Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Doctor Who 9x12 FULL LENGTH Reaction | Hell Bent: https://youtu.be/TZ4A6ZatE9o

Files

Doctor Who 9x12 FULL LENGTH Reaction | Hell Bent

FULL LENGTH Reaction

Comments

MaxValPlatt

I have to say (and agree with you on it) that while this episode is great, everything up to the ending is 5/5, but ending looks like a little bit of cop-out which brought it to 4/5 for me, personally (which is still great in my book!). I have miffed feelings about Clara having Ashildr is a partner in crime -first, Clara must be a great person because I'd probably won't be travelling with someone complicit in something that killed me before. And Ashildr must be very good at surviving being the only one immortal left right at the end of time (with only technical immortality! She could die from injuries and stuff!). And with Me being an apprentice in Manipulation 101 both in 18th century and on the Trap street, with billions of years of experience, Me must be very good at surviving, Probably threw a bunch of people under the bus during these billions of years ) Second, we see that only the Doctor is paying the price of breaking the rules of Timelords here, losing Clara and memories with her. Apparently it should stop the universe from breaking, because Clara hasn't changed much - still reckless, still adrenaline junkie, with no one (sans Me) to control her impulses. Clara might even be absolutely immortal now, with her being a frozen point in time.

Jason

Clara still dies. Her death is a fixed point, the fact the Web of Time doesn't unravel is proof in itself that at some point she goes back and dies on Trap Street. Either by her own choice or because the Time Lords eventually catch up to her. She has 'wriggle' room but its finite.

Nathan Sill

My favourite part of this episode is when the doctor responds "I had a duty of care." He says it in such a matter of fact way, the doctor truly sees all he went through as the price he had to pay to save her. To him its no big deal a simple shrug of the shoulders. He loves her so truly so deeply that literal billions of years of torture and death was just something he had to do. As someone whos friends mean everything to them it resonates with me deeply, my first ever tattoo was of the diamond mountain and the bird to represent how far I would also go for my friends and growing up with doctor who is where I credit that trait.

Jason

There is still a fair bit of debate about who or what the Hybrid is and Ive never really got why as it seems fully explained to me in the episode. The Prophecy goes - 'It will one day stand in the ruins of Gallifrey.' The Doctor when he leaves Gallifrey with Clara says they are moving in Time but not in Space, his conversation with Ashildir takes place in the ruins of Gallifrey in the final hours of existence. 'It will unravel the Web of Time and destroy a billion billion hearts to heal its own.' Saving Clara from a death which is a Fixed Point breaks the Web of Time and collapses it- as we saw when River tried it in The Wedding of River Song. And the reason for doing so is to save a billion billion hearts of its own - the Doctors grief, living, grieving Clara, dying, over and over for 4 and a half billion years in the Confession Dial. And its a combination of two warrior races, the Time Lords- biggest War in existence, and humans, love a war. Clara and the Doctor, combined by Missy to produce chaos. And the final clincher the Doctor outright says "I went too far. I became the Hybrid." So Ive really never got the confusion. It all seems to be there in the episode. On an extra point there is an interesting comparison to be made between how the Doctor imagined Clara in Heaven Sent - "Get off your arse and win!" and how he used her to drive himself on, and her actual reaction to finding out what he did to himself, "Why? Why would you even do that to yourself?" And how that comes to a head in their confrontation over wiping her memory. The Doctor is so sure in his own mind what he is doing for her is the right thing, right up till the actual Clara makes him see why its really not.

MaxValPlatt

Sure. But she is in a position where it could happen in one year or in one millennia. She is immortal until further notice. And Doctor is alone and amnesiac . I like Clara, sure, but she is having the best ending in these circumstances.

Jason

I agree its the best ending she could have got, but one she still has go die, and I doubt it would be millennia as I doubt she or Ashildir would have the skills to outrun the Time Lords for too long, as they will be very keen to get her to Trap Street as soon as possible. Its similar to Amy and Rory, they got a happy ending yes, but at same time they are still dead and gone. Better than RTD in his first run when it comes to companion cop outs- Rose, more comebacks than the Rolling Stones, Martha happily married to Mickey, Donna happily married and lottery ticket winner, Jack literally unkillable and immortal. Whereas Moffat - Amy/Rory, dead in New York, River, dead in the Library, Clara dead on Trap Street. He's done them all in so far. Moffat could be accused of having his cake and eating it, or at the least of softening the blows, but his Who is in the end one of optimism. And half the audience is, as has been traditional for Who, children. You can only go so dark.

Mark Ten

The question, "What color is it?" originally came from Rory in Asylum of the Daleks. Rory said he asked it because "there werent any good questions left." The Doctor is making a snide joke here that only he understood. In the cloister/matrix the Doctor described a man who had once broken in and stole the moon & the president's wife. Clara knew immediaely it was the Doctor because back in the Magicians Apprentice (on Skaro) Missy told her she cared about the Doctor "Since the night he stole the moon and the President's wife."

Iwasneverhere

Matrix prophecies predicted that a hybrid creature, thought to be crossbred from two warrior races, would stand over the ruins of Gallifrey and unravel the Web of Time, breaking a billion billion hearts to heal its own. The Doctor stood in the ruins of the Gallifrey Matrix with Ashildr at the end of time. Ashildr was maintaining a reality bubble that was keeping the the Web of Time from unraveling. When Ashildr left with the Doctor in the second tardis she was no longer there to maintain it thus causing the Web of Time to unravel off camera. While inside the confession dial the Doctor literally broke his heart causing his own death billions of times to escape under his terms so that he could save Clara and heal his own. Over my many decades I have become a connoisseur of passion narratives. I find Heaven Sent to be the best I have ever encountered. I do not believe it can be topped even if one invokes the “infinity plus one” path but I'm willing to hold a few beers while other authors make a valiant effort.

Merlin’s Cat

I think you are right Heaven sent was so good that there was no way of surpassing it. Still the episode has its moments and I think on balance I like the way Clara’s story ends.

vaughn DeGeer

So happy that you are getting to my favorite Xmas special. Rassilon is awful always has been he is one of the founding timelords

Literaltruth

This is a weirdly controversial episode. A lot of people hate it because they think it doesn't live up to the previous one and because of the Hybrid reveal. However, I absolutely LOVE it. Not only do I love this as an ending for Clara - it's kind of a "correction" for the, frankly, horrific ending that RTD gave to Donna. The Doctor tries to do it again and she gets to say no, eff you, I'm going out on my own terms. For me this ending also retroactively fixes a lot of the issues I had with Clara and the 12th Doctor over their entire run together. Watching along with you this time you had a lot of the same initial reactions to their relationship and how they seemed to enable each other. This episode, to me, makes all that stuff justified because it makes it INTENTIONAL. The show, since Capaldi's first episode, has been building up to this - hinting and showing that Clara and the Doctor have a toxic relationship. Not abusive - but heavily co-dependant and extremely enabling. They love each other, and help each other - but they also enable the worst parts of each other's personality. The whole run of them together builds up to this - the instant where they realise that "I love you, but we're not good for each other...look at what we make each other do". It's such an interesting dynamic that's totally unique for the Doctor/Companion.

Jeremy B

I enjoy this one. It neatly wraps up the season and Clara's journey. The first third has a wonderful cinematic, western quality to it, before moving into the pure horror of the cloisters and then the character-driven emotional conclusion. It doesn't rise to the absolute heights of Heaven Sent (very few other episodes do), but it works well for me. Moffat was criticised for 'undoing' Clara's sacrifice, but he made the point that she still has to face the raven one day, and importantly for him, he didn't feel comfortable killing off a companion in a show that has a large audience of children. The other criticism levelled at the episode is that the prophecy remains unfilled, even though the Doctor literally meets Ashildr, sitting in what's left of Gallifrey, watching the universe end. So the prophecy about "standing in the ruins of Gallifrey" is ultimately shown to be accurate. You've met an earlier incarnation of Rassilon in David Tennant's last episode when he was played by Timothy Dalton. This is him post-regeneration. Back then, a clearly insane Rassilon planned for the Time Lords to ascend to an incorporeal state while destroying the rest of creation before The Master stops him. As Rassilon's plot failed, The General worked with the various Doctors in The Day of The Doctor to save Gallifrey instead. This episode sees Rassilon and The General many, many years later. TWO Christmas specials up next - the 2015 one and then the 2016 one (there was no new Doctor Who season in 2016). Avoid seeing even the title of the 2015 special beforehand!!

Jeremy B

Exactly, we've never had that dynamic before and it's fascinating to explore. The companion who wanted to become, not just travel with, The Doctor.

Don Dino Spezzini

The Moff is great at callbacks, creating parallels, character arcs. Deep Breath ended with 12 pleading with Clara to just see him to Hell Bent where he can’t see Clara right in front of him.

John

Rory, "I waited 2000 years for you!" Doctor, "Hold my screwdriver."

John

We get two Christmas specials before the start of the season. Whee!

Jack Mingle

The way I see it is that the Timelords took 4.5 billion years from the Doctor, so she'll take her sweet time before going back to make up for it, almost like a back tax.

Kevin (GiantFutures.com)

This is an episode that gets better the more times you see it, which for me is now five times short of too many. The plot questions start to clear up after seeing it a few times. The moment that The Doctor tells Clara at the end “I know that if I saw her again I’d recognize her”, and the look of pain in only Jenna Coleman’s eyes, before she turns to quickly wipe that tear away and compose herself…………….god damn, my heart is still hurting from the first time I saw that, and it never heals. I also love the callbacks. When The Doctor is telling her about kidnapping the President’s Wife, but no, that was a lie, it was the President’s daughter….it calls back to the first episode of the season, when Clara and Missy are sitting at the table, and Clara asks Missy “Since when do you care about the Doctor?” And Missy says “Since always. Since the Cloister Wars. Since the night he stole the moon and the President’s wife. Since he was a little girl. One of those was a lie. Can you guess which one?” And in this episode, completely unconnected, the Doctor tells us which one. Also…Jenna Coleman is stunning, in every way. I’ll miss her on this show. I do miss her on this show. Watching this makes me want to go watch “The Snowmen” again just to start-ish over. (Yes, I know the Asylum was first, but the Snowmen feels like the start.) RIP Clara…whenever the long way around gets you there.

Nicholas Sulikowski

A couple things I wanted to point out: The song that the Doctor was playing on guitar, and it was indeed Capaldi actually doing it, was Clara's Theme from the series' score. A little bit of a fourth wall break. Also the President of Gallifrey is Rassilon, a character originally introduced in the classic series. He was said to have died long before the classic series and was kind of a ghost during the classic series (but not really). Then during the Time War, he was resurrected to fight in it. You've seen him before, in his previous regeneration, when he had Timothy Dalton's face. (The End of Time Part 1 and 2) Note that he has the same silver metal gauntlet from before. Last thing, the whole idea of a TARDIS taking the shape of an American diner kind of reminded me of an idea from the novel Life, the Universe and Everything, the third in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy series. In that, there's the Starship Bistromath, a ship basically shaped like an Italian bistro, which uses the complications of the check at the table never adding up at a bistro as a means of cheating normal physics and going far faster than any other ship. (It's called Bistromathics.) Why bring that up? Because the Hitchhiker's Guide series was written by Douglas Adams, who also wrote a few Doctor Who episodes in the 70s. (He also wrote at least one Monty Python sketch.) So I'm wondering if Moffat is a fan and put this in as a nod. Anyway, I gotta say upon rewatch, this episode got much better. I kind of understand the controversy when it first came out. I got the impression that a lot of fans wants a clearer answer to who the Hybrid is, and also wanted to see a whole lot more Gallifrey just for the sake of lore. But the story they arrived at I think perfectly fits everything that has happened in Series 9 and then some. I'm glad I'm doing this rewatch, because then I can really give everything a much fairer shake.

Fr. Brench

On Capaldi feeling like he has always been the Doctor... there are times (including in this very episode) when he sounds like Tom Baker, who was the longest-serving Doctor in the classic era. Of all the New Who incarnations, Capaldi sounds (and looks) like he slipped right out from the old show into the new. It's phenomenal :D

Julie Wills

Did you know Rachel Talalay tried to get Timothy Dalton back to reprise his role? Unfortunately, he was filming Penny Dreadful at the time and couldn't do it.

Alkaris

It's such a powerful message when the Doctor says "Get off my planet" it's like a very deep cut line. It would be nice to say that some people who don't deserve to be on this planet, where their existence wouldn't be missed if they were exported off planet post-haste on the next space ship.

Mike-L

unfortunately it is unlikely that you will find a better episode that the last one. Fortunately the reason you are unlikely to, is that the episode set the bar so very high. There is a reason most fans that have watched all of Capaldi found that episode to be our favorite one for him.