Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

There are some things I want to write about, suicide, mental illness, trauma, and I keep doubting myself. There's a cycle. First confidence, thinking "I want to write a book that only I could write," and then fear, thinking, people won't want to read this. This is too bleak. Be funnier! Be more charming!

Part of it is how long it's been since I began the book, how much it has changed. The mental troubles I've gone through over the past few years, and the way they've reinforced my commitment to writing this book about suicide.

But it's also the way some of the people in my life have me turned around, convinced that nobody wants to read that. No one wants to hear about that. Unless I can make it funny. Unless I can make it warm, like Malagash.

And I do want to make it warm. There's warmth in a story like this. There's always warmth in a story about people who love each other.

My long time publisher rejected the book, with not much explanation why. I think that's put doubt into me too.

So, the book isn't done. I've written a lot of books. But I'm afraid, all the time, that I can't do it again.

Sometimes I feel like this doubt will make a better book in the end.

Sometimes I feel hopeless.

Comments

Kate OfTheSea

Joey, you can turn a phrase like no one else. Part of the bleakness, without explicitly stating it, IS that search for warmth. The siblings reaching for each other, sitting against a bedroom door even if that can't take the pain away, smiling to oneself after witnessing someone beat the hell out of the assholes calling the deceased selfish.... All of these are moments of warmth and connectedness. For some of us, these little moments of warmth are all that we have going in our day to day. You've always been able to articulate the little moments, since the ASW days. All that to say, I will purchase this book from whatever publisher you end up with, even if it means you publish it yourself. Your words, even on the darkest themes, are a comfort to those of us whose souls are heavily burdened.

Jessica

I want to read this book, and have been reading the evolution of it with just as much intensity. You bring comfort to uncomfortable topics without removing the very real and necessary edges and that’s a rare gift. I hold your stories close and I hope for many more however you wish to share them.

Berit Johnson

I want this book so bad and I've loved getting a glimpse of your process as you work and re-work pieces of it. I feel like the only perspective we're allowed to have on suicide is that it's Very Bad Don't Do It Look How Sad It Makes Everyone, and I get that, but the bits of me that have wanted to die yearn for a little more compassion.

Aram

You said yourself: You've written book before. You can do it again. Imposter syndrome gets us all. Try to not let it get you, you've written great stuff before. Read some of it? Kind of like masturbation against imposter syndrome?

Chara

Please publish this book. I second what everyone else has said. Your writing is incredible, and the discomfort this book causes is evidence that the world needs it. It's dark and beautiful and healing.

Joey Comeau

Your support has always been very warm and I hope you know how much I appreciate it. And yeah, the warmth and bleakness can't really exist without each other.

Joey Comeau

The people who are left are affected, that's true., they're hurt and abandoned. We've seen a lot of their stories. It's easier, in a way, to show that arc - disaster, and then finally moving on. But the people who leave have every right to choose themselves. everyone else sure makes it hard to believe sometimes, though. You can't leave your children. Selfish. Hateful. Bad, very bad.

Joey Comeau

It's not imposter syndrome exactly. More like I feel changed. I've had a hard few years, and I don't feel like I'm the same person now. I do read for inspiration when I need it. To convince myself that books can be good. And if they can, then maybe I can do it. Shirley Jackson Hiroko Oyamada, Jane Bowles.

Cassandra Panek

big "in this economy?" take, but sometimes I think a book needs to be written, regardless how niche its audience. I read Crying in H Mart knowing it would make me weep. I read Patti Smith's Just Kids, and I read Radium Girls, and Bastard out of Carolina and Mark Lanegan's Sing Backward and Weep. I'm prepared to cry through this too. Your people are out there. They will be delighted.

Brandon Seifert

Joey! Hello! My friend Ben's dad is a studio musician. He has a quote that I love. "Do what you love, and the money will follow. (It may never be very much money.)" How I personally apply that to writing is: I'm convinced that if there's a story that *I* want to see in the world, then statistically speaking — 8 billion living humans on earth and all — I can't possibly be the only one. So the trick is to write the story... and then somehow find the natural audience for it. (It may never be a very big audience.) The flip side of this is: If you have a mass market sensation, you're kind of preaching to the choir. There's heaps of people who're into your thing, so you're touching people en masse. But if you create something, and it's very niche, and it finds a small audience... that small audience has probably never seen anything like it, because there hasn't been a market for it. More important, they've probably never *seen that part of themselves reflected in a story* before. The more personal, the more granular a story — the more unique and special — well, it limits your potential audience. But that limited audience are more likely to love it with a passion. It's more likely to be life-changing, even if just for a few people. Suicide and mental health aren't topics the public wants to talk about, so those of us who have to deal with them are left adrift and cut-off, feeling alone and freakish for experiences that are actually super common. I think that by itself is enough reason to write stories about it — and if those stories are bleak and unrelenting, the experience of living with this shit often is, too. The way you talk about, this is a story you need to tell. This is something you *need* to get down on paper. Your friends aren't you, they may have your best interests at heart... but they're only making educated guesses about what your best interests even are. Write the book, buddy. You clearly need to. And it could help other people out. People experiencing similar things to what you've experienced. Isn't that worth it, by itself? 🖤🖤🖤, Brandon

Jane Polyakov

We want to read your book ❤️

生きてるだけで、りん

though it's late, but still had to respond this book is one of few things here am looking forwards to these days, and have been checking periodically this page for many years self-publishing works and can come out well, if you're willing to wrangle LaTeX a bit; have done it here and love to share notes with people read a book recently was pretty nice, "undoing suicidism" by alexandre baril (though not so clear from just the title, about reception of suicidality by others, and argumentation on why it should change thank you for existing still, though strings are not attached

Joey Comeau

I've self published some of my weirder stuff, and it's been okay. I have friends who do it better, so I would seek out their advice. I will also seek out that book.

Marty Rachap

I felt like I had something I wanted to say, and I think it’s this. Unpublishable books can be the most important ones.