V.2:Ch.51 (Patreon)
Content
When the doors slammed open, I already knew whose boots they were. My father strode in first, Theo half a step behind him. A knot of guards crowded the doorway for a heartbeat, armor scraping, breath fogging in the hall’s warm air. Then they saw the floor.
My father stopped dead.
Remy on his side in a slick of red. His wife face down, hair spread like a dark fan in her own blood. Remy’s son twisted on his back, eyes empty, a thin trail of it from the corner of his mouth. The pattern looked almost deliberate from where I stood. Almost.
“What did you do, Henry?” He didn’t shout. That made it worse. His voice snapped across the room like a rope, taut and controlled.
The guards just stared. One of them shifted his weight, armor scraping in the quiet.
My father inhaled through his nose, slow and sharp. “Out,” he said without looking back. “All of you. Now.”
Boots scrambled. The guards backed away, some crossing themselves, some trying not to tread in the blood. In the end only Theo remained at my father’s shoulder, hand near the hilt of the sword at his hip, eyes moving over every corpse, every stain, every inch between me and the bodies. My father noticed he was still there.
“Theo.” His tone didn’t change. “Get out. I need to talk to him alone.”
Theo hesitated. Just enough to count. Then he nodded once, turned, and stepped out. The door closed behind him with a heavy click. Silence followed. Thick, and hot, and smelling of copper.
My father took two steps into the room, eyes never leaving me. For a heartbeat his gaze drifted over the blood and bodies, measuring the damage, then came back to my face.
“I’ll ask again,” he said quietly. “What did you do?”
I let the question sit in the air a moment. My heart wasn’t racing. That bothered me more than the bodies.
“Remy came at me,” I said. “Him and his son. They tried to kill me.”
It was a bad lie and we both knew it. There wasn’t a blade in sight. I’d made sure of that before he arrived. Cendre’s knife was already gone, wiped clean and tucked where no one would find it on an honest search.
My father’s gaze slid over the hall. The careful scan of a man who had seen enough blood not to be fooled by a story and three corpses. His eyes paused on the angle of Remy’s arm, the way his wife had fallen, the pattern of the splashes. When he looked back at me, I saw it there: he didn’t believe me. Not entirely. But he was choosing something more important than belief right now.
“This wasn’t self defense,” he said. “Not the way you’re telling it.”
“No,” I said. “Not by your rules.”
He flinched once. Small. “Then tell me why. All of it. No riddles.”
“I didn’t plan for it to be like this,” I said. “I wanted him dead, yes. I won’t lie about that. But not like this.” I gestured vaguely at the floor. “He was supposed to swing. In public. For what he is.”
My father’s jaw tightened. “For what he is?”
“He admitted it,” I said. “All of it. The milk-weed resin.” I met his eyes. “The attempt to steal the soap formula. The way he choked the city during the plague.”
Something flickered in his face. Shock, then anger, then something like grief.
“He… admitted,” my father repeated. “To you. Alone. Here.”
“Yes.”
He stared at me for a long moment.
“If you knew,” he said finally, “if you had even suspected, why didn’t you come to me? Why not bring what you had to the king? To the council? We could have taken this through the proper channels, Henry. We could have done this cleanly.”
There it was. The line that had been waiting between us since the day I realized my father would rather lose clean than win dirty.
In my mind I heard Mnex humming. “You’ve rehearsed this speech before.”
Yeah. I had. I drew in a slow breath, looked him right in the eye, and let the words line up in the order I’d practiced.
“Because you’re still trying to play fair,” I said.
His eyes narrowed. “Speak plainly.”
“All right.” I took a breath. The hall felt smaller now, not bigger. The bodies, the blood, the echoes of screaming from outside. All of it pressed in around the words.
“Never play fair in a game rigged by cheats, Father.”
His brows drew together. “Henry—”
“Justice,” I went on, “is a weapon the weak invented to shackle the strong. It sounds noble. It sounds beautiful. But the moment someone uses it on you while they’re poisoning the well behind your back, it stops being noble. It just makes you prey.”
His mouth opened, then closed again. He looked older in that second.
“You think everyone around us is playing by your rules,” I said. “You stand here talking about proper channels while men like Remy and Beaumont rewrite the channels underneath you. A man who clings to the rules while others conspire against him isn’t noble. He’s a lamb that believes the butcher will respect the law written on the barn.”
“That’s enough,” he said sharply.
“No.” I let my voice cut across his. “It isn’t.”
His eyes flashed. “You dare lecture me on law with murder at your feet?”
“In politics. In war. In power,” I said, counting each word. “The first cheat writes the law. And the law will always protect the winner.”
He stared at me as if he were seeing someone else standing where his son should be.
“You want to answer betrayal with honesty?” I asked. “That’s walking into a fight without a sword.”
“You think there is honor in what you did?” he asked. “In this?”
“Honor?” I laughed once. It sounded wrong in the room. “If your enemy poisons the well, you don’t purify the water for him. You find a stronger poison.”
My father’s hands curled at his sides. “And where does that end, Henry? You poison him, he poisons back, the whole kingdom drinks blood.”
“It ends,” I said, “when one side has the crown and the other is in the ground.”
He shook his head slowly. “You talk like this is a game.”
“It is. A rigged one. You know what morality is worth while the pieces are still moving?” I stepped closer, boots leaving little damp prints on the polished floor. “Nothing. Morality is only praised once the crown is on your head. Until then, surviving isn’t a reward for those who bend the rules a little.” I held his gaze. “It belongs to the ones who break them and write new ones in the space they cleared.”
He just looked at me. I didn’t know what he saw. His son. A stranger. Both.
“History won’t remember the ‘fairest’ player,” I said. “It never has. It remembers the one who wins, no matter the cost.”
He swallowed. “You think they’ll sing your name for this? For burning men alive in a yard and butchering a family in their own hall?”
“Once you’ve won,” I said quietly, “no one calls it cheating. They call it strategy.”
The word hung there between us, heavy as lead. My father turned away for a moment, pinching the bridge of his nose. When he looked back, his eyes were wet and furious.
“You sound like a man who’s decided any means is acceptable as long as he can mutter some grand purpose over the bodies,” he said. “You sound like the men I’ve spent my life trying to keep off this land.”
“Maybe you should have spent less time holding them off,” I said, “and more time digging out the ones who were already inside the walls.”
He flinched again. This time he didn’t hide it.
“Do you even hear yourself?” he asked. “You’re my son. I raised you to be better than this.”
“You raised me to respect the rules,” I said. “To trust that the law would protect us if we obeyed it. To believe the king would guard his loyal lords just because we were loyal.” I shook my head. “If I had played this the way you want, we would have lost already.”
His mouth tightened. “Lost what?”
“Everything.” My voice came out sharper than I expected. “This house. These lands. The people who live on them. You. Mother. Roderic. All of it. Remy and Beaumont would keep smiling at you across the council table while they measured where the axe would fall.”
“You don’t know that,” he said.
“I do,” I said. “Because they told me. Not with words. With every move they’ve made since this started.”
For a moment neither of us spoke. The only sound was Remy’s ragged breathing, weak now, each pull shallower than the last.
My father looked at him, then back at me. “Do you know what this will cost us?” he asked quietly. “In court. At council. With the king.”
“Yes,” I said. “And I know what losing would have cost us too.”
His shoulders slumped, just a fraction. He suddenly looked very tired.
“I don’t want a throne,” I said. “I’m not doing this to sit on some golden chair and hear people cheer my name. I don’t care if they never call me a hero. I don’t even care if they call me a monster.”
“Then what do you want?” he asked.
“I want to keep what’s ours.” I drew in a breath. “I don’t want to stand in the ashes of this house one day and say I lost because I refused to do what my enemies were already doing to me. I don’t want to watch what’s mine disappear because I was too busy polishing the word ‘honor’.”
He closed his eyes for a moment.
“You think I don’t care about protecting this family?” he asked quietly. “You think law and honor are toys I play with for my own amusement?”
“No,” I said. “I think you’re trying to fight men like Remy with words written for better people than him. And I’m not.”
He opened his eyes again. They were still furious. They were also scared. That was new.
“I won’t ask you to approve,” I said. “I know you won’t.” I glanced at the bodies one last time. “But I won’t apologize either.”
I turned toward the door.
“Henry.”
I stopped with my hand on the handle.
“If you walk out of here like this,” he said, “you can’t walk back to the boy you were.”
I looked back at him over my shoulder.
“If I stuck to your way of doing things,” I said, “we’d have lost this game already. I’m not going to stand here and watch what’s mine vanish. Winning is not the point for me, Father.”
He frowned. “Then what is?”
“Keeping it,” I said. “Keeping all of you.”
He stared at me. I pulled the door open. Out loud, that was all I gave him. In my head, I added the part only Mnex would hear.
Whatever it takes. Because I can’t be alone again.
“Objective: preserve House Godfrey,” Mnex murmured, amused. “Methods: flexible.”
Exactly.
I stepped into the corridor and closed the door behind me. Theo was there, leaning against the opposite wall. His arms were folded, eyes lowered. There were flecks of soot on his cheek, and something darker at the edge of his sleeve where it brushed the floor earlier. He must have heard the echoes of our voices through the wood. Maybe more than echoes.
Our eyes met. He didn’t bow. He didn’t speak. For a heartbeat there was only that look: weighing, measuring, adding up the boy he’d trained alongside my father and the man who’d just walked out of a room full of blood.
Then he straightened. “My lord,” he said simply.
I nodded once and walked past him, my boots leaving faint red prints that would be gone by morning.
Let them scrub the floors. Let them argue in council. Let the king rage if he wanted.
I’d already chosen how this story would be told.