Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

MOVIE REACTION POLL

  • Miller's Crossing (1990) 41
  • The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948) 41
  • Fallen (1998) 26
  • Promising Young Woman (2020) 25
  • Broadcast News (1987) 34
  • The Philadelphia Story (1940) 29
  • The Sting (1973) 34
  • Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) 39
  • Roman Holiday (1953) 28
  • Unforgiven (1992) 76
  • 2023-07-11
  • 373 votes
{'title': 'MOVIE REACTION POLL', 'choices': [{'text': "Miller's Crossing (1990)", 'votes': 41}, {'text': 'The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948)', 'votes': 41}, {'text': 'Fallen (1998)', 'votes': 26}, {'text': 'Promising Young Woman (2020)', 'votes': 25}, {'text': 'Broadcast News (1987)', 'votes': 34}, {'text': 'The Philadelphia Story (1940)', 'votes': 29}, {'text': 'The Sting (1973)', 'votes': 34}, {'text': 'Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969)', 'votes': 39}, {'text': 'Roman Holiday (1953)', 'votes': 28}, {'text': 'Unforgiven (1992)', 'votes': 76}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 7, 11, 4, 37, 51, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 373}

Content

"Great Screen Writing"

Vote on what I should watch and react to next! This Poll will end most likely Thursday Morning and I'll choose the TOP 2 to react to Thursday and Friday.

No worries, I plan on actually prolonging these recommendations so don't trip if you don't see your selection on here first!

Comments

Robert Moore

A good selection. Can’t lose.

Patrick Littlejohn

This is a hard one, but sticking with the treasure of the Sierra madre and the sting

Matt

Another great list of amazing films, I have to vote for the classic Roman Holiday one of my favorite movies of all time

Allie Lemos

The Apartment just got it and now hopefully Roman Holiday.

Keegan Duffy

The sting and Unforgiven 👌🏼

Jon Beck

These are all great movies. And there are so many more that I think a lot of people would consider great screenwriting movies, perhaps even more so than what is on this list. That's not a bad thing. So many good films, so little time. But what exactly is a good "screenplay"? I enjoy listening to your thoughts on the subject, and am glad you chose that topic, because there really is no perfect answer, and it's a complex subject. For me it's about films that are dialogue heavy. I think of Glengarry Glen Ross for example, It's kind of like a two-part play on film featuring, among other big names, Jack Lemmon who you saw in The Apartment. That's an example of a great screenwriting film to me. But others will value different characteristics. I didn't intend this post to be a pitch for that particular movie but I guess it ended up that way. hah! Keep up the good work James.

J. Arlo Mullinix

I will be shocked if Unforgiven doesn't win. One of my top 5 favorite movies and I have written papers on the writing of that movie. I could write a mutli-thousand word analysis on the character of William Munny alone. Unforgiven may be the single most important influence on my writing of any movie/tv series I have seen or book I have read. I have been obsessed with the character of William Munny and the structure of his character arc since I first saw the movie at twelve years old. It is a masterclass of subversion, character and world building and narrative structure. A lot of movies these days try to 'subvert expectations' but they have no idea what they are doing and only end up screwing up their own narrative. This screenplay comes from a time when Hollywood writers actually took the craft seriously and didn't just see it as an avenue to indulge their narcissism. It is impossible to express how much I love this movie.

john francis

you keep posting Broadcast News, and im gunna keep voting for Broadcast News ha ha

Jon Beck

I have seen Unforgiven one time when it released and loved it but you have lit a fire under me to watch it again!

Cooley

You might as well start watching Unforgiven right now.

Tetley

Miller's and Treasure for me. Rinse and repeat.

DinChild

For a second I got excited to watch the Tom Hanks, Denzel Washington movie, 'Philadelphia.' Perhaps, with the name, we'll get there.

Tetley

We all go off-piste and try to smuggle a movie pitch in from time to time. Glengarry Glen Ross is worthy.

JL Green

All the listed movies are 5 star. I think The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre is the best choice this week.

Kaitlin

Let’s go Roman Holiday!!!

Linda

Broadcast News is the best example of great screenwriting. Sorry, not sorry.

Jon Bradley

Fallen, Broadcast News, The Sting, Unforgiven lead my list from those above ... Butch Cassidy and then Sierra Madre follow it Consider 3 of my first 4 won Academy Awards while both The Sting and Unforgiven grabbed Best Picture and Screenplay wins while Butch Cassidy and Sierra Madre won Oscars for their screenplays

kevin coleman

bring Aguirre back to the polls!

MsKofi

The Philadelphia Story.... personal favorite

Kaitlin

Only 15 people are seeing the light of Heaven for voting for Roman Holiday. Audrey Hepburn and Gregory Peck don’t deserve this!

Cody

Haven't seen or don't like?

Cody

Well to each their own. but minus a couple of exceptions I'm looking at a poll of all-timers

Jessi

Yeah, not my bag this week, so I won't vote to leave it open to those who feel strongly about any of these!

Armchair Rizzard

Unforgive is good and all but its been watched a lot by other reactors. I'm hoping the Sting wins.

RICHARD

Come on peeps, let's get Miller's Crossing a win this week!

Michael Proch

I’d like to throw a name in the ring here and suggest you watch Beau Is Afraid now that it’s available to rent!

kenneth franklin

I just signed up for 10 dollars a month. I don't know how to access breaking bad season 4 episode 13. You tube goes as far as 12.

Yours truly, Johnny Dollar

I would just recommend searching the James vs cinema posts. You will find weekly posts with the YouTube cuts and the unedited reaction on Vimeo. Everything except maybe some of James' first reactions should be there.

Jasmin Holmes

How would I know if I didn’t like it if I didn’t watch?

Jasmin Holmes

I’d have to watch it first to decide if I like it or not

Cody

Just some miscommunication I guess. That's how I took it too - that you didn't like them (vs having not seen them)

MorkBork

On James' Patreon Home page close to the top under Latest posts, you should be able to filter by Breaking Bad which should make things a bit easier.

Bert Taverner

Kinda wish it was Sierra Madre pulling out for the silver instead of Miller's Crossing, but I ain't mad at it. Lotta heat on this poll

Pit Community

Hi James! I wasn't sure where to put this so I'll put it here. It would be absolutely amazing to see you react to the Star Wars show "Andor." Andor is in my humble opinion the best Star Wars in decades, so it would be wonderful to gain your insights while watching it.

Juley

I’m still hanging in there for Broadcast News. Terrific movie, great performances, wonderful writing!

Eli

Would love to see Motorcycle Diaries sometime - beautiful film, great landscapes. Makes you long for the road; a simple life and arduous struggle

Tetley

Top to bottom American movies in the poll. Not necessarily a bad thing at all, but any chance we can get some Aussie representation next round James? Just to mix things up. Animal Kingdom (2010) is well written.

Michael Proch

Picnic at Hanging Rock would be amazing to get on the poll

Chris Martin

Need to ad Prey (2022) to the list! 6 Emmy nominations this year! The latest Predator movie!

David Jacobs

Where’s Bullitt? Greatest car chase movie of them all.