Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

Edited version with post episode portion is coming, one of my all time faves to discuss, what an episode! lol there's like 7 different potential thumbnails.

Files

(No title)

Comments

Olga

this is one of my fave episodes (top 3) so i am very excited to the review, great reaction ofc

tom

I did not expect this so early. Although I do miss the pre-episode discussions, one advantage of them being gone I'll happily enjoy is that when the reaction and discussion's releases are split, I don't have to wait for the discussion to come out to watch the reaction. That's happened with other reactors before and it's the most painful thing being tempted by that reaction but wanting to wait. Also if this is the final thumbnail then Olga you win. I was so confident in my prediction... 😔

Olga

hahaha I think is not set in stone yet? so we'll see

Joseph Scrocco

Knew you would dig this episode, can't wait for the discussion

Caleb Rife

what was your prediction tom?

tom

Gendo and Ritsuko's mom. Though I forgot that the close-up was a panning shot, so it makes sense.

Ryan

I forgot just how much we got in this episode. We're really in the end game now.

tom

Episode thoughts before the discussion arrives and oh god this ended up so long, avert your eyes from the intrusive wall of text! - I wonder if there's ambiguity in the gendered pronouns in the Japanese when Yui is initially referred to as Ikari. If so, as is usually the case, it's a shame there isn't much of a way to translate that so that there's an extra few seconds of mystery before we see it's in fact Yui he's talking to -- if it said "they" instead of "he" then it would probably tip off the viewer that it's not Gendo as well. Either way was very fun watching you realize it, as well as Gendo taking her name - The use of spatial framing to separate the two conversationalists, especially with Fuyutsuki and either Gendo or Yui is a very cool visual motif of the episode. And it's always in such a unique way despite the same symmetrical left-right framing, be it the other person obscured by the foreground, different vertical spacing (Yui above him on the steps, and Gendo elevated as you mentioned too), or from a much wider shot and the lighting washing them out to silhouettes - Did you catch the postcard? Will have to see - Also, I was looking forward to this episode because I had forgotten how little we got of Fuyutsuki until this. Will be fun to see your analysis of his character in the discussion, as he was still just "vice commander" to you until now. He's an underrated character in my opinion - The cutting across time and through different characters' POV makes it feel so smooth. I especially love the sequence of Misato in the present, contemplating --> Little Misato in the past --> Revealing it's in Fuyutsuki's time as he sees her --> Ritsuko's letter as she talks about meeting Misato and Kaji --> Dr Akagi as she replies. It's so telegraphed yet so natural. - The music too plays an important role in the general feeling. I love how because of the nature of the exposition being told through flashbacks that center around the characters' feelings (which ironically centers around the exposition, only from these characters to SEELE as they're interrogated), the music is used in an almost diegetic way? Like it isn't played in-story, but the format allows for a stop-and-start that in another context would feel unnatural (ie. the happy/nostalgic music suddenly cutting in (which if I recall correctly is the same track used when Ritsuko and Misato discuss Kaji and being old friends in episode 9, so great aural connective tissue there) but Eva's pacing/editing/tone works so well with its jarring cutting together of scenes (ie. the first half of episode 14, which in a way corresponds with this episode, while its second half corresponds with episode 20) that it's smooth. I don't know if I'm communicating what I mean at all with regards to the music, but I suppose it feels like it blends objectivity and subjectivity really well, by having an overall objective view but dipping into moments of subjectivity, and those moments existing in their own bubbles (ie. Ritsuko's letter). Also, the "It's been resolved" at the end feels so meta, as if the characters are talking about the mystery of NERV itself which this episode paints the picture of. - The "Fly me to the moon" instrumental, I only realized during this rewatch, is very closely tied with Misato and Kaji. I knew that the phone call at the end of this ep, and Misato's monologue in episode 15 both played that track, but didn't realize how strong the motif was until rewatching episode 17 (well, your edited reaction of it since I've been watching on Netflix for convenience and there is no music in that version of those scenes so I don't hear it in the full reaction) and realizing it actually plays diegetically over the radio in the room with the vending machines there. It's an interesting choice to connect it to them, and I like thinking about how these external material things are connected to different characters. For instance, Rei I believe is the one in the ED, and in the "next time" previews though they aren't on your version (or you rightfully skip them), Misato narrates them in-character (and with more metacommentary, promises that the next episode will deliver with tons of fanservice xD). Then there's also the fact that the EDs are sung by Asuka, Misato and Rei, like as you noted in the ep16 one. Shinji is very much the protagonist but it's fascinating how the other characters are integrated in these areas and the layers/dimensions it adds to the narrative experience. - Small character moments because this comment is already so long: Gendo looks like a punk constantly smirking in this episode. But there is something kind of harrowing about it when you see the change from before and after Yui's death. Little Rei is a little savage. - I love the sketch style of certain characters and how it creates this distinct feeling of subjectivity as if we're seeing the abstract concept of a character through the fallible memory of another character (Gendo through Fuyutsuki's eyes and then Yui through Dr Akagi's eyes). - Misato's "Bad memories come flooding back in the dark" remind me of Shinji saying the same thing in Episode 2 (I think) but about being in the bathtub. Lends more meaning to Misato telling Shinji to scrub away the bad memories in that episode, as we know (though it was clear from ep12) that she wasn't making a general statement but likely one from experience. [Possible spoiler ROT13: Nyfb V jbaqre vs vg'f gvrq gb gurve genhzn. Gubhtu va Fuvawv'f pnfr V pna'g frr ubj ur jbhyq unir genhzn nobhg orvat va jngre ng gung cbvag. Zl bayl thrff jnf fbzrguvat nobhg orvat va gur Rin, nf vg pbhyq srry yvxr orvat va gur qhzzl cyht va gur YPY juvpu va ghea srryf yvxr orvat va gur jbzo juvpu pbhyq gvr gb fbzr angny genhzn qhr gb srne bs nonaqbazrag. Zrnajuvyr qnexarff pbhyq or hapbzsbegnoyr sbe Zvfngb orpnhfr bs ubj ybat fur jnf ybpxrq va gung rfpncr cbq ng gur fvgr bs gur Frpbaq Vzcnpg.] - Ritsuko's talk with her mother feels very warm and relaxing, despite the complicated undertones of their relationship. Them talking about Misato and Kaji's relationship feels very relatable/realistic, and it to me wonderfully captures that feeling of reconnecting with your parents as an adult when there's a less tense power dynamic and you're able to be on a more similar level, idk. - I like the way the strangulation sounds of Rei is played as we see Gendo's face while Ritsuko's mom kisses him. In my memory I actually forgot the sounds was her choking, and had remembered it as Gendo gagging. Could be both. - Im's reaction to seeing Yui for the first time (and in hearing her voice in ep16) feels so perfectly received for the show's aim with her portrayal and presence. She is instantly charming to all, it seems. - I like Ritsuko's theory that Misato is "making up for lost time" by being such a chatty person despite being mute for two whole years. As always it adds to the intrigue of Misato and the characteristically distinct facets of her personality. - Oh, and Shinji's reaction to Misato crying is very realistic. If I can bring myself to watch The Normies' reactions (no hate to them, just their approach and this show aren't a good combination for me) I might check it out, because I imagine the average person's reaction would be something like "Go and comfort her Shinji, what are you doing". But the way her crying wakes him up and he actively runs away is personally relatable to me, as I had moments like that when I was even younger than Shinji where people around me would be loudly emotional in a way I couldn't deal with, so I pretended not to hear them so I wouldn't be expected to comfort them.

A Toilet Duck

Safe to say I'm deeply looking forward to the discussion for this one! So much to say about this episode, I truly think that this episode could be as close to perfect as you can get, so much pay-off for so many things from right back since the beginning. Absolute banger. Oh, and, I'll say this right off the bat; finally the spotlight for Fuyutsuki, perhaps the most underappreciated character in the show. Have wanted to say that for a while but didn't want to set expectations ahead of time, but man this guy's a really interesting dude. His perspective on all of the events of the story up to this point, in retrospect now knowing what we do about him, is something that's a lot of fun to consider, especially during a re-watch.

Arael

Are we getting the review today?

tom

Oh, a moment I forgot to mention is that the juxtaposition of Yui's gentle voice as she says "It's a simple thing to destroy people" and plays with Shinji always gives me chills. Side note, when did you switch back to the new translation?

edamammy

Re: the ambiguity, yes absolutely, and I’m sad that the subs spoiled it here because I’ve seen other subs that avoid using gendered pronouns in this scene. Fuyutsuki even says “Ikari-kun” in that bar conversation, using the “kun” honorific for a younger man and showing that he assumes that Ikari is a man—the reveal in the next scene is all the better because of it