Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

LUKE: The best ones will be read out on the podcast.

Comments

Michael

I hope this is actually a short reign for Roman… I’m hoping for an Oba rocket to the title

Ryan

I think it’s fair to say your theory about Triple H and night two was right! Incredible main event !!

BetterThanYamcha

"Perfectly fine"... Followed by a barn burner... 3.5/5

Jake Miller

Part-timers shouldn't be champions

NerfPablo

Main event was more hardcore than the Drew McIntyre vs Jacob Fatu unsanctioned match

Drew Hahn

Definitely better than night 1, truly had that mania feel to it with more wrestling, but still felt a little short, idk good show just could’ve used another match imo

Sorry it’s a deadlock reference

Leave em happy. One of the worst shows of all time ended by one of the greatest wrestlemania matches of all time. Still an overall incredibly disappointing weekend, but man that main event will be rewatched a lot.

Jeremiah Culver

Despite what the internet tells me it was a pretty good mania. I do long for the days of video packages of backstory instead of the ad gauntlet though

TheBigBossDog

Overall a much better night, still not amazing but certainly a step up. Jade vs Rhea shocked me the most, surprisingly good.

Matthew Axup

Way better than night 1 and can't wait for RAM.

Ben

the punk entrance felt like a "last time." i wonder how much longer he has in him and wants to now that aj seems to go back on her hiatus. great great match

Rando_Scot

dragged the weekend up to a mid-level mania; but overall a poor mania weekend for WWE especially given next year will surely be another bummer.

Brendy

A much better night of wrestling, but if night one was some sort of power play by Triple H then the wrestlers should be pissed

theTimeLord97

Absolutely far better than Night 1, and Roman v Punk was excellent.

TheDerpiestofDerps

I think that Roman Punk was a great match but Roman winning was the last thing I wanted tbh. I thought we were past the era of world champions who are never on the show and here we are again

honey

The difference between both main events is ASTRONOMICAL. Great storytelling in Punk v Roman, refreshing to have no interference. However as good as it was, there's no way it can cover up how absolutely awful night one was as a whole. No clue where the RAM will go after this either! Thanks for the livestream and all the mania content!

PineJohn

So, in kayfabe, Brock returned, lost a single match and decided to quit? Doesn't that make him look like a crybaby?

Henry Riley-Edwards

Jade Cargill is a good case study for what is wrong with the booking at the moment. You could’ve done the Jade vs Bianca match a 40, giving her a massive program in her first couple of months in WWE. You should’ve done it at 41 after the mystery attacker storyline, but they waited for 42, and weren’t able to do it. Rhea’s win probably kills all the little momentum she had left, and I’ve lost all interest in a Belair program. Hate to be a downer after that great main event but that's how i feel.

Keith Below

Night two felt like a completely different show. I'm calling Raw tomorrow. Roman starts the show, Oba comes out, sets up a main event title match. Match ends in a shenanigans.

Benn Waller

night 2 felt like Wrestlemania. wish we had that for 2 nights

Connor Cox

So no interference from tko

Archie

Loved night 2 can’t shake the feeling that wwe is turning more and more into the ufc with all the ad breaks and time between matches.

Devin McNeal

Night one killed my love for wwe, night two brought me back. Lets see how long it takes for TKO to kill it again. Punk vs. Roman was match of the weekend. Hope punk turns heel after this he needs a new direction.

Jamaal Ellison

It seems to be a recurring theme where the first night is garbage, and the second night is mid to good to great, depending on who you talk to. So maybe WrestleMania should go back to being one night again.

Edward Economous

Hi guys hope you enjoyed Mania. I thought night 1 was just whatever but night 2 was pretty good curious to hear your thoughts.

Tyler

Kinda felt like after an awful day at work, you come in the next day have a good day and it ends with being let home early, much improved from night one

Tan Tan

Two matches in and it was already better than night one. Incredible main event. I know there was still a lot of ads but tonight definitely felt more like mania. Overall a really fun night

Godzilladreamer

Oba vs Roman to main event night 2 of SummerSlam has me tempted to crumble to the ticket prices to see it in person.

Brent

By far that CM Punk vs Roman was the best match of the entire weekend. It's amazing that having a match with no interference do wonders for a match. Oba vs Brock was perfect length and had Oba won in a convincing fashion. I don't believe Brock is done until this year's Summerslam. I felt the finish to the Sami vs Trick match was so anti-climatic. Trick just winning with the Trick Shot seems so empty to me. The Danhausen segment to me beat 6 out of the 7 matches on Night 1.

Pogo is here

That was way better than night 1 but still I'm sitting here asking why did iyo not have a match seeing as she had the best mania match the last 2 manias

General Jimmy G

Night 1 was 2/10. Night 2 was 7/10. Best 2 matches were punk/roman & Oba/Brock. For me no match of year contenders. AEW took wind out of mainia's sail but just putting on wrestling. I mean I love wrestling not adds. On a positive note. Was fun to watch along with you guys over the weekend. #JAMTHATJAM

Skye Shadowrun

Fun night 2 but it was an extremely low bar. I'd argue that overall, it was a 4/10 Mania. I could be convinced for a 5/10 but it was overall a forgettable Mania aside from probably an easy addition to Worst Match of the year contender

PineJohn

Hopefully they have big plans for Oba and he skips any midcard title. This is not the kind of thing that you wait before capitalizing

Will Campbell

WAY better than last night top to bottom. Women's Title and the Main event matches of the night, but I think it was super important for them to start off running with Brock and Oba, and I believe they did in a way that absolutely catapults Oba forward. And that Main Event was just incredible. 34 minutes of two guys who hate each other more than anything else in life slugging it out until they really couldn't anymore.

Rasmus Vilsgaard

I don't wanna speculate too much but if HHH really did pulled a fast one by tanking night 1 in favor of night 2... I don't like the guy, but you gotta respect the hustle

Orchestructive

Fantastic main event that shows Punk truly is the Best in the World. Plus it also means with the main belts in the two most boring positions possible, I no longer have to tune in week-to-week.

Brxdley.h

Night Two saved this mania from being an all time stinker. It just makes me believe EVEN MORE, that Trips did it purposefully. He wasn’t on board with the pat stuff, so make that whole show a pile of dog crap and dampen reviews, then on HIS night, they go out and have a proper mania. the greatest politicker in the industry. All in all, a good wrestlemania (night 2) with a stinker of a first night. But a lovely time with the boys and the live chat! This mania was - in the words of bret hart - a 4/10 (but honestly more like a 6 or 7) #Wrestlemani-ad

Adele A. Lugosi

I was hoping with all Penta, Dragon and Rey wearing red, I really wanted them to do the Spiderman meme spot. It was right there. The Match between Roman and Punk was amazing. Well told, and I'm curious about what's next. It was nice to have a clean finish to match.

Tim Pak

Reigns Punk had the best story (possibly the only actually told story) going into it, and it was rewarded. From the beautiful irony that Reigns made Punk look really strong while getting the win, to Punk knocking his main event shot outta the park, with all the terrible wrestling, glad we got something to remind us why we love this and it’s still nuts we got this match

Jamaal Ellison

It's so funny listening to Ollie, and especially Dan, make excuses for this company. You get a few good matches on night 2, and all of a sudden, it's as if the first night didn't happen.

Lewis Kelly

So, over the weekend both womens titles changed hands. The catalyst for the womens revolution Stephanie Mcmahon was inducted into the Hall of Fame. Yet Linda Hogan was the most featured woman at Wrestlemania. That doesn't work for me brother!!!

Matt

As Danhausen would put it night one very evil night two very nice

ChaseTheVillain

Great main event! Wished they just let Evans win the IC belt! Had him, Trick, and Oba winning. Rhea winning was fine. Guess Rheo is on pause. Can't wait for RAM 7/10 Night 2

Kyle Schwarze

I'm glad night 2 actually felt like Wrestlemania from start to finish. Best parts for me were Oba winning, the ladder match being great, and a killer main event. Punk's entrance was great and the match had me excited the whole time

Sorry it’s a deadlock reference

I too would like to forget that Brock Lesnar versus John Cena happened, but besides that he was also in war games and the Rumble

Lily Petal

1. Great time for both watch alongs, thank you Luke, Oli, Dan, and Keiran, and all of the WT peeps! 2. They didn't screw up Oba and Demon Balor so YAY! 3. Summer Slam prediction for the two nights main events Oba vs Cody, Oba wins and Jacob vs Roman, Jacob wins.

Thomas westhead

Dare we say it?… that main event was pure cinema? 🤣 for real tho, that main event just made up for a whole weekend. Amazing match and now genuinely curious and excited to see what happens at Ram! Thanks for watching along with us lads, always makes wrestling better when you’re involved :) much love hh kiss

Wheels

Oba Femi winning and Roman winning night 2 didn’t disappoint. When does Wrestle League start and end this is my first time taking part?

james knight

Night two just about stopped me throwing my TV out the damn window so it did it's job. My big question in the heat of the moment is.. was it actually that good a night two or were we all just so unbelievably pissed off at night 1 anything halfway competent was going to seem amazing? Also I would have oba come out in the main event of raw to confront Roman and tell him he's coming for him but since he never shows up he's going to win king of the ring and take that title from him at summerslam. The ruler being king of the ring works too well imo and considering Roman is gonna piss off for a while it sets up oba's next couple of months up to summerslam nicely

Chris McDowell

So are we setting up Roman v Cody at Crown Jewel to finish the trilolgy?

Jo M

No point doing another really long Reign’s title run, we did everything we could with that. Make it a stark contrast to his last reign. Have it be under a day.

Michael Rivera Morales

Can't wait for all those live fans that want Roman as champ complain again that he is not there all the time😂😂

rhuds 06

Think the show overall was ok better than last night but that's not hard oba Brock decent but felt like it had more in it lader match was fun the main event was brilliant for me absolutely loved the end sequence of punk just not having it in him anymore hopefully Roman actually shows up for work but I wouldn't bet on it

General Jimmy G

See how raw goes... If it actually had more "wrestling" it would have been good.

Kevin

Night 2 was way better than night 1! Oba winning was the right choice and while I don’t like Roman winning the title because he will gone for awhile, it still was an excellent match! Also hope we get a CM Punk heel turn now.

Skip

This was hands down a fantastic show. Top to bottom. I think it could have been better. Oba Brock should have had another 5 to 10 minutes, and reigns winning are my only negatives of the evening. But overall, this is what the whole weekend should have been.

Lewis Kelly

Overall though Night two unsurprisingly was great, Oba now needs the rocket to the main event and Brock was absolutely awesome over this programme.

Rhys 'The Grease'

I think WrestleMania this year was quite good. A single night of fun matches, capped off with a terrific main event. I'm still surprised they only booked 6 matches though, we didn't even get a Cody match... Sunday was the only night of WrestleMania right?

Steve Brayford

Average mania partially saved by a good main event. All the ad breaks are annoying but gave me time to catch up on the night one podcast review. Some moments this year have felt quite amateur from a production point of view. So many views of other camera men, random shots of the light during Finns entrance. Camera man falling off the apron. The crap streamers during Balors entrance. So many shots showing refs talking to wrestlers took me out of show.

AMZ2

Much better event, still way too many ads. I can't believe how much uninterested I was with seeing Roman as champion, but after that main event I am curious for his reign a bit. Magic of CM Punk.

Jamaal Ellison

I don't understand the appeal of Cody Rhodes. As a wrestler, he seems boring, and I don't remember a single good Cody Rhodes match. Randy Orton is also a boring and ring performer, so the 2 of them together was a recipe for disaster and old enough to remember WrestleMania, 25 and seeing Randy Orton main event with Triple H and seeing how that stunk up the joint.

squevin

First time patron, love the podcast. It's refreshing to have a Wrestlemania main event with no interference, post match run-in or other such shenanigans. Feels like the first one in forever. Matches were fun, sad Je'Von didn't win but I know his time will come.

Nova

I hope a decent main event doesn't distract from the fact that this was a boring WrestleMania with more hulk hogan documentary ads and door dash commercials than wrestling. I saw more we'll be right back screens than women wrestling and the night one main event can be described as confusing and bad at best, and complete shit more accurately.

Fakeport

Nearly good enough to make me forget how dreadful night 1 was. But not quite.

Josh F

I think it was pretty clear what they are doing with Brock. He “ retires” here at WM. Gunter tells Paul he owes him the favour and it’s to get Brock out of retirement for one more match at SS

Callum Hackett

Wrestlemania 42 is a frustrating and fascinating show. The first night is pretty much the blueprint to booking the most boring show you can and the second is just a solid night of wrestling. The matches had time, the right guys won, it set up the future in Oba winning. I'm a guy who is very negative on WWE as a whole because of it trying to push down any wrestling outside of WWE but tonight was a really good show maybe a great one.

Devin McNeal

Completely agree. It was only oba/brock and punk/roman I liked. The whole weekend. Everything else was pretty shit. Thankful for Tony khan.

Stewart Meehan

WWE now have the perfect template to have Oba be the new brock by doing what they did with brock in 2014. Have him come out when roman cuts a promo on RAM, congrats roman on winning then warns him that he is only holding that belt warm as oba states he will win the KOTR, get the title shot for sunerslam and claim his throne And at SS, you do the Cena v Brock match where just destroys roman, winning with two straight fall from grace and pinning roman by putting his foot on his chest while wearing the Ula Fala.

Griff 1988

This certainly felt like TKO booking night 1 and HHH booking night 2. A far more enjoyable 2nd night.

Brad Rucka

Fun fact: CM punk v Roman was longer than all the Women's matches combined this weekend. (CMP v RR = 33:57 ; Women combined = 33:48)

Badgersprite

Didn’t watch this night either lol

Mike Hunt Burns

I haven’t watched since 2014. I was one of the ones who left along with my friend Mark, Triple H.I found night 2 marginally better and only due to the main event which I considered a very high three star to a low four star match. Every other match on day one and two, I consider a 2 to very low 3 star at best. Just felt like there was no heart in the product. The amount of ads on the ring apron and then between matches is atrocious. I have no interest in continuing to watch week to week. I’ll stick with AEW.

Jamie Stidiford

If you treat night one as the preshow it was a great show. Loved the whole show. I hope it's Oba v Roman with Oba winning at summerslam.

Joe O'Leary

First ever Patreon live stream, couldn't resist after watching night one with my 6 year old son this morning and his blind love for WWE was so infectious I initially rated it 7.5/10 which I later realised was ridiculous and I need to experience this night with grown ups! Much better than night one, but the main event match was so good it casts a shadow of the rest of the weekend...if you give the talent time to work this is what they will deliver, such an amazing roster of talent being squandered, it's infuriating.

Hannah Alan

As a whole, I took time off work for this. I don't think I needed too. Yes I'm an AEW mark, still the only match I enjoyed was the main event night 2. I could have watched it on repeat though, at its core it was a normal match. I far enjoyed the watch along more than the wrestling. Trying to get over C-old-punk. Lots of love ♥️

Sage

Having a great show like this will help people mostly forget how crappy night 1 was… it’s a shame hhh had to tank a night to get good emotions out of his audience though.

Will Campbell

I think Oba *should* be the one to beat him. Personally I wouldn't wait that long (maybe Clash?) but SS could be a good shout.

Tom Daniels

A Mania weekend that was saved by the night two opener and main event.

Oscar Vargas

That main event for me at least was the best one since 40 night 2 for sure . Punk vs reigns was a fantastic main event . But That doesn’t blind me to the fact that this years WM was the weakest in a long time . Maybes it’s back to back Vegas manias and the fact that only 2 matches going over 20 mins for a WRESTLING SHOW isn’t good and the adds are infuriating. That main event saved this show from being bottom 5 WM ever but still not a good wm .

Icarus Grimm

Way better show than Night one. Oba/Brock could have gone longer but right result. The ladder match was narly. JD's destroyer sell looked crazy. Loved the Demon/Dom match. Rhea made Jade look like a star and Punk/Reigns was emence. Loved that old man Punk just ran out of gas. 7/10. Night one 2/10

Biomonkey .

Brock vs Oba had the right winner, but the match felt like it hard cut from the opening chapter to the finale. The collar and elbow tie up, Brock taking his time on the outside, the slow suplexes - it all felt like the match was supposed to be longer than it actually was. The immediate shift into finisher, finisher, 1-2-3 was jarring.

TheNemesis

2 good matches sandwich some perfectly serviceable if underwhelming stuff in the middle on night 2. Is it enough to save this Mania as a whole? No. Is it really just how you leave them? Only if you have a short attention span. But at least now my weekend doesn't feel like a COMPLETE waste because I got like 45 minutes of decent entertainment somewhere in my 7 and a half hours of wrestling... Wait, that's kind of sad.

Don

Much better show tonight with the right winners. Pleasantly surprised that Oba won. Guess the retirer gimmick is dead in the water though. Thankfully the title is off Jade. 1 defense in 170 days is laughable. Besides those 2 matches and the main event, the other matches felt short. 8/10 tonight with a overall rating of 6/10. Night 1 dragged the entire show down and night 2 couldn't have done worse even if it tried

Ryan Cadman

Watched mania with my girlfriend - her first big show and she tanked through it. Asked her thoughts at the end of the weekend and she popped most for Brock/Oba and Roman/Punk. Goes to show not much is needed to bring a casual/non fan in other than a great story and good build

Brxdley.h

I really wanna know if you guys are still dissapointed your invite was retracted after watching mania night 1, and now after seeing how much better night 2 was and you wouldn’t have been there live. does the pro of it being a mania experience outweigh the con of it being THIS mania

macarotto

The difference between night one and night two was so stark, it really swung heavily into the positive side. The thing I wanted most was for Oba to win, but every other match also delivered in a satisfying way. I wish Iyo had gotten a full match to celebrate her excellence, but I'm happy enough that she got a moment to shine alongside Rhea. Main event was excellent, not a huge fan of Roman or Punk but I got sucked in. Loved both nights of the hangouts <3

Zack Ryder’s Wheelchair

I think you guys might be right that Night 1 was worked to make Night 2 better only because the quality was so significantly higher than Night 1. They pulled the trigger on Oba, the IC ladder match was fun and served it’s purpose, Finn brought back the trunks which is a W, and the main event was leagues ahead of last night. I’d give it a 7.5 out of 10.

Brody Allsep

You guesses on the times for the matches on the podcast individually were a bit off, but overall total was pretty spot on. Not watching, but for 3.5 hours, approximately 86 minutes bell to bell. Just under 41%. Maybe when it pops up on Netflix later I'll give a hate watch, but this year and next I will be happy to skip. Hoping if the following year is in New Orleans it will be better so I can save up and go.

David Daul

What a lopsided 2 nights of Mania! So happy to actually be excited for the main event...so intense...just what it needed to be

curiousgeorgy00

Much better than night 1. Punk vs Roman was fantastic and match of the weekend, and wwe match of the Year. Oba winning was great, and the right decision. Have him beat Roman for thr world title. The Ladder match was fun. The us title match, the womans, and the street fight were either good or fine. This show wasn't a waste of time, unlike last night. Night 1 was truly awful. It didn't feel like Wrestlemania at all. Night 1 is a 3/10 and night 2 is a 7/10. Night 2 saved Wrestlemania 42 from beginning the worst.

Nicolas Iacovo

The fix is definitely in for TKO!! Trips definitely made a petty decision and booked night two like it was his greatest creation. All jokes aside this night was great. I think every match was exactly what it needed to be, you maybe could’ve done with a little less nonsense from the Finn and Dom match, but the opening two matches were fantastic, Rhea and Jade did way better than anyone expected, and that main event lived up to the hype. Better than night 1 without a shadow of a doubt, but that is not a high standard to achieve

Kevin Fleuriot

So do we count WrestleMania as both nights ? Because night 2 is a top 5 WrestleMania for me. But night 1 drags it down a lot (obviously it could be recency bias but I loved this show top to bottom)

Andrew Baylis

An almost perfect second night, aside from a very cromulent Sami v Trick match and the wet fart of an end in Roman winning. Also, the stairs used blatantly in front of the ref should always be a DQ, no matter how much commentary tried to convince us that the ref used 'discretion'.

Thomas Lippiatt

A much better night than last night the issue with ads and match timing we’re still there however the matches were largely better And it certainly helped that we had absolute classic of a main event

Brxdley.h

Oba beating brock and brock seemingly leaving has made this night of mania a 10/10, good riddance. But honestly, if you get rid of the offensive amount of ad breaks, night 2 was genuinely a pretty decent show.

Monty Pittman

I know Roman won't be on TV alot but this was a necessary sacrifice to give the World title legitimacy. Hell of a match and he did it on his own. ☝🏾🔥

Rob Steedley

Greatest opener match ever. Now they will ruin Oba Femi. You know they will.

Oliver

Incredible how much less noticeable the ad time is when the show is actually enjoyable

Tyhlir

Much better than Night 1 but that isn't really all that hard to do lol. I'd probably give it a 7, maybe 8, out of 10. Most the matches were good but not amazing IMO. Though Punk vs Roman was a banger of a match!

James

Big E put it best on the post show. There was no interference, no nonsense, just two guys out there for a wrestling match. Just wish that was true for the rest of the show. The three best things on the show (Oba, ladder match, and Roman / Punk) were given the correct time and beats for the story they needed to tell. 3 stars.

Stabitha Christie

Night 1 3/10 Night 2 7/10 Overall 10/20.... 5/10. It was like pissing the bed and not changing the sheets, first night is uncomfortable but the second night you have a better time, you just have to ignore the stink I.e sponsers and hogan ad breaks

Steve Brayford

For years we've said that the thing WWE does so much better than AEW is their amazing video packages. But this time they didn't bother making them for most matches. They can't compete with match quality and now aren't doing what made them better. Is AEW the superior brand now? I enjoyed their B ppv in Dynasty so much more than WWEs biggest show of the year.

mike wolfe

This WM felt like two shows put on by two different companies. Night two was fantastic. Jade had the best match of her WWE career, the ladder match was as awesome as we'd all hoped it would be, Oba and Brock went exactly as it should, and that main event was absolutely incredible. Still would've liked to see Iyo vs Asuka, they had the time.

Gabi Vazquez

hello my friends hope you are all well do u think this is the biggest jump in quality between manias

Michael Trayner

I think we can look at 2 night Wrestlemanias as one show with the night 1 main event as the mid point. As a whole I would say the show was able to stick the landing and round off into a decent Wrestlemania.

Joshua Bathers

Old man Punk retirement storyline can go down as one of the greatest ever. Other than the main event, a terrible showcase of what wrestling has become with adverts.

Magic Man Dan

I think Roman vs Punk will be the only match I'll go back and rewatch from this Mania. Maybe the ladder match as well. I really thought we were past the whole "one-match mania" era, but this is definitely one of them. Nothing was outright awful. Just nothing really of substance. But I guess that's par for the course of today's WWE. TKO seems to care more about how many "famous" people they can get on camera, talking about wrestling rather than actually wrestling, and how many fucking ads they can cram into five minutes. Oh, and also trying to get you to watch a documentary about a racist, wife-shagging bellend.

BlackHawk

Cody Roman 3 is gonna be a champ vs champ match at Crown Jewel

Charles Berg

Hey guys. It's a bit odd doing it this way. I used to pay 5 bucks and you were forced to read my bullshit. But maybe ill be chosen by you. It will do wonders for my self esteem im sure. Night 2 was considerably better than night 1. Although that isnt much of a feat. Its like beating a legless man in a race. Not only did matches feel longer, they all had drama that seemed to be missing from saturday. the overall night was shorter and those factors did make the ads less awful. Call me crazy but if you buy a wrestling show you shouldnt have to watch commercials. I think night two is a solid show, however the stink of night one cant be fully washed off. Take care, JTJ.

Blake Whitehouse

Show was ruined for me because Netflix kept kicking me off for using a VPN. Tried doing everything I could for an hour before calling it quits.

Faheem_786

This was night and day compared to night 1. It wasn't fantastic but the bar was set very low. Roman and Punk had a great match. The other matches were fine. It was fun watching along with the livestream.

Calcote Comics

Overall, this Mania has killed pretty much all interest I have in WWE. It’s clear they are only focused on milking as much money ass possible with no care or interest in the fans. The booking is a mess, characters make next to no sense, and the sheer lack of WRESTLING on a wrestling show is an insult to the sport. I have lost all faith, and outside of WrestleTalk videos, I have no interest in watching anything they offer for the foreseeable future.

oak_slaney

Wow what a stark difference between the two nights. Oba v Brock went exactly how it should've, would be surprised if that's the last we see of him though, Gunther's favour should be that retirement match. IC title match was excellent, was pleasantly suprised by Jade and Rhea, and maybe the best main event i've seen in a very long time from WWE. That failed GTS and swipe at reigns were genuinely heartbreaking but perfect for that old man punk story.

Vectron44

I think the opportunity is there on Raw for Roman to crow about putting Punk out to pasture, then have Oba Femi come out and stare him down and Roman suddenly falling back on old heelish habits as he becomes hypocritical about letting go.

Joseph Machado

I'm firmly on Oli's Night 1 sabotage conspiracy theory. The Vegas post-apocolyptic shit-show barren wasteland themed TKO show replaced by HHH's sleek and quality product he knows fans will like more. It's night and day how much better Night 2 was and I think Roman v Punk is an all-time Mania match.

darth Jmarks

Did low blows get nerfed this year?

Arron

this night was a definite improvement but wwe is just so hard to watch right now, 8 minute breaks after every match take you right out of it after anything good happens. i do not see how kids watching wwe nowadays will stay engaged with that and continue to be fans until adulthood. can luke bring back his “THIS COMPANY” catchphrase now?

Julian Barragan

while Punk vs Reigns was good (tho it also felt that they cut out the last 10 mins of it) this is still the most boring mania i have ever seen live.

Gali

Mania weekend was as if mother was yelling at you to let your brother play too, so you let him book night one. Followed by telling him to hold my juice box.

Charles Lawley

Adam Weistman, CEO of Upstate Shredding, the silent guest commentator made Night 2. Get him into the 2027 Hall Of Fame.

Simon Gildroy

We've gone back in time. Rhea,liv, roman and cody as champs. So much for elevating new people into the main event. Oba and Trick will get there but it'll take a while with this booking

taylordonaldson65

As much as I loved Punk vs Roman, Oba vs Brock, and the ladder match, I can't help but still feel let down by the product TKO (and therefore WWE) are presenting. There is not a single match on Night 1 or Night 2 (bar the main event) that couldn't have benefitted from going a handful of minutes more. On Saturday there was a sense before everything started that at least the in-ring work was going to be far less lethargic than the build itself, but we were shown The Cone Zone and Much Love Brother HH the Movie far more than we were the wrestling product we paid to see. Night 1 was nothing more than a random Raw episode from the middle of 2023, and while Night 2 ended far better, it suffered from the same issue of (mostly) no style, nor substance in favour of ads, more ads, and a tiny bit more ads. It'll be talked about until we're blue in the face (as it should) but the indifference that TKO has regarding putting on a meaningful WRESTLING show is so deflating. I feel like if I hadn't been watching with the live reactions on Pateron, I'd have turned off Night 1 halfway through, and not even bothered with Night 2. Now, we're strapped in for part-time Roman. As much as I enjoyed the main event, I don't think that should absolve WWE of how disappointing this weekend was.

Simon Gildroy

Also I can't believe the club wwe blimp had a QR code leading to the wrestletalk podcast

Tom Garrett

I fear we have seen the future of WWE. And it is a grim, TKO-authored dystopia, with a few glimmers of greatness amidst a very dark sky (sponsored by Dude Wipes and the Cone Zone).

Simon Gildroy

It was like having a McDonalds as a meal. Perfectly ok but doesn't blow you away

frogpaste75

beautiful main event, dont think i've ever seen a crowd split like that in a wwe main event - cant think of one off the top of my head, it elevated the match even more for me. wish people just tried to appreciate the build and the story they told instead of shitting on the "you're old" line and constant speculating of the rock because i thought it played into the match excellently.

James Ford

Incredible show, Roman/Punk just delivered one of the matches of the year so far, Jade/Rhea was surprisingly great, ladder match was great as expected and so glad Brock put over Oba as the next big thing. This show was a proper WrestleMania

TheOldSparkle

Really enjoyed the show. The main event was excellent, but now we have Roman as champion barely showing up. Doesn't make much sense unless it's a short reign.

Stew Sizer

A weekend of two halves, night 1 was a dark place of too many ads with one shining light. Night 2 was a beacon of what WWE can be when they let wrestlers do their job and give them time. Still too much time given to Hogan though

Stew Sizer

Imagine if Iyo vs Asuka was added to night 2. It would've been a 9/10 show

Mick Kerrigan

I enjoyed both main events. But it’s obvious that the ESPN deal came with requirements on length, frequency and gap between ad breaks. The under card on both nights was starved for drama due to time, I think you can find less than a handful of false finishes in the undercard. You need a variety of matches on a 7-8 hour card. Leaving the main events out, the ladder match and bits of the demon vs dom were good and the rest was too predictable and underdeveloped (even ignoring build)

Magic Man Dan

P.S. Oli, STOP PLAYING THAT FUCKING SONG

Finn

Really enjoyed night 2, it suffered all the same issues as night 1 with too many ads and short matches but the quality of the matches were much better and made it a very enjoyable show especially the main event.

Lex Sells Merch

Bye bye Bork. I can’t say I’ll miss him. Rest of the matches were decent. Even Rhea finally dragged Jade to a good match

Prag24

Night 1 Felt more out of touch with the fambase than vince did coming to the end of his run. The only remotely redeeming quality was rolling gunther that I'm sure was only put on night one to both make it look like a match of the year contender in comparison to the other stuff around it. The quality of the matches as a while was nowhere near good enough to quantify the lack of wrestling that we actually got to see. And I can say with absolute certainty that I wouldn't notice nor would I care if night 1 was removed from netflix. Night 2 There was a similar ad issue but they didn't feel as bad whether that was due to the match quality being better or night one wearing me down and getting me used to it. The match quality was better with it seeming like there was actual care for the matches but still not the wrestlemania quality that should be showcased. The main event was really the main if not only saving grace for advertmania 42 with roman and punk putting on a clinic. Overall The crowd for night 2 seemed so much more into it which doesn't really surprise me considering the 2 openers. The main event of night one left alot to be desired but was luckily overshadowed by night 2s main event. Wwe needs a real refresh over the next few months, building oba up to challenge for a world championship hopefully at summerslam and getting more young talent showcased as the current main eventers won't be round much longer and we can't keep relying on bringing out slow working randy because we don't have any other heels we wanna put with cody. Hopes Cody and punk should both fully turn heel. Cody just needs a refresh. I think he should drop the title in the next few months then visit the us title scene for a while. Punks could play the story of cheating when he was younger because it was easier but now he has to do it to stay at the top of the card. Like a fallen angel type of character. I'm disappointed with the whole weekend but pleased with how it ended and while I'm not necessarily excited to see where they go now. I am definitely intrigued.

Lee Bauer

Brock retiring tracks with his introvert nature. If he is actually retired I'm glad he put over Oba

MoOnaMission

Can't believe they interrupted my adverts with their wrestling

James Stevenson

Much better than last night. Demon and Dom could have used more time, but everything else was good. Main event was awesome, ladder match was great, Oba vs Brock was perfect. Really liked this show. Also to the arsehole who stole my Jacob Fatu hat, screw you.

Jonnathon The BBQ Nerd

Night 2 was a vast improvement over Night 1. Of all the matches that could have gone short, Oba/Lesnar was the only one I thought should have. While Lesnar's farewell- for now- might have been tainted by real world scandals, it was definitely an emotional moment for the crowd. The ladder match was very fun indeed, and the main event was great! The run time on the other matches did hurt a bit, and the fact that Balor/Dom ended in a top rope dive through a table just like Drew/Jacob did make things repetitive. Same with the interference in the Women's title match. But the right folks won all night, newer talent got a much-needed spotlight, and there were no outright stinkers.

Md Tahjeeb Hossain Chowdhury

Talk about a one-match weekend. But night 2 was close to more of a Wrestlemania feel, feeling that Brock said "if I'm losing today, then no retirement storyline" or dunno really. I have a suspicion that night 1 was done as a 2016-2019 Raw to show TKO "see? Your ideas mean [word for excrement]". Crowd was way louder today. Ladder match was what it needed to be, Rhea-Jade did better than any women's match from yesterday, dom-finn was....okay, Oba-Brock was short but right, and Main Event was proper wrestling storytelling. Glad I stayed up for it.

Gorilla Martini

The main event was really good, potentially top 15 ever but definitely top 20. Overall night 2 was much of the same as night 1, too short of matches and too long of waits killed all the momentum. I consider WM42 a bottom 10 Mania, and honestly, maybe even bottom 5. Jam that Jam

Whole F'N Show JayMula

Trouble Trouble that's Toonnyyy.... Khan and Darby after that Roman Punk Main Event. Just Jokes, but night 2 really felt like WM and night 1 felt like the 1st hour on ESPN. Roman Punk delivered, no run ins no shenanigans just 2 great wrestlers putting on great a match.

chrisg146

John Cena with Little Hausens and Roman after Punk wadded up tape and threw it at him are two WTF faces I was not expecting tonight.

Ben Pavett

Sure, Night 1 sucked. Night 2 however, was great. The ladder match was awesome. Oba beating Brock with a single fall from grace in under 10 minutes was insane. Trick v Sami was good. Didnt watch Balor v Dominic but I can only assume it was also very good. Nor did I watch Rhea v Jade so can’t comment there. That main event though!! Bringing back Miseria Cantera for Punk was a nice touch. Roman being champ again is, well, a choice..

Sam Hedges

Personally, I loved night 2, and I feel like night 1 was overhated, and I liked the main event. But night 2 was very good, and I think it sets up a very interesting looking raw after mania that im looking forward to

BTKaisen

So, WWE can book a good Wrestlemania night? WTF was last night about then?! I was so hesitant about getting ESPN+ after last night, but I had hope that night 2 was gonna at least better than 1, and it was! Match length was still a problem and not all the matches had the best stories going in, but they were all mostly great. Standouts for me were Oba dominating, Rhea vs. Jade, and despite not liking the winner, the main event between Punk and Roman. It was exceptional; a proper, well-worked, and intense Mania main event to be remembered and that others have worded more beautifully than I can online. It frustrates me that WWE is the way it is right now, because night 2 proves they can put on a good show, but they keep messing things up. He may be a hypocrite and not always stand by his morals, but CM Punk is the goddamn man. He’s so special to me. He always manages to truly bring out my love of wrestling (at least within WWE) and remind me why I fell in love with this sport. That includes you guys, Wrestletalk. I’ve been a fan of you all since 2017 when I was 16, and now I’m 25. You guy’s always manage to keep my love of wrestling alive when the going is good and I can’t be anymore thankful.

Ieuan Hurford

A vast, VAST improvement over night 1, I think punks heel turn is inevitable on raw, and I hope oba squashes Roman on raw too

Matt Patrick

Watching Oba Femi throw Brock Lesnar into the air for a fall from grace is equal parts horrifying and majestic. If it’s legit, having Oba retire Brock was a brilliant decision.

Mohammed Albanai

Is it me or did Cody, Sami and punk (cus of the low blow). All worked heel. Not saying it's bad, it's just strange that they were presented as baby faces during the build, then worked as heels during their matches

Harry Jackson

Typical wwe when their backs are against the wall. Pulled it out the bag tonight. Even the Danhausen bit made me laugh. Theme throughout both nights was them bastard adverts man. Seen more of hulk hogan than my own mother this weekend. I do wonder how the wrestlers feel with such short times for their matches. Main event was superb from start to finish and night two I really enjoyed

Bdazzle

so SOOOOOO much better than night one, i tuned in around the end of the rhea match and felt like it was really good, the brock retirement damn i mean okay?, but the punk match was sooo good the story telling at the end was great

Lawson Douvier

Nah, it would make me respect him even less if that was the case, and I already have no respect for him. That would be such an awful thing to do to the talent on night 1. But I can’t put anything past that scumbag.

Dev King

Few words, Cam’ron and mases’ interview with jey uso

Tom Shucksmith

Much better tonight yet again for another Mania night one is below par only for night two to smash expectations

bongo

If Cody Randy had been in the middle of the card tonight and Oba Brock main evened last night, with the exact same results, this whole mania would be multiple grades higher.

KidCutty

Night 2 was some 🔥 AT this point people are gonna complain so just let em 🤷🏿‍♂️ but maaannn My son and I had some fun with this show tonight! Even the IWC cant ruin these memories for me 🥹

Hollywood33

... Trick winning with his finisher feels empty?

Brent

I meant that the finish wasn't as exciting it could have been. I'm fine with Trick winning with the Trick Shot but wanted more an exciting Trick Shot. The way it happened is okay on Smackdown but not Wrestlemania.

Craig

So Jade holds the belt for a little over 5 months, has 1 defence against jordynne grace, then the moment it's confirmed bianca isn't coming back she drops the belt in her first big feud against an establiahed superstar. No alexa, asuka, charlotte etc. Either wwe have no faith in her or she was literally just brought in for a bianca feud and now they don't know what to do with her.

Paul (The King)

Wrestlemania Night 2 was the best Wrestlemania of all time!! Purely for one guy - future G.O.A.T Danhausen! .... Just a shame that we have to deal with yet another Roman & Rhea title reign 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

Jimmys Stuff

Was it better the night one: by far. Was I too drained by the first night to enjoy it: almost. I'm disappointed about WWE's future I haven't seen a 5/5 "big" show from them in a minute.

Magnus Grey

Punk losing was such a shock to my boyfriend that we're LITERALLY at the hospital right now because he was having chest pain. (he's fine, btw! it was a false alarm that we have actually been monitoring all day, but he gave me permission to make the joke)

Ilan Woll

That might be Jade Cargill’s best match ever, add in a fantastic opener and main event and I was really happy.

“Chump Mark” Adam Corona

I believe the Lesnar retirement angle is a set up to baby face him for a real retirement match at summerslam vs Gunther. Gunther is owed a favor by Paul Heyman and I believe Gunther will terrorize heyman over the next few months leading Brock to coming out of his “retirement” to have a real retirement main event in his home state as a face at summerslam.

John Hall

I feel like this WrestleMania was our introduction to the new AD-itude Era. Next year, it’ll be called ADiMania.

mike wolfe

Also, God tier entrance by Punk. As someone who has followed him since those ROH days that was amazing. I really loved that the main event had no runs ins, no ref bumps, no bloodline shenanigans, etc.

Thevivalajady

Awful 2 nights of advertising with a touch of sub par not mania wrestling sprinkled on the side.

Luke Kelly

I can’t stand the ads, the Hogan documentary ads played so much that my sister, who couldn’t be more of a non wrestling fan asked, “is Hulk Hogan the best wrestler in WWE at the moment” I said “he’s dead” and she was like “oh why have they played the same thing 10 times” and all I could do was shake my head. So much time spent on a guy who you will never see wrestle again, and you’ve got 7 minute matches at WrestleMania. IMO, if there’s a title match at Mania, the match time should be 10 minutes minimum, but no, I have to watch bs ads. Also, they only played video packages for the main events, all that dead air, you could’ve put some video packages to build the matches

Dev King

Really though, i think this is Gunther’s storyline for Heyman, the favor is pulling brock out of retirement

ATallstalls

This was a brilliant night 2 and whilst the wrestlers will get all the praise in the main event and rightly so I want to give a shout out to the referee who told a story of his own getting frequently more annoyed with the actions of both men and what he was having to let go despite both men breaking the rules in more and more blatant ways he sold it really well

Justin A. Thomas

Night 1 was so disappointing that I honestly didn't get into Night 2 until the main event. If Brock is done, at least he put over someone under 40 on his way. I can't watch another WWE hardcore match with the same kendo stick and table spots. I don't need thumbtacks and skewers but at least get some color. Overall: the matches were still too short and there were still too many ads. Loved the main event and the ladder match.

Adam Cav bae bae

Assuming it's a real retirement the fact that a move called "The Fall from grace" was what did him in is pretty hilarious

Brandon Rummel

I liked the majority of this night. However it felt like I was saying “this is good” in comparison to a shit first night rather than “this is good” objectively. Up until the main event of course. Jade significantly impressed me.

Brandon

I have no idea if that was actually a really good show or a really good show in comparison to yesterday

Peter Brantuas

So the main event of night 2, which is regarded now as good to great, had a 4 to 5 minute out of the ring series and it’s okay because it’s WWE? No, it’s not okay as I’ve listened to far to many complaints when other companies do that.

Derrick Taylor

So I guess we’re getting Roman/Cody III after all - night of champions… yay

Brad Rucka

Match by match review: Oba v Brock: Quick, fun, decent simple story. You'd think Brock's retirement would have more weight behind it and/or build up too it. Sort of makes sense, I guess. Let's hope they don't fumble Oba and waste this. Kind of bummed we won't get a Gunther/Brock match (which I thought they were going to do for the "favour" Gunther got for taking out Seth, but oh well...getting Brock to job 2 shows in a row is a hard sell, so it would likely mean Oba getting the legs cut out from under him, so this is better) 6-pack ladder match: Fun and quick paced....but this feels like a mid-card match from the late 2000's/early 2010s where a lot happens, but nothing happens or matters. Especially when half of the participants got jobber entrances....on Wrestlemania. That tells you right there "don't care about these guys". Still, everyone got their 1 spot and took at least 1 big bump. Right winner, but no one stood out. No stars were made and don't expect anything to come from this. Trick v Sami: The strong fan reaction against Sami in the build and lack of time to actually tell a real story ruined this. Sami went from one of the best and most compelling babyfaces with the capabilities to have a slow burn heel turn, back to someone in joke segments with bad props, bad jokes and bad builds (see Bobby Lashley's sisters as an example) I feel like they pivoted hard to make this fit the "if you're going to treat Sami like a heel, we will make him the heel". Embracing the heel was the worst decision of this night and him losing as a heel rather than a rejected babyface buries him. Most disappointing match of the night but not the weekend. Moving on... Balor v Dom: Fun and decent match, but nothing overly memorable. Doesn't really strike me as a deeply personal blowoff to a multi-year breakup story. The best of the actual "No DQ" matches this weekend, but that doesn't take much. (although they have curiously similar endings...) This match only makes me wonder, "what is next for Balor?" Dom is safe as the Judgement Day doesn't seem to be going anywhere with Liv's win. Scared Balor is going to disappear into the booking void.... Rhea v Jade: Better than expected. Jade had her working hair on. In a vacuum, this was good. When put on the same weekend as the similarly interference ladened Women's World Championship match (this match was 3 mins longer, BTW), this makes me be more disappointed in the Night 1 showing. Still just perplexed by the billionaire that paid to silent ogle the pretty girls from the the commentary booth.... Danhausen: Loved it. Dumb fun. I can see Cena pushing hard for involvement in this. Cena even got a his chance to bury young talent. The smoke bomb at the end in full lighting with no attempt to hide it...Comedy. Gold. Protect this man and gimmick at all costs. Reigns v Punk: FINALLY, a match that didn't feel rushed, although, giving you time to slow down and think didn't do it so much of a favour. About 15 mins in, I had to stop and ask "so....what's trying to be accomplished here? What are they trying to say?" Turns out it was "Punk isn't a kid anymore and can't go all night" but that didn't flare up until the end. The pace wasn't that fast that Punk couldn't keep up....he just gave out at the end. Punk did the wild, missed tired swipe that he did at the end once near beginning, but that was about it. It seemed more about ego, because whenever someone stopped to taunt, they momentum switched...but that was soon abandoned. It was still a great and enjoyable match, but not the classic that it might end up being remembered as. It benefited from lessoned expectations from the rest of the weekend and card. Also, BIG kudos for the restraint in having no interference. You could feel the tension during the double down for people to expect someone to come out... Overall Day 2: I think this was a perfectly adequate night of Wrestlemania. Benefitted from a piss poor night 1, so that expectations were lowered. 7/10. I wish I have only seen this night. Overall Weekend: This reminds me SOOO much of X8 if it was split into 2 nights. Only real difference is that they put the right match on last, so people have a better final impression of it. Disappointing weekend, even with the crummy and disjointed build. Wrestlemania 31 actually hurts this one, because it gave us hope that "bad build might make good matches", but nope....money and corporate greed to maximize profits with advertisements and sponsorships took away from that. This truly was the Superbowl for Wrestling... Not the worst Mania by a long shot. It suffered from being compared to prior years setting any real expectations. Final rating: We'll be right back: 3.59/10

TroyWolf1990

By far night two was better than night one Punk v Roman was spectacular story telling though I'm still scratching my head at the stairs spot not being a DQ when Rhea was DQ'd for less against Charlotte at backlash 2021 speaking of Rhea v Jade was far better than what I thought it was going to be and that Jaded counter into the Riptide was so Smooth. Overall I give Night 2 of Mania a 7 out of 10

Eric Kearney

Best match of the two nights was punk v Roman, but seeing Oba’s interview afterwards. Do you see oba dethroning Roman?

SirFoop

Two/three good matches on an 8 hour show don't a good Wrestlemania make

Mr. Samuel Scratch

Genuinely went into tonight convinced they were going to "swerve" the audience with Oba Femi/Lesnar. I'm glad they chose the obvious, far more satisfying, result.

Khalid Tirawi

WrestleMania Night One was the WrestleMania Night Two go home show, that's why it was such a drastic difference in quality

Shavinder

It felt like night 1 main event copied night 2’s homework and rushed to hand it in first, but didnt realize why night 2 put those answers and ended up with a messy result. The “phases of cody” entrance worked far better for Punk’s “old man phil” story, along with the desperate low blow and methodical pace

Shavinder

That would mean he intentionally ruined a fully priced product fans paid exhorbitant prices for and overstressed his talent to put on a good show with heavy restrictions, just to stick it to his bosses. Thats not praise worthy imo

JamieG

A good ending to a mediocre mania. Oba vs Brock was good with enough high impact to enjoy. Rhea had a good reversal to end an okay match. The ladder match had some fantastic spots though ending did just seemed to happen. And while the street fight had more violence than the unsanctioned match, both left me unimpressed. Punk and Roman did some heavy lifting at the end, but I can't deny they did it well with great wrestling and story telling. Its how you leave them as they say and I will say that was a sweet ending, but not enough to remove the sour taste of night 1.

Peter Siddorn

Night 2 much better then Night 1 but then it wasn't a hard bar to clear. Also know I can just skip RAW now since the world champ won't bother to show up most weeks.

kyle McAllister

Great Mania. Glad Rhea is champ again, now to get Iyo a title. And the Old man punk story was so well told. I’m especially glad they went back to only one night. Having a shit night 1 could have really tainted this show.

Rakaihautu Kereama-Thomas

Cargill and Rhea both being heels, one for hitting the OWA and the other for kicking out 🤣

Real One's Georgie Tuffs

Wreslemania night 2 Brock Femi ⭐⭐⭐ 3/4 - loved it for what it was with right finish and match length, with all that said, I'm rating wrestling, and can't rate matches under 10minutes above 4 stars Ladder match ⭐⭐⭐⭐ - great advert for the lucho scene, lots of fund with some inventive spots Zayn ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2 - good match, good amount of wrestling, however, screamed of SNME rather than mania Finn ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2 - liked the match. Took 2/3 of the fight to happen before came really invested. Stip was dumb, think their should be some differences between a street fight to a no dq. Where are the street signs and shopping trolleys?! Jade ⭐⭐⭐ 3/4 - Enjoyed more than expected. Gave them time to work. Think Jade looked good considering the limitations I believe she has in ring. I was waiting for the interferences to happen that did happen but didn't see rhea winning. Special shout out to IYO for sorting out the nip slip while flipping. She got this match an extra 1/4 star cause she turned up. Reigns ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 1/4 - was it a 5 star meltzer, no. Was it a wrestling masterclass, no. Was it a wrestlemania main event. Hell yea, it felt special and they both told a story. 5 mins from end was close to going 4 1/2 stars but thought the finish was weak for a mania main event. Night 2 mania ⭐ ⭐⭐ 3/4- better than night 1, was shorter and had more time dedicated to wrestling which is what I like to see. However. This is all mediocre wrestling and the pomp does help with mania. I would not be happy is a company like AEW had given me this show. [4/20, 07:26] Georgie Tuffs: Wreslemania night 2 Brock Femi ⭐⭐⭐ 3/4 - loved it for what it was with right finish and match length, with all that said, I'm rating wrestling, and can't rate matches under 10minutes above 4 stars Ladder match ⭐⭐⭐⭐ - great advert for the lucho scene, lots of fun with some inventive spots Zayn ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2 - good match, good amount of wrestling, however, screamed of SNME rather than mania Finn ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2 - liked the match. Took 2/3 of the fight to happen before came really invested. Stip was dumb, think there should be some differences between a street fight to a no dq. Where are the street signs and shopping trolleys?! Jade ⭐⭐⭐ 3/4 - Enjoyed more than expected. Gave them time to work. I think Jade looked good considering the limitations I believe she has in the ring. I was waiting for the interferences to happen that did happen but didn't see rhea winning. Special shout out to IYO for sorting out the nip slip while flipping. She got this match an extra 1/4 star cause she turned up. Reigns ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 1/4 - was it a 5 star meltzer, no. Was it a wrestling masterclass, no. Was it a wrestlemania main event. Hell yea, it felt special and they both told a story. 5 mins from end was close to going 4 1/2 stars but thought the finish was weak for a mania main event. Night 2 mania ⭐ ⭐⭐ 3/4- better than night 1, was shorter and had more time dedicated to wrestling which is what I like to see. However. This is all mediocre wrestling and the pomp does help with mania. I would not be happy if another company (not saying who) had given me this show.

Real One's Georgie Tuffs

*Wrestlemania weekend rating* ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2- first up wrestlemania was saved from being a poor show by night 2. That being said, thinking about what wrestlemania is ment to represent, the greatest show in the wrestling calendar, it was lackluster. I had 3/13 matches recieving 4 stars and not a single match at 5 star quality. I respect everyone has their preferences but I think you're mad to have had a 5 star match rating this weekend. This show was at the level I expect a fair summerslam PLE, not Mania. Another note from the weekend, nobody left mania with anything set up going forward, shows the lack of imagination in creative at the moment

Cerebral Rage

Night 1: Your place of employment promised a bonus for months, talking it up about how amazing it’s going to be, only to get a pizza party and an Amazon giftcard by your supervisors and the C-Suite. Then you hear that your supervisors decided to prove a point to the C-suite by giving you exactly what the C-Suite wanted, even though your supervisors know it’ll make people quit or think about leaving. Night 2: The next day at work your supervisors announce that you will actually be getting a moderate bonus, a slight raise, and one extra day off a year. But there is no accountability or acknowledgment about how their ploy affected you. Thanks for the actual stuff that might help, but now you don’t trust anyone at your job. And you can be grateful and joyful as well as insulted and disgusted by the treatment.

Sedin Magic15

I think, and hope, that Brock actually retired. Oba retiring him is so much better that Gunther retiring him. I don't care about Gunther or his "career killer" gimmick

Gregg Murphy

They absolutely botched brock and oba, ended the match while it was in 2nd gear. Rusev, JD and Dragon Lee not getting their entrances shown because of ads is criminal.

Eric#13

As much as the Main Event was maybe good, I just cant deal with ANOTHER Part time Championship reign by Roman. Give me new faces as World Champions

Jonathan “The Headmaster” Hedman

I just wish that Netflix treated mania or other PLE‘s the same way that they raw with exclusive content instead of the five minutes of be right back in different languages or the Hulk Hogan trailer. Also I cried when Punks ROH theme played. (I did at Revolution against MJF also and that one I was there live lol)

Jonathan “The Headmaster” Hedman

For what it’s worth Roman said he’s going to be a raw and said something like Summer of Roman If true I’m going to be happy

Eric#13

I guess time will tell, I would be happy to be wrong

Cooper

Michael Cole’s use of (and defense) a slur regarding short-statured people was… a choice.

DevanDumbStuff

A much better show than yesterday. Saves this mania from being legit bottom tier. Despite my enjoyment of this night, this is still the coldest I've felt coming out of mania since 32. Of everyone, I'm only really interested in the trajectory of Trick and Oba after this. 40 people wrestled on mania over the weekend and I came away only wanting to see two of them. That feels so bad. Hate the current state of WWE. Hope it gets better, especially for the women.

CJ Sharp

Is this the best they can serve up for the money?? Time to move on from this set of main event wrestlers. Slow, turgid and power sappingly mundane. 2.5/5. The whole weekend was like watching a Christmas Special of Last of the Summer Wine. I think the thoughts of Triple H tanking night one are spot on although Night Two wasn’t classic either

deztista

This only proves that 2 nights don't work , night 1 was a disaster while night 2 was a classic like WM , in the record books they will say skip night 1and watch night 2 but that shouldn't be case it should be a whole and reviwed as one and WWE/TKO need to fix this qickly before Summerslam.

jad_ofalltrades

I've come in here before I have even finished the show, the fact that there was jobber entrances, people didn't get to have their entrances live during the ladder match because there were ads, is absolutely disgraceful, everyone has talked about how Oba and Brock should just be spots and shouldn't be that long...but goddamn it should've been longer than that.

Georgi Pelov

Roman to Punk I'm sorry I hate you that's how I should have ended

Ben

Longtime first time, Oliver Guinness out of a glass not stright out of the can please and thanks Jam that jam

Zac Silk

Oba has to take the belt off Roman before the end of the year. Strap the rocket to him.

Charlie Wood

My big takeaway from this weekend is the ads. I get that sponsorship is important and I commend WWE for getting the bag but it seems like when building the show they place the adverts and sponsorships first then build the matches around as filler rather than the other way around. Apart from that, Night 2 was a great show and every match was enjoyable, when it comes to end of year awards you're gonna have to split the two nights for the votes.

C Mac

Watched the first match of night 2 with my mate who doesn’t follow wrestling at all. Said the only thing he’d seen in his social feeds from night 1 was the Speed frog splash. He was captivated by Oba and was asking loads of questions about him. Think it’s the only thing they got properly right all weekend

G the B (Greg the Bastard)

Hi guys! I was away for Saturday night so didnt see it live, watched it Sunday afternoon within 2 hours as skipped all the adverts. Was planning on just watching Oba v Brock live but it's fucking Wrestlemania season so ended up watching the whole Sunday live. Were the gaps between matches shorter for Sunday compared to Saturday as I didnt think it was that bad? I obviously can't compare the two myself. Also, There's a Hulk Hogan documentary coming out soon. Not sure if you guys were aware so just spreading the word!

Jack McEwen-Quy

Watched Punk vs Reigns with my wife who isn't a wrestling fan. She enjoyed it but kept shouting kiss when they locked up and you know what maybe a lil kiss was all that match needed 9.5/10

Homerstar

I’m kind of confused why everyone is hyping this night up so much. Besides the main event it had all the same problems as Night 1, matches ending before they really got going. Again, none of the matches were bad, but it really didn’t feel like Mania until the main event. It feels like people want to give WWE the benefit of the doubt but I don’t think they deserve it.

Guy

I can think of one potentially compelling thing that might come out of Wrestlemania this year, but I think it would come at the expense of having more than one good story to work with. Now that Cody and Roman are both World Champions, having the next Crown Jewel be their rematch could be big, especially if they lean the right ways in to their respective face/heel changes. But that would almost certainly knock multiple other wrestlers out of the top spots, since building to that would make it obvious that nobody was beating either man until whenever Crown Jewel happens (if it does at all this year). Honestly, I'd much rather see Oba take the belt off of Roman tomorrow night, or at least in the near future, not to mention doing something other than the Cody story that's been frankly bogging down the WWE Championship contention for quite some time now in my opinion. Maybe if Crown Jewel were in a month, and we got Cody turning steadily more ruthless and heel by then, it could work well. But I have this sinking feeling that WWE might see dollar signs in the prospect of the Cody/Roman rematch with that structure. I'm not very confident in most of their storytelling or booking as of late, but I hope to be proven wrong.

Harriett (Manga Girl)

Both shows were very much a chalk and cheese in comparison. Night two was way better than night one. Just a shame that both nights couldn't have been set to the same standard

Harry Burke

I just know that somewhere Dave Meltzer is quivering with rage at Jade doing the One Winged Angel and then Rhea having the gall to kick out

Monty Pittman

Well my last comment aged like Oli's takes.... Triple H got Roman to stay full time 4D chess against TKO

Chris Harrison

The ads for mania unfortunately follow the same structure ofcombat sports presentation in UFC/Boxing. I am not saying I like it but I am familiar with the structure so it doesn’t annoy me as much. P.S Luke Owen you are a genius I now also use the keep brushing technique to the tune of rollin by Limp Bizkit and it works every time. Thank you for parental advice with my side of wrestling!!!!

Tariq Ali

Night 2 of mania was a marked improvement on night 1, which is probably the most backhanded compliment I have given in a long while. Don’t get me wrong Oba vs Lesnar was good, especially since Oba just won clean with his move. But much like night one, matches are way too short to feel befitting the WM stage. I skipped the ads and down time and IT´S STILL atrocious to watch. This is compounded by the woman being shafted on both nights with too little time and both title matches ending with interference shenanigans. I realized before the main event that there have been No big entrances either. I guess they would´ve hurt TKO´s bottom line of the show. Overall night two is probably a 2/5 and both nights combined are in my book the worst mania since 32. WWE wont go away, but with the path they are currently on, the fans will and do.

BlackBruceWayne

No Iyo vs. Asuka? Even though the Kabuki Warriors weren’t needed on Night 1 so both were free? Even though we SAW Iyo in Rhea’s match— wait hold on, what’s that smell? Luke, you smell that? Oli, I know you smell that. Ohhhh I know what it is. it’s BULLshit! Thanks WWE! You’ve done it again =D

Lando

Says alot when HHH doesn't make an appearance on either night of Wrestlemania... Even he didn't want his name associated with this Aditude era

welly

I'm not sure if everyone would love night 2 so much if night 1 wasn't what it was. Also, as a lover of women's wrestling, I am disappointed with the whole weekend.

Dan

After falling out of love with WWE years ago, I tend to only watch Royal Rumble and WM each year, and so far this year I've learned they are not worth watching live with the ridiculous breaks in between matches and how garish the ring looks with all that branding (silly thing but that Credit One turn buckle branding looked awful). Night 1 was just terrible but I enjoyed night 2. Not amazing but entertaining at least. Shame they didn't commit to Punks full AFI entrance but it is what it is. However, from now on I'll catch clips of their PLEs on YouTube, it seems this is how they've designed it as live is unwatchable. Followed AEW since the start and although PPVs are long, they are stacked and flow so well, so this ad-first format felt very jarring. Half the fun of a PPV is feeling part of this massive show, however I felt like I was being excluded from the arena for prolonged periods.

Nathan Lopez

Main event was awesome. Also Roman laughing after he sandbagged the backslide attempt was sick.

Lucas Viola

Long time viewer, bought the pateron for the first time using the code RAMPAT for 50% off my first month. Very happy with night 2. Even though apart from the main event, every match needed an extra 5 minutes. Looking forward to the Hogan documentary. Excited for the episode decided to his "Jam That Jam" tattoo.

Matt

I would love to know who to properly blame. Is it HHH? I don’t think so, he’s creative and ads are business deductions. But is it TKO or is it ESPN? I’m annoyed I just want to be annoyed at the proper party

Badseed

Night 2 better than Night 1, that's not saying much though, Can't disagree with any of the booking choices save that there should have been more match time and Iyo and Asuka deserved a match. Hopefully Roman's first opponent is Oba who takes it off of him.

Kevin

My comment about Roman leaving for awhile aged like milk

JJ Bittenbinder

Roman saying on the post show that he is back full time reminds me of The Rock in 2011 saying he's back home You better keep your word And also please drop it to Oba Femi 😅

Hamzah Al Qadi

This was complete whiplash compared to night one! They actually prioritised wrestling on a wrestling show what a shocker then that it results in a good show! Ladder match was great oba was awesome, trick vs Sami was fun rhea and jade was better than expected in my opinion dom vs Balor was inoffensive and the main event delivered. Pretty decent bounce back from a lacklustre night one!

Sean Skorpion

It was definitely better than night 1 but I didn’t feel like I got into the show until the main event which was genuinely really great, Oba vs Lesnar was awesome (put the belt on Oba immediately he’s a star). I feel like night 1 deliberately stunk so hhh can put the blame on tko rather than his lackluster booking. Also the ladder match was fun but it felt like it missed something but I can’t really put my finger on what that was

Dean Brereton

CM punk knows how to professionally wrestle. Great main event, easily best match of both nights. Night 2 felt more mania but still not amazing.

Sean Skorpion

Maybe it’s the ads (I know everyone and their nan have beaten that dead horse) killing the momentum of the show or the shorter matches with longer gaps in between each match compared to previous wrestlemania’s. Night 2 was good though

BKManc

Night 2 far better then night 1 (all be it the standards were on the floor) an CM Punk once again reminding me in the main event why I fell in love with his character all them years ago. Brilliant card from top to bottom.

Farhan Bilgrami

It genuinely felt like they only cared about Mania Night 2. The Sunday show could’ve been the whole card and it would have felt like a complete show.

Vikrish-Ingi

What a difference a day makes . Oba beats Polish Joe and he retires (at least till summerslam) 6 man ladder carnage was great fun. Trick gets a push Demon and Dom was excellent from entrance to last bell Jade's reign is done thankfully. And punk roman was so good . The old man running out of gas . His tape turn hopefully leads to full heal punk . 6 of the 7 best matches on night 2. And let's not forget Danhausen . The segment was lol fun.

Kevin Wakeham

Yeah Night 2 was far better than Night 1, but the bar was set deep into the ground, so unfortunately it doesn't save the show for me. Night 1 was so bad and so concerning, conversations need to be had about it.

jasong316

Night 2 was better than night 1 but the bar was very low. Must matches below 10 minutes though with the exception of main event.

TriedAndTrue

While night 2 was better overall than night 1, i feel like a lot of the same issues still plagued this show, with a few more standout matches/moments. It's especially a shame that rusev, dragon lee and jd couldnt fit their entrances in so wwe could cram in more hogan. . punk vs roman will be a MOTY candidate, and the ladder match was super fun, as well as oba being shot into superstardom which is exactly what should have happened.

Hok

Night 1 was like TKOs version of what they think a wrestling ppv should be. Night 2 was like triple h showing them how it shoukd be done. The main event specifically

Adersh S

Only Night 2 felt like WrestleMania. Night 1 was just a Saturday Night Main Event. TKO vs HHH power struggle is really evident. And HHH has the upper hand till now.

Harry Ledger

No backstage interviews, no legend appearances, entrances being cut, stupid amount of ads. Maybe it’s just what we need to get used to, but it just didn’t have that Wrestlemania feel.

Jonathan Davies

Much better than Night 1. Started and ended on a great note. But the adverts still kill all momentum within the show.

cameron_in_space

the double GTS is what punk beat Moxley and Rollins with, so if he was younger he might have beaten Roman with that too. 5 stars

Azumi

Peoples opinions on night 2 will be heavily skewed because of how bad night one was. Lets not get ahead of ourselves and act or think that night 2 was the Mania that people should have gotten, for what it was it was still just an ok show as the only talking point coming out of it (bar the adverts and the downtime between matches) is Punk and Roman and possibly Brock retiring? But people didn't want him there anyway so him going away for good is like yeah ok fine, whatever. Before people start mocking any AEW fan annoyed at Jade using the One Winged Angel, need i remind them that they got pissy when Ospreay used the Styles Clash. But on Rhea winning the title, are people more happy that Rhea won it, or just that Jade lost it? There's been talk before of people getting tired of Rhea being a dominant champion and always being in the title/main event scene, so is this just gonna end up going the same way where the fans start to sour on her as champion after a couple of months. At a push i'd give night 2 a 3/5, but realistically more a 2/5. Mania is slowly starting to feel like any other PPV.

Dmangamr

Was honestly hoping the next Oba feud was Oba v Gunther. Since Brock retired, Oba killed a career that Gunther didn’t get to kill.

Jared Rasmussen

Reading the reviews online, nearly every review says “better than Night 1” which makes me think you all are onto something. I suppose all wrestling is graded on a curve, but it seems very pointed/intentional to have so MUCH of a gap - that Night 1 was actually sandbagged. It could be that everyone rallied together to produce a better Night 2, but the pacing and ad problems were still there; people are just more forgiving of them because “hey, at least it (the card) was better than Night 1”.

Dean Brereton

CM Punk tells great stories, easily Romans best Mania match, no run ins, no silly distractions, no cinema. just wrestling.

Luca Olias

Night 2 was a huge jump up in terms of quality compared to night 1 which is slightly bitter sweet. Thankfully we got a great night to watch, but to think that this was somewhat intentional because Triple H wanted to politic his way into more power is profoundly disappointing and irritating. The idea of a TKO vs Triple H Wrestlemania battle once again validates that the viewers are not the priority in it all. Buzzing Roman's back on top though ☝🏼

James Markin

Night 2 was really good and this felt like Triple H went "now this is the night I care about". Only clunker was Rhea vs Jade and that's cause it felt copy/paste from Night 1 women's match just with the face winning instead. But if Night 2 was the only of Mania it possibly would crack my top 5 Manias for sure. I don't want another multi years Roman title reign. But him and Punk's match felt like a WrestleMania main event unlike Cody vs Randy. One idea I found interesting is what if Oba challenges Roman on R.A.M. tonight and beats him at Backlash right away.

Mansour Maghlouth

Its like you guys always say “its how you leave them folks”. Also this might be a hot take but that main event is so good that I think its even better than anything on Dynasty and this is coming from an Aew shill.

Hunter Torbett

I think AEW has ruined WWE hardcore and unsanctioned matched. The level of violence that WWE sponsors allow for big blow off feuds just doesn’t touch what AEW can get away with. Note I’m not a huge fan of hardcore wrestling, but it’s hard not to compare the Texas Death Match to the Unsanctioned match.

Dylan Gardiner

Perfect ending, perfectly set up for a slow (not too slow Triple H) burn Punk heel turn out of desperation as he struggles to keep up with the younger guys at the top of the card

Jonathan Ortega

Wrestlemania felt like a wrestlemania I wonder if Aireal sees what we see and that’s triple H shitting on his ideas

FelKat

For all his faults, Brock retired like a true professional. But over a younger talent big time, left his stuff in the ring hugged his manager and went out high fiving fans.

Team HAMMA FIST

The crowd during the post show was chanting “F*** TKO!” While I agree with the sentiment, the chant rings a little hollow when bouncing around in the thousands of dollars hole in their pocket.

fkaY!KES

So close to getting a new inJe'Vontinental champion but no :(

Fhat Guy Taylor

It was nice to watch the last match and not know who was going to win. It was nice to see character in the match and not just moves.

Omer Ulkay

Need to know Oli's favorite Turkish takeout order

Mike S.

Can someone tell me what the heck the booking for Jade is now? Gave her a group… debuted a “new move” at mania (had it kicked out of)… lost anyways… what’s the direction for her? Her trio and the kabuki warriors vs Rhiyo and some random trio at War Games?

Jack McEwen-Quy

We did it guys we got ep 8 of MNW unlocked Oli Emanuel and Luke Khan caved to our demands. Now to get Brian Children back. #wewantBrian