Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Files

VS1x14EA.mp4

This is "VS1x14EA.mp4" by FILMBuFF on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

ya ya

Look at how beautiful this animation is. Incredible frames back to back. I always get hate when I say this but Mappa has honestly ruined shingeki s4, You cant pick up an anime and then deliver far less quality then the first three seasons. Wit has like 40 people and they have made vinland and shingeki some of the best looking anime I have ever seem. Yet mappa, with there 200+ employees are unable to deliver on the same level.

elliot

I knew you'd appreciate this episode, it had me speechless the first time as well. Just unreal

Rudi_SP

Let's not hate something because we love something please, I 100% agree that Wit is better than Mappa but Mappa didn't ruin shingeki, there are some greatly animated episodes in Season 4 Part 2.

ya ya

I don't mean to hate on them I'm just saying the took an amazing story with amazing animation and gave it decent animation. They also accepted a bad schedule in order to make a lot of money from the buildup of s1-3 despite knowing the quality would be way worse and they would be putting their animators through hell. There are certainly some greatly animated episodes in part 2 but pretty much all of part 1 looked terrible. I would not care so much if it was just another show but Shingeki is a story that comes once a decade, it deserves better.

Rudi_SP

To be honest with you I fully agree with your second comment, I just found the term "ruined" a bit exageratted.

Polygon

Sure, but Wit's animators were literally killing themselves trying to push SnK out on time while maintaining the quality they're known for. Sweatshop conditions are unfortunately the norm in the animation industry but it was particularly hard for Wit. Yeah, I wish they'd kept SnK for S4 but I'm glad they realized that it just wasn't doable anymore and they prioritized their mental and physical health.

elliot

I don't think its entirely fair to blame Mappa - I'd blame the production schedule more than anything. It's clear some things are rushed, but there isn't much they could do when deadlines need met. Certain episodes you can tell they spent more time on because they look incredible, if the production schedule was more lenient, the entire show would've looked that good (and they wouldn't have had 3D titans apart from the rumbling if they had enough time.)

Pablo Santander

You need to see Naoki Urasawa's Monster anime or Planetes that is from the same creator of Vinland Saga. If you are looking for the same vibes or feelings that gives you this anime.

David Salazar

I am so happy you enjoyed this episode. There are many reactors that don't really appreciate/enjoy the middle part of the season. This an S tier episode and a masterpiece of an Anime

Rudi_SP

Just finished watching your reaction and got to say that this was probably one of the best post discussions you ever did.

Shmengels

I appreciate how much you recognized the open-endedness of Anne's "lesson" from this massacre. There is a lot of different ways you can interpret it and it's not uncommon for viewers to sort of give up on trying to figure it out, but I think it's because it was never meant to bring clarity. Anne clearly took her own interpretation away from it, we know she comes to some kind of epiphany, but the audience, which is privy to dramatic irony, knows a bigger picture to contextualize why this happened. I think this sequence might even be meant to sort of illustrate how, if a higher power does exist, interpreting their will is effectively impossible. For instance, from my perspective, there's no doubt that Anne's family have all sinned at some point. They even go so far as to illustrate how some sins pale in comparison to others. Because of that running theme that all mankind is dammed to this hell on earth, sure you could lean one way and say that her family escaped from hell via death. But the other perspective can just as easily be that because death doesn't discriminate between the good and the evil, when she fell into the snow, despite the fact that death *should* have taken her, it did not. If you follow that line of thinking, she was indeed spared and has some purpose left to fulfil. Of course, you can also see this from Anne's own perspective that she might truly just be stuck in hell. It gets rather circular after a while, but it's so good and thought provoking and there is so much more I wish I could add to this given future revelations in the series but dammit am I excited to see your analysis when we get to that point! I know I'll be here to write another rambling essay in the comments lol

Serodin

"Yet mappa, with there 200+ employees are unable to deliver on the same level." This is an invalid point. Mappa studios produced 6 anime during the 2020 - 2021 period, 2 of which were airing alongside Shingeki. The other 3 that aired in 2021 would've had to have pre production animation work done, as usual. Additionally, there were 3 anime produced in 2020, 2 of which finished airing two months prior to Shingeki airing and the other finishing the same month. Criticism is fine, but it should be factual.

Hydro

Amazing reaction as always. This was definitely an incredible episode. Looking to more Vinland Saga.

Rinne

You are tripping with the WIT talk. Rewatch season 3 part 2. The fight between Eren and Reiner was animated as stiff as possible with shots of CG bricks flying around every 5 seconds. Not to mention the abysmal Colossal CGI. There are 2 impressive sequences in the whole 10 episodes, Eren turning into a titan in E13 and Levi vs Zeke in E17 Now imagine that they had to animate a hundred thousand more Colossal Titans or the battle in Liberio with 5 shifters at the scene. It would look TERRIBLE. WIT are remembered for their Levi scenes that are not even made by them. Their still imagery is amazing absolutely stunning, sure but that is different than animation. Their ODM gear scenes were also ahead of their time but the most impressive ones are done by freelancers.

Renato

I always wondered if the girl ever blamed herself for the pillaging of her village, as in her seeing all this to be a heavy/divine punishment from God because she stole that ring

Sarah S

My personal take on Anne is what you were saying about her feeling liberated. There’s a lot going on there, but I think in that moment the only way she can process and rationalize what happened is to tie it to her fear of judgment and how she can be released from it now after seeing such cruel people that day. Pretty surprised after reading the comments, how in the world did this episode receive negative feedback? This is in my top 2 or 3 favorite Vinland Saga episodes

Sworderline

"Mappa has honestly ruined shingeki s4", "pretty much all of part 1 looked terrible" You must be joking... What about S3 then? I understand criticizing rough edges in Part1, due the time they had that was inevitable, but Part2 are best looking season for me just like Season2 from WIT. "Incredible frames back to back" all background art was outsourced and done by Studio Bihou. Just can't stand such a disrespect towards Hayashi & his team. We are very lucky to have such people working for the Final season 😭I recommend to watch, subtitles included(Spoiler free if you pass 81Episode) https://youtu.be/xClVSqTVAeg

Sh3nx

IMO its not that Mappa its bad, its that WIT its too damn good, they are bar none at the top when it comes to anime. And its expected, WIT was formed from several veterans from different studios getting together. Howrever, lets keep in mind that WIT dropped AOT, because they were getting abused, S4 was expected to be done in less than a year, with vinland Saga as well they had a tight schedule. This is why WIT its now doing much more lighthearted productions like ranking of kings, wich its on the more simpler side of anime, yet WIT seems to be unable to make mediocre stuff because Ranking Of Kings its still top tier of this year lmao

Kelvin Estevão

I do want to know how season 4 would be handled in WIT hands sometimes, but I'm glad that we have and studio such as Mappa, yes, season 4 part 1 was rushed but the only people to be 'blamed' are the production committee and not Mappa, also we need to do justice, WIT's season 3 was 'poorly' executed (besides the crucial episodes) not only animation wise but they cut some good dialogues, especially in season 3 part 1. Now in season 4 part 2, I think Mappa really delivered, we had a bunch of cinematic shots and insane animation, probably one of the best seasons in both animation and adaptation wide, both of the studios have their own differences and qualities, snk is in good hands with them.

Sh3nx

Rinne, with all due respect you are shitting on WIT just to defend mappa. even the worst scenes of S3P2 are at the top of the best if you compare it with S4 in general. the only noticeable worse comparision for WIT its the colossal titan, wich was in less than 5 minutes of S3P2. and this is questionable, the CGI on S4P1 its sometimes even worse. Fine if you want to give mappa some credit but when you compare both Mappa doesn´t stand a chance, in detail quality, lighting, texture of the scene, animation in general, sometimes mappa its literally a powerpoint (like the purple trees episode),and even in this still frames, wit its always more detailed, and also the direction although sometimes has some gems, in some episodes its extremely poor and formulaic. like flmbruff says, WIT sometimes makes episodes that could be compared to art house movies, Mappa Rarely has ever touched that level of involvment in the series. its repetitive (ost), the scenes are frame by frame from the manga and mostly still shots exactly remade from it. Fine to give mappa credit, they actually did a masterful adaptation with S4P2. but NOT at WITs level.

Rinne

I guess we will have to agree to disagree. Check out some scenes from S3P2. In episode 3 when Bert and Reiner are running and talking for example. Or the CGI they used for Marlowe and some soldiers in ep 2. Or the whole Marco sequence. Or perhaps scouts vs Reiner. Or the whole Basement episode. Just rewatch those. I feel like a lot of people praising WIT have just looked at S3 once, remembered it for the good scenes and moved over. If we're talking whole adaptation instead of animation, WIT also censored and cut out a looot more than Mappa. I do not think that Mappa have done some miracle with S4, it's amazing for the time frame but the animation in P1 is 7.5/10 lets say and for P2 its 9.5/10. But for me personally S3P2 was like a 7. Beach episode looked stunning tho.

Rudi_SP

Please read his post "End of March Update", it states that hinting and sharing excitement towards future episodes or scenes is not something he wants in his comments, I agree that it is very vague but it still creates some sort of expectations.

Anonymous

You'll be pleased to know that the boarder and director of this episode, Atsushi Kobayashi, will be working on the second season of Vinland as well. He boarded four episodes this season (5, 7, 14, 23) and this is the only episode which he also directed. Elevated his own board even further. The second opening which you'll get to see once you're done with the season is also his board and direction. Beautiful work by the man. My favourite, and hands down one of the most beautiful episodes of the show.

Serodin

Video thumbnail depicting the passive energy released by Im's brain. The imagery combined with the music at the end was so great, everything felt so ethereal.

Kat

Wit fanboys are at it again... Wit were the ones who dropped Shingeki because they weren't making money off of it. Shingeki was going to die and never return if it wasn't for MAPPA picking it up, and they did an amazing job with it considering the time frame.

Sarah S

@Rudi I edited my comment just to be on the safe side, hope it’s ok. I don’t want to spoil anything!

Hassan

Shen, I find you unfair with your comparison. First S4 of Shingeki was the most ambitious to adapt and Wit wouldn't be able to do better than Mappa . They don't have the workforce and we can see in Vinland Saga and shingeki s3 pt 2 that they were reaching there limit in term of animation and were using more and more CGI or static scenes (Titans scenes, or scene with a lot of people) . Concerning ODM gear animation it was thanks to freelancers they can't have everytime. When it comes to designs (especially backgrounds) yeah, WiT were clearly the best ones but let's not forget the time they were given unlike Mappa. Wit use more power point scenes. The use of ost is little more repetitive but there is a lot of diversity and experimentation in the use of colorimitry and staging and even the framing. When we see older Mappa production we can see they are capable of great things (Jujutu kaisen, Ippo rising, terror in resonnance, yuri on ice, dororo, banana fish...). The only problem was the Schedule not the studio and Mappa was probably the only one who could handle it and give an anime with this quality. What I'm saying here is that the shingeki case is special here and we can't base its capacity on that's production. Also its not just about the studio's "talent", there's a lot to take into consideration (planning, staff, directors, production, condition of the staff, type of anime...) when it comes to anime's quality.

Anonymous

In regards to the talks about the production of Vinland Saga. A wall of text in the next reply for those interested:

Anonymous

The show leaving Wit Studio is near guaranteed. It is possible that Vinland is going to Mappa, but nothing is confirmed. The only reason why people are throwing that around is because the director is currently employed there. Being on a studio's payroll doesn't necessarily mean that their contract disallows them from working outside of the studio. He was never an employee of Wit's but directed a whole show for them. It's confirmed that the director, animation producer, as well as the character designer/chief animation director are sticking with the production. Same with some other staff like this episode's director. Out of these the only person who has ever been an employee of Wit Studio's is the animation producer. In Attack on Titan's case, the studio and the whole core changed. The industry is extremely freelancer dependant. The name of the studio definitely matters, but it doesn't matter nearly as much as the extremely loud majority of anime viewers make it seem. The biggest factor in talent showing up in productions are friendships and connections amongst the staff members themselves. Just in this comment section there are talks of this "40-person studio giving us the first three seasons of Attack on Titan," when in reality the staff headcount in every season exceed a thousand. Wit was a studio of Production I.G's that changed its name and went independent. Production I.G is a massive studio and is regarded as one of the greatest spawns of animation talent. AoT was their first project and they were still leaning on Production I.G for a huge amount of help. This is why the "tiny studio" worked as such a magnet for talent to gather together. An animation studio often is just a hired hand by the production committee and nothing more. No matter what the end result might look like, Wit quite literally dropped AoT because they couldn't handle it anymore. There is a reason why it took five years for the second season to ever see the light of day. The executives of the studio no longer wanted to put their staff through the extremely pathetic conditions they had been working under so far. They weren't a part of the committee, just a company hired to handle the animation production of the show. They were raking in zero profits from the series' massive international success. Lose-lose situation, so they dropped the show. The committee needed to find a new hand to hire and no studio wanted to accept the terms the committee was offering, until Mappa's CEO raised their hand. Options were either Mappa, some other studio which's executives care as little about their staff, or the adaptation of Attack on Titan stops at episode 59. Here are also two interesting interviews between CEOs with polar opposite views on how to run an anime studio. Otsuka (Studio Mappa) https://otakumode.com/news/5ef5be86a516d17635f4dbf1/Anime-Site-Collaboration-Project-Vol-21-MAPPA Minami (Studio Bones) https://otakumode.com/news/5bc11f7889172b6a7aa76bc8/Anime-Site-Collaboration-Project-Vol-2-bones

Celeborn

Had a very strong feeling this ep would blow you away. It's just visually stunning.

Rudi Gonçalves

@sakesake Since you seem educated in how studios work, did this situation ever happen before (referring to a show changing studio but keeping its core staff)? If so, what changes when they change studio in terms of the final product? does the art style change? is there a different approach? I want to know because as a manga reader, I feel like the season 2 content is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to make one of the best seasons in anime.

Anonymous

From the top of my head, I can't recall a similar situation where the core stays with a studio switch. But I am still confident saying that this isn't the first time this has happened considering there's half a century worth of anime history. I would never rule out anything. So yeah, the art style could change, the approach could change. The committee might only provide enough funding for a 12-episode season instead of a 24-episode season. Much of the above can often happen even if the studio doesn't change. That being said, I don't believe any drastic changes are going to happen. The director and the character designer are both fluent in English and very in-touch with the overseas fans of the series on Twitter, who are the sole reason the adaptation is getting continuation in the first place. The anime's success wasn't anywhere near similar domestically in Japan, be it with viewer count or BD/merch sales. Be cautiously optimistic. The show is in great hands. Personally I'm just crossing fingers that Takeda and Studio Bamboo have room for Vinland in their schedule. He and his studio are one of the most sought after art directors and studios for TV anime.

Sacha

When I realised Vinland Saga won the poll all that time ago I knew in my heart that no matter if you loved or just liked the show that as a fan of filmmaking you’d adore episode 14. It’s honestly magical. I’ll never forget when I first watched this episode. A friend and I usually watch anime together and we’d often pause them to talk about and debate the episode’s contents but when we watched this we stayed in silence almost all the way through and for a good few minutes after the episode finished. We just sat there and I honestly thought I had transcended. It sounds ridiculous but it’s honestly true. And honestly… there are some episodes even still to come that left me feeling the exact same way. This is such a special story. You made a comment about the character’s hands in your discussion and it made me remember something. I have no idea if someone has already brought this to your attention but just in case you haven’t there was an interview with Yukimura (the mangaka) and he had this to say about drawing hands “Hands take time to do well. The strength of a character’s grip on a sword, for example. Male and female hands are hard to differentiate, too. Hands are the most expressive part of a character, after the face. I’ve heard that you can tell a person’s character from their hands, so I always look at them [laughs] You can fake a facial expression, but hands will show how hard you work or how hard you don’t. If you show the character’s life in their hands, you’ll get a good result.”

Raijincloud

Absolute cinema. One of the best standalone episodes of anything ever. Yukimura is very talented when it comes to focusing on one individual character/side story that's happening during the main plot.

Kinne Rathler

I don’t think I’ve seen any mangaka that can draw hands as well as Yukimura. Not even Murata