Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hi!

When I first saw the MV-1 Verselab from Roland, I was hesitant to review it - it's designed to produce vocals-based songs: I've heard myself sing, and I didn't like what I heard (though with auto tune I'm a darn good robot!).

MV-1 seems like a real attempt to create a DAWless-DAW. Maschine, Deluge and AKAI Force already have arranger based sequencing options fully capable of producing full tracks. MV-1 ditches the real time performance features to focus on making arranger style song production as simple as possible.

It seems like Roland are marketing it as a hip-hop/rap production station (the default BPM is 70 and the default kit it very trap) - and, while I have a lot of love for the genre, I completely lack the talent.

But then I remembered a track a good friend of mine wrote, produced and never published anywhere. I asked her for the vocal stem, and took upon myself to reproduce the track in MV-1, as a challenge to whether MV-1 can be used to produce a "real" song, which was produced on a DAW, with no real orientation towards "electronic music". Plus it was a good opportunity to force her to publish the song somewhere...

I've attached my direct mixdown export from MV-1 to this post.

Hopefully, my reproduction does her version justice! Here's a link to her bandcamp if you want to listen to the original, and if you like what you hear, please leave her a nice comment!

Have a great weekend!

Ziv (unfortunately still not rapping on youtube as "Loopop"...)

Files

DAW-less DAW? MV-1 VERSELAB Review and full song-making tutorial for Roland's portable studio

After watching this video, check out my update about the new "BYOS" option: ► MV-1 Update: https://youtu.be/74q7kCenEJ4 Can you produce a full song with vocals on Roland's MV-1 Verselab? Here's my attempt to reproduce a professionally produced track. Liked the tips and ideas in this video? Check out my ever-expanding book of electronic music ideas, tips and tricks here: ► Patreon: https://patreon.com/loopop Listen to Dana's original lovely production of the song I recreated in this video here (leave her a comment if you like it!): ► http://bit.ly/DanaPorter-Bandcamp Check MV-1 prices here (affiliate links help the channel): ► Sweetwater: https://imp.i114863.net/VLGEO ► Thomann: https://www.thomann.de/gb/roland_verselab_mv_1.htm?offid=1&affid=369 Other places I hang out: ► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/loopopmusic ► Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/loopopmusic ► Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/loopopmusic ► Web: https://loopopmusic.com My music: ► Bandcamp: https://loopop.bandcamp.com ► Spotify: http://bit.ly/LoopopOnSpotify ► Apple Music:http://bit.ly/LoopopOnAppleMusic TIMELINE: 0:00 Intro 1:45 Overview 8:15 Connectivity 9:20 Building a song 12:40 Arranging vocals 14:00 Vocal processing 16:25 Kit & track plan 18:00 Sound design 19:55 Kit design 20:55 Sampling 21:45 Editing samples 22:45 Looper tracks 24:15 Step sequencing 25:40 Live sequencing 26:35 Automation 27:30 Effects 30:30 Zenbeats 31:10 Quick tips 33:40 Pros & cons 38:55 Full track mixdown Want to email me personally? ► Ziv (at) loopopmusic.com NOTE: Occasionally I’ll try out affiliate marketing and include affiliate links. This means that I may earn a commission when you click on or make purchases via affiliate links. The content of this clip is entirely my opinion, and was not paid for or dictated in any way by the company creating the gear. Without addressing the particulars of products shown here as they might be under NDA, gear shown on this channel may be either sent by the manufacturer, on loan for review or bought at a discount.

Comments

Avétis KAZARIAN

While I think it's a good product for allowing beat making to reach a wider audience, it seems that Roland is kind of becoming a mere marketing monster: the last products' build is a shame, and some of the crucial "varnish" totally neglected (just looking at the MC 707 makes me want to cry). It feels like the best things Roland is able to make now is revamping their old prestigious line of synths...(well, you could say that about Korg too, but their renewed products bring a crazy lot more than redesigned smaller plastic "boutique" boxes...) Anyway, my point is that if they put much brain, it seems that it ends just to reach more customers, not necessarily making actually better products. (Yes, I'm still feeling bitter about my MC-707, and a bit vindictive too :p)

Loopop

What in particular were you disappointed about or was not as advertised about the MC-707?

Avétis KAZARIAN

Well, maybe they were advertised but not enough (or I wasn't attentive enough). Here's the most annoying ones: - build quality is extra cheap, just the top cover seems to have been glued by a drunk guy who couldn't make the the holes face the knobs properly (can't turn easily some knobs because of that) - the filters are sooooo muddy, it feels more like you're lowering the volume of the track than actually filtering for the LPF and for the HPF, it's kind of a total failure (don't expected to pump up that bass properly), and so are most of the effect based on filters - the default sound banks are from another century, and while it's nice to have a lot of cool synths from the past, the drum kits are actually...cheap. And the most annoying is that the numbers are used in a cheating way: you have multiple variants of the same drum kits, with just a little effect applied on them, so in the end you have 5 times less kits than actually advertised. - I wanted to fix that buy putting my own sound banks, but I ended up slowing down the embed system, and whenever I needed to save/load/check projects, or do anything similar with samples/sound banks, it would take ages (we're talking around 5secs at least, which is, for such operation a lot!). - the pads are harder than chrome-vanadium, I had a tendinitis on both hands and wrists after using it for a week (and I am very very soft when I do finger drumming, and yes I changed the sensitivity to the max in the settings) - the menu diving is sometimes nightmarish with the 4 knobs navigations and if you're doing something like, well, you end messing things And the most frustrating is that it's a 4 timbral crazy digital synth! But as far as my skills go (and they don't go very far, unfortunately) I couldn't get out anything amazing enough from the MC-707. For that price, I would have preferred going for an MPC One or Force. I know that this is extremely subjective (expect the build quality which I double checked in different stores), and that my skills are pretty much low, but I did spent a great amount of time reading and practicing with the manual, trying to push the beast to its limits. Yes it does amazing things too, but just the cheap filters are enough to make me want to move away from it.

Avétis KAZARIAN

One last thing I didn't mention: the workflow can be very tedious if you want to achieve something similar to Live, but there is the feeling that you can (because of the "pattern grid" view). Especially due to the limited amount of loop track's duration. Plus the well know issue with accessing samples.

Loopop

Makes sense. My experience with the hardware build is good but maybe I'm lucky. I agree the synth is very complex - it's really four full synths in one so it's quite a handful (not just for beginners...)

Avétis KAZARIAN

Oh, what I meant about the 4 synths was positive, the point was that having something so powerful one side yet having cheap things (like the filters) on the side made it even more frustrating. And strangely, I could easily get through the part editor after the first few headaches. It's heavily based on menu diving on that little screen but the overall workflow is OK.

Avétis KAZARIAN

I was so upset about Roland I forgot to mention that I really liked the track you made with your friend’s vocals stem. Really nice 👍

Tekrytor

Very nice track! Both versions are very clean and dynamic. Loopop, are you ready to toss your DAW out the window yet?

Loopop

Thanks! The DAW I make most of my music on is and will probably remain as long as this channel is going is Adobe Premiere Pro...

Loopop

Thanks very much! I have to say that with all of Roland's gears flaws you mentioned (and I agree they're far from perfect), the track sounds good (aside from my friend's voice) because the instruments and effects work well together. But indeed, getting to them isn't always easy

Avétis KAZARIAN

Well, I guess the French saying is correct: "Il n'y a point de mauvais outils, (mais des mauvais ouvriers)". Which translates to "There's no such thing as bad tools, (only unskilled workers)". Then I need more skills! Thank's God, there are skilled masters like yourself to learn from on the Internet :)

Loopop

totally my pleasure - thanks!

Jeff Shuck

Great video as always. I’ll offer a counterpoint to the posts above and say as an owner of the most recently-released Fantom, I’m actually quite impressed at the level of investment and cohesion Roland is putting into Zen-core. Some manufacturers are better at long-term commitment than others (it’s so great that Elektron, for example, keeps releasing meaningful firmware updates for their gear years after release). I wasn’t sure how willing Roland was going to be to make a sustained commitment. Zen-Core always struck me as long play, but now 18 months on, their vision is coming together. So my own sense is that while each piece of gear can be considered in stand-alone, it is also necessary to put Roland’s releases in the context of this larger world they’re building. (The Avengers is so much richer if you watch Captain America, too!) I’m not sure I would have looked at the MV-1 two years ago but now it is compelling to me, partly because I could take all of my Fantom sounds in a backpack. And in a related point, I think the Zen-Core world has also made Roland better and keeping their gear current — the Fantom’s functionality has been greatly expanded in only a year. I’m still waiting and hoping for Korg to release the Oasys II (still unmatched to me in terms of integration, elegance, and build quality), but the Zen-Core world is getting more and more attractive as a way of mixing and matching highly integrated and complimentary products.

Jeff Shuck

On the subject of Elektron, Loopop, does the MV-1 offer any Elektron-esque randomization? It’s one thing I’m really hoping they’ll add to the Fantom sequencer — the ability to set a probability per step. Anything like that on offer here? Looks like there’s a “random” function on clips but nothing beyond that?

Loopop

Hey Jeff - yes, other than random as a pattern playback option, you've got per step probability on the kit sequences (not the tone ones for some reason). Thanks for your ongoing support BTW!

Connor Sol

Aw man! Was hoping for an exclusive "Loopop raps and sings with autotune over an entire track on the MV-1" bonus track here on Patreon! I might rescind that million dollar offer and pay it 1 at a time on Patreon instead 😁

Connor Sol

Off-topic note but I hope the developers of the Anyma Phi send you a review prototype someday. (the Phi looks to be a physical modeling synth in the "handbox" style that Loopop culture is all about, and I think it recently completed its crowd-fund.) Hope they get a unit sent your way when the time is right!

Loopop

Heyyy - welcome! You can't rescind an offer once there's acceptance I'm afraid, but you never said how long it would take you to pay, so $1 a month technically is in compliance. I promise an autotune rap track when you get to $500k ;)

Loopop

Indeed seems cool! And you're right that I prefer the smaller synths with character and this seems to have plenty of it

Harry Imster

Again, under horsepowered, no undo. Today, when a Rasberry Pi 4 with 8GB and a quadcore processor costs $75 retail, someone should be able to put together a "portastudio" that is easy to use, can manage long audio stems, has decent efx and instruments, and allows for punching in and comping. These are things that songwriters and producers really need. And (as much as I love you and your channel) your comparison by taking vocal stems from the original session leaves out all of the comping, splicing, de-essing, compression and eq-ing that goes into making them. Finally, what happens when you hit the wall? When your track needs that 17th part? Can you export the project as stems to be put into a DAW? My recommendation to people who are considering it: A cheap windows laptop, Reaper, a decent audio interface, and a good mic. In the future 3 /4 of those things will still have value. The Verselab will be an expensive paperweight.

Harry Imster

I could not agree more. The load time of the 707 makes it unusable in a live situation unless you have a "look over here!!" distraction while you take 45 seconds to load a new project. As a sampler it is practically useless. And it may seem minor, but after 3 or four updates, they have not fixed spelling errors in the software: "THE FILE IS EXIST". As a software professional, this is a smell that means the developers are not paying attention. To me it seems like Roland just repackages the same bad technology in different ways to saturate the market - like Taco bell - it's all the same shit, just with a different name and format. I've kept my 707 around for some sounds - I think the pcm pianos and eps are good. But watching this video made me decide to put it on the market, just because the thought of it made me choke down a little vomit.

Harry Imster

Jeff, look at the Deluge. It has that and more.

Loopop

I think you underestimate the cost of the physical hardware controls, R&D and bundled content, but I agree with you that someone should, and I promise you I'll cover it when they do cause I'd love me one of those, but for some reason, no one does. Regarding me using a prepared stem, 16 parts etc - all of those are disclosed in the video and as I mentioned to another commenter in the video, there are cons throughout and 5 minutes of cons at the end compared to 30 seconds of pros. I still had a ton of fun making the track compared to using a DAW though. My recommendation would be a DAW too, this is for people who don't want or are intimidated to use one - we take for granted using a DAW and sometimes forget how intimidating it is to get one set up and use.

Harry Imster

I see your point. But I think singer songwriters are going to think they can make great sounding tracks - when they can't do the amount of vocal pre-processing that is required (especially using non-studio grade mics and conditions) to make a vocal really shine in a track. As you know, producing a track, you'll spend about 10 minutes on a sax solo and days getting the lead vocal right ;) Of course the interesting part of the product is the integration of vocals/audio with a groovebox. My question is: how many singer/songwriter/producers are geeky enough to buy a groove box? And Ziv, I apologize for my crankiness. I'm one of those who got sucked into the 707, and have felt like a concept with so much possibility was handcuffed from the start by lack of foresight and sloppiness. I mean I'm all for the Zen core engine, but using it with these boxes is like trying to carve a sculpture with a toothpick. It just seems like Roland is like Taco Bell: repackaging the same food over and over again and it still makes you feel like crap after you eat it. As you know, Ziv - I'm a big fan of your work ;) I hope you might make the trip to Knobcon this year so we can meet in person.

Loopop

oh no worries - I enjoy a good debate :) plus I agree with you a DAW is better and that the 707 is clunky. BTW I think the MV-1 is perfectly capable of capturing a good vocal take and applying effects to it. I didn't go through the details of the vocal processor but aside from the ear candy of autopitch (which can be made subtle) and "radio mode", it actually has quite a few traditional vocal processing capabilities, including a de-esser. It's actually no joke

Loopop

maschine now supports clips in the arranger and is a serious competitor to this

simon cunningham

defo. I think I have an emotional connection to the versalab because of its predecessors and it was a tough call re Maschine +. After spending a weekend with Maschine it felt like a recording studio in a box wearing a groovebox clothes.....but ive found it very well disguised, the options often overpowering and often get sidetracked into learning rather than writing. as soon as they added clips, they made a standalone entity that could compswipe.... im not sure if ill regret.... some of my best pics and the most fun ive had with a camera have been with a gx8 which doesnt have the best sensor or lenses but is easy to pick up and use....and well just fun.... applied design often takes a back seat to system spec...im a slow learner with not much time...limitations are sometime simplicity....maschine+ is in the back of my head (grrr) but SHINGA instant techno brought a smile to my face...hes already subverting versalab to his will. Thankyou for running such a great channel and I hope well meet one day at superbooth.