Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 708425756.mp4

Downloads

Content

Shout Out goes to Elsa Wang

Files

Comments

Diana

Actually TNT makes me feel a little awkward. their agency used to be heavily influenced by sm entertainment and seemed to love imitating sm’s approach. From their trainee days, TNT were strongly influenced by the company and repeatedly studied and covered songs by EXO and NCT and more. Their popularity really started to skyrocket in china not because one of their own songs became a huge hit, but when they covered nct 127’s “kick it.” what makes it even more awkward is that they did the cover without sm’s authorization. At the time, china was under the so-called “korean wave restriction,” which significantly limited the spread and development of kpop in mainland china. as a result, many people were more likely to know the chinese boy group TNT before they even knew sm’s groups. Their agency was extremely good at promotion, and that’s also a major reason why TNT were able to almost dominate china’s idol market. What makes it even more ironic is that some fans came to believe that TNT’s cover versions could surpass the original kpop versions, when in reality, their overall abilities were far behind those of the kpop groups they were covering…

SupPotatoes

This is a pretty selective way of telling TNT’s history. Yes, TNT may been influenced by K-pop, and they trained with and covered groups like EXO and NCT. Nobody is denying that. But “being influenced by K-pop” is very different from “becoming successful because of SM.” TF Entertainment’s trainee/养成 system actually predates TNT and was developed from the company’s adaptation of the Japanese-style idol/trainee model, which they later modified for the Chinese market through online content, fan participation and their own training system. The company had already created TFBOYS, one of China’s biggest boy groups, before TNT even debuted. So it’s misleading to imply that TF Entertainment essentially built TNT by copying SM. And yes, the Kick It cover became a huge viral moment, but reducing TNT’s rise to that one NCT cover ignores everything that happened before and after it. A cover can bring exposure, but it cannot explain why a group develops a huge fandom, sustains popularity for years, releases successful original music and becomes one of the major groups in its own domestic market. The Korean Wave restrictions also don't automatically explain TNT’s success. They may have limited the visibility of Korean groups in mainland China, but TNT were competing in and building their career specifically within the Chinese entertainment industry, with Chinese music, platforms, variety shows, advertising, fan communities and domestic promotions. That's part of what made their success possible—not simply “NCT couldn't promote, so TNT won.” And everything they've achieved since then is because of the work they've put in themselves. Their music, music show performances, concerts, awards, individual activities, their growth as performers, and even things like continuing their education and reaching major milestones outside of music none of that can simply be attributed to SM, K-pop, or good marketing. A company can create opportunities and promotion can give someone exposure, but the members are the ones who have to work for those achievements and maintain that success over the years. I don't want to be that person who dismisses the influence K-pop had on TNT, because they were influenced by groups like EXO and NCT. But TNT didn't just wake up one day and become successful. They started training young, literally as kids around 10–11 years old, spent years working toward their debut, faced criticism and setbacks, constantly tried to improve themselves, and worked hard to build their own identity and career. Whatever influences they had along the way, they still had to put in the work themselves to get where they are today. They may not be as polished as some K-pop groups, and that's okay. Being less polished doesn't mean they're not talented, nor does it make what they've been through and achieved any less meaningful. You can acknowledge K-pop's influence or TF Entertainment's promotion without making it seem like TNT's success was simply handed to them. I find you comment a little unfair, It feels like you're taking years of effort, growth, and everything they've been through and reducing it to “they copied K-pop and had good marketing,” which seriously downplays their journey and everything the members themselves have accomplished. Their journey was long and difficult, and they've been through a lot to get where they are now.

Becky Padilla

Thank you, guys, for reacting, i love the songs and thanks to elsa wang as well! also can you or someone please recommend more stages or videos (or perhaps make tiktok compilations) about c-pop more specifically about the tf family or tf entertainment? i like them very much:) thanks again!

Dila

Tws club please😭🙏🏻

Samatchanan Rod

This is a very selective and negative way of telling TNT’s history. TNT did not become successful simply because of K-pop or “Kick It.” They already had recognition and a growing fanbase, while TFBOYS had paved the way before them. TF Entertainment also had its own trainee system long before TNT. Yes, TNT was influenced by K-pop, but that is very different from saying they succeeded because of K-pop or simply copied SM. TF and SM have also had cooperation, including training-related connections. As for your claim that “Kick It” was unauthorized, please provide a credible source. TF has obtained licenses for songs used in performances and has provided licensing information to fans. And saying TNT’s abilities are “far behind” K-pop groups is your opinion, not an objective fact. You can praise K-pop without diminishing artists from other countries.