2017 Transparency (Patreon)
Content
In 2016 and 2017, I wrote blog posts titled "Transparency" to provide information about how the Patreon money had been spent in the past, and how I planned to spend it in the future. Now that we're at the beginning of a new year, I think it's appropriate to create another "Transparency Post".
As you know, my personal monthly salary is capped at $3,500, and any surplus goes towards the game's budget. By January 2017, I had raised a surplus of $24,725.30 and spent a total of $17,500 compensating volunteers for their help, leaving us with a surplus of $7,225.30. Instead of immediately putting the money towards a specific purpose, it was determined that I would simply store the money until there was a good opportunity to use it for the betterment of Yandere Simulator.
Here is how much money was raised over the course of 2017:
January $5,120.18
February $5,268.68
March $4,976.85
April $5,168.45
May $4,919.34
June $4,935.48
July $4,702.56
August $4,786.04
September $4,752.13
October $4,549.06
November $4,909.67
December $4,751.23
$58,839.67 in total. Every month, $3,500 of that money went to me, leaving us with a surplus of $16,839.67.
In 2016, seven different volunteers asked to be compensated. In 2017, only three volunteers asked for compensation. (Aliases will be used instead of real names.)
Hana Piana - $862 for 2D artwork
Sheltor - $900 for 3D animations
Hayden - $100 for 3D models
In 2016, $17,500 was used to compensate volunteers. In 2017, only $1,862 was spent on compensation. That's a pretty significant difference! The primary reason for this is that there were far less volunteers this time around.
If we subtract $1,862 from $17,500 and then add the $7,225.30 from last year, then our current surplus is at $22,863.30.
So, we've got $22,863.30 that we can put towards the game's development. How are we going to use this money? First, I think I should address the words on the side of my Patreon page. Let's take a look at the description of the $4,000 goal:
"Yandere Simulator relies on help from volunteers. If I reach this goal, I could pay a professional-level volunteer $500 per month to provide me with more assistance."
The $4,500 and $5,000 goals have similar wording; I imply that each $500 milestone puts another professional-level volunteer on the project. However, $500 per month is nowhere near the amount of money needed to pay a professional's salary. So, what's the explanation?
In 2015, I accepted assistance from a 3D modeler who was between jobs. He provided me with phenomenal work, and quickly proved himself to be invaluable to the project. Eventually, he said that he wanted to go looking for a job, but could be persuaded to stick around on the Yandere Sim project for $500 a month. I agreed to his terms, and began paying him $500 per month. I figured that there would be more professional-quality volunteers in his exact position; wishing to help out, but in need of minimal compensation. The $4,000 / $4,500 / $5,000 goals were created with this in mind.
However, to this day, that one modeler has remained the only person in such a position. It's simply not common for someone to say, "Hey, I'm between jobs, but I'll stick around on your project for $500 per month." Either someone wants to volunteer for free with zero expectation of any compensation whatsoever, or someone wants a full-time employee's wage. There's no middle ground.
As a result, we're in a position where we've got a surplus of $22,863.30 that is intended to go towards "$500 per month" volunteers, but that type of volunteer simply doesn't exist, and only three people even asked for compensation over the course of the entire year. The Patreon money simply isn't being spent the way that the text on this page describes...in fact, the majority of the Patreon money simply isn't being spent at all.
I can predict what you're thinking:
$500 isn't enough to pay a professional for a month, but with $22,863.30, you can definitely hire a full-time professional programmer to assist you for multiple months! Why don't you do that?
For a long time, I was extremely reluctant to consider the possibility of bringing another programmer onboard the project. I didn't want to risk losing weeks or months of my time teaching someone how the systems work, how to modify various aspects of the game, where important files are located, etc. I didn't want to risk "merge conflicts" that occur when two programmers modify the same script and then have to resolve conflicting code. I didn't want to risk the programmer modifying my code in ways that make it alien and foreign to me, impeding my ability to make progress on the game. I didn't want to risk losing time waiting for a programmer to fix a bug he had caused. I didn't want to risk being forced into a situation where I'm reliant on the assistance of someone whose personality is difficult to tolerate. I didn't want to risk all of the other annoying headaches that come from working alongside a programmer instead of just working solo.
In 2017, I actually did work alongside another programmer for about 5 months. And, tragically, all of the fears described above became a reality. The programmer made a small number of meaningful improvements to the game, but overall, the majority of the work he did was to go over my code and re-write it without actually improving the game's performance. For example, changing (foo == false) to (!foo). Busywork that had no actual impact on the game.
The primary reason that he was doing busywork instead of significant work is because, in order to make really meaningful improvements and optimizations to the game, a large number of systems would need to be entirely re-written from scratch. Gutting the game's code and then putting it back together again would be a very time-consuming process (several months, at least); during this period of time, I wouldn't be able to put out any new builds of the game or release any video updates, because most of the game's systems wouldn't be operational until the overhaul was complete. I'm not willing to put the game into that kind of state at this point in time, so his hands were kind of tied, and there was very little he could actually do.
(Think of it like replacing a car's engine. You can't do it in the middle of a road trip while the car is running. You need to pull over to the side of the road, turn the car off, do the necessary work, and then get back on the road again.)
In short, there's no way that a programmer can make significant improvements to the game unless we completely pause development for several months while the game is taken apart and put back together again, during which you'd get no videos, no new builds, and no updates. I think that right now would be an absolutely terrible time to stop updating the game for several months; the fanbase is very, very eager to see significant progress, and ceasing to update the game at this point in time would severely anger a lot of people.
If you're looking for a bullet-point list:
After watching all of my worst fears come true over a period of 5 months, now I'm even more reluctant to bring another programmer onboard the project than I was before.
By the time a programmer was familiar enough with the project to actually begin making significant changes, we'd have run out of surplus budget for paying him.
A programmer can't actually make significant changes to the game at this point anyway, since in order to do some serious work on the game's systems, we'd have to take the game apart and put it back together over the course of several months, and that's not something I'm willing to do at this point in time.
There are already some professional-level programmers volunteering to help me for free, so huge monthly payments aren't even necessary to get programming assistance.
Once the game graduates from "debug sandbox" to "official demo", that's when we'll do a crowd-funding campaign. Once the game's budget has been secured, that's when I will be in a position where I won't be worried about pausing updates for several months while working together with a professional programmer (or two, or three) to take the game apart and put it back together again.
If you're looking for a summary: At this stage, money and volunteers won't speed up the development of the game; the only thing that will get us closer to the finish line is me, working solo, going down the checklist of features necessary to transition from "debug sandbox" to "official demo".
After hearing that, I have a feeling I know what you're thinking:
Money won't help? Then why should I support your Patreon?
I understand that this blog post probably won't make you feel like your money is making a big difference towards the game's development. This is not the type of blog post that a dude on Patreon will usually make. I fully acknowledge that some people might pull their support as a result of this blog post, but I'm telling you all of this information anyway. Why? Because I'm committed to honesty, and - like it says in the title of this blog post - transparency. With that said, please allow me to encourage you to look at this from an optimistic perspective:
In a previous "Transparency" post, I mentioned that the surplus of money we raise through Patreon is money we don't have to ask for once we're doing a crowdfunding campaign. For example: If I need a budget of $100,000 to make the game, and we raise a surplus of $22,000 on Patreon, that means that I only need to ask for $78,000 when I do the crowdfunding campaign. This increases the chance of the crowdfunding campaign succeeding.
In short, even if your money doesn't have an immediate effect on the game's development speed, it still goes towards the budget that the game will eventually need once we enter the next phase of the game's development. You're not paying for an immediate result, you're making a long-term investment.
Of course, if you're thinking, "Wait! There are other ways to use that money to benefit Yandere Sim, besides spending it on volunteers or hording it for the crowdfunding campaign!" then you are absolutely 100% welcome to share your thoughts below!
So now what?
Before I wrap up this blog post, there are a set of questions I'd like to ask you, my Patrons:
1. When there are long gaps of time between significant updates, do you feel like your money is going to waste?
2. When you pledge to my Patreon, what do you want in return? For me to work harder and faster? Or something else?
3. My worst fear is for people to feel that the money they are pledging to me has been "squandered" or "wasted". What would make you feel this way?
4. How do you feel about the situation described above? Are you upset or disappointed that the $22.8k surplus isn't being put to an immediate use? Or are you okay with me simply saving the money until the right opportunity to use it?
5. Considering the above information, do you believe that the goals on the side of the page are misleading? Do you believe that the goals be reworded or removed? Do you have suggestions for new goals? (EDIT: I updated the text on the side of the page in accordance with patron feedback below.)
I'm a little nervous about how this blog post will be received, because I know that it's possible to interpret all of the above information in a very pessimistic way, but I'm still looking forward to reading your responses.
Thank you very much for supporting the development of Yandere Simulator!