsen’s waist, laughing breathlessly as Arsen smacked a hand against his thigh possessively. 

They still lived over Jericho’s shop, but the house was more put together now. Less bachelor pad and more a home. Cozy, even. They had throw pillows and artwork, shadow boxes filled with photos of all of Ever’s firsts. They had been in the spare bedroom, their gaming room, but the primary bedroom was right across the hall, barely five steps. 

“You sure about this,” Levi asked, wrapping his arms around Shiloh’s waist. 

Shiloh looped his arms around Levi’s neck, letting himself become dead weight. “Do I seem unsure?” 

“No, but I like to check in,” Levi said, kissing his nose. 

“Are you sure about this?” Shiloh countered. 

Levi nodded. “I fantasized about Arsen so much as a teen, it feels surreal to actually cross that line with him now.” He locked eyes with Shiloh. “But you know I love you more than anyone in the world, right? That I’m attracted to you over everyone else?” 

Shiloh did know that but hearing it made his blood sing and his heart dance in his chest. Levi was a bit rough around the edges, but that just made his accidentally romantic sentiments all the more special. 

“I know,” Shiloh said, smacking several kisses on his lips. “I’m not afraid of losing you. I know you love me.” 

Some of the tension left Levi’s shoulders. “Good.” 

He lifted Shiloh up. He let his feet dangle, making him haul his dead weight into the next room until he tossed him down on Arsen and Ever’s bed unceremoniously. Ever giggled from his spot on the edge of the bed. Shiloh had laid in this bed hundreds of times. Their entire friend group had. But it felt different now. Heavier. It settled warmly in his gut. 

Ever had worked hard on their bedroom. It now had a pale green comforter with cream-colored sheets. Pillows shaped like succulents, gold mirrors, more pictures of Ever and Arsen, blown up and framed. There was mood lighting and ambience. 

It felt like home.

They didn’t bother turning on the overhead lights, just the soft LEDs that lined the ceiling and the leaf-shaped hanging lights that dangled above the bed. It made everything glow. Soft gold and pale green painted over bare skin, turning everyone warm and ethereal. It felt…otherworldly. Like whatever they did was happening outside of space and time.

Ever pulled Shiloh into a sitting position, turning towards him until they were and Shiloh sat on the knee to knee, holding each other’s hands. Neither of them let go, even when Arsen and Levi crowded in close behind them. Arsen sat behind Ever, his hands settling on Ever’s narrow hips. Levi did the same, his palms warm as they slipped beneath Shiloh’s loose shirt. The rough drag of Levi’s fingertips against his stomach made his breath catch.

“What do we do now?” Shiloh whispered, like they were standing in a sacred space.

“Depends on how far you’re willing to go,” Levi said. 

His voice had gone lower, roughened around the edges with restraint.

“All the way,” Ever and Shiloh blurted at the same time.

Levi and Arsen met each other’s gaze, then cracked up. The laughter broke the tension just enough to let Shiloh breathe again.

Levi shook his head. “‘All the way’ encompasses a lot.”

“What if we started off like we usually do and then just…see what happens,” Ever asked, sounding breathless at the prospect. 

Like he was trying very hard to sound casual about something he’d clearly imagined before.

“Usually do?” Arsen parroted.

Ever shifted, his fingers playing with Shiloh’s in his lap. He could feel how hard he was beneath him. Anytime a finger would brush against him, he’d gasp prettily, biting his lip like he wanted Shiloh to just wrap a hand around his aching cock and take care of him. 

The thought had Shiloh shifting restlessly. This time it was Ever who let a finger drag along the thin material of Shiloh’s shorts. He bit back a low whine, biting back the urge to buck up into the pressure. 

“Zane and Felix said that when the four of them first hooked up, Asa fucked Zane and Felix fucked Avi from behind so Zane and Felix could make out and grind on each other,” Ever explained.

Shiloh’s mouth went dry. The image hit him all at once, filthy and weirdly intimate, heat curling low in his stomach. “So the four of us have sex, but you and I can still touch each other?”

Ever shrugged. “If that’s something you’re comfortable with. It’s kind of a baby step when you think about it. Right?” 

His voice had gone softer now, eyes searching Shiloh’s face carefully despite all the excitement vibrating through him.

“I think my greedy mouse just wants to get fucked and play with his best friend at the same time. Isn’t that right, besonok?” 

Arsen’s mouth brushed Ever’s throat as he said it, teasing and possessive all at once.

Ever’s cheeks turned pink. “Is that so bad?”

The blush only made him look sweeter, more eager. and Shiloh understood why Arsen looked at him like he hung the moon.

Arsen and Levi exchanged glances. Shiloh watched the two somehow have a silent conversation, before Levi nodded. There was years of history in that look, old affection, trust and curiosity all tangled together.

“Of course not,” Arsen said. “I think its sexy when you tell me exactly what you want and how you want it.” 

“Are you okay with this?” Levi asked, checking in again just as he always did before they tried something new and a little risky.

For all of his recklessness, Levi was always very careful with Shiloh. 

He smiled. “More than okay. I mean, if you are. Exhibitionism is on our bucket list.” 

His pulse kicked harder just admitting it out loud. He wanted them to see. He wanted Arsen and Ever to know just how much Levi wanted him, how good he was to him, how generous. How sexy they looked together. Shiloh also wanted to watch. Was voyeurism on their bucket list? He couldn’t remember. If not, he’d add it. He wanted to watch his best friend get fucked, wanted to see his face contorted in pleasure, wanted to swallow the cries that Arsen fucked out of him. 

“How do we start?” Ever asked. “Do we just do our own thing and eventually just…meet in the middle?”

The way he said it made it sound less like sex and more like an adventure the four of them were about to take together.

“A few housekeeping issues first,” Levi said, pulling out his ‘responsible adult’ voice. “Condoms?”

“We’re both negative.” Arsen said. “We never use them but we have them…I think.”

“We got tested when we first started dating and we haven’t been with anyone else,” Shiloh said. “We don’t really use them anymore unless it’s, um, inconvenient to clean up afterwards.”

“If we’re not swapping, can’t we just do what we usually do?” He sounded adorably practical about the whole thing despite his blown pupils and heaving chest.

Arsen cleared his throat. “I think he’s trying to be practical. Things happen in the heat of the moment and it’s better to know our boundaries so we don’t make stupid mistakes.”

“I don’t have any boundaries,” Ever declared confidently.

“We know, besonok,” Arsen said around a grin. “We know.”

The pet name made warmth bloom across Ever’s face all over again. Little demon. Never had there been so fitting a nickname for his friend. 

Ever flushed to the tips of his ears, but giggled, scooting closer to Shiloh and taking his hands. Their knees pressed together, grounding each other through the nerves and excitement vibrating between all four of them.

Levi looked at Shiloh. “Anything off limits for you, fox?”

“No. As long as it won’t upset you,” Shiloh said, leaning back against Levi. 

His chest was warm and solid against his spine, his familiar scent calming some of the frantic energy buzzing through him.

“As long as whatever we do never extends past the four of us, I don’t have any restrictions.” Levi looked at Arsen. “You?”

Arsen shook his head. “Whatever Ever wants, Ever gets.”

The quiet certainty in his voice sent another rush of heat through the room.

Ever glanced at Shiloh. “Ever kind of wants you and Levi to finish what you started on the live,” he said, licking his lower lip.

Shiloh’s cock twitched at his words. The image hit him instantly, vivid enough to make his stomach tighten. “You want Levi on his knees for Arsen?”

Ever ran his teeth across his full bottom lip like he was savoring the thought, then nodded. 

He looked at Shiloh. “Don’t you?”

Shiloh thought about the way Levi had gone to his knees in front of Arsen, yanking his chair closer. The way he’d curled his tongue around the tight peak of his nipple. He imagined Levi peeling off Arsen’s jeans, taking him into his mouth, his hands tensing on Arsen’s muscular thighs while he choked on his cock. Arsen leaned back, hand fisted in Levi’s hair while he sucked his cock. 

Would Arsen be rough with him? Would he call him names? Would he coach him through it like Levi sometimes did for him? Ever said Arsen had taught Ever everything he knew about sex. He’d been so patient, far more patient than Ever himself. 

The fantasy burned through him so hard he almost squirmed.

“Yeah, definitely,” he said, unable to hide his excitement.

Arsen arched a brow at Levi. “I am fine with it. But you are the one on your knees for me so it will be up to you.”

Somehow Arsen’s Russian accent was a thousand times sexier in this moment. Low and rough around the edges, like sex had already started changing the sound of his voice.

Maybe it should have made Shiloh jealous. Levi blowing his best friend, who he’d had a crush on for years…but it really just made him impossibly horny. He wanted to watch, wanted to see Levi get to live out his fantasy. He wanted to touch Ever while they watched the men they loved touch each other.

The realization settled over him in a rush—there wasn’t an ounce of jealousy in him. Just affection and want and excitement for all of them.

Did that make him weird?

Shiloh nodded his head at Levi, letting him know that he would support whatever he decided.

“Yeah, okay. Let’s do it,” Levi said. 

His voice had gone thick with anticipation, his eyes already darkening as they flicked toward Arsen.

Ever jumped to his feet. “Okay, you sit here,” he said to Arsen, instructing him to sit on the side of the bed. He looked at Levi, pointing. “You, on your knees between his legs.”

The excitement vibrating through him was infectious, making Shiloh’s pulse jump even harder.

“Guess we found our director,” Levi said with a smirk.

“Does someone else want to take over?” Ever asked, sounding a little pouty.

Immediately, all three of them looked at him like the idea was ridiculous.

“No, besonok. This is your stage. Guide us how you like,” Arsen said.

The affection in his voice softened the command enough to make Ever beam.

Arsen leaned back on his palms, spreading his legs suggestively. The position made him look devastatingly confident, all broad shoulders and lazy dominance. Levi stood, walking the short distance to Arsen, before dropping to his knees before him. Levi wasn’t small, but something about him seemed to recognize Arsen’s authority, his body language growing submissive. 

The sight sent a sharp rush of heat straight through Shiloh’s body. He was questioning his whole life. Was it weird to want to see your boyfriend get railed by his best friend while he and his best friend watched? 

Ever clapped eagerly, bouncing on the balls of his feet, making the mattress rock. “You guys look so hot,” he all but squealed. “You should kiss.”

Shiloh’s heart accelerated dangerously, leaning in to get a better view without thought. The room suddenly felt electric, every breath and movement amplified.

Arsen curled his palm around Levi’s jaw, drawing him upwards as he leaned down. The first brush of their lips was timid, like they were testing the waters. Like neither of them quite believed this was real yet. After a beat, Arsen took charge of the kiss, sweeping his tongue into Levi’s mouth.

Shiloh throbbed at the low, throaty moan that escaped from his fiancé’s mouth. The sound hit him low in his stomach, intimate in a way that made his skin feel too tight. Their lips made a smacking sound each time they separated, then came together again. Slow at first, then increasingly desperate. 

Ever caught Shiloh’s gaze, then looked pointedly at Levi. Shiloh frowned in confusion. Ever stood, bypassing him to kneel behind Levi, nodding his head towards Arsen.

Shiloh nodded, moving to kneel behind Arsen, the bed sinking beneath his knees. He curled his hands over Arsen’s shoulders, watching him kiss Levi from a much more intimate vantage point. From this close he could see the way Levi’s fingers flexed against Arsen’s thighs, the way Arsen’s chest rose heavier with every kiss. 

When they broke apart, Levi kissed his way down Arsen’s muscular chest, once more curling his tongue around his nipple, tongue teasing the metal there before biting hard enough to make Arsen grunt.

The sound rumbled through Shiloh, rough and unmistakably pleased. 

Ever ran his hands across Levi’s bare back, fingers playing in his hair. His expression had gone dreamy, flushed with awe and arousal as he watched them together. He pressed kisses across Levi’s skin, keeping his eyes locked on Shiloh, like Levi and Arsen were the instruments they were playing, but the music was for them. 

Shiloh caught on, mirroring each of Ever’s movements. Arsen’s breath caught when Shiloh curled his tongue around the shell of his ear, then bit down enough to make him hiss. Ever’s hands slid around Levi’s torso, fingertips exploring the ridges of his abs. Shiloh mirrored the movement, cock throbbing at the warmth of the skin beneath his palms. 

Levi sat back enough to reach for Arsen’s button, tugging it roughly. Shiloh sucked in a sharp breath when he took in dark eyes and pupils blown wide with lust. Arsen lifted his hips, letting Levi drag his jeans down to his ankles, but not bothering to remove them. 

Arsen’s cock sprang free, flushed and wet at the tip. Ever whined at the sight. Shiloh ached to touch it. But it was Levi who licked his lips, who wrapped his palm around the warm flesh, who gave Shiloh one last look before leaning forward and dragging his tongue along the underside of his cock. 

All four of them moaned in unison, like they were all separate parts of the same organism. Shiloh teased Arsen’s nipples, tugging on the metal bars there. Arsen leaned back into his arms, eyelids fluttering. Shiloh scraped his teeth along his shoulder, then the side of his neck. 

Arsen’s hand floated towards Levi’s head, like he wanted to force his mouth down over his cock, but Ever’s hand got there first. Levi looked at the smaller boy, who nodded encouragingly, eyes darkened with a hunger Shiloh had never seen on his friend before. 

Ever pushed Levi’s mouth back towards his fiance’s straining cock and Levi gave up control, letting Ever guide his movements. Ever’s fingers knotted in Levi’s hair, making him take Arsen deep enough to gag. The sound shot straight through Shiloh. 

“Oh, fuck,” Arsen groaned, hips coming off the bed, forcing his cock deeper into his friends throat. 

Levi moaned, saliva dripping from the corners of his mouth as he acted like a cocksleeve under Ever’s complete control. 

Arsen’s hand that had lingered over Levi’s head, went backwards over his shoulder, cupping the back of Shiloh’s head. Arsen twisted, his mouth finding his in a sloppy off-center kiss that stole Shiloh’s breath and had him pressing his palm against his own aching cock. 

Arsen and Levi had a similar kissing style, raw and forceful, controlling. It had Shiloh whining into his mouth. The kiss broke as Arsen gasped, both of them looking down to see Levi and Ever kissing around the shaft of Arsen’s cock, their tongues tangling even as they licked over his warm skin. 

“Fuck, that’s so hot,” Shiloh whispered. 

“Feels amazing,” Arsen said, sounding like all thoughts had left the building. 

Shiloh’s fingers returned to teasing over Arsen’s piercings. His head fell back on Shiloh’s shoulder as Ever relented, letting Levi suck his cock how he wanted. His fiance closed his palm around his wet flesh, pumping him a few times, before he swallowed him down, gagging wetly. 

This time Arsen did fist both hands into Levi’s hair, not just guiding his movements, but fucking up into the wet heat of his mouth. Ever abandoned Levi, crawling onto the bed and pushing Shiloh onto his back, his mouth finding his as he pushed Shiloh’s shirt up, teasing his thumbs over his nipples. 

Shiloh moaned into Ever’s mouth, his hands closing over the mounds of Ever’s ass, legs spreading to let him get more comfortable. They both whined as their cocks slotted together through the thin material. Shiloh rocked up, pulling Ever down to grind against him. Ever’s lips went slack on his, another pretty whine leaving him. 

Shiloh licked into his open mouth, rolling them so Ever was beneath him. He hooked one of his legs over Shiloh’s elbow, before rutting against him once again. The sensation had him reeling, his skin both hot and cold, every nerve ending electrified. Ever wasn’t kissing him back, just rocking against him, a bit of saliva escaping the corner of his mouth as he let Shiloh use him to get them both off. 

Heat crept up his spine, that tingling sensation at the base of his spine, telling him he was close. They were both panting into each other’s mouths, Ever’s fingers biting into his upper arms, his little cries letting him know he wasn’t far from his own release. 

Then the friction disappeared, Levi hauling him off Shiloh, peeling his shirt over his head, then hooking his fingers into Shiloh’s waistband, dragging the fabric down to mid-thigh. 

“Lube,” Levi said, like a surgeon asking for a scalpel. 

He caught the tube as Arsen tossed it to him. Shiloh’s mouth went dry as he watched Arsen manhandle Ever out of his clothes, forcing him into a little spoon position before he pushed one of his legs up and out of the way. 

“You know the drill, besonok,” Arsen said, spanking him lightly. 

Ever’s bent leg shifted higher, his lower body twisting just enough for Arsen to slip two slick fingers between his cheeks. 

“I wanna see,” Shiloh whispered. 

Arsen looked at him, gaze falling to his straining cock, leaking like a faucet onto the mattress. “Yeah?” 

Shiloh nodded almost frantically. 

Arsen spread Ever lewdly, letting Shiloh watch as he pressed two thick fingers into his hole. His breath punched from him like he was the one getting penetrated. He bit his lower lip hard enough to taste blood. Levi’s fingers rubbed against his rim, the lube cool despite the heat of their skin. He didn’t push in, instead, circling the muscle, making like he was going to push inside, but pulling back again. 

“You love this, don’t you?” Levi murmured against his ear. “You love watching your best friend get his ass fingered. Such a dirty little slut. Both of you. Isn’t that right?” 

“Yes. Fuck, stop teasing. I’m so horny, I’m going to come the second you get your dick in me,” Shiloh panted, chest tight as he watched Ever fuck himself on Arsen’s fingers. 

“You’re awfully bossy,” Levi teased, his other hand coming around to stroke a single finger over the length of Shiloh’s aching length. 

He cried out, his cock jolting from the unexpected caress. Before he could recover, Levi pushed two fingers deep in one quick motion, dragging a moan from deep in Shiloh’s chest. 

“That better?” he taunted, his hand coming to wrap gently around Shiloh’s throat. “Is this enough to satisfy you?” 

“No. Want you,” Shiloh whispered. 

Levi’s fingers roughly thrust in and out, making him cry out every time they curled inside him. “You have me.” 

“Want your cock.” 

“Oh,” Levi said, dragging the word out like it was completely new information. 

He pulled his fingers free, gently pushing Shiloh onto his side beside Ever, who looked lost in pleasure, teary eyed and mouth slack. Arsen was mouthing at his neck, his jeans twisted around one ankle. Ever’s shirt was shoved up under his armpits, his shorts—like Shiloh’s—were sitting at his thighs. 

Shiloh pushed his shorts the rest of the way off, then grabbed Ever’s, removing them too. He wanted his legs free. Levi stood just long enough to rid himself of his clothes, then joined him on the bed, curling around him, his length resting in the cleft of his ass. 

Ever crawled closer, tangling their legs together so they were pressed together once more. Levi was dragging his lips over Shiloh’s thigh, the head of his cock now a blunt pressure against his rim. He wasn’t nearly prepped enough, but that only added to the thrill for him. Shiloh liked his pleasure, tinged with a bit of pain. 

He cried out the same time as Ever did, Levi sliding home in one rough thrust. Shiloh could barely catch his breath. Not only could he feel Levi filling him, he could see the way Arsen’s hips rolled rhythmically, knew every time he bottomed out by the way Ever’s wet cock, rubbed against his own, tiny little uh-uh-uh’s escaping. 

Ever’s mouth found his just as Levi and Arsen found a rhythm of their own, fucking into them in tandem until they were drowning in sensation. The feel of Levi drilling into him, Ever grinding against him until he was dizzy with his need to come. Ever’s soft tongue in his mouth, his needy whines, the way they clawed at each other while their men used them. 

When Shiloh looked at Arsen, it was clear, his gaze was locked on Levi behind him, a hungry look on his face. It was like Shiloh and Ever were simply proxies for Levi and Arsen finally getting to fuck like they wanted. Somehow that made it better. Arsen wanting Levi the way Shiloh knew Levi once wanted him, Arsen loving Levi the way Shiloh loved Ever. The four of them hopelessly intertwined forever. 

Ever gripped Shiloh’s thigh, pulling it over his hip, not only changing the angle of their dicks dragging over each other, but the of Levi’s cock, which now nailed Shiloh’s prostate with every thrust, pulling sounds from him that he had never made before. 

“I’m gonna come,” he warned. 

“Me, too,” Ever said, kissing him again, blunt nails digging into the meat of Shiloh’s ass, allowing Levi to get impossibly deep. 

Arsen made a low sound in the back of his throat, almost like a growl just as Ever cried out, wetness spilling over Shiloh’s cock. Watching Ever come sent Shiloh over too, his release joining Ever’s. 

“Fuck, did you just come?” Levi rasped. “I can feel you clenching on me. Fuck. Fuck.” 

“Yeah,” he panted, riding out the aftershocks of his pleasure. “He looked so pretty. Felt so good.” 

Levi ground his hips against him, driving deep before he came hard, his teeth sinking into Shiloh’s shoulder hard enough to leave a mark. 

For a while, none of them spoke. The air was thick with sweat and sex. 

The silence broke when Ever giggled, looking at Shiloh like it was Christmas morning. “I can’t believe we did that.” 

“Me either,” Shiloh said, grinning at him. 

“Did you like it, besonok?” Arsen asked, kissing his shoulder. 

Ever giggled once more, looking back over his shoulder. “Yeah, did you?” 

Arsen nodded, meeting Levi’s gaze over Shiloh’s shoulder. “You guys?” 

“I did,” Shiloh said. “It was amazing.” 

“Me, too,” Levi said. “It was…intense. Hot.” 

“Do you think we’ll do it again?” Ever asked. 

“Yes,” the other three answered at once, setting Ever into another giggling fit. 

When they fell into silence once more, Shiloh asked, “What do we do now?” 

Arsen laughed softly but shrugged. 

Shiloh grimaced as Levi slid free of his body, that familiar wetness running down his thigh. “I don’t know about you guys, but I’m starving.” 

Ever gasped. “Ooh, yes. Food. Let’s shower and go to the diner.” 

Arsen and Levi exchanged looks. 

“Sounds good to me,” Levi said.

Shiloh sat up on his elbow. “Should we invite the others?” 

“Might as well. They already know everything from the live. It’s going to be a whole new game when we see them again,” Levi said.

Arsen grinned. “Less Truth or Dare, more 20 Questions.” 

“Who wants the shower first?” 

“Me,” Ever and Shiloh said together, then laughed awkwardly. 

“Together?” Ever asked, an almost shy smile on his face. 

Shiloh looked up at Levi who shrugged. “Fine by me. Just don’t use up all the hot water.” 

Shiloh nodded, then got up, following Ever into the bathroom. Once the door was shut, Ever turned on him. “Well, that went even better than we anticipated.” 

Ever twisted the knob for the water, waiting for it to heat. 

Shiloh grinned. “Building our own polycule step one complete.” 

“Easy peasy,” Ever said. 

Shiloh laughed. “Easy peasy.”