Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hi!

The hype for vintage synths always surprises me until I get my hands on one and try it... The SH-101 is a simple, single oscillator synth, and yet actually playing one is an experience I highly recommend. The interface is very clear, easy to understand and definitely knob per function. Well, slider per function anyway...

So, obviously when Behringer came out with the MS-101, I was interested in checking out if they sound the same.

The short answer is, they're very close. I put the oscillators under the scope and despite the fact that they look different, they sound the same to me.

When it comes to the filter though, the difference becomes a little more interesting, though still very subtle (or not, depending on your point of view). The SH filter drops a lot of bass out almost immediately, and spikes up a warbly resonance. The MS's resonance is slightly less pronounced, more stable, but the filter maintains more bass.

The SH-101 was borrowed from my friend Isak - an SH fan who builds his own synths and fixes/modifies, among other, SH-101s  - and I also brought him along to do a blind test and jam a bit - which I included in this video.

I dialed in settings to the point where I couldn't tell the difference between the two, and then put Isak to the test - he got 20 out of 21 tries right, which is quite amazing.

I've added the test as a high quality download attached to this post, as well as an audio file of the jams both Isak and I had some fun with, making this classic do what it does best.

Which do you prefer? Can you hear the difference? 

All my best,

Ziv (listening to slight variations in resonance on youtube as "Loopop")

Files

Roland SH-101 vs Behringer MS-101/MS-1: Can you hear the difference?

Here's a link to my Patreon if you want to download the raw test file and outro jams as well as my In-Complete Book of Electronic Music Ideas, Tips and Tricks (hint: it's in-complete because it's always being updated…): ► Patreon: https://patreon.com/loopop Check prices on the MS-1 (MS-101) (affiliate links help the channel): ► Sweetwater: https://imp.i114863.net/2byOO ► Thomann: https://www.thomann.de/gb/behringer_ms_101_rd.htm?offid=1&affid=369 ► Amazon MS-1: https://amzn.to/2UzZZ9q Other places I hang out: ► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/loopopmusic ► Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/loopopmusic ► Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/loopopmusic ► Web: https://loopopmusic.com My music: ► Bandcamp: https://loopop.bandcamp.com ► Spotify: http://bit.ly/LoopopOnSpotify ► Apple Music:http://bit.ly/LoopopOnAppleMusic Scopes used are by Melda: ► http://bit.ly/Manalyzer and http://bit.ly/Moscilloscope TIMELINE: 0:00 Intro 1:00 Feature comparison 2:30 The Oscillators 4:15 The Filter 6:05 Envelopes 6:40 Blind test 8:20 Conclusion 9:00 Loopop jam 10:30 Isak jam Want to email me personally? ► Ziv (at) loopopmusic.com NOTE: Occasionally I’ll try out affiliate marketing and include affiliate links. This means that I may earn a commission when you click on or make purchases via affiliate links. The content of this clip is entirely my opinion, and was not paid for or dictated in any way by the company creating the gear. Without addressing the particulars of products shown here as they might be under NDA, gear shown on this channel may be either sent by the manufacturer, on loan for review or bought at a discount.

Comments

Richard Olpin

Great stuff as always Ziv. I can hear the very slight differences, but honestly for me I really don't think it would be enough to matter. It's a great little synth and I'm looking forward to getting my hands on one when the blue/black ones are available as I'm not keen on the red..

Loopop

Thanks! I agree Behringer did a fantastic job on this... and regardless of whether it's exactly like the original (which it's damn close) - to put together such a great sounding synth, with keyboard, sliders, etc for $300 - it's hard to argue with that

Rob Hetland

I'm curious about how close the SH-O1A is compared to the SH-101. I don't really care about a keyboard -- I have a nice controller I would rather use. Also, I have concerns about Behringer in terms of both quality and ethics. And the SH-01A and the MS-101 cost about the same, so that makes it an interesting comparison. I know the SH-01A is not new, so perhaps not so exciting to compare in a video, but I'm still curious. What does Isak think?

Loopop

He thinks it's pretty close... what bothered him was that the filter controls were steppy - even though they cost the same, he'd go with the MS because of the keyboard, size convenience, controls. Soundwise he thinks it's the closest boutique to the real thing (and he thinks the others are pretty close too)

Ben Thies

Hey! I would love a comparison between the new 1010 Blackbox an the Octatrack. I have an octatrack that I want to use as the center of everything, but I'm thinking the blackbox will do the same stuff and I'm not sure if I should sell my Octatrack for it or not, or if I should use it with the octatrack somehow. Whatever you can fit into a video with both of those devices would be amazing!

Loopop

Hi Ben! Regarding a video - hopefully I'm working on something better. My plan is to take the buyers guide topics that I added in last month's book update and create a comparison site with information of as many samplers/drum machines/sequencers as possible and then share it with the world... I think I've found a way to do this quickly, so it may be live soon, but until then, if you have specific questions, feel free to ask. If I had to sum up the differences, Octatrack can do way more (though there are some things Black box can do and it can't), and since you have one, you already "spent" the learning curve effort, which is Octatrack's biggest disadvantage. That said, Blackbox is so much more simple, and does have the polyphonic features that Octatrack doesn't, and it's smaller, more portable and with more outputs. Hopefully this helps - feel free to ask any followups.

Ben Thies

Thank you! I'm thinking about having both

Ben Thies

Also, I have yet to get past the learning curb. From your experience, what can the octatrack do/be used for that the blackbox can't? I'm trying to decide if I should sell my octatrack or not. I don't have too much extra free time so I'm not too fond of how long it takes to understand the octatrack.

Loopop

For sure Octatrack can do things Blackbox can't, the question is are those things valuable for your workflow and worth the headache. Don't forget, you don't have to use everything in the octatrack ;) right now it beats blackbox on ease of sequencing, parameter sequencing (non existent in blackbox) and live looping (better in OT yet still possible in BB)

Ben Thies

Parameter sequencing!! Thanks! Didn't realize Blackbox couldn't do that.

Loopop

That's why you pay me the big bucks ;) feel free to consult any time