Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 709329718.mp4

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

A Toilet Duck

Miyano Mamoru, Miyano Mamoru, Miyano Mamoru. There's really very few who can do it like he can. Those last few minutes of this episode have lived rent free in my head since I first watched it. Whenever that man starts to monologue, it's special. (Unrelated, but only a few days ago I finished watching (as much as has been adapted so far) Chihayafuru, in which Miyano also plays a key character. He and Seto Asami put in special performances there too for me, loved the show, desperately hope we get more!!!). And that moment for Okabe, the declaration, that moment defines his character for me. The elephant in the room, Dr. Nakabachi. I can't disagree with you, those scenes with him at the start of the episode do bring it down, he comes across as cartoonishly evil, with dialogue which is very on-the-nose. I do wish that his character had been handled better, although I wonder whether the limited amount of screen time that they had in which to adapt him meant that any level of subtlety or nuance to his character had to be stripped out, in order to not make cuts elsewhere. I suspect that that was probably the case, although I can't say that that excuses how poor his scenes this episode where. I would say that I love this episode, but, that's a slip-up that I can't really ignore. Maybe it'd more accurate to say that I love 75% or so of this episode.

Zed

Great analysis as always! We finally reached the episode 23, although I can't decide if I love it more than episode 22, depends on how I feel that day. Phenomenal voice acting and music as it's always been the case with Steins;Gate. And also I have to give huge props to you for how attentive you are, noticing the difference in the damn scream 23 episodes later... I only noticed it when I watched the show because I binged it all. I do agree with your critics for Dr Nakabachi, I'm not sure but I'm guessing that maybe he's a bit more fleshed out in the visual novel.

T_tameallah -__-

I didn’t remember this scene being like this, so I was a bit conflicted. I didn’t remember there being cut content about Nakabachi, and I started seeing this assumption that there must be more to it in the visual novel. Since it’s been some time since I last played the game, I went back and revisited this part, and this is what I found. (I’m very sorry, by the way, this comment is soo long This is literally the smallest I could get it and i dont feel like its that long when i read it.) The scene is longer in the visual novel, which is expected, but the thing is how the anime handles the dialogue. It basically takes a much longer conversation and keeps only the main points. It’s like taking a 30-line conversation and turning it into a 8-line conversation using the same lines, just cutting out the other 22. In the visual novel, Nakabachi actually explains why he invited Kurisu after all those years, talks about how he feels like he created something that even she couldn’t, but then that brat in the lab coat (Okabe) ruins the moment. He also talks about why he left, and he’s not aggressive the whole time. He’s calm at first, even smiling, and only starts getting worse after she brings up how he was shunned. He goes back and forth between calm and angry, and the tension builds naturally. The parts shown in the anime are between all of this, not from before or after, so when Kurisu offers to publish it together, it feels like it jumps straight to violence. In the visual novel, that moment is part of a longer buildup where he clearly feels looked down on throughout the entire conversation. That’s when he starts lashing out, saying things like a child shouldn’t be smarter than their parent, why are you so smart, and if only you weren’t so smart, I would have been, and that it’s all your fault. Those statements can seem strange or overly simple or weak when looked at on their own, almost like he’s explaining. But after the full conversation and buildup, they come across as pure frustration. They aren’t rational thoughts. They’re things he’s been holding inside for years and finally blurting out. when he pulled a knife okabe questiond it why does he have a knife on him he though of him as insane unstable man. The problem with the anime version is that the conversation was not even a conversation. It was too fast, didn’t build anything, and didn’t display his unstable behavior. Instead, it characterized him as pure evil, like he came in scowling and mad, and the second she tells him something he doesn’t like, he starts choking her. The entire time, his dialogue is only the simple lashing-out parts. this is not to say that the visual novel writing of nakabachi is perfect but it is diffently much better.