Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

First week in a while without a Wednesday post, which feels odd. There has been more TLS art finished in the background, though, so look forward to those sooner instead of later!

Originally I had hoped to get out Four Liars 0.2.0 quickly, even if it was still all placeholder assets, in order to keep up momentum. It looks like the schedule will have to be a little bit different, as some obstacles have come up. This is always the case with development, so let me give the overall situation.

Resolution Woes

One of the issues is that there were things I didn't know about the best way to display pixel art on modern monitors - lessons learned for the future, but in the short term it means a whole lot of things need to be rejiggered.

This isn't even as bad as it looked at first, this is after some work:

Now, the screen is controlled by many different plugins and settings, so it would be unreasonable to expect it to magically all work together. Getting the different pieces resized and repositioned, however, requires more fiddling than you might think.

Sometimes the proper setting is buried deep, or sometimes it's controlled by a different plugin than you'd expect. Sometimes I'm dumb and look straight past it, but sometimes the setting really doesn't exist or is weirdly labeled. It took a lot of work to get to this:

A UI that most people will probably never think twice about, and will think is mediocre if they do notice. T-T Perversely, the art actually looks worse than 0.1.0 because I had to compress the placeholder graphics for the resolution.

However! This is the necessary framework for the final assets, so it will look better once those are added. Everything is at x1 magnification with no skewing, so it should have pixel-perfect scaling. The UI will change further in the future, but for the time being my goal is to make a reasonable experience for players.

New Assets

So what work am I doing with the pixel artists? The nice thing about art as opposed to all the writing or design work I do is that you can just show it:

These are progressive iterations we went through after deciding on our angle and basic proportions. The first row is before the full shading, just choosing colors and shapes. I thought this was pretty good, but that the characters were too much on the default model, so I asked for more unique stances that would communicate some personality.

In the second row you'll see that we made some attempts at that - Thunial was great, but we did further iterations on the other three. I've found a new plugin that will let me use multiple sprites for characters, so they'll walk around normally and then fall into their default stance when they pause. You'll notice two more extreme poses in the second row, which I hope to repurpose as little animated poses the characters can do during cutscenes.

Meanwhile, we also have initial work on the character faces:

Before you say it, I know that her hood is pointy in the sprite and round here! I'm doing my best to avoid inconsistencies between artists, doing things like choosing a core color palette, but some issues do pop up and will be changed.

I've also begun work on custom tiles, but none of that is complete and quality enough to share yet.

World Map Question

Since I'm taking a bit longer with the build, this is also the time to reconsider other decisions. For the most part I have no intention of changing things, but I find myself wondering if I should have the game make use of a world map (to be clear, a navigable region, not just a map of the world).

On one hand, a world map is a bunch of new assets and would require a little redesigning. On the other hand, maybe it's part of the cozy nostalgia of the 16-bit era? I feel like world maps have received a surge of popularity since Expedition 33 used one, and even the upcoming FF Resonance uses one. The current game doesn't require one, but if I redesigned navigation along these lines, a world map does offer new affordances for exploration.

I don't know, it's rare that I'm on the fence about a design element like this. Anyone have strong opinions?

Next Goal

Because so much is changing, using old saves would be inadvisable. If players have to replay, I want the experience to be meaningfully different, so I want to try to get all of the major changes that I had planned.

Four Liars 0.2.0 should be a significantly upgraded experience with final character sprites/faces, more systems intact, and hopefully a new chapter on top of that. I'm not sure exactly how long this will take, but I will be reporting on it week-to-week as progress is made.

Current changelog/progress for the WIP build:

- New scene added between Dark Approach and Fortress of Darkness.

- New scene added between Chapter 1 and Chapter 2.

- There is now a message log, accessible via PageUp.

- The in-battle Status menu is now configured, including descriptions for all status effects.

- Battle UI has been improved.

- Menu rearranged to try to be more useful.

- The bug regarding loading from post-battle autosaves has been fixed.

- Mouse movement should no longer cause crashes on certain maps.

- Rachnera improved the gauge auto-hide feature and fixed the autosave bug.

- Guandi now has an open accessory slot. Accessory is automatically removed when she leaves.

- Misc bugfixing.

Files

Comments

lostone2

I'm just bad talking about art, so no comments on that, sorry. It's great to see a more ambitious 0.2 roadmap, so it sounds pretty exciting. One of my favorite things about DoW was the world map, so it would be nice to have it appear again in one of your games.

AchtungNight

World maps always improve my immersion in RPGs. First came the original Final Fantasy. Then maps that changed with Chrono Trigger and FF6. Since then many open world games have had them, including TLS. I think they’re cool.

An_Insane_Rogue_AI

I am definitely in favor of a world map in just about any game in the rpg genre

Ark Tolei

I'm not really sure where in the process your fundamental design work is, but it feels late in development to me for a tool like a world map to be added. That might seem crazy, considering how early in development the implemented product is, but I think of the choice between world map and not world map as one of the most fundamental questions because of the cascade effects it has on the rest of the games pacing, as well as the implications on the structure of the content. Games with well implemented world maps typically have a huge ratio of optional to required locations (not just content, specifically entire tilesets and maps that are off the beaten path, think about how little of ff6 or ff7 is required. the expectation is to have entire towns you don't need to access in your playthrough at all), and a pacing that allows for abandoning the plot for protracted periods without feeling like you're losing anything. World map games are somewhat episodic in nature, with the plot turning on and off depending on where the player is, and a deliberate obfuscation of the passage of time between set pieces. Compare this to FFX, which fully allows you to backtrack to earlier areas, but you have to walk the entire way until the very end of the game, at which point you can just teleport. The expectation is that the player will keep moving forward, and the plot is paced accordingly. Each individual plot beat has to be centered on a location with a world map. 90% of Barret's Corel backstory takes place physically in a single location with very little room to escape the plot until it's resolved, for example. The entire plotline from the point he starts acting weird occurs in contiguous section of areas without ever needing to see the world map. The path to Corel, into new corel, into gold saucer, into the prison, and back up to gold saucer for the resolution might actually be the largest contiguous series of truly distinct areas (i.e. not all the same city) in the game. It's design that emulates, for a brief moment, a game with no world map, because the narrative requires that we understand the time scale of events and focus on an extended piece of plot across multiple set pieces. Barret's Corel arc stands out against the broader design of ff7 as a singularly important moment of gameplay that necessitates bending the rules of the game's design to fit, but you could drop the entire Barret arc into almost any wilderness>town sequence in FFX's area design seamlessly at any point in the game without needing to do anything more than add an event marker to prevent you from leaving once you reached the point of no return. Neither choice of design is better than the other, but I feel like swapping between the two styles partway through requires a really fundamental restructuring of both the narrative and non-narrative content to make work.

Grim8P

> world map What's the highest number of screen transitions between two places I could conceivably want to travel between if I had to walk there screen by screen vs. hitting up a world map and using that instead? I think that's the sort of thing I'd want to consider before worrying about the world map existing so I can traverse it. I recently played through Rise of the Third Power which I loved in almost every respect, but traversing their world map was painfully slow and is one of the things I disliked the most. So just adding one isn't straight improvement. I saw a lot of people complaining about how much time it took to walk from one part of TLS to another, for chapter 4 and 5. Probably the worst for some of your "traverse everywhere in the world" quests, but still, walking from one place to another maybe takes 1 minute? So for my above question on map transitions, the tolerance for some is way lower than I'd have ever guessed. Hope this helps.

Sierra Lee

Interesting, I did not expect such an extensive response. While I see some of your points, I'm not sure that I entirely agree. The main three affordances I see from world maps are exploration, navigation, and scale: - Exploration primarily in the sense that you can have small side areas that seem more separated than just regions on a single map. - Navigation in that you can travel less linearly between previous sections. FFX could have been just as linear plot-wise, but had different kinds of sidequests that re-used old areas, if they had been connected differently. - For scale, the main effect is separating your setpieces - think of Stineford, which easily could have been attached maps with no change to the plot, but I hope feels more like a whole region because you navigate between areas via the map.

Sierra Lee

Honestly, navigation time is probably something to be considered regardless of which method I ultimately use. I had a good time with Rise of the Third Power! I don't really remember the world map, but the point is taken regardless. Most likely that depends on map design, and I would favor relatively compact map regions that should substantially reduce travel time, at least in theory.

Ark Tolei

I would have written a shorter comment, but I did not have the time and all that. I think everything you said is totally fair. I don't really think of the subregion maps in TLS as being a world map despite the aesthetic similarities because they cover such a small portion of the play space, and tended to have some fairly specific mechanics involved (i.e. the timer attached to entering each section of the Feroholm area). With that being said, the arbitrary lines in my head are not the arbitrary lines in the head of anyone else, and there are many examples of hybrid approaches, including the example you gave. Chalk it up to waking up very essay prone and being on a time crunch that meant it actually got posted instead of edited for 40 minutes before eventually just being deleted when I realized that it was an answer to a very narrowly defined question nobody asked. That is generally the preferred result for all involved.

Sierra Lee

You're fine, I'm just glad people care enough to be passionate about the design decisions. ^-^

Pieter Koornhof

Can't wait to play this after finally finishing TLS!

ushiroace

The adjusted UI is a big improvement, nice work. As for the world map, I'm strongly in favor of it. The classic JRPG moment where you're let free in the overworld in an airship or some other form of unrestricted travel is always magical, particularly when there are many optional areas to visit with unique rewards. You could certainly add some nonlinearity and optional content without the map, but I think the world map really sells the size of the world and adds a sense of discovery (literally discovering the location) that would be lacking otherwise.