Behind the Scenes on Haikyuu vs. Kuroko no Basket: So Similar, Yet So Different (Patreon)
Content
Haikyuu was among the batch of shows which started airing in early 2014 right when I first began talking about modern anime on youtube by way of my episodic vlogs over on the Digi Does Anime channel. I had found the show to be well-made, but overall not that engaging, and I didn't get far into it. Vlog here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AvPZLW2z3Vo
I later listed it as an honorable mention on my end-of-the-year list since it, seemed like sports anime fans were really into it and I didn't think of it as a bad show so much as one that just wasn't clicking with me for some reason.
Over time, I would repeatedly see Haikyuu receiving high praise from fans, especially when its second season went to air. I would also hear a lot of comparisons to the similar Shounen Jump/Production IG sports anime Kuroko no Basket, usually in the context of people saying how much better Haikyuu is thanks to its sense of realism and grounded characterization. I kind of got the impression that Kuroko was a really dumb show that presented its sport in a frustratingly unrealistic manner, similar to how Prince of Tennis is often accused.
A while back, my brother Victor got really into marathoning different sports anime, and Haikyuu was the one which sort of broke him. He was pretty unenthusiastic after finishing the first season, and then didn't manage to finish the second one. He tried to watching Kuroko afterwards, but he said that it was just more of the same dumb sports tropes which he was already burned out on, so he didn't get very far before ending his sports-a-thon. I remember him explaining Kuroko's whole quirk of having so little presence on the court that no one notices him, which I thought was incredibly stupid because he's got bright fucking blue hair, and most of the other people around have normal black hair.
So for the most part, I just kind of assumed that I wouldn't be into Kuroko because I hadn't been into Haikyuu, and Kuroko was supposedly the worse version of the same. I ended up watching up through episode thirteen of Haikyuu recently as a result of the Second Chances Board vlogs and found myself as unenthusiastic about it as I'd ever been; video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_94oEv_i7_k
Where this comparison video came together was a week or so later, when I started up another vlogging series dedicated to watching shows I might not have looked at otherwise, in the form of Random-Ass Recommendations. This got me started on Kuroko, and I was immediately fascinated not only by the fact that I really enjoyed the show, but that so much of what I enjoyed about it was entirely in the way that it differed from Haikyuu. It really felt like Kuroko was a sports anime for "people like me," in a way that Haikyuu wasn't--both in terms of its personality and characters, and in the style of its narrative presentation. I ranted about it for like 30 minutes unscripted in that vlog video, making a lot of the same points that I'd later use in the final one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLd2Az-3FRI
After having so much fun talking about their differences in that video, I knew that I wanted to make a fully scripted video comparing both shows. To do so, I would need Davoo to catch up to me on both, and then I figured we could watch the rest together after he moved in with me; especially because I felt like Haikyuu would be easier to watch in a group (it wasn't, but we'll get to that). I wasn't really sure if Davoo would be into either show, but it turned out that his reaction to both was exactly the same as mine: he was hype about Kuroko, and totally bored by Haikyuu.
Once Davoo and I were able to get to work, we marathoned Kuroko no Basket season 2 together, and then set our sights on Haikyuu--but it turns out that the second half of Haikyuu season 1 is almost insufferably boring. I really think episodes 14 through 16 were some of the worst episodes of sports anime that I've ever seen through sheer lack of interest. Neither one of us was able to bring ourselves to care about the later matches in the season, to an extent which was honestly confusing, because the first half of the season had been far more inoffensive in its construction.
I'd heard a lot of people say that season 2 of the show was a lot better, and I didn't want to talk about the series without at least knowing its general trajectory, so we decided to skim through the last five episodes of season 1 and get the gist of them, with my brother Vic filling in whatever we didn't know, and then we tried out season 2. It did start off better than season one had gotten, but was only really as engaging as the early episodes of season one had been. Once the proper matches started, we both found ourselves totally losing interest again, so we just skimmed through a few episodes of the rest to get a sense of what goes on.
I've seen some criticisms of this video on the basis that some of my critique of Haikyuu isn't true of the latter half of season 2, but I honestly don't think this changes the point at all. Saying that a show is hype and has interesting villains for just a short period of time as the end of a season doesn't seem like much of a defense, considering that Kuroko no Basuke never had these problems from the very beginning. I think it's more than fair to say that if 60% of the show is bad at generating hype or getting me to care, then the show is bad at those things.
Aside from that, though, the reception of this video has been everything I hoped for. Fans of both shows have remarked on how this video helped them to contextualize what they like about one or hate about the other, and my largely non-partisan approach seems to have paid off. Some people even said that they thought it seemed like I was more into Haikyuu up until the end when I said otherwise. It really goes to show how much someone's personal values effect what they think of as praise or criticism. While the things that I talked about as problems with Kuroko no Basuke did bother me, they didn't actually bother me anywhere near as much as the things that I found to be problems with Haikyuu. Seeing such a broad range of reactions from different kinds of people with opinions all over the spectrum in response to this video has been super cool.
Having Davoo here to edit right in front of me has also proven beneficial already. Aside from him being able to easily show me changes and ask about what things to show, in this particular video we were able to make a pretty big change that would have been time-consuming enough before to set our whole schedule back: the addition of title breaks. Originally this video wasn't broken into parts; but when I watched it fully-edited for the first time, I found it to be exhausting, and like it wasn't clear enough when I was done making one point before I moved into the next one. Adding in title breaks was surprisingly natural since the video already basically moved between a series of different sections anyways. Had we done this over the internet, Davoo would have had to re-edit, re-render, and re-upload the video without my input, and coordinating what I wanted the timing to be on the fade-in and fade-outs would have been impossible. On Davoo's old connection, it might have taken another half a day to reupload the video and get it to me. Instead, we got it out that night and were able to go marathon Mob Psycho 100 and get a video for that written and performed before bed. Expect that one tomorrow!