Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I rented this on Amazon prime

If the embedded link doesn’t work:Doctor Who 6x4 FULL LENGTH Reaction | The Doctor's Wife https://youtu.be/H7__dKP7OQA

Files

Doctor Who 6x4 FULL LENGTH Reaction | The Doctor's Wife

FULL LENGTH REACTION

Comments

Cen

Prediction before watching. Angela crys so hard

Ash Davis

Also prediction before watching. I am going to cry so hard

Leo Cap

this episode is incredibly necessary and kind of overdue if you think about it the TARDIS is, for all intents and purposes, Doc's Appa -- the one friend who's been with him since day one, his only true living connection to his people and his planet left

Alkaris

This is one of the best episodes in Series 6 I think.

Hayat

Really is one of the episodes that no matter how many times I watch it it still just gets to me. And Im never ready.

Ash Davis

House was voiced by Michael Sheen by the way! This was one of my absolute favorites for a very long time, but the Neil Gaiman of it all really does mark it way down in my estimations now. The important parts, like the ending, still makes me cry and is still very meaningful to me, but Neil’s worst parts of his personality are on full display in the writing for so much of this episode! You’re right that this was an absolute fandom darling of a very long time, but now that the rose tinted glasses are off, there are a lot of dark implications to a lot of the writing choices made. There is unfortunately one more episode written by Gaiman, but I won’t spoil anything about when it’ll pop up or about the story itself. Just know that his other episode has always been massively hated, even before the news came out, so you won’t have to worry about stepping on fans toes for the next one.

Nathan Jasper

Well said! People need to separate person from work more. For instance Joss Whedon. He's a crappy person but man do I love his works. Firefly, the first two Avengers, Buffy, Angel, Dollhouse... why is it the brilliant ones are more often the crappy people? If we boycotted every bit of art a crappy person had a hand in making, there would be very little art left to enjoy. Anyway, enough about that, love this episode. Being able to have the TARDIS become a person, even for a short time, was so brilliant and lovely. Michael Sheen was ever so creepy as House. Aro vibes, just with a deeper voice. Matt Smith's brilliant. He can go from kind to aggressive in 2 seconds and it's all in the tone too. He doesn't need to shout or growl or anything. All he has to do is talk but you can always tell when he's serious and when he's playful. Dude's amazing.

Dead Can

I would love if you could watch minisodes as well, would be so great

Lintrinsic

I can finally say how gutted I am someone spoiled the "I always took you where you needed to go." reveal. That line hit a lot of fans, even from classic like a sledgehammer, myself and my Mum included and she watched right from the start. It's something that seems obvious but it was never overtly stated before this episode. It was a wonderful moment.

Lintrinsic

Isn't that kind of a spoiler for a future episode?

Ash Davis

Less of a spoiler and more of a trigger warning, really

Sorcerer Rumburak

"The only water in the forest is the river." .... Some said it was a literal hint of river song in the library (forest) - but if's were true - what's the meaning of the water, if we took it literally? I don't think it's the meaning. 🤔 But it's to early to write me thoughts down - not before mid-season.

James B.

Gotta love when a comedic story turns into a tearjerker.

Michael French

I personally would not consider this a spoiler, but there is an episode next season that does revolve around different rooms in the tardis

Lintrinsic

I'm reasonably okay with separating artist from art with the likes of Gaiman, although I'd probably avoid anything new with his name on it. Not so much Rowling. She brags on social media about the royalty income she gets from Harry Potter as an IP and uses her money to fund legal cases in the UK aimed at removing rights from trans people and making their lives as difficult as possible. It's one thing to enjoy the work of someone who turned out to be a shitty person. Another to indirectly fund their hate campaign by continuing to buy their merch, books and movies. Also if the person is continuing be in a position to do harm due to the promotion of their art and them by extension, I avoid them and those that promote their art. But that's my line in the sand, to each their own.

Jay Willis

One of my favorite episodes. I just love the performance by Suranne Jones (the Tardis/Idris) and the chemistry and back and forth with Matt. Just love everything about that aspect of the episode. The "House" part of it is fine, it's just a vehicle to facilitate a great concept.

Fr. Brench

Huh, I'd never heard about the allegations that came out against Gaiman last year until I looked it up after you alluded to it. That is a shame when great artists have their inner evils revealed. That aside, I'll add my voice to the crowd here: this was a phenomenal episode which hit home very closely when I first saw it. The Time Lords were only an occasional presence in the course of Classic Who, but I always loved the Gallifrey/Time Lord lore bits and pieces that come through. This story not only honored that but felt like one of those rare perfect links between old Who and the New.

Frank (MetronV) Izzy

I can only say this...I knew my wife was pregnant with our second child (her third) before she did. So there's that. :) Plus, I don't think Amy's been pregnant before, so I don't know if she'd recognize if she was pregnant or not to begin with, let alone her body going into and out of the state like it seems to be doing. There are tons of anecdotal stories about women giving birth without even knowing they were pregnant to begin with, so it's really not unreasonable that she wouldn't be aware that something was going on, or maybe just thinking it's "space sickness" :)

Martin

If you need an alibi for getting a kick in on JK let me know, happy to help with that lol I love this episode, as an episode on it's own it's great but the interaction between The Doctor and Idris is EVERYTHING, it's fantastic and I always forget how tear jerking her good bye is, in fact that whole final bit where Matt's crying his eyes out, it's all wonderfully heart wrenching. For all that alone, great episode.

funnylilgalreacts

Yeah, I’m not too thrilled about that either. When they release the new Harry Potter series on HBO Max, I’m definitely going to be wearing trans lives matter gear and donating the ad revenue wherever I can help.

Frank (MetronV) Izzy

I did actually consider that, but then went down the rabbit hole in my head canon about how much time has passed since the doctors discovery and her last cycle and if how her body is fluxing in and out of pregnancy then would she still miss a cycle…then my brain started hurting :)

Ejigantor

I think this is a fantastic episode - and yes, as far as I'm aware it is a fan favourite episode. Good performances all around; Matt continues to bring it, Arthur knocked it out of the park again, Karen was great - especially during the freakout sequences - and even the guest stars were really good. I love Amy's line, "Did you wish really hard?" and how it's delivered with the perfect amount of sass. And Matt's "Fear me, I've killed all of them" is so flatly matter-of-fact. As far as the resident pachyderm goes, I agree - especially in regards to multimedia art created by such a large group of people; we talk about "separating the art from the artist" but with a TV show or movie there is no "the artist" there's dozens of artists - from the set designers and costume designers to the lighting and sound crew, all the way up through the performers, director, writing crew, and showrunner. Should we discard the work of all those other people because of unrelated actions by one person? If it turns out the Boom Operator was a car thief, how would that affect the episode or how we feel about it? Bah. Bah, I say. Huzzah for the Moya shout-out. If anybody reading this isn't watching Farscape with the rest of us, well, you should.

Jeremy B

Hi Angela, hope you're continuing to heal and recover from your recent operations and I'm glad you enjoyed this ep. It's definitely a fan favourite and one of the most loved episodes of Matt's run as the Doctor. You're absolutely right that the Gaiman association shouldn't taint what is an incredible piece of work by everyone involved. Some of the episode's most memorable lines were added later by Moffatt in the script editing process anyway. The performances are great and the set design is just stunning. Suranne Jones, who played Idris, is phenomenal. She started out in soaps, but has gone on to become one of British television's most versatile and acclaimed dramatic actors - Doctor Foster, Vigil, Gentleman Jack, etc, etc. She's won bags of awards. "No, but I always took you where you needed to go," sums up their relationship beautifully. And explains why the Doctor doesn't always end up where he intended! This story was originally intended to air in season 5, but they ran out of budget, so the James Cordon episode took its place. As a result, when the script was reworked for season 6, they had to add Rory back into the story. Glad you've enjoyed the Graham Norton interviews, he's such a big supporter of the show. But I'd gently advise you to steer clear of any more of Graham's interviews with any of the Doctors (past, present or future) as that way major spoilers lie! :)

John

The only thing I'll say about Neil Gaiman is that one can appreciate a person's work without liking or supporting that person's other activities or views. Like the Doctor said, everyone's life is a pile of good things and bad things and the writing of this episode is one of the good things in his life. Even if it was the only good thing, while it doesn't lessen the bad things, neither do the bad things invalidate the good. As for seeing the swimming pool, the Doctor deleted it at the beginning of this episode to free up power to get through the rift. Maybe Sexy archived it?

John

One of my big takeaways from this episode is that Suranne Jones would make an AMAZING Doctor. Idris' personality was so much like the Doctor, it's easy to see why they chose each other.

John

While I understand you're not giving away story points, you've now removed any surprise Angela may have when that happens even if knowing that doesn't affect the overall story. If she hasn't seen it yet - it's a spoiler.

Jeremy B

Best not to give any clues as to what might, or indeed what might not be important in future episodes. We didn’t know what was important or not when we watched the show in 2011 and it was definitely more enjoyable that way 🙂

Jeremy B

Suranne Jones is amazing! She’s so brilliant in every role she plays. Definite Doctor vibes for sure! She’s actually co-starring in a new heist series with Jodie Whittaker at the moment.

Joel Palenychka

One of my all time favorite episodes and one I can rewatch over and over. So many great lines in this whole season, not just this episode. I was particularly fond of the exchange "You want to be forgiven, don't you?" and "Don't we all?" It resonated with me. Speaking from my personal experience I'm pretty sure everyone I know have events in their past they regret and wish they could be forgiven for. Not absolved, just... forgiven. Idris/Tardis was a fantastic character encapsulating the personality of the Tardis so perfectly. Of course you wish you could stay but it would have deflated her emotional impact if she did. And we now have a face and a voice to attach to the Tardis and it's actions.

Earthen

We need to separate the art from the artist or we'll never enjoy anything. And yes this is a fan favorite especially for Classic series fans. Well, its a favorite of this fan anyway :)

Jacob King

I was a Gaiman fan for 30+ years and I don’t think I’m ready to sit down and watch this. I don’t think anyone has any obligation to feel any sort of way on this issue - there are definitely worse people whose art I’ve consumed but there was a period of my life where Gaiman meant a lot to me and that’s why it hits different.

SeeJay

I think it's easier to separate the art from the artist when they are "behind the scene's" such as a writer, director, composer etc. It's definitely harder if they are up front and center. That being said, we came to love this episode loooooong before anything about Gaiman came to the surface and I can't just suddenly dislike the episode, just like I can't suddenly dislike Harry Potter (or Good Omens).

SeeJay

I know not intentional, but this is considered a spoiler. When commenting treat each reaction like you don't know what's coming in future episodes.

ZapWing

I think the biggest thing with the Rory kill-bait is (in my narrative interpretation) to show us that Amy does love and appreciate Rory and while he is insecure in his position when compared to the Doctor, we as the viewer know that Amy would only ever choose Rory. While he's not a Timelord from Gallifrey, he is her bigger on the inside life and that is something we've never seen the Doctor do or provide.

Malamute

This is one of my favoritest episodes of NuWho. Great Episode.

Malamute

I've always REALLY loved this episode, but i was always kinda surprised of the generally "just decent" reviews i see of it. Saying the classic fans find it is a fan favorite moreso makes sense. Tom Baker was my doctor. :-)

Ben “Bentendo” Dawson

Gaiman's writing is always brilliant, and after we had Curtis bring us Van Gogh I was hoping this would be another home run, and it really is! Separating the work from the person is possible, he is a brilliant writer no matter what else he has done. As you say, the same for Rowling.

Lazzy

That's kind of an unfair comparison because the boom operator may help produce the episode, but he's not the one that's putting part of himself into it the way a writer does. I'm not saying that people should hate this episode because it was written by Gaiman -- it's a great episode -- but that's a very disingenuous argument that just sounds like a justification. Whenever you try to justify something, it makes it look as though you are supporting something bad while trying to appear as though you are still righteous despite it. It's better to just acknowledge and condemn whatever is bad about it and ensure that you are consuming the media in a way that is ethical.

Ejigantor

I'm sorry, but no. You're wrong. There is nothing disingenuous about my argument, and my comment doesn't serve as justification for anything but watching the episode. What appears to be disingenuous is you - where you attempt to rank the level of commitment and engagement with work of people based on their role, but you don't know that the boom operator isn't putting themselves into their work - you appear to simply have decided it must be so to establish a justification for your premise. What I said is about separating the art from the artist. That you would attempt to claim that my doing so is justifying the horrific things Gaiman did is not only disingenuous, it's disgusting. You are disgusting.

Chris B.

Fully agreed about the comment towards JK Rowling; I love the world and story she created, but she's also said some things in the past that are deeply misandrist and occasionally give me pause.

Matthew

If you want to see Tardis bedrooms, swimming pool, closets and other rooms, then you need to watch Classic Who.