Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Dear WaveShapers!

A major recent event inspired this month's book update. 

No, it's not the trip to space by the suggestively shaped Blue Origin rocket (it looks like a mushroom, right?), but rather the fact that Apple announced Spatial Audio with support for Dolby Atmos in Apple Music, which is anticipated to become even more immersive when head-tracking is added in iOS 15 and AirPods Pro/Max. 

I've been passionate about spatial music for a while and have covered quadraphonic music in the past, but with a lack of a standardized delivery method, there wasn't an easy way to share it: unlike video, surround formats for audio like SACD, DVD-A and Blu-ray Audio have been rejected by consumers (wild guess: most of you don't have a single one at home).

So, you can imagine my excitement about the potential of this development, hoping that "this could be the one" that finally lets us all easily experience immersive, spatial audio in the comfort of our own headphones and surround-enabled TV setups. It's not just about Apple by the way, Tidal also supports Atmos and even Bezos took time away from launching rockets into space to support Atmos in Amazon Prime HD.

So great, I thought, I'll just cover Atmos and be done with it!

However, the "cheapest" Atmos renderer costs $300 and the only other current option I found is Nuendo, which costs way more. And don't get me started with the learning curve for those tools. 

But, when you think about it, head-tracking notwithstanding, an Atmos render into headphones (which is how we're likely to experience spatial audio) is really just a binaural effect sent out to two speakers in our ears. 

So, coverage needed to expand to binaural audio, as an alternative, until an affordable Atmos renderer comes along. I cover quite a few free or cheap binaural renderers that can pretty much do the same thing as far as listening on headphones is concerned (as opposed to a massive speaker setup)

But, when I started trying out different binaural tools, it turns out binaural tools are not all created equal, and some of the better ones had an Ambisonics core.

So, coverage needed to expand to Ambisonics :/

And then what if you wanted to use field recordings of this stuff, not just generate it on your own?

You guessed it, coverage needed to expand... 

So, I decided to dive deep into the tech and nomenclature rabbit hole that spatial audio entails: panners, renderers, mics, Ambisonics, Binaural, HRTF, Atmos, DTS:X, MPEG-H, AmbiX, FuMA, VR and on and on - in this "mega-chapter" I attempt to explain everything in as clear and succinct way as possible. Of course, if I missed anything do let me know...

Aside from that, I moved the table of contents into a two-column format - thank you Brett E. :)  shaving 10 or so pages off the book - which were quickly then gobbled up by the new spatial chapter :/

I'll keep following this space (unavoidable pun): I can't imagine Spotify and others won't follow suit, and hopefully, someone comes up with an Atmos tool that doesn't cost hundreds of dollars and person-hours to learn...

All my best,

Ziv (surgically removing spatial hype from fact as "Loopop"...)

PS As usual search for JUL2021 for the updates

Files

Comments

Brett English

Love the TOC format! Thanks Ziv!

Loopop

Thanks for the tip :)

Jason Gillman Jr.

In re spatial audio, I've gotten some decent stuff using dearVR Pro. Getting something to sound "behind you" I haven't been able to really pull off in a binaural render, but I'm guessing that could be due to any number of things.

Loopop

dear VR PRO's reverbs really help sell it... Waves Ocean Way does a good job too, and Logic Pro is decent I've found

Jason Gillman Jr.

Yeah, for $70, or whatever I got it on sale for, I've been pretty happy with it. At a minimum, it does a bang up job for making things sound wide in an easy manner. Like you said, the verbs help.

Tekrytor

Is there a parallel world for us non-Apple folk or is some/most of this applicable?

Loopop

I'm not sure if you're referring to creating spatial music or listening to it? But for both the chapter has non-Apple solutions - they weren't even the first Atmos streaming service (Tidal and Amazon Prime beat them to it), but it seems like they will be the most widely distributed one until other mass market players adopt spatial and the first (If I'm not mistaken) with head-tracking come fall.

Tekrytor

Both, yes. Sorry for my ambiguity. Good to know. I used Nuendo in the early 2000's with a Behringer x32 digital mixer, their best at the time, to experiment with 4 and 8 (7.1) channels and it was great in my studio where i had the right gear, but almost impossible to get out into other equipment exactly because of the lack of standards. I really thought at the time that 7.1 would become popular, since it was showing up in living room hi-Fi and Hollywood output. But it seems that it wasn't ever really utilized much in the music industry except by fringe outfits like Pink Floyd. Those of us old enough to remember 8-track tape (4x stereo) may also remember the very short lived 4-track (2x4 - and similar reel-to-real) version of it that released car stereo cartridge and home versions for a few hundred dollars, mucho dinero at the time, but almost affordable, when the 2-track could be had starting around $50 in the late 60s and early 70s. It sounded pretty good but there was very little media to be purchased, mainly The Who's Quadraphenia and Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon (worth the price of entry alone > talk about spacial!). Also soundtracks. In any case, this is extremely cool for us techies, but I think it failed then ultimately because the bulk of the population has only two ears and less interest in the tech and possibilities as in the price and can you dance to it (?). That two-ear thing seems like one of the bigger impediments, sadly. Because we do interpret more than two directions with those two ears, but try to convince consumers to pay a little more for that. I still think it's best chance is embedded in movie and video soundtracks, where the standards are long present, like 7.1 and 5.1, etc. The old Behringer has settings for that, as do most modern DAWs and some digital mixers. There are also some VST plugins that support 7.1. I wish Apple and Amazon luck, it's music to my ears and could actually move me back into the Apple camp after a decades long absence, if it gains enough artists and quality content. If it were emersive, so i can trackball my location in the London Symphony during Knights in White Satin, yeah baby! Cozy up in the string section for a while, sit on Justin Hayward's shoulder for the chorus, and move over to the tympanies for the finale. Some doing film soundtracks will probably yawn, they've been doing this for decades; but for the musicians looking for creative ways to play with their audiences ears, this is great. And despite this being rather old technology, there is very little current talk about it, so this addition to the book is fantastic!

Loopop

Thanks and my pleasure! Even if you have a simple 5.1 setup and (I know, Apple camp) new Apple TV you *should* be able to get Atmos to translate to that on Apple Music (my guess is the Amazon streamers should work too but I've not tried). Distrokid supposedly distributes Atmos to any service that supports it so, this may be something that, whether consumers know to ask for it or not, will just happen naturally. I'm waiting for Apple to make their move in the fall and then I'll try and release a few spatial tracks to see what happens...

Loopop

My pleasure thanks for the comment!

Schuyler Schwarz

i was wondering if you might be convinced to do a video or chapter comparing some of the more popular granular modules (clouds/beads vs morphagene vs arbhar vs nebulae vs any i forgot) - i've been trying and failing to decide which one is right for me for quite a while now

Loopop

That would be an interesting and massive undertaking! The thing is that because these modules often each have a different twist to them, there would be so many "yes buts" in this video, it would be very long. So, not likely, unfortunately, but I'll consider it. Meanwhile, it's best probably to just watch dedicated reviews and see what ticks most of the boxes for you.

Schuyler Schwarz

Yes, I've been watching the reviews for a few months and don't feel any closer to a decision... I guess I'll probably just go for whichever one pops up at a good 2nd hand price first