Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

LUKE: The best ones will be read out on the WrestleTalk Podcast

Comments

Pat the booker

Every match seemed like just as it was in gear 3 it ended abruptly and needed another 5-10 minutes

Gavin Kashiwabara

As said on Worst Match Ever, "Well what did you expect" sums up the whole night it feels like

Swerve

1hr and 24 minutes of wrestling on a 4hr show. Gotta rush to the ads and the celebrities that no one knows.

Stevy Martin

Trying not to be negative for the sake of it - but it felt like matches were rushed to shove adverts for a Hogan documentary over and over.

Bryan Grieme

You guys are the only reason I had wrestlemania on my tv the whole night. I just would watched the nascar o’reilly race instead. Great stream crappy show

griffin martin

i absolutely LOVED the main event! i felt cody finally letting his dark side out and going full heel was a great story! however the post match really confused me and now i don’t know where they are going

Apesh 07

Fuckin Wrestlemania season 🍻

LP

Didn’t expect much, and still left feeling underwhelmed, all matches especially the women’s were way way to short

Yagrammy Lemons

Felt like an episode of raw or smackdown, just downright bad, 4/10

Dev King

That show was a decent smackdown before mania, cant wait for the ONLY night of WrestleMania Sunday

Harshdeep Singh

A decent go-home show for Wrestlemania 42 eh😇

Brxdley.h

The build has been trash but as I always do, I got excited because it’s mania. This wasn’t a wrestlemania … apart from Paige’s return and the Seth vs Gunther match, this is one of the worst wrestlemanias. Short matches, a boring match with cody being pushed once again, women getting no time, and it just being a glorified Hulk Hogan documentary with wrestling intervals… honestly night 2 has a big task to make this mania better…

Harry Jackson

If I see one more fucking Hulk Hogan advert I’m going to lose my mind 🤣

TheDerpiestofDerps

That might be the messiest ending to a night of wrestlemania since the Women's 3-way. It really felt like the booking was all over the place about what they wanted to do and now everyone looks worse from whatever that clusterfuck came out to be.

Mohammed Albanai

Overall a fine night one, not great, not bad, just fine. My main complaint is the short matches, every single match felt like it needed another 5 min

Vault-Tec Doormamu

Too little wrestling and too much hulk hogan documentary, but at least when we got wrestling it was decent. No idea what Cody does next. So glad to have Paige back. Hopefully this run goes better than the last.

Blake Whitehouse

I actually fell asleep during the main event. That tells me everything I need to know about how boring the Post-Mania lull is going to be.

Amomantra94

I think the show can be summed up eloquently in four words. Trouble trouble… That’s Mania

Justin

Matches were too short. I felt like I there was no story to them, just a sprint to the finish. Way too many ad's as well.

Brxdley.h

i made a joke in the live chat that it would be a 10/10 but for oli to review this mania as a 4/10… but 4/10 is way too high ://

Pedro Hodges

Bloody livid that my Hulk Hogan documentary kept getting interrupted for something called 'Wrestlemania'

Ezra Mitchell

seth vs gunther and paige return gave me rose colored glasses that kinda made me think the show was better than it was until i really thought about it as a whole. overall like a 4/10.

Ryan

Just soulless seemingly from beginning to end. Hulk hogan getting the most screen time of any wrestler during the whole show, abrupt match finishes throughout the show and spots being repeated across the card. Pat McAfee ‘payoff’ was poor and a main event with more turns than I can count. My 16th Wrestlemania watching live and understand recency bias may be a thing. But right now feels the worst overall show let alone a Wrestlemania I’ve watched live.

David Daul

This was as much of a meh show as I've ever seen! I was jumping off my couch a few years ago for Mania 40 to being so disconnected this year. Thankful to have you guys to watch with at least

Cory Graham

This was a two match show for me. Gunther vs Seth I loved. Stephanie vs liv I liked as well. The rest was either ok. Pre show or ended before going to the final level.

Isaac Glover

Unfortunately but predictably lackluster, I’m a Cody guy so I was happily surprised but confused at the post match stuff. Weird show all around for me lol

KayfabeKyle

On the basis of night 1, I'm dreading night 2, Oba/Brock is over after 1 finisher, the ladder match is going 5 mins and Punk/Roman is ending in a count out finish, I feel sorry for the wrestlers, Triple H / Creative and more importantly the fans, TKO have sucked the life out of WWE .

Callan Walker

Just glad I didn’t have to take work off for this show, absolutely rubbish

Dev King

The best part of Wrestlemania was your stream

Lucas P.

After night 1, my interest in WWE hinges on whether Oba beats Brock, and whether Trick has a good showing. I fell out of wrestling in 2018 and picked it back up at mania 38 but this is genuinely getting to be my last straw moment after such a bad year. I’m so close to just buying tickets to Double or Nothing and letting that be my starting point of AEW fandom

Wheels

I understand that they are probably going to do a second match between Randy and Cody but I thought it was a strange choice to go off the air with Randy standing tall after losing. Do you think they are risking more people starting to boo Cody if they continue this feud

Brody Allsep

Didn't watch the show (maybe later on Netflix, and at least will watch your live reactions) and I am so glad for it. Just read results and saw stats. Mania in Vegas can only be done for casuals, huh?

Alex Christopher

Night one one straight garbage. Something like 85 minutes of wrestling on a 4 hour show. WrestleMania??? Nahh. More like AdvertMania.

Matt Eager

the fact that they kept highlighting the word “polarizing” all night was definitely not by accident

James Ford

I honestly don’t know what to make of this show, Gunther/Rollins was great and easily match of the night, but the rest of the matches were far too short and if you’re having Randy stand tall at the end, have him win the title. Night 2 will hopefully be better

Zack

The sun was still up in Vegas when the show was over but that crowd was so dead for that main event….there were moments where you could hear a pin drop. A lackluster ending with a confusing finish. Why have McAfee be with Orton and do this all-in build just to have RKO him in the match AND lose. TKO now means Terrible Karma Outbreak, you give shit….you get shit.

David Daul

Exactly...they at least had some intensity

Jaws 24

It was a decent mania so far, hopefully night 2 will be much better. Please god let it be good. Anyway at least cody has a better main event than last year mania.

Jacob Dickens

Hoo boy, a show that felt fairly inoffensive as I watched it, but kept getting worse in my memory the more I think about it. Simply put, an hour and a half of wrestling on a four hour show is criminal. Add to that the expectations placed on some of these matches and you can’t help but feel underwhelmed. Liv/Steph were given no time to work, Drew/Jacob had such a “safe” Unsanctioned match and Randy/Cody wasn’t even entertaining in a bad way. Genuinely the best parts of the show were Bianca announcing her pregnancy and Gunther/Seth. Overall, it was a show that wasn’t egregiously bad at any point, but the sub-par to average nature of everything on the show makes it feel pretty bad as a whole.

Monty Pittman

I'm not mad at Wrestlemania I'm just disappointed. It was like they got their money now so go half speed so we can get more of it in 4 weeks

everything.notshell

Loved the Paige return for my inner child but felt like a huge kick in the gut for the other girls who have put in the grind each week…

DeadBadger

It made me sad. Corporate enshittification at its finest. What 90 minutes of matches, one video promo, I thought these live events were supposed to be premium.

Stefan Lowe

The entire first night seemed to fly by at maximum speed. Matches did not seem like they were presented or wrestled in a big wrestlemania feel. It felt like a regular night of Raw or an average B-show PPV. The main event was an absolute stinker of a match. Literally had Randy wearing the same color and style of gear he did for the horrible Mania 25 main event which I guess made sense because this match was just as bad as that one except we didn’t get an all time great match before like Undertaker and Shawn Michaels, instead we got the inevitable Liv Morgan championship crowning that will lead to judgement day strife in about 2043 if Triple H has his way. Also the “double turn” if that’s what they were truly going for made sense when Randy was bleeding in a way to give him that same appeal of Stone Cold Steve Austin from the Mania 13 double turn. Having you guys on my phone doing the live reaction was leagues better than the first night. Also they keep doing my girl Alexa Bliss dirty by making her eat damn near every pin in every loss. RUBBISH

Brody Allsep

Most results I expected, aside from Cody and hoping Stephanie would win, but apparently they just had her be Stephanie Vacant until they could get the championship back to Liv. Stephanie Vacquer, NXT Double Champion just over a year ago, loses the world title to Liv Morgan in less time than Pat McAfee's entrance.

Alberto Camargo

call me a wrestling casual, or a mark, but in 27 years of life i’ve never watched another promotion. i’ve lapsed and come back several times, but it was always WWE. i consume AEW through podcasts like yours and social clips. but over time i’ve been grinded down to the point of not watching AEW out of stubbornness for being a WWE guy. tonight grinded me down further, and when i saw fucking jelly roll hit an elbow during the main event, i genuinely thought “can’t watch to watch dynamite on wednesday”

Isaac hansel

Well that show sucked. The fact that they didn’t have breaker vs Rollins is criminal behavior. It will be interesting to see the contrast of night 1 and 2 once it’s over. As of right now it feels like AEW has done far more interesting tv/ppv this week than wwe has done.

Jamaal Ellison

People were waiting years to see Cody Vs Randy and once and creative has shit the bed it's so funny that people have paid a college tuition for THIS!!!

Wyatt Ready

It felt like I was watching a Saturday night’s main event where nothing mattered with a couple cool moments but 90 minutes of wrestling on a four hour show is inexcusable

Gabi Vazquez

i fear i watch too much wrestling cause when cena hugged bianca i was half expecting the camera to cut to cenas deadpan face and they would have elimination chamber 2025 part 2

Joseph Krusoczky

What an absolute B show. Paige’s return and Bianca’s pregnancy announcement were legit the only highlights.

Tifa Simp

I’ve seen bad manias, I’ve seen manias that have been brought down by one or two matches, but I never thought I would see a mania the company itself just didn’t care about

PineJohn

Not the worst mania I've watched, but definitely the most boring, specially with as little actual wrestling in it

Sage

That was the first ple to have over 4 matches since crown jewel in october 11… 189 days ago.

Vectron44

A really listless Day One. Just hope they're giving Hogan the health spa next week after making him do 7 advertising promos...

Alex Anderson

3/10 Almost all of it was mediocre at best. The matches were short, underwhelming and predictable. Overall just a boring show.

Mr. Grimes

I'd consider this one of the worst Wrestlemanias of all time (Night 1 atleast). Opener was nothing. Fatu vs McIntyre didn't go as far as it should've. Paige's return clearly meant a lot to her, but I'm not excited to see her and Brie as the tag champions. Becky vs AJ was fine, nothing more. Vaquer vs Morgan was dogshit. Rhodes vs Orton was steaming dogshit. Rollins vs Gunther was good maybe even great, but I'm afraid it might be perceived as better than it actually was because everything else in Night 1 felt so formulaic and underwhelming considering it's Wrestlemania. Where's the love? Why does it seem like no one cared? Why did I have low expectations but still walk away disappointed? Hopefully Night 2 is better, I guess it's about how you leave them.

Jamaal Ellison

The folks at Lucasfilm and the creative team at WWE have pretty much the same hit-or-miss track record.

HashtagSideburn

Truly shocked by how short these matches were. Such a disservice to the wrestlers who work their tails off just to be given a basic middle of Raw/Smackdown match layout. Fully expect tomorrow to be more of the same. I'll kiss your ass if Rhea and Jade go longer than 5 minutes after seeing this.

Sage

I don’t see myself ever going back to watch any of these matches, so it cannot be a good wrestlemania… almost all of the right winners (Cody should’ve lost) but 0 time to tell any stories. But hey, at least Paige is back.

Murray Wrestling PT

Legitimately I was pleasantly surprised at how good Wrestlemania Saturday night (aka night 1) was but I also started it late on purpose so I could skip commercials 😇

Paul (The King)

Opener ok, Fatu/Drew was good, women's tag match was meh but I am made up Paige has returned 😍 (i assume Nia & Lash were doing a crap White Chicks cosplay?) Becky/Aj was ok but why did the referee not (like every other referee) go down for a long time when they were hit in the corner? Gunther/Seth I thought was pretty decent & I was happy to see Bron refurn, Liv/Stephanie was meh in my opinion - livs entrance was awful, the match was pretty poor & the fact that it took two interference means that it doesn't make Liv look good .... and the main event was 😡😡 awful!! None of it made any sense, did the shenanigan spots before the match and still the match was dire, Randy then RKO'S the referee which is whatever & then Pat turns up again fine in a ref's shirt and gets an rko too ... Cody wins lol 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

Inexplicable Shorts

Was at the show. Absolutely electric atmosphere. Particularly when Paige came out. Spoilers be damned, the place was loud. I even got a little emotional. PS: Ran into a rude woman who said she hated my AJ Lee shirt on the way out. It was Becky Lynch.

Untrusted 0ne

That main event was confusing. It really felt like they were setting something up for maybe like a surprise interference with the ref bump, the McAfee coming in as a ref (With the wrong ref shirt by the way) to make a count didn't make any sense. Underwhelming overall Paige here! Glad to see her back but I'm not sure about the direction they are going. Maybe Nikki tricks her into taking the title and then betrays her and set up a Paige and Aj vs the Bella's.

Threads of Dragons

As I said in the comment on the show. This was a RAW that somehow managed to provide more ads than usual. Bad build, bad matches that weren't allowed to get beyond second gear. Also, if Cody is holding the title going into next year do not have a veteran turn heel on him in the last stretch of the Mania build. It has failed two years in a row.

Noah Fortner

I rejoined Patreon just so I can hear you lads talking shit about the ppv and not actually watch it myself and it did not disappoint! So glad to be a Patreon again

Julian Barragan

WWE put a ton of effort to make sure the best show of the week happened on wednesday, at least as of sat night.

Harry Jackson

Mixed emotions with it as a whole. The women’s matches were too short, riddled with adverts and no back stage stuff. The actual wrestling as a whole was good, I thought Seth and Gunther stole the show as expected. Cody vs Randy was a very slow burner but got going towards the end. Feel for Cody tho, two years running he’s had his storyline AND main event match fucked with by a daft celebrity appearance

Matt

2/5 Thankfully we got those injuries because Pages return was moment of the night thanks to Nikki's injurie and Seth vs Gunther was match of the night thanks to Breakker's injurie, if that moment and that match wasn't on this night it would have been a 1 star show

theTimeLord97

You mean Adlemania Night 1. It was disappointing. Too many damn ads not enough wrestling. It felt like an avenge weekly episode of Raw. WrestleMania should feel like the biggest show of the year, but it doesn't anymore. No backstage promos, or even special legends moments in the back or in the ring. Hopefully Night 2 is better, cause what's the point of watching anymore. 2nd year in a row where the Vegas crowd has sucked. No more Mania at Vegas.

Sedin Magic15

I missed night one, was busy, and didn't really miss it at all

DevanDumbStuff

I'm usually one to see the best in a show. I don't like focusing on the down spots as a benefit to the actual wrestlers and wrestling on the show. Unfortunately, this genuinely feels like the culmination of every bad tendency that WWE has built up over the past year+. More ads than wrestling, short matches, women being particularly shafted, any match that did have hype/build was a massive let down. Whether you want to blame HHH or TKO, nobody can deny the downward spiral in quality. Here's hoping night 2 is better but it's not looking good.

Faheem_786

The matches all felt rushed except the main event. I think they prioritised fitting as many ads on this show as possible. It's like they aren't even trying to entertain people anymore. Night 2 has to be insane to make up for this clusterfuck of a show.

Handsome Kian

Seth vs Gunther is exactly what the tribal wwe accounts accuse every AEW match of being. Well performed but next to zero in storytelling and Seth basically didn’t sell a thing. Two power bombs back to back on the outside and Seth just stands up and reverses and goes into his finisher without selling it. Gunther has his sleeper hold in the middle of the ring, Seth just stands up. They made Gunther into 2004 JBL and it sucks

Chris Dudley

This show was the DEFINITION mid.

iatco

2 1/4 ⭐️ in all honesty. Besides Paige's return and seth and gunther's semi decent match, there is quite literally nothing worth of note from this show. it was like a decent Saturday nights main event, or maybe even a good raw episode. You know the show wasnt good when the best part of the show was someones pregnancy announcement

Handsome Kian

I felt liv and steph had 10 minutes cut from it. Liv teasing the devil’s kiss didn’t amount to anything and that was perfectly in her character to do. As for Seth vs Gunther, really felt like Seth no sold all of Gunther’s offense for 15 minutes and then finished with interference

Brendy

Watching WWE makes me realize you don't need to watch the weekly programming to know what's going on, but if you don't read the dirt sheets you'll have no clue why anyone does anything. The logic seems to be confusing at best, or just missing. Why did Pat count slow? Why does Raquel help Liv? Why is Ram the truck of the year?

Jamie Stidiford

It was a total waste of time. If it wasn't for your watch along I could have just watched the highlights and saved 3hrs.

kyle McAllister

“I felt the night had a lot of positives. They were generally interrupted by us being forced to have wrestling matches, but otherwise great!” - Some TKO executive probably

Gage Rosenow

I haven’t watched a WWE show in a couple months but have been keeping up with what’s been going on. Tonight felt off. The crowd was dead for the majority of the show. The vibe just felt off. Small production mistakes were occurring that usually never do. Overall the company just doesn’t feel the same right now

Keith Below

It was very telling that Nick Khan was at ringside for the main event and no one really brought attention to it.

WinnerLoser

I think it was a fine night, but hard to call it Wrestlemania-worthy. Gunther/Seth and Fatu/Drew were the high spots, and I wouldn't call anything genuinely awful, but a lot of just, "meh". Liv/Stephanie was fine but short, Women's 4-way was fine, opening tag was fine, but with a nice ending. As for the main event, I will start by saying I think they handled Pat AS WELL AS YOU COULD'VE DONE. If you had to have him here(which I guess you did), he was there at the start to get the heat on and get the crowd worked up, then got taken out. Celebrity part over, now we can get to the actual match. And yes, he did come out at the end(which did earn a loud profanity from myself and the rest of my watch group), but then Randy giving him and RKO brought the crowd back up, just in time to give Cody the win and big reaction. The match itself was alright, something I would expect out of an older, slower Randy working with a faster Cody, although I did notice about halfway through how Cody seemed to be working a more traditional "heel" style. He was the one working the body part(Randy's back and head once he started bleeding), keeping the pressure on, being in control for long parts. It kinda reminded me of Hogan/Rock(although obviously not as good), with them changing their styles to align with the crowds reaction. Does that, plus Cody's more heel-ish actions during the match mean a turn is finally coming soon? Who knows? Either way, a fine night of wrestling, although it felt more like an average WWE PLE than the "biggest event of the year", and the crowd certainly didn't help. Night 2 could help elevate it, but so far, the title of Wrestle-meh-nia is earned.

Nirmal Job

Mid show, only Seth v Gunther was any good. How bad was that knuckle injury on Bianca 😅

TheSerraphim

Is there a chance TKO have purposefully tanked 41 and 42 to then try and push HHH out without any fan backlash?

Magnus Grey

My boyfriend and I were kinda done with the main event after the nonsense with Pat being taken out on a stretcher. The heel/face dynamics were all over the place. I was positive they were going to do a double turn because *that's the story they were telling in the match* and the ending frustrated me. Randy was booked as the sympathetic babyface for most of the match (and RKO'd Pat which is a face move) but then had to do the megaheel beat down after the match. It made no sense. I am very happy for Bianca though. That was a lovely moment.

Captain Nick

4 hour show, ~1hr 20min of wrestling. Entrance and advertisement company.

Sam Ryan

Main event was confusing to me. Other than Randy’s injury, I wasn’t sure what the story of the match was. Crowd clearly booing Cody, WWE and commentary don’t lean into it and keep putting him over as face. Crowd clearly cheering Randy - again nothing from Cole. Cody - eye gouge and low blow, heel moves sold to us by Cole as ‘champion has to do what a champion has to do’ babyface shit. Randy, RKO Pat - massive face move, attacks Cody with the belt after the match as a huge heel (after being cheered the whole match). Perfect chance to turn Cody heel and WWE continue to ignore fans. Slow, boring main event to cap off a disappointing night 1 (maybe it’s time for the main event scene to include people born in the 90s at least?)

oak_slaney

Just did not feel like wrestlemania. Gunther/Rollins was by far the best part of the night, and while predictable, the breakker interference was the best way to protect both Rollins and Gunther. The main event was very strange, with the crowd and the way the two were wrestling, it really felt like the heel face dynamic was reversed. Did enjoy seeing mcafee get rko’d tho. Also think it’s worth noting that none of the women’s matches went over 9 minutes 👀

Dukect

You know, it's amazing how one wrestling show could have so many ads and yet very little substance in the wrestling. And this is only night one. The funniest part is that the whole minute was what the fans wanted. Most of them anyway, they wanted 2009 Randy orton and they got it a bland, boring, and long matches with a lot of b s finishes. Also shout out to Pat McAfee for learning how to referee from Nick Patrick to not doing a fast count in the main event when he needed to

Quothetheraven79

I have seen necrophilia, attempted vehicular homocide, suicide attempts, voodoo curses, & a ton of other stupid things in pro wrestling, & then I saw THIS!!!!!!! People legitimately paid up to $30k for this garbage?!?!?! I saw this through Tortuga, & even I felt ripped off!!!!!! This Wrestlemania will go down in history as not only a black stain on WWE, but in pro wrestling in general!!!! & the worst part . . . We have one more night to go!!!!!!

CDE

Through the years Wrestling has made me happy, sad, disappointed, it's made me laugh but never genuinely angry as it's just a TV show after all, tonight that changed! How do you book a women's world champion that badly! It's indefensible. We've had a poor build but the card meant I thought the matches would have at least been good, instead they were at best 3/5,and most were 1.5/5. the last 3 matches all having interference didn't help. But hey at least we can get another hour of hulk Hogan clips tomorrow night!

James Stevenson

From the perspective of someone in the building, I enjoyed the show. Nothing blowing me away, nothing overly offensive. The women’s world title match and the unsanctioned match could have used more time, and the main event was a confusing cluster, but i had a good time! Looking forward to night 2!

Matt

There's apparently a new Hulk Hogan documentary coming out!

Brody Allsep

With only Rhea vs Jade left, it looks like there will not be a Women's match over 10 minutes this year.

Don

Tonight showcased that HHH is bad at booking and doesn't care especially in the women's division. He's seriously telling me that Iyo (who had a moty candidate last year) and Asuka couldn't find a way on the card because of the injury to Nikki, but can put Paige on as a surprise? GTFO with that nonsense. Stephanie Vaquer became the longest transitional champ through no fault of her own. Also, why couldn't Bron be against Seth? Trips sidelined a months long story for a 3 week build that will probably result in another months long build and rehash the same plot points. Can't even call this the vision story because Logan Paul hijacked that group name. 3/10 show, but congrats to Bianca (not like Montez had been doing much to begin with so might as well start a family)

Matt

Terrible!

DWERF

I don't think there was anything god awful on the show its just not memorable really in anyway. The women match lengths is disrespectful but the main event match was the only one that somewhat felt like Wrestlemania but still brought down by the Pat BS. The ending also felt like it should of been Randy that one and the punted Cody.

Ponk

WrestleMania 42 presents: HulkaMania 42 Night 1! Oh my goodness I felt like i saw more Hogan than actual wrestling 😭 If i can be positive, im happy for Bianca and happy for Paige. But everything else that wasn’t Rollins vs Gunther just felt like Raw or Smackdown. Makes me nervous for night 2, but i won’t let tonight determine how i feel going into tomorrow.

ChaseTheVillain

I'd definitely give this show a 4/10. I did enjoy Gunther vs Seth, but that was about it. Happy to see Paige back. Sunday better make this Mania worth it. Night one suuuuuuccckkkeedd

Graff

I think if they have entrance music trope might need to be retired. There's a new trope in town. Kids in your entrance. Shane, Bianca, Cena, and now AJ have all lost when having kids in their entrance. It's got a 100% so far.

Don

I've been to 2 aew ppvs and I've had a blast both times (dynasty 24 and all in texas). If you'd be willing to listen to someone on the internet, if you're thinking about going, then I would recommend doing it. DoN already has Okada/Takeshita would should be a great match and DoN is home to the anarchy in the arena events

Andrew the Last Airbender

We’re all so dumb for thinking Cody would lose. Roman and Cody both promoting Street Fighter, both holding gold. Should have seen it coming.

Nova

Felt nothing but disappointment this entire show only interrupted by anger that they're now showing ads and commercial on a payed for show and that they can only find 90 minutes on there 3 hour biggest show of the year for actual wrestling where there's no story lines or heat and if there is it's only because of a celebrity that people actually hate is there

Jason Trentham

Do you think HHH is given a time sheet from TKO for the advertisements and then needs to book the show around them? There are no real talking segments or any of the weekly shenanigans that take up air time on RAW or SMACKDOWN. Only a hour and a half of Wrestling in four hours, probably around 30 minutes for entrances. So that means TKO sold around two hours of advertising time. I bet HHH and the booking room tried their best to get as many people on the show as possible, but that's an insane restriction on time for the biggest show of the year.

Derek

I had a friend I hadn’t talked to in years call me after the event and said “what the hell was that main event” I’d say I was disappointed with the show but that would’ve meant I had expectations for something good. It felt dragged out and nothing was wrestlemania worthy. When I go through and rewatch wrestlemanias, this show will be one I easily skip. Easily up there with 2, 9, 27, and 41 as forgetfully bland

Alex Brett

Randy looks like a giant dumbass after that main event. Standing around whilst Rhodes takes out McAfee. RKOing little Naitch despite Cody being in front of him and not moving. Taking out Pat when he came down to ref and saving the punt for AFTER the match. Bad boring main event in which nobody comes out looking good.

Tyler Lunsford

Very predictable and average matches overall. Worst Night 1 Mania they’ve put on

Michael Trayner

Kind of feels like Wrestlemania night 1 was the under card while night 2 is the main card. At least they moved the polarizing main event to night 1 instead of night 2. Night 1 was good/fine but hopefully night 2 is even better

Matt Patrick

Negligible booking, poor time management, and blatant disregard of nearly 20 years of history that could’ve been jet fuel for what was a borderline asthmatic main event between Cody and Randy. For a show meant to entertain its fan base, I bet I speak for many fans when I say I never once felt considered in WWE’s decision making process for how that show was booked. The cameraman falling off the ring apron was pretty funny though.

mike wolfe

I think the biggest story out of night one was how little time they gave the women's matches. An insult pure and simple. Seth and Gunther was great, big congratulations to Bianca and Montez, but the rest of the card was mid to downright bad. Night two needs to deliver in a major way. P.S. Ya'll wanna see an excellent women's match? Go to YT and watch Kris Statlander vs Charlie (aka Dakota Kai) from EVE. Absolutely fantastic match. It'll make you feel better.

JNorms

Did anybody think Becky’s daughters fav wrestler is AJ Lee because she only shows up every couple months to fight only her mother 😭

S.Rice

Pat Macafee is the Boris Johnson of wrestling. They're both blonde eejits who people found funny until they were placed into a position beyond their station and people very quickly found them frustrating. The best bit of night 1 was Liv's entrance - it was so camp! Liv and Steph stole the show with the 6 minutes they had. The pacing of these shows is diabolical, mania having ad breaks is diabolical. Mania night 1 simply... Was

Ilan Woll

I had said before to critics that WM30 ended up great despite a terrible build. Well, I was wrong. This was garbage. Outside of Fatu-Drew and Gunther v Seth, this was lazy. And, i know it’s nitpicky, but if you are going to put McAfee on a stretcher, how do you put no effort into not making any of them look like medical personnel, except Dr. Jason Jordan

Malcolm Burgess

As someone that was in attendance the matches felt longer than they were. That being said Cody and Randy confused everyone. We didn’t know how to react and honestly they turned the wrong guy.

Ben Pavett

Look, I don’t know. I only started watching from midnight because i thought it started later. I personally think Paige should have been saved for RAM. I believe Rollins v Gunther was the best match of the night, and I think the main event STUNK the place up. Cody should NOT have won this, but to be fair neither should Randy.. The only redeeming thing from that match was the way Pat sold a kick to the mid-section, I found that genuinely funny. Hoping that night 2 is a landslide better, because this was dreadful.

Shawn

When Gunther and Seth stated my friends and I looked around at each other and said Mania has finally started

Rick Horsman

You know you've got a bad show on your hands when one of the major highlights is a returning Paige and that surprise had already been widely reported (that's no particular dig at Paige) Why did Randy RKO Pat? I'm glad he did, but it makes absolutely no sense in the story. I'm looking forward to night 2 but night 1 was as kissable as many of us predicted.

deztista

What AEW does in 4hrs and WWE do in the same amount of time , WWE & TKO should be ashamed .

Brent

The best match was Seth vs Gunther by miles. It's actually funny that it got the shortest build on Night 1 but in terms of match quality it was the best. The Randy vs Cody match I expected to be a trainwreck and boy it met that expectation so perfectly. But I didn't expect it to derail even before the bell rung for the actual match. Cody vs Cena on last year's Wrestlemania had expectations of being a good match while Randy vs Cody we could set our expectations so low. Hanging out with the Wrestletalk crew was the best way to enjoy the clusterf**k aka Night 1 of Wrestlemania 42. Watching it alone live would have been torture.

Brandon

why did Cody and randy do 2 seperate double turns over the course of 5 minutes. I don't even know who's heel and whose babyface between the two at this point. just so everyone knows the math, that was cumulative 85 minutes of wrestling on night 1 of wrestlemania, that is only 35% of the 4 hour show. tonights card has even less matches on it so I hope that means longer matches and not a shorter show

BlackYakuzu94

I have no idea why they rushed so many of these matches, there's barely anything to talk about for anything besides the main event. And that's the strangest match of the night, but I was so effin fascinated by it, I couldn't take my eyes off. I can't tell if it was good, but I was invetested.

Badgersprite

I didn’t watch the show because Iyo Sky not wrestling was the final nail in the coffin of an awful build. In retrospect I would like to personally thank Iyo Sky for her sacrifice of missing Wrestlemania as it sounds like it spared me from a godawful show. Heard Liv/Steph lasted six minutes and all women’s matches combined were shorter than Charlotte/Rhea at WM39. Lol. Lmao even.

Caine Graham

Same comment as most I assume, lackluster show, too much advertisement, not enough wrestling, hogans the star, what the fuck was that finish to Cody Randy. What’s up with no backstage segment? Middddd

Ryan Daniels

Where to even begin… I’ve been watching WrestleManias since WrestleMania 9 as a kid. Like you guys my interest peaked in the attitude era and I subbed to WestleTalk to watch the invasion series. I don’t watch a lot of wrestling nowadays but I always keep an eye on the road to mania and watch most Manias. It honestly feels like Wrestlemania has been stripped of its assets to maximise every bit of revenue it can possibly make. What made Wrestlemania special wasn’t always the in ring work but the aura of the event, the backstage segments, the VIDEO PACKAGES. All of that has been stripped away and replaced with ads and corporate filler and it’s completely killed the viewing experience. The TKO era Manias have been SPONSORmania gone wild, but unlike last night, the others have been balanced well ensuring the focus stayed on the stories, the wrestling and the experience but quite frankly last night was simply UNWATCHABLE.

Hamzah Al Qadi

That was the worst mania I’ve watched live say what you will about 27 32 and other notable bad manias but I least they felt like mania. They had the surprises the video packages and a least a couple good matches and moments. All of the matches here felt like a Saturday night’s main event not your biggest show of the year. I never thought I would care less about wwe than 2019 but here we are! F TKO triple H you know how to play the game stop prioritising cutscene!

Vic Cutting

4/10 show. Drew fatu was good but didn’t feel unsanctioned, Gunther Seth was great. That was kinda it for the good, the main event was fine

ScottJDev

How strange of them to air a 4 hour pre-show the day before Wrestlemania?

Charlie Wood

If the punt angle was the end of the match, great Randy wins Cody takes time off. But now what happens? Cody can’t come back on Monday completely fine, he just got punted and if Roman wins tomorrow both champs will probably be away for a while. It just seems a bit stupid.

Matthew Philpott

Just a bit meh, the lack of match time and video packages before each match hurt the overall show, it felt like the crowd were cold by the time we got to each match and then every match was cut short. I don’t understand the main event, why did Cody wrestle the whole match as a heel? He was attacking Orton’s back when it was clearly hurting him, doing Orton’s moves, laying into him when he was bleeding, wiping Orton’s blood on his chest, doing a low blow, winning the match… and then switched to babyface when it was over? It would’ve made so much more sense for him to punt a bloodied Orton after the match, that would’ve made it a lot more like a Wrestlemania main event.

RowdyRoutyPiper

Solomonster said on his podcast recently and its an opinion I cant unsee, WWE is now a Wrestling Fantasy Camp for celebrities, if you are big enough star or have enough follwers on twitch, WWE will let you live out your dreams of being a WWE superstar and put someone through a table in the main event of Wrestlemania.

Harry Burke

I'll say what I said during the livestream. Four letters, one word, uh uh, dull.

Frank

If there is one thing that this show taught us it's that WWE's overconfidence of assuming their core fan base will be ride or die forever will be their long-term undoing. Too many adds, the crowd doesn't have the energy of old (probably due to the price point) and they have forgotten the theatre of wrestling matches telling stories. The whole show felt like scrolling through an Instagram feed. 4/10 at best and I really want to like it.

Real One's Georgie Tuffs

Gunther match my match of night at 4 stars, Steph's reign was a joke with a joke finale, WWE need to stop doing hardcore stop matches cause their too tepid for their product. Gave main 3 3/4 star. Was watching a injured heel Vs face with mad a weird dynamic and the heel turn twists got to much for me. I felt like we were getting a different heel/face turn fakes every 10 seconds near the end. Neutrals would have been lost watching this match which tells you it was a bad story

Slamintin Hamiltin

Too many ads and even after the ads I got stupid ads in the arena and ‘celebrities’ that somehow we need to see

Gareth Jones

Mini bit of booking: Nikki bella is cleared and costs brie and paige the belts (gets them onto someone else) Paige needs a new partner and we end up with bellas vs Paige & AJ lee at backlash

Peter Siddorn

In a world where we see that people are given shit they make something beautiful sometimes they are just given shit and make shit and yeah we got that for night 1.

RobbieG

The wrestling kept getting in the way of Advertmania

Nathan Lopez

Watched with friends and we thought it was a fine show. Really liked the main event even if the way they worked didn’t make much sense. Wrestling rarely makes sense.

Nathan Lopez

Also Randy in the main event was quite good

Actually an Otter

I liked the Hulk Hogan documentary, but ending it with Cody vs Randy was an odd editing choice.

Fin Levett

The Wrestlemania feeling is fully gone these last two years

Real One's Georgie Tuffs

Match ratings night 1 Uso match ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2 - Feel good to open the show. Not my vibe but for the fans it would have started the show well. Drew match ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2 - was a fair match but these stips don't work if your not going strong. AEW hardcore ppv events have put these kind of matches on another level. I think this match with another stip would easily be a 4 star Women's Tag ⭐ ⭐⭐ 1/2- Paige returned team for injured Bella. Was a good match, let down by the fact we all knew their was better tags to put in this match plus not a fan of Bella's winning even though I did predict. Not exciting going in. Not exciting going out. Becky match ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ 1/4 - was expecting this match to be a 3 star. Worked better then thought. Waste of Becky and should be the last time we see AJ. Just not made for the new world 🏆 Rollins match ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ 1/4- Clearly fight of the night going in. Clearly fight of the night going out. 2 wrestlers who know this game and performed at the level. I think with bigger build and a few warm up matches for Rollins could have made even better. Only match I would recommend on this show Liv ⭐ ⭐ 3/4 - Too short. Too much interference, just pissed me off to conclude this terrible title run for Steph with a joke match at mania. Clearly don't care about Steph, and you almost made me not. Super disappointed, this toilet break after a few beers would have had more feel good Factor. Rhodes ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ 3/4 - was a strange dynamic to a match, Randy the heel, looked like a injured old man and Cody the face looked like he was just beating him up for 90% of the fight. Was glad to see the BS with Pat done nice and early but by the end end was confused. I had Cody turning heel here but I felt he was turning heel back to face about 5 times in the last 5 mins. Then Pat ran down, than before I knew it Pat got RKO then cody won, then Randy went back and beat him up post match. WHY? I don't know. I left this match and show not sure wtf happened in the main event story and character wise and no idea where it's going. And not in a good way. Show Rating ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ 1/2. Was ok, not a mania you would care to see again and would be crying if you were now sleeping in a tent cause you sold your house for front seat tickets. If Gunther match wasn't on this show I would not have enjoyed it. Infact only think I enjoyed. I also think if this was any other ppv than mania I would have given main event and opener less stars so saying that in the out of mania world I would give it ⭐ ⭐ ⭐

Kei

Genuinely wondering how much we'll see of Paige in ring. The reason she wasn't exactly a fighting champ in AEW is because her neck is made of loosely packed sand and the concentrated prayers of a dozen orthopaedic surgeons. Genuinely surprised the more conservative doctors at WWE cleared her tbh.

DerBilz99

This was the length of a AEW PPV and hab about 20 less matches on it... Mania should be a celebration of wrestling biut is now just a commercial...

Tom Daniels

Excluding the Paige return, night one of Wrestlemania could have been an email.

Aaron Hadfield

Did anybody else find it weird that they sandwiched 90 mins of wrestling between my ad breaks show?

Findlay

Every match was about 5 minutes shorter than it needed to be. This really felt like they didn't respect the viewer's time. Can only hope night 2 is packed with bangers

RKOWarrior999

Very long time listener and patreon backer, Ive always envisaged my first message / contribution to be an amazing piece, so here goes....wrestlemania 42, night one...pile. of. Shite.

Paul McP

Do the producers and talent know that it's wrestlemania? The biggest show of their year? When putting their matches together did they just think "yeah that'll do"? None of the matches would be out of place in hour 1 of Raw. People paid thousands of human monies to see that live. I saw it for free on television and I want compensation. Felt like the whole thing was just an ad for the Hogan doc. To come back from adverts (ADVERTS) to more adverts is beyond baffling. The winner of the night is Tony Khan, he must have been laughing his ass off watching this

Kenny2002

Very boring and uneventful wrestlemania hopefully

Ph7

This was a weird experience. While none of the matches were worked badly, I will also most likely have forgotten about all of them by monday. The best Match by far was Seth vs Gunther, but even then it won't be in the top 50 of their respective catalogues. And even though the Main Event was memorable, it's not because it's good, but rather because it was so... weird. Here's to hoping night 2 will be better.

rhuds 06

An absolutely awful night of wrestling for me Seth Gunther only thing worth watching and even then that was a alright raw main event at best I had no expectation for this show yet somehow I'm still disappointed

Jack McEwen-Quy

Now the pre-show is finally over we can all enjoy Wrestlmania tonight

beccabee

wrestlemania 42 night 1 was the ‘ant man and the wasp’ of wrestlemanias

Homerstar

It wasn’t bad, but it just didn’t feel like Wrestlemania. Drew vs Fatu was good, but they didn’t wrestle like a proper unsanctioned match, felt like just a normal no DQ match. Seth vs Gunther was probably my match of the night and I liked Bron getting involved, but it ended up feeling like a match we’d get in the lead up to Wrestlemania. And whilst I liked seeing Paige return, it meant that Asuka vs Iyo got scrapped for no reason.

Ben peacock

It felt like it was the night the prestige of WrestleMania died even in bad years it still felt like a celebration of wrestling night 1 felt like it had no soul whatsoever

Herman Falck How

Beyond obvious Pat and Jelly stuff the main issue with that main event was just that it was confusing. Why are we doing the back injury/double turn angle if we're going to do a long back and forth match? Why are we doing this at all when the first 10 minutes of the segment is about Pat McAfee? Why did Pat count so slow? Why did Randy turn on him? Why did Randy fully do the punt after wrestling like a babyface the whole match? It's all just very confusing. Some twists and turns are fun and make for good stories, but this was just ridiculous.

Frederick Tobin III

After tonight, I'm extremely worried about Oba winning tomorrow. That card was booked to piss off the same fans who are desperate for the Oba win.

Jonathan Davies

This shows over all others proves that you can no longer watch WWE live. To much downtime. Take the adds out and it will be an okay show. Seriously considering just watching tonight's show on Monday morning. Shame as it used to feel like I can't miss it live.

Dean Brereton

WrestleAverage! The Showcase of the Matches we should have done 6 months ago or...are still doing the same ones!

Charles Lawley

It had its moments but it wasn't better than a single episode of Dynamite this year so far.

JJ Bittenbinder

Any show can be bad, it happens, but decisions were made here which just make me furious. I thought it was WRESTLEmania, but it just was ads ads ads. Matches were insultingly short. Multiple times a match ended & just went: "that was it?!" This company is a joke. Can't wait for Dynamite. I'm jumping ship.

Mark Robertson

I’m not angry, I’m just disappointed…….with myself. The fact I thought WWE could create a good show after a poor build was misguided. I think I’m done with TKO/WWE, I’ll watch wrestle talk to keep updated but for my weekly American consumption it will only be AEW moving forward, I can’t sacrifice any more of my time watching a show full of commercial with average matches sprinkled in between. An insult of a show

Kevin Fleuriot

As expected, Seth vs Gunther was the best match and a banger. Paige's return was nice (I should really get off social media) and Bianca's announcement put me in a great mood. The main event was alright. The rest was WrestleMeh-nia.

Jon Miles

Feel like one of the biggest things missing was backstage segments. I get the “sports presentation” feel they are going for - but those “only at Wrestlemania” backstage interactions really added to the non-spectacle last night was.

Dean Brereton

Was dogshit wasn't it? there you go Luke use that great analysis from me on the show today.

Mark Robertson

I counted just under 90 mins of wrestling on a four hour show

RealDoubleJ

My favourite part of the night was watching Dan on the livestream going through the same stages an 8 year old goes through when they realise the easter bunny isn't real when Liv came out to her song

Stabitha Christie

Wwe is not for the middle, its for diehards or people who shout "do a suplex (or kickflip) " then clap. It's a real shame that with all the talent on the roster, they were given little to chew on and even less time to chew. 3/10 wrestler-mani-ugh

Gregg Murphy

They got the timing of their angles wrong. Could speed not have turned on Logan mid match and they got the win off the splash. Could Gunther and Seth not have had a clean banger then breakker run down. Could Randy not have hit the punt during the match. Overall it was like a 2/10, the matches felt utterly pointless and the sheer amount of ads was insane.

Gregg Murphy

Michael Cole said “Randy vs Cody is next” with 1:10 left in the show. The video package played, the bell rang with 25 minutes left. Saturday night main event vibes

Hok

I settled in for a night of adverts and got interrupted by some damn wrestling.

Chris deaton

Idk if it was just me but it felt like there was a lot of dead air throughout the whole show? There was also quite a few times where Cole would start to say something but then stop mid sentence and it’d just be silent for a camera shot from the top of the rafters through the crowd to the ring. It was weird. Also absolutely insane to only have an hour and a half of wrestling on a 4 hour show.

Andrew Baylis

Having slept on it a bit, I thought it was decent overall, nothing really disappointed, most matches were pretty much what I thought they'd be, even if all the undercard could have done with a few more minutes. The main event though left me really confused. I get that they're trying to give Cody an edge, but- Why was the he viciously beating up Randy to the point that commentary was talking about Randy as the sympathetic babyface? Why/how did Randy "accidentally" RKO the ref who was stood on the opposite side of the ring to where Cody was? Why did Randy RKO Pat? Why was Randy immediately back to being a ruthless heel as soon as the match finished, having been the injured babyface veteran throughout?

Ryan Daniels

HULK-A-MANIA still running wild - somehow the hulkster said, ‘that doesn’t work for me BROTHER’ from beyond the grave

ItalianJosh

No backstage segments with the host, no video packages, blood feuds ending in boring 8 min matches, AD Mania going wild brother… I hate saying this: but even crappy Vince Manias felt more "entertaining". AS A SINGLE NIGHT, this has to be one of the worst Manias ever, right?

Wayne Rogers

Really wasn't expecting Cody to retain, but pleased about it. Maybe they can actually build the feud without any stupid additions like McAffee and just run with the history between the two of them.

Jehanzeb Kureshi

After watching that wrestlemania all I could think was, it got split into two nights to feature more wrestling. Now it just features more ads. Wrestlemania could be one night and it would still have less actual wrestling on the show than an AEW card. It's not even buy one get one free.

Rhys Bithell

It's a strange one. None of the matches bad but a lot of them were just nothing. Seth & Gunther was probably match of the night but I think I would have preferred to see Brons return on RAW just because of the lack of quality matches on the night and would have liked to just see a straight match between Seth and Gunther Cody and Randy is more interesting. I think they handled Pat pretty much perfectly. His entrance was far too long but they got rid of him early then brought him out at the end to get the RKO. Cody is acting more heelish but everything he did was justified as Randy did it to him earlier in the match so that is interesting going forward I hope the matches get more time tonight but can't shake the feeling Brock is winning BTW do you know that Netflix has a Hulk Hogan documentary coming out. They should have done a AD for that on wrestlemania

Lewis Stephenson

I haven’t timed it, but it felt as if the Hogan doc ads had more screen time than maybe all the women’s matches.

Wayne Pereira

82 mins of wrestling in a 4 hour show. 40 mins from the end of the Liv match to the start of the Cody match. Cody Randy match was 22 mins but the entrances and vid packages was 20 mins. And the 'superstar' that had the most screen time was Hulk Hogan! Not a good show

Josh Lane

9/10 show I loved the hogan documentary shame it kept getting interrupted by quick or average wrestling matches, in all seriousness you know the show isn’t good when the best part of it is Bianca announcing she’s having a kid

Shellhard

6/10 show I like the paige return and gunther vs rollins but only giving 24 minutes to three women match and one being for a world title is unforgivable in this day of age

Jack Goodwin

Was cody vs randy supposed to be a double turn? It looked like that was what they wanted to do only the crowd wasn't into it.

Vikrish-Ingi

First match was a fun opener get everyone in the mood. Paige is back yay, was already all over the Internet. Gunter rollins and bron best thing of the whole night by a mile. Blimphausen brilliant. Belhairs injury is so bad its taken out montez and the swelling has spread to her stomach!!! But seriously congrats to them. And then a whole bunch of boring crap. Our 17 year old feel asleep during the main event. Chap doesn't sleep at night 🤣. Night 2 cant be as bad . Right ?

Benn Waller

nice to see Paige back but with all the short matches & ads made it feel like Raw instead of Wrestlemania

Herman Falck How

I do feel people are giving the Gunther match way too much credit because that was really dumb too. Why make a match where Gunther sells pretty much the entire match to Seth and then Gunther gets lucky in the end if we want both of them to look strong? Gunther should have smashed Seth and then during Seth's comeback where you are supposed to think he might be able to pull it out then Seth gets hit by Bron. Now Gunther just looks like he was lucky Bron showed up.

Callum Hackett

The matches were nothing from what I saw. I fell asleep after the Gunther Seth match and woke up as Cody won. WWE should be putting on a much better show for their biggest of the year. Watching your guys' stream was the main thing keeping me entertained

Andrew Harley

TKO remind me of that old Kevin Nash (if i remember correctly) story from WCW, when he peaked round the curtain and said to himself "Well, we've already got their money...". Very little to no effort on the wrestling side, as long as they've got your money and can subject you to countless ads that's all they care about. Show could've easily been any other PLE or an episode of RAW. WM should be the spectacle and stand out from the rest.

Good Evening Gamers

I have a weird feeling certain old events that used to be seen as prestige events will start to have there prestige removed under TKO and they'll either end up trying to make Wrestlepalooza there big thing to complete remove all the Vince stuff. That or we'll suddenly start having WWE 1, WWE 2, WWE: Orton Vs Punk. Basically making all the excitement null and void

Alex Drew

Probably me being Naive, but hopefully that was the "Okay let's get all the ads out of the way" night, and tonight will be better. I doubt it..Alot.

Ben

That wasn't Wrestlemania, that was a random episode of Raw with title changes

Mansour Maghlouth

I might be the only person with a positive thing to say about this show but going into the main event I didn’t expect to enjoy it as much as I did. Other than that what a boring show lol

PublickEye

Last night wasn't surprising given the buildup, but there's always a naive hope that after botching the entire routine they will somehow stick the landing. Instead they broke both of their legs. Gunther - Seth is the only thing I'd recommend anyone watch, and even that was equivalent to the fifth best match on an average AEW PPV.

Neweyes66

Wrestlemania? More like Adsmania! With only two matches that I would say are good enough for Wrestlemania, the rest were alright at best. I'm just so disappointed that Stephanie Vaquer Vs Liv Morgan didn't get the time it deserves

Matt Hibbert

Sooooooooo boring. Fatu vs Drew & Seth vs Gunther were the best of a bad bunch. Guessing that night 2 has to be better. Seems like WWE can’t do 2 night events as one will just suck!!!

CJ Sharp

You need to don your WWEntrances Trashflowers hat for night 2 because this is all it's about. The matches were ordinary at best. Gunther v Seth probably the best but their career ending heal spent the whole match taking bumps and only won by interference which really makes no sense. PLE? More like PPE to protect against excrement and human waste that WWE are throwing out. Imagine paying >£1000 quid to attend.

jad_ofalltrades

the whole show was so meh, it wasn't bad, but it really was WrestleMania, Micheal Cole literally said after Jacob vs Drew "It was as violent as we expected" was it fuck, everything on the show was so meh, Paige coming back was fun, but every few minutes I go back to my phone because, I don't expect night 2 to be as underwhelming because I'm excited for almost all the matches on it

James Markin

My roommate asked during the main event if Collison was on. It's a WrestleMania's main event and my more casual fan roommate wanted to watch a different wrestling show. This show minus Gunther vs Seth was pathetic and Night 2 has a lot of work tonight or this will easily be the worst Mania I ever saw and we all sat through 27.

Jonathan Davies

Just realised that the pre show at 3 hours (no matches) was double the length of the actual in ring time of night 1. Spent roughly twice as long on previewing the matches. Who thinks this is a good idea?

Chris

Did anyone else keep getting random Wrestlemania ads during their Hulk Hogan Documentary?

Ashton

WrestleMania Night 1 felt pretty underwhelming. The matches were short, there were too many ads, and the main event was confusing. The only real highlight was Gunther vs. Rollins.

Dylan Travers

Wrestlemania (night two) baby woo!

Craig Jackson

Not-So-Fun fact, a women’s speed title match on nxt went the same amount of time as 4 WRESTLEMANIA NIGHT 1 matches (being 8 minutes long)

Callum Lucas

Don’t know if this counts as a hot take but I find Orton and Rollins to be good, but not nearly great. Rollins calling himself the generations Mr WrestleMania is hilarious, and Orton hasn’t had a great one on one match in over a decade!

Gregg Murphy

Without hyperbole, I think that’s the worst night of mania ever. Name one other mania that doesn’t have at least one banging match. 27 has hhh/taker, last years night one had the 3 way, even the bad manias have fun “bad” matches. This one lacked basically ANY redeeming qualities

Ryan Daniels

How do you think the talent feel? They spend their entire year trying to ensure they stay relevant enough to have a spot on Mania, put in countless hours of media, promoting the show and then rewarded with 8 minutes to actually wrestle and try and pay off the story they are trying to sell. It’s diabolical.

Michael

I’m so confused on that main event. Cody wrestled heel the entire time like it was a double turn, then the post match made it feel like a double turn back. I’m just confused on what this is supposed to be.

Christopher Hamilton Sr

Did you all see the imprint left on Cody's face from the impact of that Championship belt?

Andrew

The Wonder Years are one of my favourite bands. Hearing them announced got a massive pop out of me. Then it was immediately obvious it was lip synced. Made the band, and even Becky by association, look like chumps. Why have a band come out if youre gonna decide to not have them play? Boy, I really hope someone got fired for that blunder!

Michael

Also Naomi’s baby vs Bianca’s baby for wrestlemania 69 main event you heard it hear first

Mani Umaria

Is there an argument for the women's belts being the wrong way around as in, AJ vs Lynch should have been for the main title and Vaquer vs. Morgan should have been for the IC title?

Andrew

For the first half I was swept up in the Mania Fever. Every match, I was nodding going "ah that was fun". Then I realised after gunther/seth that the biggest compliment I could give any match so far is that some spots were "a bit fun". Nothing of actual note was really happening. Mania is the place for a few short "bit of fun" matches (we got this out of the way with Speed and the Vision) but then it also needs other matches to balance it. Emotion, drama, stakes, etc. I felt none of that. Just "ah, that was a little fun". This night of Mania was the equivalent of exhaling sharply out of your nose instead of laughing

Zack Ryder’s Wheelchair

I realized after the show started…I didn’t care about any of these matches at all. This did not feel like Wrestlemania. The entrances were underwhelming, there barely felt like any stakes because of the weak build, and the crowd was kind of dead through most of the show. I have higher hopes for Night 2, but everything from the Chamber until now makes me want to stop watching all together and stop giving them my time and attention. Luke has said, “People will pay, until they won’t.” And I think this is the final nail in the coffin for me

Jordan Moser

Cody v Randy was a better match than most people will think because most people will dwell on the finish and crowd reactions, but it was pretty well constructed from an in ring perspective imo. But God was it thematically confusing and paired with a lame show ending tho

Thomas westhead

Night one left me confused, and not in the fun nonsensical way that Lost (and currently ‘From’) did.. particularly the main event Is this just a strange backtrack on the Pat Plans because of the fan backlash?… Why did Randy suddenly have a back injury if Cody wasn’t turning Heel? Strange night 1, my friend gave me a load of gummies this week, and I’m starting to think I ate them all by mistake before night one started. Surprisingly from the build and up until the interference, I was really enjoying the Liv - Vaquer match, am I still high? Help me understand lads, I need you right now. Praying night 2 makes this all feel like a distant fever dream. Love you all, it’s fucking Wrestletalk season 🙌🏻

Ruutti

Maybe it's a good thing Iyo vs Asuka isn't happening at Wrestlemania after all, if they would only get a 5 minute match then.

Jonathan Bourdeau

New orleans dodged a bullet on not getting this show.

Padraig O’Callaghan

It is a sad thought but the fact is we have been chasing the high of WM40 for the past 2 years now. I don't think it's all HHH's fault because of his booking choices, but it really shouldn't be this hard - Oli has put it brilliantly before " the average fan is no longer the customer of WWE, it is the other businesses/brands that are advertised throughout the broadcast. I know that advertising tends to be different in the US vs Europe, but the fact is mutiple statistics have come out stating that in-ring time was only ahead of overall ad time by 12 mins....on a 3.5 hour wrestling show....with only about 1.5 hour of wrestling. Not every match needs to be a 5 stars but I think at this point, WWE are only interested in booking people who have cross-industry fame from their roster. I think the failure of the Cena turn last year will only make WWE more resistant to turn Cody heel since their main event scene is too thin for them to find him someone who would actually be able to fill the babyface spot and sell as much merch as him. Hopefully night two is better ,and by better I mean it has matches longer than 6-8 mins...

Tino RSA

I hated this night of WrestleMania. It was Ad, match, ad, match. There was no video packages, nothing backstage. Very very cold. I enjoyed WM36 better than this. At least there was some sort of variety. I would never pay thousands of dollars for this

KSC

Mark My Words: Kenny and MJF will have gotten more time in 1 match at Dynasty than the entire women's roster during a 2 night Wrestlemania.

Christopher Gibson

Complete shambles....90 min worth of matches with 5 mins of that being Mcafee taken out on a stretcher. A 3 star match between Gunther and Seth (two top tier wrestlers) made to look like a 5 star classic due to the rest of the booking. WWE made night 1 the most expensive pre show in history. The wrestlers deserve better. The fans deserve a refund.

Christopher Gibson

I think they never got on cause they were too good at this rate.

KSC

75:10 according to Wikipedia

Brxdley.h

genuine question for the boys. did last night make you feel better about not getting invited to mania? you would’ve spent so much money on the trip to watch that show - BUT you would’ve been at mania..

CB

Night 1 felt like the first half of a ppv before the exciting main event. Incredibly middling show, only getting remotely exciting towards the end but then ending abruptly because they gotta save the crowd for the main event...but in this case its tomorrow? Baffling.

James

First WWE show I've watched in a long time. What happened to backstage segments? Pre-match promos? Every match just felt like a placeholder for the next ad. If this is the future of wrestling, then we're in for some dark times.

KSC

There is no reason to be kind to people with the level of contempt for their audience this company has, but I respect your good natured soul. :)

Lordsummerilse

TKO somehow made Wrestlmania feel like a boring add filled episode of Raw.

Christopher Gibson

What can I say....I am an optimistic soul. 😀. I do agree 100% that last night was a complete piss take of the audience and a company that is living on its past success. 👍

Charles Berg

The first night felt like someone gave me a big glass of chocolate milk but it was actually just diarrhea frothing in a glass. I feel like i got pranked by malicious individuals.

Matthew Penfold

Thought most of the actual wrestling was fine, just as soon as it got going and it felt like it was going up a gear someone just hit their finisher and won.

TheBigBossDog

How has nobody talked about Nikki’s promo to announce Paige. Was she drunk? High? I don’t know, but it was fucking hilarious

Joecxz

Matches were so short and underwhelming. Why the main event just a raw angle?

Badseed

if you look at the matches out of the mania context, and separate from how much time there was between matches, most vere perfectly fine, for a b-show or tv. In context they were abyssmal, only Gunther vs. Seth actually felt like it belonged. While i am fully on team "AEW shows are way too long" i'd take those over a 3/4ths of the show is commercials. I deperately hope WWE does some last minute changes to day 2 after seeing the reactions to this show

Mike S.

On a night where we saw Paige return, Bron return, a wild Bianca appearance and three title changes - it feels like nothing really happened on this show. Gunther v Seth was great - I’m still floored at how short every match went… none of the women’s matches went longer than 10 minutes? With the amount of talent in that division that can’t be acceptable

Mike S.

Agreed on Liv and Steph - there wasn’t anything in their match that we haven’t already see on a regular Raw… felt like they left plenty on the table. “that was it?? Wowww”

Redrum972

Kind of boring and way to many advertisements

Brent

So you're saying that Liv and Vaqueur would have gotten 1:50 and 3 other matches would be under 5 minutes. I think if I paid thousands of dollars to be at Wrestlemania and gotten 4 matches under 5 minutes each, I would be pretty angry.

Findlay

I don't understand how you've come to this conclusion from what I've said? Every match was at least 5 mins too short

Grant Wragg

Didn’t feel special is the main problem.

Kevin

It would be interesting to see if they do Becky vs. Jessica, she didn’t take a normal ref bump showing that she can take a hit and get back up

Dxsolo

I couldn’t get past the fact Green Shirt guy has seemingly multiplied

Gregg Murphy

What time is the podcast out at?

Joshua Bess

Have you ever wanted someone to succeed so bad you'll even support them in terrible story lines? That was Austin theory for me and idk how much longer i can hold on. They just dont give a shit about the guy 🫠

Kevin

Breaker’s second spear should be featured on Oli’s “He didn’t get all of it”

SDSD

Didnt feel like wrestlemania. Entrances and commercials were longer than matches. Only a couple of matches clicked. Randy-Cody was one of the worst matches because of inverted wrestling psychology.

Sean Skorpion

Night one was fine bordering on mediocre, the only matches I enjoyed were gunther vs Seth and Randy vs Cody (especially pat getting battered twice) but it was a nothing show. It wasn’t a terrible show but it definitely was one of the shows of all time

Leo

This is the first time since I've gotten back into wrestling (just before Mania 40) where I decided mania wasn't worth losing sleep for. I decided to just watch it the next day, and boy did I make the right decision. I had fun with the speed match, the seth and gunther match was the only great thing this night imo. The rest was a snooze fest and just felt like it was building to something else (besides like the final 3 minutes of the main event). I've recently started watching AEW and just like Oli mentioned, I ended up comparing the two and Dynasty was by far the superior show. The "counter programming" worked. I really hope Night 2 is better, excited for Oba vs Brock and the main event but that's about it. PS: Liv Morgan's entrance made me cringe like you wouldn't believe, and no Cenahausen disappointed me.

Will B

Is it just me or does the stage and entrance ramp look like they just re-used last year's?

Bryson Suggs

Remember, after you watch Wrestlemania that cost you $30 make sure you: 1. Buy a Dodge Ram 2. Watch the Hulk Hogan doc that is completely accurate and not a retelling of history at all 3. Eat only Drumstick cones while telling yourself that HHH is the greatest storyteller in pro wrestling history. *cracks a Fosters* it’s fucking Wrestlemania season!

Magic Man Dan

I think the AJ/Becky match made me the most irate. If Jessica was just gonna get up straight away and count the pin, I think it would've been better if she went to disqualify Becky, Becky gets distracted, AJ rolls her up and Jessica fast-counts. That would've made more sense than Jessica just counting the pin as normal, especially when she already went off on Becky earlier in the match.

Red Surefire

I've been watching WWE since 2014 when all my friends and I would go to our local hobby shop and keep the store open late to watch the PPV's. We'd do prediction competitions, talk about the matches and stars, would even do wrestling maneuvers in the snow. (Mind you extremely carefully). It was a fun after school club like activity for us. Made me love wrestling for the last 12 years. Even through some rough spots I'd always watch the PPVs. This is the first time in a LOOONG time where I fell asleep through the show. And thats just damning especially since it's Wrestlemania.

babbage

After night 1 I realized that on the last few years WWE is slowly killing all the love I had for it or atleast the child in me that did. Also I mean why couldn't the heel guest character ref count to 3? I'm grateful that my love for wrestlt however, is still being met elsewhere.

James Wolf

I think Wrestlemania is still booked as a single show, rather than 2 separate ones. The main event of Night one is just the mid point, instead of the main event, with the intention of building each match up culminating at the main event from Night 2. I don't think they're doing it particularly well, but I think that's the intent. It's not to be watched over 2 nights, it's to be watched all in one. Can't explain away the absurd amount of Ad's though. :(

Michael McKenzie

I personally don't get all the hate. I tuned in to watch bright, flashy entrances and enjoy the top-quality ads that only WWE can create, and boy did they deliver! I reckon its about time WWE realised that no one cares about people in their underwear pretend-fighting for a belt (bit ironic, isn't it?). Although I will say, no one play-fought in underwear like Hulk Hogan. I learned so much of his history watching this show. And it was so nice of WWE to play the same trailer 4 whole times throughout, understanding that my Tik-Tok-rotted brain can't possibly be expected to absorb all that fascinating information in one, loooooong 4-minute stretch. 9/10 show, only missing out on 10 because they only showed the Cone Zone! (tm) once and I missed half of it playing subway surfers on my iPad.

Gary Dodds

I really hope there is some sarcasm in here somewhere 😆

NerfPablo

I got a surf shark VPN and signed up for the Patreon rather than going to Wrestlemania. Money well spent

William Turtle

Perhaps Brock did actually retire and Summer slam being in Minnesota is to announce his HOF induction

Steve Brayford

Has AEW set a match quality standard that WWE cannot live up to? I've felt underwhelmed by every match so far, even the better ones like Oba v Brock and Balor v Dom. Wheres the drama, the near falls, the edge of my seat anticipation.

Doug Stover

Remember when a street fight use to go into the street. I miss those days. Not sure why that is even a stip in WWE anymore.

Sam Sullivan

it's genuinely impressive to have a 2 night show where the first night is one of the worst shows I've ever seen, and the second night is the best thing WWE has put on in months

TheNemesis

Night 1 was such a bust. One decent match that still didn't feel like it fulfilled its potential (Gunther/Rollins) sandwiched around a bunch of underwhelming nothing that didn't really accomplish anything and several matches that were sloppy in getting there. The only good things besides Seth/Gunther were the nice Paige return and Bianca's pregnancy announcement. Though the latter is marred by the realization that it means WWE KNEW she wasn't going to be back and we still got months of Jade's pointless title reign for no good reason.

Ilan Woll

So weird that night 1 was dog awful while night 2 was one of the best nights ever. Though, if I am afraid of Nigerian wrestlers, do I suffer from Obaphobia?

ItalianJosh

Night 2 was an easy 4/5 for me, but the real question is: was Night 1 better or worse than Billy Gunn?