Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi!

Quite a few people have been asking me for a Prophet 5 Rev 4 review, but frankly what's really interesting to me (and I think many others) is whether it's worth the extra cost (and fewer features) over the Prophet 6.

Now, I probably would have been trying to get my hands on both if it wasn't for Julian Pollack (J3PO) making such a fine comparison already.

The thing is, when I watched his video, at times I felt the difference was minimal, and at many others, I couldn't tell the difference, which is different from the conclusion he got to. 

While I do believe in "mojo" and things that are beyond what we hear, in the presence of an instrument made by the legendary Dave Smith, the big question is, is that worth not only the extra cost but also the lack of additional features in the Prophet 6 (stereo voices, digital fx, arp and sequencer, analog distortion and more).

Anyway, I reached out to Julian and told him I couldn't hear a substantial difference, told him about what I wanted to do, and he was awesome enough to send me the raw edit and let me chop it up and make a blind test out of it, which is what I did.

So, if you were considering a Prophet 5/10 (or a 6), hopefully this helps you one way or the other!

All my best,

Ziv (remixing synth videos on youtube as "Loopop"...)

Files

BLIND TEST: Prophet 5/10 REV4 vs Prophet 6 // Can you tell the difference? // (J3PO remix...)

Thanks very much to J3PO for sending me the raw files for this video! Check prices here (affiliate links help the channel): ► Sweetwater - Prophet 5: https://imp.i114863.net/OVWGP ► Sweetwater - Prophet 6: https://imp.i114863.net/OVWGP ► Thomann - Prophet 5 https://www.thomann.de/gb/sequential_prophet_5.htm?offid=1&affid=369 ► Thomann - Prophet 6: https://www.thomann.de/gb/sequential_prophet_6.htm?offid=1&affid=369 Julian is a keyboard player and producer, tours with Marcus Miller and several members of Snarky Puppy, and works closely with Sequential and Nord Keyboards, most recently contributing to some of the factory presets for the Prophet 10 as well as the new Nord Wave 2. Here's a link to his full video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnWUHld91Ko Here's his site and patches: ► http://www.julianpollack.com/ Check out my ever-expanding book of electronic music ideas, tips and tricks here: ► Patreon: https://patreon.com/loopop Other places I hang out: ► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/loopopmusic ► Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/loopopmusic ► Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/loopopmusic ► Web: https://loopopmusic.com My music: ► Bandcamp: https://loopop.bandcamp.com ► Spotify: http://bit.ly/LoopopOnSpotify ► Apple Music:http://bit.ly/LoopopOnAppleMusic TIMELINE: 0:00 Intro 0:45 Specs 2:20 Tests start 2:35 Saw #1 3:05 Saw #2 3:30 Square #1 3:50 Square #2 4:15 Filter 5:20 Rev 3 vs 1/2 6:15 Resonant sweep 7:05 Vintage break 7:30 Triangle 8:00 PWM 8:30 Brass 9:00 Filter envelope 9:55 String 10:30 Outro Want to email me personally? ► Ziv (at) loopopmusic.com NOTE: Occasionally I’ll try out affiliate marketing and include affiliate links. This means that I may earn a commission when you click on or make purchases via affiliate links. The content of this clip is entirely my opinion, and was not paid for or dictated in any way by the company creating the gear. Without addressing the particulars of products shown here as they might be under NDA, gear shown on this channel may be either sent by the manufacturer, on loan for review or bought at a discount.

Comments

Loopop

I don't like to state my opinion so that it doesn't sway others before they listen, but since this is an answer to a comment, no, even if they were the same price I'd prefer the 6

Avétis KAZARIAN

Funny enough, I think I heard the difference (had an average of good answers around 70/80%). Is it worth the price difference? I have no idea. The difference is so small, that I don’t know if it’s justifiable. On the other hand, I found the 5/10 to be a bit reacher (at least to my ears), I had the feeling that it had more harmonics (pure speculation here). And also, if I’m not wrong, on some tests, the 5/10 seems to get systematically few more harmonics before the fundamental. I’m not sure, it seemed to me so.

Jan Tuitman

I really hear no difference. I also don’t see differences on the oscilloscope. And, different point but well worth mentioning, I am relatively new to the synth hobby and find this culture of worshipping precise sounds a bit odd..... because while I hear differences between synths I generally fail to perceive the musical relevance of the small differences between analog synths. When there are larger differences like between paradigms, for example wavetable vs analog, of course it can be very relevant. But within one type of synth..... well. Given a basic capability of the synth I feel one could do any piece of music on any synth, with a small timbre difference perhaps but not large enough to invoke really different meanings in the listener. At least when that listener is me...

unccostfallacy

The 6 sounds fatter and warmer to my ears; the 10 sounds like a digital emulation of an analog synth. Not as much of a value judgement as it sounds, though; the 10 might be easier to slot into a mix depending on the circumstance

0VRLNDR

Unless you first train your ear to the difference immediately before the test, this is just a game of confirmation bias. I would challenge anyone—without first identifying what the patch sounds on each in isolation—to identify which one was used in a complete mix, in different songs.

Peak Charcoal

I'm wondering if the sound is different straight through an analog mixer vs compressed audio? I think my local music shop has both on demo so it'd be an interesting comparison. Both instruments are really nice though!

Peak Charcoal

Thanks loopop! This is making my decision making even harder! 😂

Philip Wilson

Hello Loopop! I have just signed up for patreon and have no idea where to post this....I'm certainly not entertaining buying a Jupiter right now but, any chance your amazing book could be made available in an e-book format too. I've just run it through Calibre so I could convert from PDF to Mobi and read it on my Kindle. So far it's not completely mangled but there are some formatting idiosyncrasies. Thank you!

Loopop

Welcome! Thanks for the kind words about the book :) Indeed I would love to have an e-book format for it, but as you've experienced, making it look good would require quite an effort, and I've not yet found a fast workflow for it. Happy to take any suggestions, I've not explored this in depth yet (the book is written in Word if that helps)

Loopop

My pleasure! I have to admit making this video made mine easier - I'd go with the 6, but maybe I'm not hearing all the frequencies at my age ;)

Philip Wilson

I guess it depends what you used to write and format it in the first place. Something like indesign will have an epub format that allows for indexing and the text to reflow. Amazon will let you e-mail a pdf to your kindle and have it convert. It sucked. The calibre (free software) did a half decent job. Index was a mess but as I plan to read it from start to finish that doesn't matter. Images tend to have bounced around a bit too. Looks like there's a MS word to ebook convertor too which is free in the microsoft store if you wrote and update the book in word. Thanks again for an awesome channel. Your keystep, and 0-coast videos were a missive help to me.

Loopop

My pleasure! I will explore these tools for next month's update

Doug _

The thousand dollar difference would come in Inspiration. An extra octave is a big deal, to someone who is a pianist, by training, as are stereo voices to an pipe organist, who’s fine with five octaves. Considering the venue; the Live Sound Engineer only wants a clean mono feed, that gets the effects added at the House mixer. Stereo only works in a more intimate setting. Example: the Buchla 200e is an inspiring instrument, that outputs mono to quadraphonic locations in the room (I learned synthesis on a Buchla 100 in a quad studio.). It’s not the same as placing recorded instruments in an “orchestral seating”. If that matters to you, then the extra cash may be very well spent.