Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Question: Loopop community - should we and why?

  • No need, keep doing what you're doing and focus on book updates & videos! 453
  • Discord would be awesome for the reasons I'll list below... 39
  • A web based forum is better and I'll tell you why! 17
  • 2021-07-16
  • 509 votes
{'title': 'Question: Loopop community - should we and why?', 'choices': [{'text': "No need, keep doing what you're doing and focus on book updates & videos!", 'votes': 453}, {'text': "Discord would be awesome for the reasons I'll list below...", 'votes': 39}, {'text': "A web based forum is better and I'll tell you why!", 'votes': 17}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 7, 16, 13, 1, 10, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 509}

Content

Hi there!

I've received a few requests over time to open a Patreon discord, and another option is a web-based forum (using a web-based platform called discourse, like the Elektronauts or Lines forums).

I've not done it so far because it would take some of my attention away from book updates and channel videos and my concern is that only a small number of Patrons will end up participating in either one, ultimately not benefiting most supporters.

So - the question is, would you like a Loopop Patreon community, if so which one, and more importantly why - meaning which topics you'd like to be discussed?

What would make a loopop forum stand out as opposed to all the other synth/music forums, facebook groups, etc.? If it's me giving tech support then sorry that's not an option :)

Please comment below with the topics, and I'll consider any non-vote as a vote against opening a community feature...

Thanks for participating either way and have a great weekend!

Ziv / Loopop

Comments

Carsten Sorensen

Just keep doing your excellent reviews and keep updating the book as in the past, and all will be well in the world! More frequent engagement and chit-chat does not mean more content, it will mean less content but more superficial chit-chat ;-)

Ando

I can only guess at how much work it takes to produce an hour of video to your standards.

Loopop

Thanks and yes that was my concern! Even chit chat requires time to review and respond to...

Ando

(oops pressed Return early ). If I wanted anything more it would be a structure like this page to make easily-collatable suggestions for what supporters would like to see in the book.

Loopop

Thanks and yes, quite a bit...

Jacob Shulkin

The use that I would see out of a discord/forum would probably be to filter discussions about patch ideas on different instruments that we can share ideas in. I suppose this could be done on elektronauts itself but where I would see value is trying to, as a community, expand on your “hacks” ideas. I’m particularly interested in engaging with the community on ideas for the Digitakt with the new firmware especially, I have been playing a lot with time stretching and finding ways to make it performance oriented. Thanks!

Loopop

I agree! I've been looking for something that would make that better but haven't found it yet

Tim Hofmann

just as good and easier for Ziv would be to have a convo here about which existing fora/discord servers are good options for interested folks.

Martin Dinnage

I think Discord and Discourse are great options for communities around products, where the developers can interact with the user community, announce updates, and gather feedback. But they are less compelling in the case of content providers, unless they become the primary location for content releases and the provider is actively engaged with the community there. I’d say your brand is something different, so probably not the right move for you. Just one opinion!

Ando

It's a tricky one, cos I guess folk would have suggestions that would vary from the detail level "more stuff on.. pls" to stylistic "a diagram about x would help me get my head 'round this aspect of synthesis" to meta-analysis on structure of the work itself!... ... all of which takes your time!

Avétis KAZARIAN

From what I have seen on other communities around a “synth reviewer” (sorry Ziv, couldn’t find any simpler and better words 🙏), it’s quite useless. For instance, Benn Jordan has opened a Discord server and nothing much happens except the usual chitchat. And anything beyond that could easily be achieved with other means, like the poll you just made here. Let’s make less noise online and more on the gears 🙃

Balazs Benyo

Voted for discord. You probably don't want to host/maintain/spend time with a forum. It is probably a lot of time and effort. I'm on a couple of discord servers related to Patreon memberships and they are usually very good places to share/discuss ideas and connect with other supporters.

nanotopia

I am all for you keeping your focus, which has been amazing! IMHO discord, etc., just becomes a cluttercluster drawing energy vacuum and also, everything Martin said above :)

Chris Bartley

You have a perfect format...no need to change if you ask me. Your videos and book are trusted and provide a lot of insight not only on a piece of gear but more importantly, how to put it all together. I don't care what others would have to say on a forum - I only care what LoopPop has to say. Stay the course, good sir. PS - More interviews with other synth nerds showing us their workflow would be cool. You're awesome LoopPop, love your stuff.

johndoe

i do not need a community (today), but if i do some day: please no forum. it's a 90s thing and no fun to maintain (for you, ziv). discord and co. do better here and i would not need _another_ account and password :) greetings!

Sergey Kataev

Discord is a great option, and I have a very positive experience using a server of one of Patreon creators I support (Jay Hosking), very nice community, we're discussing gear and music, sharing our creations etc. I don't think even if you're creating a server you must always engage in conversation there, not at all, most of the questions that might be addressed to you will be answered by the members of your community. So I'd say it's a very nice way to interact with your community, more than just a comment section on YT or Patreon, I don't think that counts as actual conversation. And remember - all those people on your server are people supporting you already, they will most definitely gonna be friendly and supportive. So if you want to engage into conversation with your community Discord is a very good option. Except initial setup I would say it wouldn't take more of your time than you yourself want to spend on it.

Loopop

Thanks for the comment - yes that's what I would envision it being as well but my fear is that many people don't log in (as I've seen with other servers) and miss out on the ideas and discussion. By the way, I am planning on another Digitakt video hopefully in August!

Loopop

Indeed that was my thinking as well so thanks for chiming in! I just wanted to make sure I wasn't wrong

Loopop

Thanks for taking the time to write :)

Loopop

Thanks very much for the comment and ongoing support! Yes I'm out looking for more guests - I'm looking for people that don't already talk about their setups on their channels so that I can bring a new perspective to the table - if you have any ideas please let me know!

Jason Gillman Jr.

I was originally of the view that "Yes! Would be neat to have a discord server for the Loopop community!" While I still do hold that view, I also see the concern in expending the limited resources (read: time) needed to make it work. Through time this could be handled by way of adding trusted individuals to moderate, but there's going to be an up front "cost" to get things in a position where that will work. I absolutely love being able to discuss audio and music production real time - in fact that's why most of the discord servers I'm on are audio related. And I think it's that fact that got me to reconsider my position. So with that said, maybe instead of Loopop expending the time to build a quality discord server of his own, he could possibly instead identify and recommend quality existing servers for the community to converse on. There would obviously be some time that would be spent to identify the servers (starting points could be made by the community?), but I'm guessing that amount of time would be lower than starting from scratch - and could be updated over time.

David Goldstein

While I can see the value of a discord that was restricted to patreon users as a way for them to interact, network, socialize, and share, I would really hate to see you spend time on that unless it was helping your own goals. Your videos are an asset to the community. I consistently find people discussing gear point to your review/walkthroughs of equipment for folks who want to get a deeper understanding. You have managed to create a consistent highly respected brand that people trust, and we all know that it takes a lot of work to be clear and informative on such an ongoing basis. In short, unless something is going to make it easier for you to keep producing marvelous material (book & video), or earn more money for your hard work, I don't see much virtue in you investing your very valuable time.

Loopop

Thanks for the comment - I support Jay and agree it's a fun forum - I just know myself and that I wouldn't be able to stay away...

Jack Moffitt

As opposed to an always available forum/discord for more community engagement, have you considered doing a monthly live stream? That would time box your commitment, use tools you already have, and still provide a way for us patrons to get some more interactive time with you. Or if a livestream doesn't fit, perhaps a monthly Q&A video where you take questions here on patreon and then answer them.

Synthesiste

I will echo this. Your brand is different and I think your best value is to do the videos and book updates and double down your efforts there :). You are probably the best talent in the ecosystem and what you do is extremely valuable which I am afraid will be diluted in some way, shape or form with these distractions.

Loopop

Thanks Jason - BTW feel free to point to any servers you think are worthwhile! I know you like the Venus Theory one :) Any others?

Loopop

Thanks very much for the comment and ongoing support!

Joe Pfister

If you are going to go forward with a community platform, then my vote would be for discord. I enjoy having discussions and hearing ideas from those with similar interests. However, not having this wouldn't be a deal breaker as your current format suits your content well. You do what you think is best for your workflow. I trust you. :)

Aaron Kinney

If it’s a forum of directed questions with NO chit chat would be helpful. Setup the “rules of engagement” in advance with the community holding each other to them. Some times there is a need for short but direct questions. Modular etc is at times too complicated for beginners and it would help to engage with you.

JX3D

I voted no. Only problem with Patreon is its difficult to find (browse to) older stuff. So if you could spend some time on posting a contents-list one or two times each year, it would be great.

Jotta Arango

I think that your videos and the book are the beginning of a discussion that can be complemented by user experiences. The videos have helped me a lot to make my purchase decisions but it would be also very helpful for me to advance faster with my process for example through the exchange with more users of an specific devise/synth or with some kind of mentoring! have you thought about doing this? I think the best option would be something like discourse to avoid losing focus on what is important: music!

Stujay

I get the sense that people are starting to suffer from Discord burnout. With the world seemingly opening up slowly, people’s time is becoming more limited. I suspect people will want to use spare time to make music, and will have less time to spend on Discord channels. I’ve already sensed a slow-down on some channels.

Jason Gillman Jr.

I guess the ones I might recommend are: Stranjah & Friends -- This one is focused pretty heavy on D&B given that's what Stranjah does, but I've still found it a good community even though that's not a genre I produce or really even listen to much. Kilohearts -- This official server by Kilohearts (developers of Phase Plant) is obviously going to be heavily focused on their products. That said, still a good community in general and a source of information if you use their products (or are interested). Voltage Modular Community -- Another server focused on a particular soft synth (Voltage Modular, surprise!), however this one is, at least for the time being, unofficial. Not as active as my other recommendations, but a good place if you're interested in VM. A few of the module developers are active there as well. Vital -- .... yet another focused community (official server) for the amazing free soft synth developed by Matt Tytel. I'm not too horrendously active on this one, but it's certainly active, and I want to promote this one given my appreciation for what Matt's done for the community.

Martin Junius

A Discord channel would be great, but I understand the opinions against it. And I second the idea of Q&A videos similar to what eg Adam Neely or Hainbach do.

Joerg H

I think there are many opportunities out there to exchange ideas, concerns, issues and to discuss them in diverse forums. But there is nothing like Ziv's book updates and videos. Please continue to focus on those, Ziv. They are of great value and unmatched quality.

Tim Harrison

I believe the channel is mostly gear focused right? So I think a gear focused discord could be useful. Supporting each other with gear questions?

Jason Hoffman

There are plenty of communities for this already. Perhaps you could join or partner with one and contribute there when necessary if you feel like it to have more quotidian communication with your audience. For example, LMNC has a Discourse and Hainbach and DivKid both have Discords, and within the greater YouTube synth community there is a lot of cooperation already. Focus on what drew us to you in the first place, and keep playing to those strengths!

Michael Faille

Get a forum like discourses to discuss have scaling and interesting discussion around your project theme.

Loopop

Thanks! Yes, I've considered both - still pondering the right format... regarding Q&A - feel free to ask me anything :) re live streams I find that many of those I view are too long and it's hard to find your way around - I think people value edited content more, but perhaps a time machine would allow me to time stamp live streams in advance!

Loopop

Thanks, and thanks for your ongoing support! Overall I don't do 1x1's but I've tried to answer every possible modular question in my book - if there's a particular topic you'd like me to cover just let me know

Loopop

Thanks and I agree. Have you checked out the end of my book - that's exactly the problem I try to solve in the appendices (and the whole book really...). I'd love to make it better - let me know if you have any ideas.

Loopop

Thanks for the feedback and ongoing support! When I thought of opening a forum that's exactly how I'd structure it (by device) - but overall my concern (which seems to be echoed by this poll's results) is that it won't be visited much. I can't offer mentoring but wouldn't it be lovely to have a place like that. I think the closest for now is good facebook groups for a particular instrument (like the ZOIA or Circuit users group). Worth some further thought for sure...

Loopop

Thanks for the feedback and ongoing support :)

Loopop

Thanks so much for the comment and ongoing support!

Loopop

Yes it is a gear-centric channel, the question is, what would make "my" discord different from all the other gear discords? (I'm a member of over 10...)

Loopop

Noted and thanks for supporting :)

aseeon

This idea is definitely worth thinking about - maybe there is a synth community you could join or partner with. Existing communities would give you the freedom to engage whenever you feel like it but at the same time you wouldn't need to put time in maintaining and managing them.

Toby

Nah. You stick to what you do demonstrably well. Discord's and fora inevitably turn sour with flame-wars, posturing and all sorts of unwanted stuff ... as well as the off-topic and irrelevant. Encourage discussion of your pieces in existing places but stay out of them and on the high ground. Certainly don't waste energy and other stuff. Sadly there's too much immaturity, stupidity, outright aggression and the just obnoxious that piles into the well-meant, thoughtful and encouraging places. If you want to promote discussion, spend time and energy on your book (as a text and a video library?) and perhaps "tutorials", "techniques" or "tips'n'tricks" revisiting ideas and perhaps equipment ... explore a synthesis or musical idea, a programming or performance technique, a modulation or a sound idea ... and promote threads discussing those ideas and their implementation and inspiration in places. Other people do "shoot-out's" (sometimes well) ... but "here's some ideas for rhythmic/percussion" demonstrated on a variety of X-by-X pad-devices/DAW's ... more inspirational than a more traditional "tutorial", "manual" ... a modern take on the excellent Sound-On-Sound "Synth Secrets" perhaps?

Tim Harrison

I’m no expert, but I find the discord communities seem to reflect the owner. Your content is thoughtful and respectful and I would expect you’d attract like minded individuals. If that’s true I’d stay engaged. If it turns into bros talking about getting drunk and doing cocaine then I’m less interested. ;-)

Tekrytor

These Patreon and YouTube comments are forum enough, IMO. Toby said it well already that forums often turn into debating venues with very polarized stands, disharmony, and can end up diverging far from the intended course. Keep things simple, IMO. It isn't necessary to adopt *every* new tool that comes along, e.g. Twitter, Instagram, FB, etc, etc, etc. and they often just distract from our prime objectives. Focus is paramount.

Dieter Pomberger

Voted no also. I'm already in enough Discord Servers. Love the Book! And thats enough for me.

Adi Soffer

So after voting I saw the majority just wants you to carry on as you do. I guess the only plus (web forum’s my vote) is to enable more dialogue. And that’s probably possible with your encouragement here as well n

Loopop

yes of course - I answer every question/comment here!

Loopop

Indeed agreed on focus - I actually didn't want to lose focus from patrons' needs, and there were a few who asked for a discord forum, but apparently from the vote they are the minority - so stay the course it is!

Loopop

Thanks, and yes that's what I try to do here! Will keep exploring such ideas to the best of my ability :)

Loopop

yes I would very much like that (I actually hoped discourse would be the end result) - but in light of the voting unfortunately it seems not many people want or would use that

Tonverfall Studio

I generally don't think there's a need, but r/loopop would be easy to create on Reddit, and would certainly serve the purpose for the small group who want a forum. I think Hainbach does this.

Craig Warrender

Less is more imo... keep up the good work

Loopop

Hainbach's reddit is cool, but if I spend time on something I prefer it to benefit people who support here on Patreon because this is what makes the channel possible (and thanks for your ongoing support!)

John Hickson

You have something very unique and quite informative with the current format. My vote is to keep this work going. There are already plenty of places for dialog to break down into muck and mire.

Origin ST

The Divkid discord is a lovely place and would be good to be able to have detailed discussions with other loopop supporters and your good self on gear and techniques. Would say discord over other forums because of existing servers it’s easier to look in one place rather than many...

John Cook

I voted for Discord, but I think ideally you could delegate the moderation to other folks, and maybe just participate from time to time.

Charles Ginsberg

I like discord. I'm in a few other discord channels and like those communities. I wouldn't expect Loopop to moderate the forums. I just find the Patreon forums to be a bit static here. I'm for anything that allows a community to organically form and engage.

Tom Martinson

Initially I voted for a Discord but then changed it to a 'nahhh'... I think what you're doing is great and the book is indispensable. I agree with others that with things opening up, screen time is going to diminish for many, myself included. Also I think a Discord on a gear channel would just further enable my already raging case of g.a.s....

John Stewart

Agreed, just because it's 'trendy' to open a Discord doesn't mean you should. I like the Loopiverse the way it is :0)

Doug Nicola

I think your content and focus is totally awesome just as it is. Wouldn't change a thing!

Loopop

Thanks and thank you for your amazing support :)

Loopop

well ok then! :) Thanks to both for your feedback

Roman Turkiewicz

I voted for the Discord option. As great as your content is, sometimes there is an assumed knowledge starting point which might suit a lot of experienced gear users but not for me. It would be beneficial if there was a detailed way to discuss topics slowly where ideas/concepts can be hammered out in depth for a greater understanding. I learn slowly these days...I blame my advancing years. Regardless of what choice is made above, big thanks for all that you do

Henning Sprang

I could say a discord or forum would be nice, but i doubt i‘d be looking into it regularly unless something very special would pull me there. Theres already so many possibilities, a forum or fb group for each device or software you can buy, and kvr with areas for many products and general stuff. Electronauts is also about many different topics. What would i get in an extra loopop forum that’s not already in the great videos and book, any of the previously mentioned or here and on YT where i can ask questions about your tutorials and stuff? Maybe you might want to open your own loopop section on kvr?

Michael Koehler

I might have a unique viewpoint here as I am not sure many fit the same profile as myself. I am a professional in this industry for over 30 years (ie. make a living working in it). I hold several "roles" in the industry with various "jobs" - from making records to sound design to MI development. I am involved on a professional, business-level with many of the brands that people have seen reviewed personally by Ziv. With that said, I am supporting Ziv via Patreon because I find him unique in what he does. He provides immense value to his followers and supporters - something I do not see the same as with others. On a personal-level, I have come to really, really enjoy his reviews and also the book. It is of insane value. Everything he does is extremely professional and top-notch. Someone already mentioned the amount of work it takes to create one video - that is not a lie. When an MI manufacturer releases a new product, even a 60 second video takes an emmense amount of work to pull off. Ziv's productions are just as equal, yet he makes them look so natural and effortless. I think it would be a distraction to start up a forum and take away from the high-value he provides today.

SpookyPenguin

God no, this is the perfect complement to a discord community I'm already involved in, this would just split my attention span that's already too fractured. And it's way too much work on top of what you're already doing.

Christopher Tabecki

Great Work as it stands Ziv I’m one of those slow learners but intuition I trust in .. you give a person like me the groundwork of information I need : This electronic music / noise making - is essentially experimental after all

Shamus

You do an amazing job with the video and the book, for me that's enough and thank you!

Chris Bilsland

I know you put a lot into your content and wouldn’t want you to take away from that. If you were pulling in enough money for staff to help out with these things it makes sense but don’t want the content to suffer. I do like the idea of a forum because most of the forums that were good have turned to garbage but I can still find answers on the net even if it takes awhile. I helped co-found the forum for Access Virus and building a community is fun but a lot of work.

Loopop

Thanks and thanks for your amazing support!

Loopop

Thanks for the feedback and for your ongoing support :)

Loopop

my pleasure - thanks for the kind words and support :)

Loopop

Thanks - I really appreciate the comment, thanks for taking the time to write!

Loopop

Thanks :) feel free to share which one!

Loopop

Thanks - those were my thoughts too regarding other forums, but since a few people asked, I thought I'd open up the poll. Regarding KVR, if I divert time from what I'm doing now I'll only do it to give more value to Patrons - you guys make this possible :)

Loopop

Thanks for the feedback and ongoing support. If I was to open a discord what you mentioned is what I'd look to give/get from it, but since it seems like there isn't much support for it in this poll, feel free to engage in the comment section of each video - I'm happy to respond and have a dialog there.

Oliver Schedler

I agree with the numbers so far. I don't see how either platform would add much while at the same time drawing from your time and energy. I feel your net output would even suffer. I really enjoy the concise walkthrough to more ideas with gear. Thank you!

Martijn Calkhoven

I've been in a few other Patreon Discords and personally find them overwhelming. Don't get me wrong, I love Discord as a platform, but logging in and seeing all those white dots marking hundreds of unread messages in 30+ text channels (per server) just fills me with anxiety. Now imagine feeling the obligation to stay on top of it all, because it's your own server (been there). IF, despite of this landslide off a poll, you decide to launch a Discord server, my advice would be to take a very hands-off approach.

Svetlin Simeonov

Your current format is great, and as I see numbers - others think the same :). Best Regards from Bulgaria.

Bram Damman

I voted the web based option, since sometimes I feel it could be useful to ask this community a question every now and then. Also it could be nice to meet some people with similar setups as I have to exchange ideas. My only experience with Discord was joining the Plinky community, but since I never intended to become a very active member, I never bothered to even try to understand how Discord works: it is somewhat intimidating, when all I want is just to read a few threads and maybe ask a question or two. I don't think I would bother to join a Loopop forum on Discord. But looking at the votes, it seems that most people aren't really interested in a forum. There is nothing more tragic as a forum without contributors. I can totally live without a dedicated Loopop forum.

Bram Damman

BTW: I do like this Discourse software. It looks modern and flexible. *If* you would start a web based forum, than I think this is a good choice.

Chris Diehn

I have too many communications platforms that I can't keep up with. The video and book updates are much better for me!

John Fraboni

I could go either way. I use discord and slack all the time, but they're better suited for working groups or real time communication. In terms of a knowledge base, those types of chat platforms are not the best for cataloging topics and inquiries. The book you're compiling is great, and the videos I'm sure take alot of your time. Moderating a discord channel to success is another thing altogether. Maybe what you could do is compile a short list of the better, more active user groups,and ask your user base to contribute to that list. You've probably already listed these resources in your book, but I'm not at the end yet - don't tell me how it ends, tho, the suspense is killing me :)

Loopop

Thanks - much appreciated :)

Loopop

Thanks and yes I agree and would have preferred a forum too - but indeed it would seem very few people are interested.

Loopop

Ha spoiler - the butler did it! The most useful forums I've seen so far are the usual suspects - Elektronauts, Lines, KVR, GearSpace, Instrument-specific Facebook groups. It's actually a good idea to add that as an appendix! Coming up in the next update...

Tim Moore

I guess another way to look at this would be to look at what people are looking for with more interaction, then how do leverage what you do best to provide that additional need. I "voted " with the majority here, but if I were to brainstorm, the first place I would go is: Wouldn't it be cool if each chapter of the book had a way to ask questions within chapter for problems that people are encountering, and then the community can pitch in to help, while you focus on the content. Not sure how to do that best (linked discussion boards from each chapter, publishing the book as HTML with attached comments/discussions to each chapter...lost of ways. Push comes to shove, though, do what you do best, and we can leverage other forums for further support. Or the youtube channel. And BTW, thank you so much for all you do.

Loopop

Thanks for the comment and ongoing support! That indeed would be cool - if I see something like that (or you know of one) I'd be happy to implement it. Ideally, it would be sort of like a wiki, but I'd want it to be Patron only, so I'm not sure how to pull that off technically in a cost effective way. If you have any ideas let me know!

GRK_Astronomer

My vote is against a discord type of group. My experience with them is they don't seem to lend a lot to any particular subject and the topic of discussion become lost in the Frey of everyone diving in with their experiences or opinions. I see it as a major distraction for the readers as well as the host. I much prefer your traditional style and greatly appreciate all the effort you put into that. I know of other knowledgeable people that have gone this route (won't mention their names or channels) and just feel the distraction has really impacted then intent they originally had on Patreon. Reviews as nicely conceived and executed as your's are would seemed to be challenging enough with all of the new equipment coming out.

Fabio Neves

I don't understand Discord's appeal. I already deal with Slack and MS Teams for work and the last thing I want is using yet another group chat platform on my free time. My vote is stick to videos, they're great and we already have Patreon for comms.

Kevin Menshik

Some really interesting ideas in the comments. I like the idea of doing a couple of Q&A videos a year to address common questions. I really like the idea of this community helping out a bit. I am sure there are a lot of folks who would be happy to volunteer to monitor and summarize questions or moderate a forum for you. You could be briefed on what is going on without having to be “on” all the time. You control the overall tone, look, and feel of the forum, but others share the load. Options that spread the tasks, while allowing you to focus, this feels like the option I would get behind. If you are spread too thin, you will add work and stress to yourself with little positive results.

Loopop

Thanks for the feedback and ongoing support!

Loopop

Thanks for the feedback and ongoing support. Knowing myself I wouldn't be able to stay away, which is why I asked the question because it would indeed take away from what I would be able to give as I do today. I would love to get the community together in some other way, so will certainly stay open to other ideas. Meanwhile of course feel free to keep asking anything as comments / DM's!

dyce.

As much as I want to vote for another Discord server.. I'm in /so many/ Discord servers already. I'd rather see the community aggregate around a few rather than having every Patreon person have their own. Keep doing what you're doing, and if you feel the need to engage in a more direct way, hang out on the existing Discords, IMO.

Loopop

Cool and thanks for your long time support!

Tim Moore

I haven't been ignoring this...just thinking...

Tommi Kärkkäinen

I think this current version is adequate. The videos are very informative and thorough and one can always ask the questions on comments section on YouTube. Besides you should also have time to do other things too. Life is more than just doing videos and writing a book and any type of forum would eventually grow too big to handle.

Devon C Johnson

Honestly Discord doesn’t have to be run by you. It can be a community fostered by people you trust and you can pop in like Santa on xmas. So start a Discord AND focus on the things you need to focus on 😀. I’m sure you have plenty of supporters with experience who would be willing to help (myself included)!

Loopop

Thanks for the kind words and offering to help! Right now it seems like most people are against it, but if I do take a look at it again I will certainly take you up on that offer!