Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Oi! Another more review-like video, this one being quite negative. I've got one more like this planned, but after that I'm gonna be changing gears back away from this style. This one kind of had to be done to get it off of my conscience, because one of the biggest bones I have to pick is with shows that ride on a neat premise to massive popularity without really having anything to back them up. What was the appeal of this show? The promise that it might get good? Well, I'm not much a man of faith. Anyways, hopefully you'll enjoy this video. I don't know if it's particularly helpful for anyone, but I was really really happy with how tight the script came out, and with the narration and editing. It's a really fun and satisfying video to watch, but idk how much stake you'll have in it if you don't care about this show. Hopefully some!

Files

Previews only

ERASED Was Never That Good

A lot of people seem to be let down by the later episodes of ERASED. Personally, I'm not sure why anyone got their hopes up based on what the early episodes gave us. If you enjoy my content, consider supporting me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/digibro Not convinced this show isn't worth watching?

Comments

Reverse Spectrum

i'm looking forward to this one ever since you fought the people at that 4h video about all of the seasons shows

General Winter

it isn't a 2/10, i could understand a 5 to 7/10, but it isn't a cringe feast either like an actual 2/10 like i had no problem with main protagonist sounding non-anime-ish compared to everyone else, in addition while the sound department could've been better, it wasn't cringy either, now while you say some focuses are a waste of time, others find joy in them (though thinking about it, i can see why its a mixed bag) the thing i least agreed with however was your statement about the kids intelligence, throughout the most of my life (and as a kid), i have generally had a higher IQ then the lot, which at times led to me being bullied, but that was long ago and off-track, my point is that IQ isn't determined by age but rather by the capabilities of an individual, both in character and experience & knowledge in life, the IQ of the 10 years old is nothing unrealistic, the reason there is a gap in IQ between "your favorite show" and this is because the situations of the children are in two drastically different situation and the kids have drastically different personality which overall leads to different displays of IQ, this comparison is about as good as comparing drunk men in a bar to the NAVY SEALS in combat, they are both in the same age group, but have drastically different lives, i could turn this into an essay given more time, but if you care about what i said, please respond, I'm open to constructive criticism and accepting opinions so a discussion doesn't turn into a shit throwing contest

digibro

Well, it's not as good as Zankyou no Terror, which I gave a 3--which isn't as good as Ergo Proxy, which I gave a 4--which isn't as good as Clannad, which I gave a 5, so I feel comfortable giving it a 2.

Ramiel

Hey Digi, love ya man but I can't share your feelings about this show. Seemed to me like you were really nitpicking the show and while most of your complaints are valid, some are awfully petty. I mean, I think you were the only person in the world who complained about Satoru's VA. It honestly seemed like you had a negative opinion about the show from the beginning (I listened tp the weebcast) and you pretty much maintained that hateboner throughout the rest of the show. As for what got people (such as myself) interested about ERASED: I think the fact that that it was based off an award winning manga; the trailer looked cool; and some people just like stuff that looks dark and mysterious. Both my wife (who is pretty casual when it comes to anime) and I were pretty captured by the suspense of the show and were always excited to see the next episode. As of the conclusion, most of my friends who I consider to be well versed in anime enjoyed the show, and while I don't think it was amazing by any means, I'd probably give it a 7 or 8 out of 10. There were problems with the show. I think it was too short, and rushed a lot of stuff in the story, some story elements were contrived, and there were some lapses in production quality here and there. But I found the overall story itself to be interesting enough to warrant my continued viewing. I know you might refer to that classic Demo line "if you just ignore the bad parts of anime...", which is great btw; but here I don't think the bad parts were bad to sully the anime as a whole. I do like that you made a comparison to Steins;Gate, which is also one of my favorites, and I agree that as a time travel mystery its much better. But I think that ERASED was meant to stand apart from S:G in terms of tone and characters. Otherwise you'd probably be ripping it for copying S;G.

digibro

I don't think I'd rip anything for copying S;G. I wish more anime would seek to copy good anime rather than mediocre stuff lol. Anyways, sorry you feel differently, but I really and truly hated everything about this show.