Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

May I have your thoughts on this matter?

I've struggled quite a lot with stat checks because I do want my readers to feel a sense of accomplishment when passing them, but I'd also like to avoid this being turned into a super hard game where you need a guide to pass the checks. Im more focused on the story and enjoyability aspect of the game, so please, lemme know what you think if you have any input! 

Are the stats still hard to pass? Or are they at just the right level? 

Files

Previews only

Comments

Elizabeth Bencomo

Hmmm I mean 3 and 4 is hella easy and give more options for other points, but 4 and 5 are okay but that's because I stat int up to five from the start that way I can stat up either charm or combat

Thanh Chung Vu

Well, it really depends on how many points you have given people. If I remember correctly at the first check (Caravan) you have given people 7 points. Unless people doing the jack-of-all-trades master of none, they should always be able to pass them: People should always have 4-3. So the question is at the later point in the game do you intend to have the choice of utilizing all 3 stats at the same time? If not then you don't have to worry anything, the stat system is fine for 2 stat.

Craig Keller

Just like how Kenneth said, it's still a little too early to say. And just keep a tab on these for now just in case for later when stats might be an issue or not. However, I will say that in my personal opinion with my many play throughs that I really don't have an issue with the current layout of the stats. I find the current layout to be quite enjoyable. I think the 5 point stat choices are agreeable, especially since the splash they makes of there scale when choosing them. I wouldn't really want the lesser 3 point stat choices going any lower. I could say lower the 5 point stat choices but like I said before, the splash they make of there scale, I would prefer keeping them where they are. I don't see an issue with them currently.

Anonymous

I'm the guy who posted that tumblr ask. I played through this last night and I've noticed that during the festival stat checks, you automatically fail and end the story too quickly if you don't have any stats at 4. That's why I posted that. The festival stat check is the only issue I have atm as it's too high at that point of the story and the stats that we've built up this far.

Anonymous

I can see where the asker is coming from, having only one choice available despite so many option being there did feel a little bit frustrating. It feel less like a reward and more like being left with only one option because I didn't build enough stats despite the fact that I had only been building two. That being said it's really the only choice so far where that's come up, even if I am a little nervous because I consistently just barely pass stats checks (for example during the festival my intellect was 4, charisma 3, and combat 0.) and I feel that might cause problems for me later on if I don't build my character right. I don't need every option available all the time but it would have been nice to actually have a choice between my two chosen stats, especially since logically speaking there was nothing stopping the mc from going another direction save consistency. Even if you can't steal the show with a high stat, it'd be interesting to use the options mc doesn't have a high stat in as a learning opportunity for mc to build further stats rather than simply ending the game or removing choice from the... choice. I don't think replayability should come solely from stat lockouts in games like these, rather a balance between the main characters capabilities (i.e. stats) and the direction the player wishes to steer the narrative, else why have choices like this at all. I think you accomplished this balance very well with the personality stats, by selecting traits you determine a set personality for the main character but you always allow for choice within that personality. This way I have that incentive to go back and play a different personality, but I also feel like I have freedom to control over the character im supposed to be piloting around. A quick suggestion, If you dont want to rework the whole system to make evenly balanced builds more viable, you could try to rework or remove the death by truck option. This is a very early choice and therefore the precedent for how important these stats are hasn't quite been set yet. This choice may even be what's locking some people out and breaking their game or killing them, as the case may eventually be. As it is currently, this option feels more like a pitfall than a legitimate way to play the game. It will frustrate new players who might not be able to continue the game because they were unfamiliar with the "rules" so to speak and may put some off entirely. I'd recommend advertising it in-game as a more difficult way to play the game. It would prevent some from banging their head against the wall while drawing in others who love that extra dash of challenge to spice things up. It would even lend itself to replayability for those who like to know what they're in for before turning on any kind of difficulty option I apologize for the small novel in response, but I hope it's at least a somewhat helpful novel 😅 Have an wonderful day!

Anonymous

I think still not all the people knows the stat check rate, so they say "i have 3 points to spend and i already have 3 in one skill. I'm gonna rise to 4 the first one because 5 will let me with 1 in the other and that's too low, and i'm going to add the points i'll get playing the game to the second skill, because 2 points still looks too low". And after that prologue with the goddess you only have 1 point to add, they get 4 in one and 3 in another when they reach the festival where you ask 4 for the minimum, and if they choose to be balanced mc they can't do nothing at all, you should add a choice for them, nothing too awesome, (balanced=normal guy to me), just something to do. If the first skill is combat they need to choose pig rodeo and lose, that could feel unfair, because you're asking 4 in the other two skills while 5 for combat. I know is a combat test, but if you kill a hard boss, you want a good loot. It could have felt more rewarded letting the combat points reward if you win like before. But know that you low the higher stat check to 5 it seems useless unless you create a super dooper awesome special scene in the next update for combat mc that will use an stat check of 7 or something for the first time, because i assume that you will gradually rise the stat check while we advance in the game. You'll need to make some math though, because you can increase your skills after the festival.

Thanh Chung Vu

I believe in the festival, as long as you have at least 4 in one stat you would get a boost in a relationship, it only increases your reputation if you have 5 - which consider top prodigy at that age base on Sir Belial reaction -. The other options have not been written yet, I would presume that they will have the same stat requirement

Anonymous

Yes how i said, the minimum is 4 to choose something and 5 to win the rodeo, but we are not going to use reputation this early in game so gain that little amount of reputation for win the rodeo is the same as nothing, don't feel as a reward at all.

KingdomsAndEmpires

Festival stat checks are gonna be lowered so that one should be able to choose two! Thanks for asking this btw, sometimes one forgets where to reflect the changes to the stats and change the design philosophy for the whole game you know? Besides you're a kiddo here still, so the stat checks will be lower. Thanks!

KingdomsAndEmpires

This is a REALLY good point, and suggestion. Maybe...maybe ill do the opposite and have it set as the cheat run? O.o HEY that's actually not a bad idea lmao!!!!! Thank you for your explanation dude!!!!

Moonsong

Speaking of stats if we don't have enough combat stats for the festival the demo ends?

Sheena F

I kinda liked only getting second place in the rodeo. It's not like the royal family needed the prize as much as the other family. I admit though I restarted multiple times in order to get my stats optimized to be able to get second place and later answer grandpa's intelligence question.

Thanh Chung Vu

I don't think so, I believe if you don't have 5 then you got 2nd place and a relationship boost, that is it.

FauxCouer

I find them at the right order. One main stat, and one second hand stat