I Fixed All The Terrible Feats of D&D (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
The 2024 version of D&D has done a pretty good job of rebalancing feats. Some are obviously stronger than others, but most are still useful on the right build.
Then there are the feats on this list.
They are all terrible.
This is my attempt at fixing them, while keeping to the original intent behind each feat.
I'm making this post free, because I believe it can help many people who feel underwhelmed by some of these feats.
Below you can find an explanation of each redesign:
General Feats
Athlete
Feat was pretty underwhelming most of the time. Now it gives you the ability to save against prone or forced movement, which is very useful in 2024, where most monsters inflict these without a saving throw. Which is a big nerf to Strength based characters compared to 5e
Charger
Damage is now 1d6 + prof, so that it’s the same damage from level 1-5 but it actually scales up with your character. Same for the pushing distance, it now scales with your character, and you can decide how much to push them. You are sacrificing a feat for this ability.
Chef
Added Xanathar’s cooking utensils rules to Replenishing Meal. Buffed healing so that they feel better to use. A potion as a bonus action is better until level 9 (7 hit points regained rather than 8). This keeps the feat viable at later levels.
Durable
Added powerful recovery, a feature from the Bloodlust feat from Astarion’s book. Because using Speedy Recovery in the middle of combat means it’s an emergency, and if you roll and only regain 1 Hit Point, well it’s just terrible.
Added +1 to the healing so that it is a bit better, but still not as good as taking a Short Rest for characters taking this feat, because it now has a 13+ Con requirement, meaning they’ll have at minimum 14 Constitution, so +2 to each die on a short rest.
Piercer
Removed the once per turn limitation on Puncture. It’s barely a damage increase and you take a full feat for it. Compared to Crusher this is still weak, but should feel better now
Slasher
Adds utility at higher levels, at low level still reduces Speed by 10 feet only.
Weapon Master
The only classes that would want this feat are ones that don’t have weapon masteries (Monks, Gish bards, wizards, etc.). Allowing any ability score increase makes it an easier fit on these builds.
Origin Feat
All the origin feats are very useful for all kinds of builds, except for one, savage attacker, which is just bad, all the time.
Savage Attacker
Removed the weapon’s damage limitation so this scales with Sneak Attack or Smites. I kept the once per turn on your turn limitation for balance and to prevent reaction Sneak Attack. It’s also there to avoid slowing down combat too much because we’re rolling so many dice.
Some damage calculations:
Assuming 4 round per combats
4 combats per day
1 short rest per day
60% chance to hit, 5% chance to crit
So at the bottom end it’s adding 1.2 damage per turn, and at top end 2.8.Still less damage than duelng would on a fighter.
Is an average of 2 extra damage per turn better than the Tough or Lucky origin feats? Probably not, but now at least there is some benefit to the feat.
Fighting Style Feat Fixes
Interception
Just adds some scaling. Protection is still a better fighting style, but this option is now viable for tank characters that do not have shields.
Unarmed Fighting
This one is bad, but doesn’t need a fix because the tavern brawler origin feat exists.