Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi!

Quad is back baby, and then some! As long-time channel viewers may know, I'm a fan of making music with and for more than two speakers - the experience makes stereo sound flat and lifeless. 

I've already published two videos about Quadraphonic music-making - a theory masterclass with Suzanne Ciani and a follow-up with practical quad performance tips and ideas. Over the years since I've expanded on both topics in my book as well.

However, while those tips are still valid and great for live performance, actually delivering quad/surround/spatial music to a large number of people over the web remained a challenge, until recently:

A standard for creating a mix to any number of speakers is emerging with the adoption of Dolby Atmos as a delivery format by Apple Music, Tidal and Amazon Music.

Soundbars with multiple built-in and wireless speakers are getting cheaper, and binaural rendering with head tracking simulates the experience well, to a certain degree.

Authoring tools are getting cheaper and easier to use, in particular, Logic Pro's Atmos implementation is a no-brainer for the most part.

With the technical hurdles out of the way, how the heck do you mix in space? I mean creatively, not technically.

I checked last week's billboard top hits, and it turns out 7 of the top 10 tracks already offer an Atmos mix! So, pro mix engineers have been doing it for a while, but it's hard to decipher exactly what's going on with pair of headphones, plus, the end result rendered using binaural tech in headphones isn't always better than the original mix :/

A few months ago I stumbled across a $28,000 box by Trinnov that can help unpack these mixes both in space and into separate channels, and they were kind enough to let me borrow it for a few weeks.

This video is the result of me listening to over 100 Atmos mixes and attempting to bring to you the best of the best ideas and techniques with which they were mixed.

It includes actual examples of 14 top tracks, so, hopefully it doesn't get taken down by a copyright strike (it has already been claimed, so no ad revenue for me... despite the fact that I think a video like this is fair use).

So, if you've ever wondered how the best minds in the business are putting together spatial mixes - consider those secrets unlocked!

All my best,

Ziv (giving the lock picking lawyer a run for his money on youtube as "Loopop"...)

P.S. All the ideas in this video and more will be added to the next book update of course

Files

Unlocking Top 10 Pro Atmos Mix Secrets with a $28,000 decoder

No, this isn't the lock picking lawyer's channel, but if you've ever wondered how pro mix engineers put together their spatial mixes, this video is for you! Get the ideas, tips and insights from this video and all my others in my ever-expanding book of electronic music ideas, tips and tricks here: ► Patreon: https://patreon.com/loopop Thanks very much for Chris from Why Logic Pro Rules for this short and sweet tutorial about spatial mixing with the Atmos Renderer: ► https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UH6vl1vpzDI Gear used in the making of this video: ► Trinnov Altitude 32 + Optimizer Microphone ► Adam A8X Monitors and IK Multimedia iLoud MTMs ► Scopes by Melda: https://www.meldaproduction.com/ Other places I hang out: ► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/loopopmusic ► Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/loopopmusic ► Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/loopopmusic ► Web: https://loopopmusic.com My music: ► Bandcamp: https://loopop.bandcamp.com ► Spotify: http://bit.ly/LoopopOnSpotify ► Apple Music:http://bit.ly/LoopopOnAppleMusic TIMELINE: 0:00 Intro 1:45 Why Atmos 2:50 Objects vs channels 3:15 Mixing Atmos 4:20 Panner types 5:40 Atmos renderer 6:20 How binaural works 7:40 Trinnov viewer 9:50 Clusters 11:00 SONG ANALYSIS 11:25 Industry Baby 12:25 Bad habits 13:55 Stay 14:50 Heat Waves 15:35 Up 16:20 Blinding lights 17:05 Come Together 17:35 Rocket Man 18:10 What’s going on 18:35 Bohemian Rhapsody 19:00 Autobahn 19:50 Suzanne Ciani 20:35 King Ghost 21:00 Latch 21:50 Summary & outro Submit review and video ideas here (sorry I don’t offer 1x1 sessions/setup/purchasing advice): ► Ziv (at) loopopmusic.com NOTE: Occasionally I’ll try out affiliate marketing and include affiliate links. This means that I may earn a commission when you click on or make purchases via affiliate links to stores like Amazon, Sweetwater, Thomann and others. The content of this clip is entirely my opinion, and was not paid for or dictated in any way by the company creating the gear. Without addressing the particulars of products shown here as they might be under NDA, gear shown on this channel may be either sent by the manufacturer, on loan for review or bought at a discount.

Comments

David Riley

If you've got an Altitude 16 (or any other surround receiver), can you output directly from Logic via HDMI to the receiver for real time mixing through that system? Or are you mixing with individual outs from an audio interface, and then render to bitstream and then play that over HDMI to the Trinnov? I've got a 7.4.4 system in a combined theatre/studio space and I was hoping to use that for mixing and get the benefits of the Trinnov room correction, but I haven't found a good to get audio from a DAW to the processor.

Loopop

Hi David, for this video I plugged a 4K Apple TV into the Trinnov, and then plugged its analog outputs into Audiofuse Studio and 8PRE. It's probably best to ask Trinnov, but as far as I understand, no, unfortunately you can't use the Altitude 16/32 as a dual function monitoring/playback device. It can't act as an audio interface/processor on its side, and on Logic's side (again, to my knowledge) you can't output Atmos over HDMI. Wouldn't that be cool though! I've seen people on forums say they render an MP4 and run that file through a 4K Apple TV but I've not tried it. I'm sure there's a way though, since the Apple TV does output Atmos from files if they're formatted properly.

David Riley

Yeah I could have an audio interface after the Trinnov before the amplifiers, but I'd need a 16 in + 16 out audio interface to be able to pass all the channels and more importantly would lose the Trinnov's room correction. I think for 7.1 I can get my Mac to use Core Audio to output a 7.1 bitstream over HDMI, but that's less than ideal.

Loopop

small note about that - when I first calibrated the Altitude to my room I thought it had a bug because I couldn't see the speakers on the "map". Then I somehow had the thought to zoom out, and it turns out the optimizer calculated that my speakers were 17 meters away in my "huge" room - that's because the audio was passing through my DAW, adding latency. So, I asked Trinnov if that's OK and they said that yes, as far as they're concerned they're adjusting for delays whether it's in space or in a computer...