Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

FMAB 1x3 Reaction Extended (YT link in description) (Patreon)

Published:
2020-11-21 01:59:56
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

YouTube Link:

https://youtu.be/ScY86VM83yM

Files

Previews only

Vimeo

Join the web's most supportive community of creators and get high-quality tools for hosting, sharing, and streaming videos in gorgeous HD with no ads.

Comments

benj

First comment Pog

Sitasien

oh my, you are going to love this show soooo much

Nick

Not sure what you think of the dub so far, but honestly this episode isn’t the best one to showcase it. It could be cool to hear what you think about the dub vs sub maybe after rewatching pivotal scenes in the series using both versions If you did like the dub work in this episode, it’s mostly just up from here on out lol

NitrousOxide19
>>48102784

the dub voices for hawkeye, mustang, armstrong (Vegeta's VA) and bradley are so good, i usually prefer sub but this anime is an exception

agoodwintv
>>48102784

I like the dub so far. It was a pretty easy adjustment. I found the scene with Rose quite moving and thought she especially did a good job :) But a lot of that is just the writing I think, it comes through in either languages. Oh and the music as well.

Trevor

Fun fact, the voice actors for Lust and Mustang are married in real life

hays collins

Dang I’m really enjoying this. I tried watching the other show a LONG time ago and stopped because it got pretty confusing but this one is much more easy to follow. Im enjoying watching this show for the first time with you!

Ben Barringer

This episode is where the other series begins, it takes up I think two if not three episodes and is our introduction to alchemy, automail, the main characters, etc. The dialogue of this episode still shows a lot of resemblance to its' old version, but out of the "first episode" context it feels a bit weird. The whole interaction with Rose lost basicall all of its' gravitas, compared to FMA. Still, Brotherhood is better overall, I'd say, it's just this first bit that get's to me.

Brimmy

only thing i miss from the original is that by the time Brotherhood became a thing Aaron Dismuke was too old (hit puberty) to voice Al so they got Maxey Whitehead instead idr if the tech was better then or if she still had to do her lines into a metal bowl to get that sound effect ahh memories~

hays collins

I know this has nothing to do with FMAB but did you hear they are very tiny rumors but substantial none the less that they are thinking about making another avatar show

Kassandra
>>48103526

Yeah the original show spent two episodes in Liore so I think the Rose moment is much more powerful. Overall I do still think Brotherhood is the better show. I do really like the '03 show though

Kassandra
>>48102784

Yeah, the dub voices are all really great and I definitely think the voice acting gets better from here on out. Also fun fact, Rose and Hawkeye have the same English VA

agoodwintv
>>48103526

Interesting. The more I hear about the original the more I think I will have to watch that as well. Probably after I finish this series.

agoodwintv
>>48103780

I have heard some rumors about this and I really hope it happens :) It would be the first time I get to watch Avatar while it's airing! I want to speculate like everyone else haha

Drake Chuckle

That was the story of Icarus, not the sun god.

estellijelli

Every day I hop onto Goodwin's Patreon to get personally attacked by his monologues (and yes I do still plan to reply to messages)

Nick
>>48103761

Both voice actors do a fantastic job. I was watching FMA after finishing Brotherhood and thought they were the exact same VAs, didn’t know they were different until now. Granted I’m still watching the original FMA series so I haven’t heard too much of Al yet but still

hays collins
>>48103780

Haha how do you think I feel. I haven’t had any new avatar content except comics and books(even though I desperately want more avatar books). I just want ANYTHING new

Ben Barringer
>>48103526

@GWTV It's the first one I saw, back before Brotherhood came out, and it's also a fantastic show. There are major plot differences, HUGE sweeping changes that have massive story implications, it's great. All the same voice actors, too, except for Al. The Brotherhood Al voice actor always grates on me just a little for the first few episodes, I'm still expecting the old one every time.

Bruce Gil

Not sure how true this is, but I've heard that Asami's character design from LoK was modeled after the villain at the end of this episode.

R'Mani Leavell

As you already know, the 2003 anime goes into more depth for some of these earlier episodes. I suggest watching that one after this one, but not only because you get more detail in episodes like this, but the story is honestly pretty good, even if it isn't as good in my opinion. And if you see people say the 2003 version sucks or isn't good, I would compare it to ATLA and TLOK. Some people don't like it because of the turns it take and how different it is from the original.

Zavooloo

Hey Alex, just wanted to thank you again for being apart of my routine nowadays. Your videos always give me a different perspective on shows I've seen, but more than that you really know how to put my/your thoughts into words. Idk, I'm just thankful that your success and wisdom has been therapeutic for me. Please stay yourself haha

Say

I enjoyed that you go in depth about how people cope and deal with various harsh pains of life; you will see much more of that going down the road. FMA is, at is core, about people who have been greatly wronged by the world and themselves trying to become better, and one of the greatest parts about it is that each of the main and supporting cast are incredibly strong and inspiring. Right now you've only seen Ed and Al for the most part, but you'll see more as you progress. I'm especially looking forward to your eventual analysis to Ed's superior officers and the military characters in general, because once you see the extent of their backstories, motivations, and actions, they are a protagonist of their own as well!

Doug Thomas

Longtime watcher, second-time commenter - your dissection of this episode was fantastic, and I love the wisdom you bring to the table in regards to the fanaticism that Rose exercises. It really is tragic, and when I first watched that scene at the end I almost teared up for a character I'd only known for roughly 20 minutes. As a longtime fan of the show, it's so refreshing to watch someone examine aspects of it in ways I never even considered - like Al specifically was a character I always appreciated but never at as deep a level as most people, and just with this episode and your thoughts on it alone I'm starting to realize how wrong I was. Also, 'is this what church is like? I might start going to church' is easily the funniest thing I've heard all week. Great reaction, excited to watch you continue. Thanks!

Aidan Pullen

others have already brought up most of what I was gonna say, so I'll just mention this thing I think is cool: the character Lust (evil lady) is the inspiration for Asami's character design. Just think that's a fun little fact. Loved this reaction and your breakdown of everything as usual. Can't wait for you to keep unraveling things and traveling down this road!

R. Lewis

As a huge fan of both versions who prefers Brotherhood, I will admit that this episode and the next one really suffered in the transition. Both were given two episodes in the original, and both carried a lot more weight in my opinion. Even if you never watch the whole original series or even if you don't react to it, I highly recommend watching this story and the next one in the original series just to get a much better experience of these events and the impact they carry.

Brimmy
>>48103761

I caught it right away when i watched for the first time years ago (7 or 8 years now) i was just like \wait that's not the same person what the heck?!\

agoodwintv
>>48106551

Awesome, the more I hear about it the more I want to watch it. I'll probably do that on my own after I finish Brotherhood.

Trevor
>>48102367

Pogchamp is a twitch emote, its used to express excitement and has made its way into general internet speak

agoodwintv
>>48107724

I can't wait. Even without having seen much I am really interested in some of the "side" characters, like Roy Mustang, Liza, my boy Alex Louis Armstrong... King Bradley, etc.

agoodwintv
>>48108124

Thanks for the comment :D Rose really spoke to me, as does Ed's reaction to her, and also poor Al just being such a good guy being kind to everyone along their path.

agoodwintv
>>48110388

I'm not sure I wanna go through the little girl and her dog story again haha. JK, I would love to check it out after I finish this series.

Nick
>>48107724

I think for some of the military officers it’s less about them being wronged and more about them accepting and coming to terms with the fact that they followed horrible orders, and now they’re trying to do good, or follow their own morally based orders so to speak

Aaron Ong
>>48102784

The music is my third favorite part of this series, with the story and characters being my first and second respectively. The music is just so fitting, intense, and memorable, and I can just never get enough of it. Even the Openings are great. So glad you're enjoying it as much as I do. Makes me smile everytime you comment on it.

benj
>>48102367

Poggers, Pogchamp, Pog, PeepoPog, it all means the same thing. Its a picture of a dude going ":0" but in excitement

HamboneKablooey
>>48110388

Oh man, I'm not even gonna lie, it's so much worse when you have two episodes to get attached. XD

Kassandra
>>48106152

I think Bryan said it was just a coincidence. He said he watched FMAB about a year after he'd already designed Asami. But I think he mentioned that after he watched FMAB, he did choose to give Asami the same lipstick color as Lust on purpose

Kassandra
>>48110014

Nah, Laura Bailey voices Lust and Seychelle Gabriel voices Asami. And Bryan debunked Asami being based off Lust. He designed Asami before watching FMAB. He did admit that after watching FMAB he did give Asami the same lipstick color in TLOK tho lol

Kassandra
>>48103526

Yeah, it definitely took some getting used with Al's new VA. I think she does a good job in Brotherhood but I was so used to Aaron Dismuke that it took me a while to like it