Fighter: Dragon Knight - Devour the Hearts of Dragons (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
Hello everyone!
Let me rant about a fighter subclass that has been brought back from the dead times and times again by WotC, always to disastrous results.
The Purple Dragon Knight
In 5e that subclass was the worst fighter in the game.
It was so terrible, that back then, it was probably better to not have a subclass, because at least this way you wouldn’t feel so disappointed.
This knight with a glorious history as an elite warrior, capable of commanding troops, ended up useless, and stayed that way for nearly 10 years. Even the Undying Warlock got some rework done in the form of the Undead Warlock in Van Richten’s Guide.
You know what the purple knight got?
It got smacked across the head and buried in a ditch.
My conspiracy theory is that D&D willingly kept it bad so that whenever they would release a terrible subclass, they could point to the purple dragon knight, and say “hey at least it’s not as bad as this”.
I can't touch the PDK, it's official content.
But what I can do is create my own version of a dragon knight, and not make it useless.
So, enjoy the Dragon Knight, who happens to be wearing purple clothing purely by accident.
Enjoy!
Evan | MonkeyDM
P.S: Get access to the rest of the Arcane Archeology Compendium, with brand new subclasses, spells and more, by joining us on Patreon!
Balancing Notes
Assumptions
60% baseline accuracy and 5% critical-hit chance.
Four encounters per Long Rest.
Four rounds per encounter.
One Short Rest per day.
Charisma +3 at levels 3, +4 at level 10, and +5 at levels 15.
The level-18 ceiling assumes Scale Tyrant is active in all four encounters by expending all three Indomitable uses.
Official Fighter benchmarks from treantmonk's_dpr. (Treantmonk is a fantastic YouTuber who does some great math analysis of subclasses, the math in this breakdown is following the same as his)
Saves, Magic Resistance, Necrotic defenses, and condition immunities from 5.5 Monster Analysis.xlsx. Caius did a phenomenal job gathering and analysing all monsters from the new Monster Manual.
Damage per use
The attack calculations include critical hits. At level 18, they also include the expected contribution of Draconic Surge.
Maw adds damage using a Reaction, so it does not replace normal Fighter damage.
Claw replaces a weapon attack and adds a control effect.
Dragonbreath also replaces an attack and needs multiple targets to outdamage it.
Dragonbreath
Dragonbreath is inefficient against one target. It becomes viable at two targets and excellent at three, which is exactly where such a feature should land imo.
Battle Master and Psi Warrior remain stronger against single targets, Eldritch Knight remains the king of tanks, but Dragonbreath is stronger specifically when multiple enemies cluster together.
At level 18, roughly 77 total DPR across three targets is powerful but requires:
Three enemies inside the cone.
All 12 points spent on six breaths.
No Claw, Maw, or Predator’s Ascent.
Scale Tyrant active.
All three Indomitable uses.
That is a reasonable Tier IV area-damage ceiling methinks.
Single-target DPR
Three spending patterns are useful:
All Claw: Every point is spent on Tyrant’s Claw.
Mixed: Maw triggers once per encounter; remaining points fund Claw.
Maw Ceiling: Every point is spent on Maw and every trigger is available.
At level 3, the theoretical Maw ceiling is about 11% above Psi Warrior, but basically requires the gods to be in your favor to get the optimal set up
At level 7, equal to Psi Warrior.
At levels 10 and 15, below the strongest options.
At level 18, the practical mixed result is exactly level with Psi Warrior and The 64.8 DPR ceiling requires Scale Tyrant in every encounter, requiring all three Indomitable uses! Didn’t do the math on using it once or twice, but I don’t need to, seeing as this barely exceeds max DPR, by sacrificing your biggest defensive ressource as a fighter.
So subclass is balanced mathematically at least. And in play felt that way too.
Let me know your feedback!