Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Just uploaded 0.40.2 in the other post. It is definitely not the final balance, but if you were just waiting for a smoother experience, this one should have most of the bugs and typos ironed out.

The Council of Gawnfall updates are done and people generally liked them. This is good, because I'm likely to crash in December. Version 0.41.0 content will be scattered between many different components and require less concentration, so hopefully I will be able to make decent progress on it no matter how rough things get.

There will probably be a midweek post coming soonish. The reason is that I took some steps to make an audiobook version of my novel and I may need some help. =/ I put in my audition application on Audible's site, not certain if I would get anyone, since some other authors have complained of that. To my surprise, I've received quite a few auditions, enough that I'm not sure how to choose between them.

I don't know if anyone is willing to listen to different narrators read the same scenes, but once auditions stop coming in, I will select those that I think are decent quality and put them up for people to vote on. Kind of wish I hadn't gotten that ball rolling at this time, but it's nice that my book wasn't ignored by the narrator community.

Anyway, that will happen. Then maybe the public TLS release on Friday, but it's fine if people want another week to look at the inner workings. I will try to start on the next update's content tomorrow, though I also hope to start writing NGM#2.

EDIT: Anyone who happens to see this, please note that I've uploaded version 0.40.3 to the previous post. For those who are getting into balance or looking into game files, this update will be very relevant.

Comments

Scol

Been fiddling with the new update and with 40.1 balance I was able to get best outcome in all votes in days 4-5 except Tak'kan one where I got the medium one (I've been trying to undermine Ignias to promote Kalant and didn't have sanitation mages) and had exactly 14/14 needed Sarai influence to boost everything needed on the last day. Still unsure how to allocate party members to different problems. Ellani boosting Ardford case doesn't seem to work though (in 40.1 so it might be already fixed). As I said in earlier post I digest books almost exclusively in form of audiobooks, so I'm excited about the news. I'm not a native english speaker though. For me, depending on narrator english audiobooks vary between being almost as enjoyable as ones in my language and being hard to understand without replaying some fragments few times. Because of that, I'd love to help you pick a narrator that will let me enjoy your work. :)

Lamsey

I should have a decent amount of spare time in the coming week, so I'll happily help out with NGM narrators as well as exploring balance in the second half of the Council.

Sierra Lee

On TLS: an optimized game capable of using Sarai influence on everything was something I wanted to avoid. I'm not sure how, but something will definitely need to become more costly. You're right that Elleani was missing. Fixed! On audiobooks, I'll be glad to get the opinions of those to whom it really matters!

Dream Fractal

I would love, love an audio book version. I don't have as much time to read as I would like, but I have a lot of listening time between travel and chores.

DuckTogo

Judging people from my armchair sounds fun! As long as there are not 20+ people to choose from I'll definitely have a listen.

Seil

For what it's worth my optimized save had to sacrifice Tak'kan support alltogether, and i only got little support for dwarves and no overwhelming support for Goddess of Magic request. Maybe i just didn't optimize enough, but without exact numbers i am not quite sure what could be changed.

Grey Wolf

So I finally feel like giving feedback on .40 and I would say overall it was satisfying to get through with most everything I wanted, only token support for Tak'kan probably because of the sanitation mages considering I committed nothing but in this play-through they're doing amazing anyways so it's really nothing concerning. This wasn't on my sub-optimal save which missed the Elleani talk, this save was nearly perfect with the first half of the conference had me integrating succubi into the church totally, Annah olive branch, moderate reform with the full 5 Ivalan acceptance. So I went into the conference with 10 influence and maybe had help on the unpeople vote from the sarai bug. Though I only got acceptance rather than full support for the succubi knights. But this possibly could be chalked up to me going with Kaskia's plan but then obliterating her bid for deputy 1 - 6 which costed a lot of influence, definitely may not have the needed to weaken her bid for advancement to that extent. Overall I don't see a pressing need to make it too much more difficult considering even with Jhenno's support, the unpeople bug, and a totally minmaxed first half and setup I didn't get every optimal outcome throughout. On the subject of the reveal I found it more interesting than some, I don't really see it as offensive as something like when Chrichton threw out "quantum foam" multiple times as a if it would somehow justify time travel but I'm not really a physicist so maybe it's my ignorance limiting my ability to find it unsatisfactory. I would understand Alonon's reaction if he were characterized as a learned mage who understood magic being as esoteric as it is in TLS's world, with there being 3 fundamental categories that are further subdivided in the way visible light breaks down red to violet but itself is only a small part of the electromagnetic spectrum where arcane breaks down into frequencies which can be used to heal or at other frequencies burn freeze etc, that the foundation of reality being built upon such a simple duality would be shockingly simple and unsatisfactory. But I never got the impression Alonon really had a solid grounding in sophisticated magical theory. I know he has access to great power that exists in a unified form but so does Simon and he clearly wasn't as disturbed by the revelation though I get the implication that is due to him being not as in touch with the more esoteric facets of the world. I guess the nature of his acquisition of that unified power isn't simply through a shard and it may become evident in a future lore dump exactly why simplicity of the duality broke him?

Scol

I think the issue might be on how easy day4-5 votes were for me, there was almost no reason to spent Influence on them. I optimized it a bit more and here's a breakdown of my influence spendings in 0.40.2: Starting: 14 Vote1: +1 influence (do nothing) [best outcome] Vote2: -1 influence (nudge Annah; this pushes Annah influence to 10 for later votes) [medium outcome, best outcome unreachable for me (would need 7 more temp points)] Vote3: +1 influence (do nothing); -1 influence (Qum + Vhalla; this pushes Nabith influence to 10 for late votes) [best outcome] Vote4: +1 influence (do nothing) [best outcome] Vote5: (can't do anything) [best outcome 6:1] This left me with 15 sarai Influence on final projection while only being able to spend 14 there.

Sierra Lee

Yeah, I'm not saying that everything will be overhauled to be harder. I do think that I might need to modify certain votes on days 4-5, as Scol noted.

Sierra Lee

You're not the only one, hence why I'm trying to move forward with the audio book version. Thanks for your interest!

Sierra Lee

I'm at 17 auditions now, so we'll see how high it goes. However, I intend to pare down the list as much as possible before showing people, because while I'm not good at judging narrators, there are some that I feel definitely aren't appropriate for the book. Anyway, thanks!

Sierra Lee

Thanks for your feedback! It's good to know that that some players need to make tricky choices balancing things. For the record, you do get benefits for an overwhelming victory for one candidate. I didn't have plans to detail Alonon's recent history, and it's possible that I didn't imply it strongly enough. Basically, after the war tore apart his continent, Alonon began exploring the Tower, seeking answers about reality. First to fight the Incubus Emperor, then to find some sort of answers to all the suffering he'd seen during the war. He did gain fairly advanced knowledge of magic, but that wasn't the main issue. It's a common human response to tragedy to want to find meaning in that tragedy, which can be a healthy way to cope. But when Alonon went looking for meaning, he found an objective answer about his reality that he knew he could never find satisfying. From his perspective, the world of TLS is cosmic horror.

Hartmanns Youkai

Had a chance to go through the update, and wanted to point out a couple quick errors: After everyone talks about whether or not the succubi should be accepted on the first day, Sarai says "All of you know that succubi are a part of Arclent that it is impossible to remove, not now." There should be at least one extra word in there somewhere, maybe something like "All of you know that succubi are a part of Arclent now, and that it is impossible to remove them." When using a point of influence for Simon to argue for the care of existing Unpeople, his chat window does something funky during his lines of "...I would like to remind the synod that the Church struggles to support..." Where it has to scroll up the chat window text by the end of the line. This also scrolls up Simon's portrait, funny enough. There is another case of the same thing happening with Annah's dialogue of "...but I feel that Herin's compassionate attitude has much to..." when they are resolving either which priestess to promote or which proposal to accept (sorry, I don't remember which one). During the night when Esmera and Kerannii are both watching the dancers, they are also inside their own rooms with the same dialogue from the 2nd night. When you are first splitting up the party between Simon's combat team and Iris' politics team, Sarai has a small typo: "It might have been possible, but I didn't want to do anything to weakn our strong position overall." As for the actual gameplay, I enjoyed it. Thanks as always for the update. To me it seemed like Alonon was worrying WAY too much about something that isn't a problem, but maybe that is just a matter of personalities dealing with these kinds of things differently. Just because you hope to find some universal meaning to life by analyzing the basic building blocks of the world doesn't mean that you'll find one there, just as it doesn't mean that you won't find meaning somewhere else. He seems a bit too quick to drop down into extreme depression while still not knowing a good deal about some of the hidden facets of the world, but he also isn't one for excessive conversation so maybe we're still not hearing the whole story from him.

Sierra Lee

Thanks for all your feedback! The first line is actually what I intended. The last part is shorthand for "It might have been possible to remove them in the past, but not now." The next error you describe occurs when a line is too long for the text box, and if you keep bugtesting, you'll probably run into more. It helps me find these to identify the exact location and the beginning of the line - you can use the arrow keys to scroll up the box and see. I found and fixed the first one you reported but haven't found the second. On Esmera and Kerannii, that's another outcome that isn't handled. Fixed, thanks!

Hartmanns Youkai

Oh, I see what you're going for in the first one. In that case, I don't think the word "it" should be in that statement. I went back and found where Annah's dialogue scrolled down. It is one of her possible comments after the section where the two proposals for the purity system are discussed, and the meeting has reconvened to vote on which proposal to use and how to modify it. Her whole line is "My thoughts about this whole situation are in turmoil, but I feel that Herin's compassionate attitude has much to recommend it, regardless of her specific proposal."

genericname12345

Reading up more on the above, I suppose the fact that Alonon is asexual while the world he inhabits is, at its most fundamental level, completely based off of sexuality, lust, and purity wasn't a particularly pleasant revelation either? Especially given the fact that it's a solid, objective answer to the questions about the nature of the universe, and a wholly dissatisfactory one when applied to things like 'why do bad things happen'?

Sierra Lee

I agree that would read better, but honestly it'll take me a good bit to track down the line. Located and fixed Annah's line, thanks!

Sierra Lee

It certainly didn't help. When thinking about a world based on NSFW game rules, one of my early thoughts was that 0.5-1% of the population would find it deeply troubling. From Alonon's perspective, it's like getting a chance to ask God why there's suffering in the world and finding out that all God cares about is professional sports.

genericname12345

Heh. Also: Looking through some of the actual math behind what's been set up in the forum dropbox and holy hell, you weren't kidding about both trade-offs and complexity. This is beyond ludicrous. Looking at it, I can sweep through most of the events with the exception of Tak'kan. Which, with how I've set things up, isn't worth bothering going for the 'Major' since it's basically impossible. Not too fussed - I did kind of screw over Ignias as a suitor, but even then I'd have had to go way too hard on this to be worth it. I'll just take the +2 to Annah and get her to 10, call it a win with minor support. Which, left me a hefty chunk of influence for the Minor Issues - I might be able to scrape out one or two more points, not too sure. And I could *definitely* influence everything if I had Sarai sacrifice her prospects for getting some action - holding off on that, though. Anyway, it looks like I can get the absolute best result for Mercantile, Goddess of Magic, and Mothers Guard, second best for Eustrin and Ardford Ban, and the neutral result for the Succubus Order. Which I don't feel that bad about given that I've burned a lot for Yelarel already. If I'd had Sarai sacrifice herself, I could instantly get the best Order result possible. If I went down to second best in Mercantile, I could have the second best Succubus Order. Honestly, this is actually a tough choice - with how optimized I am, Sarai's option is really tempting. The question is, whether Yelarel's order will be worth Sarai. EDIT: If I just keep Simon's mouth shut more and avoid burning influence to talk on anything outside of the Unperson vote, I could feasibly get Yelarel. Again, though, would lose out on Annah support so....myeeeh.

Grey Wolf

Ah, now that you spell it out I probably should have inferred that the beginning of his despair was his impotence in the face of the AoA's atrocities. His responsiveness to Vhala's emotional plea makes sense in this light, he recognizes how that war consumed so much of both their lives, and put him on the edge of this despair. It was the revelation of the arbitrary nature of fate along with the simplistic duality that makes up matter that sent him into the pit.

onepot

Hm. On balance... My save felt rather optimized before the council (heavily focused on economy though I guess), and I even used the recent ProN returns to last-miute-invest in Lustlord Temples. Still, overall I felt I got rather mediocre results after several playthroughs. For example, I'd love to integrate the succubi into the church, but for that I'd need to burn my influence with Hester, and for some reason I want her to like me so I avoided that. ^^ Tak'kan only got token support, which I can live with. I got Herin chosen for deputy position, but for some reason, they used Kaskia's much more extreme approach as basics for further discussion. No idea why. That isn't necessarily a bad thing for me, it just doesn't feel logical. Possible bug/oversight? On the last day, I had 3 Sarai influence. I don't think I got optimal results there except for the Mother issue, though I must admit that I only did that part once, wasting Wynn's support on Succubus Order proposal that didn't exist (new religion) and Elleani supporting in Ardoheim still being bugged. Overall, for someone not using wiki walkthroughs etc., I feel a bit more guidance would be helpful. Especially Simon's talk options often felt like a guessing game. Having to go back to priestesses' house for Aram priestesses after meeting them in the guest quarters seems counterintuitive. Kerannii's color scheme makes it easy to overlook her in her room, espeially at night. Maybe she could be positioned more towards the center of the room, to make her stand out more visually? I'll replay the section once balancing is final and a guide is posted. Without it, I feel pretty lost there, it's like throwing eggs at the dark corner of a room and hoping tomorrow there will be cake. Don't get me wrong, I like the concept and watching the results is fun, it's just that, only using ingame information, I feel like I don't have a clue what I'm doing and if I'm finished with doing it half of the time.

Sierra Lee

Thanks for your additional feedback - I'm glad the complexity leads to some difficult choices in most cases. I don't know if I've said this, but Sarai's decision will be significant but not permanent.

Sierra Lee

Thanks for your feedback! >I got Herin chosen for deputy position, but for some reason, they used Kaskia's much more extreme approach as basics for further discussion. No idea why. That isn't necessarily a bad thing for me, it just doesn't feel logical. Possible bug/oversight? Uncertain, sorry. The two candidates and the two proposals are separate issues, though. >Overall, for someone not using wiki walkthroughs etc., I feel a bit more guidance would be helpful. Especially Simon's talk options often felt like a guessing game. Since this update is on the far end of the complexity spectrum, it's certainly possible that I need to do more along these lines. However, I'm not certain what would help in this and other cases. What type of guidance would make the section feel better to you?

Hartmanns Youkai

Without going into anything that would require a huge amount of additional text, maybe you could add some more details to the Projection areas. For the first half's projection, you could add a short summary of that priestess' general attitude/tendencies that would display along with their influence score (you could do a simple one that stays static throughout the event, or have it change vote to vote based on what is the current issue being voted on but that would be significantly more work), and then have Simon's options for speaking use some of the same keywords as you used in the priestess' summaries so that the player would be clued in more on what Simon was going to attempt to change. The votes between the Herin and Kaskia stuff were a lot simpler to read since they were really direct issues and you spelled out Simon's choices directly, but for the earlier stuff involving most parties arguing a decent bit I'll confess I was also a bit lost and ended up just going through each option and trying to check the results. It didn't help that at this point in time I was still trying to get a feel for what each priestess cared about most, but I assume that is also a bit of your intent because Simon and friends would be in the same position as the player trying to figure out how to best influence all these different people. For the projection after the party split, it would be nice to have more of a solid idea on how much sway you have on a specific vote. Even just a simple toggle between something like "we don't have much influence here", "we are likely to get some support", and "we have a lot of influence on this point" would be great for those trying to identify how to spread out their resources. I know it doesn't make a huge amount of sense for Simon's team to specifically know how each vote will turn out, but from a gameplay perspective I would much rather be able to chart things out from that projection area rather than have to take general guesses and then sit through the Alonon speech over and over again trying to minmax things as though Simon has the power of time travel. I'd even suggest maybe giving the players an option to toggle between more specific readouts of how things are going vs the more lore-friendly guesses by Simon's team that you already have (since different players will value different approaches more), though that would be even more work to implement and check that everything is now properly responding to a new toggle variable.

Sierra Lee

Anyone who happens to see this, please note that I've uploaded version 0.40.3 to the previous post. For those who are getting into balance or looking into game files, this update will be very relevant.

Grey Wolf

Alright I went through again, this time not blind, though I didn't make my own spreadsheet or use a calculator. I did appreciate being able to use Fuliminato's as a point of reference, thanks man, ended up with only 5 votes throughout the conference resolved as less than exceptional: Tak'kan, Estaven, GoM, mercantile, and Eustrin all ended up with good but not great results. Everything else in the whole conference was optimally resolved, a lot better than results for this second half than in my initial blind play through but still not perfect in every way. If during the magical disturbance I had supported either the Goddess or the merchants I might have been able to bring the total sub-optimal results to 4. Seems that for me church support may have been a mistake in retrospect. I didn't get to see Esmera's confession on my first time through, felt validated as I was one of the few who never believed her portrait could be for Annah, I said she looked too "defeated" but I suppose disillusioned would have been more accurate. I appreciate Sarai's hesitance, I always saw her vulgar humor as a way to blow off steam rather than showing her true self. Trin's protest inclusion in the projection was funny, hope she's right about Herin, though Yelarel would be fine too. She deserves it after putting up with the old purity standards.

Lamsey

I've been thinking about this as well. As best as I can tell, there are certain key points that you need to hit for each priestess' influence level, and the ranges vary widely for each - for example, you can't move Hester much, but you don't really need to, whereas the Aramites need a lot more movement to be friendly. It's very difficult to know what the influence numbers mean without looking under the hood or replaying a bunch of times. Instead of a potentially-complicated toggle between numbers and narrative, I was thinking that each priestess could have a "disposition" displayed alongside their influence level, kind of like the relationship levels for harem members. The transitions between dispositions would be set at the significant vote-altering levels for each priestess. That would be a subtle signal to the player that they've achieved a nudge in the level of support they'll get from that priestess, while still leaving room for ambiguity about the exact nature of the nudge. For example, if appealing to Nabith in a particular vote increases her influence from 3 to 4 but her disposition still says "Hesitant", whereas appealing to Bertricia also goes from 3 to 4 but takes her from "Friendly" to "Aligned", that might give the player a signal that they've nudged Bertricia but they still need to work on Nabith. It'd also be nice if the dispositions were unique for each priestess, to reflect their overall attitude. I've sketched out some rough examples below, but the numbers would obviously need tweaked to match the real internal thresholds for voting. It'd probably also be necessary to hide the figures before the initial conversation, similar to the tweak that was made for Kerannii. Bertricia: <1: Betrayed 1-2: Sympathetic 3-4: Friendly >4: Aligned Nabith: <1: Unsure 2-4: Hesitant 5-7: Confident >7: Assured Hester: <2: Suspicious 2-3: Skeptical >4: Agnostic Esmera: <1: Opposed 1-5: Neutral 6-9: Cooperative >10: Allied Kerannii: <1: Appalled 1-5: Ambivalent 6-9: Encouraged >10: Welcoming Annah: <2: Utterly hostile 2-4: Hostile 4-7: Mostly hostile >8: Conflicted I think something like this would be a subtle way to give the player a bit more support in making the decisions, and take a bit of focus away from the raw numbers to improve immersion. Hopefully it wouldn't be a nightmare to implement, either, though I recognise that RPG Maker often makes things more complicated than they seem... I think it's good to hide the numbers for the last set of votes, since it reflects the fact that Iris has less visibility on everything than Simon. That being said, I like the idea of some kind of narrative "Chances" option for each vote to get an opinion from Sarai, to give some sort of idea where the influence needs to be focused. There are some hints in the intros to each issue, but they're pretty vague and it's difficult to keep track since the intros are only played once.

onepot

Sorry, time is sparse lately, and writing in English still takes me forever. -.- On High Priestess score variables: I agree that they're too ambiguous, but adding ANOTHER score that really only is a reflection of the first one doesn't seem helpful to me. Also I believe that would only work if the same thresholds would apply to each vote?. I think it's more about making more clear what the scores actually do. In the introduction of the projection, Carina says: 'We'll be trying to guess how much additional pull we have with each High Priestess, but the numbers will be relative.' and then next textbox 'Bertricia will always be friendly to us, for example, and at most we'll be able to budge Annah slightly.' I know it doesn't say that, but what stuck with me was: 'The higher the value, the more she likes me, and it's gonna be easier to raise Bertricia's score than Annah's. Duh.' Besides my linguistic ineptitude, part of the problem was the nature of text boxes. In a running text, I would have jumped back to the first sentence after reading the second one, but that wasn't possible here, so my mind filled in the blanks by itself and I just went with it. And when Bertricia stayed at 4 throughout the whole council and Annah climbed to 5, I started to feel like something was going very, very wrong. :> Maybe to Carina's introduction could be added: 'Though in many cases they might, the numbers do not necessarily reflect a High Priestess' affection towards you, but rather how open she is to your arguments.' That's the definition I came up with now, still not 100% sure it's adequate. ^^ If nothing else, I'd let Carina make the Bertricia-Annah example first and THEN explain what she means by it. >What type of guidance would make the section feel better to you? I'm actually doing another playthrough on 0.40.3 right now to check step-by-step what added to my confusion. ^^ The above probably was big part of it, cluelessness about Simon's speech options a recurring theme and other than that a few more minor issues that might seem nitpicky but just added up, especially when you're still figuring out the rules of the current political game. Not sure how fast I'll get it done though, might be not before tomorrow or even Friday at latest, I hope it will still be useful to you then.

Sierra Lee

I appreciate the additional feedback, but I'm going to have a rough time deciding exactly how to do this. Combined with some of the other long reports I've received, I'm starting to worry about a Friday release. =/ I'm not opposed to adding labels like Lamsey suggested, and it could potentially work my making different labels work for different votes. Collecting that information and implementing it would be another fraction of a headache, but it might be worth it if people feel it would add clarity to the section.

Sierra Lee

Thanks for your additional feedback! Also glad to hear you enjoyed some of the character notes. ^-^

Lamsey

Another option might be to have feedback from Sarai/Carina after each vote on the actions that the player took, e.g. "it seems like your plea for unity had an impact on Nabith" or "sadly, it looks like appealing to Annah may have backfired", that sort of thing. I can see that being a nightmare in terms of all the different combinations, though.

onepot

I'm sorry again, Lamsey, I've misread your post entirely. (EDIT: the first one) That would actually be a great idea, and it would resolve most of my issues with Simon's talks as well as they're often about picking the right Priestess. Sorry Sierra. :> This actually seems to solve the main issue, so I'll postpone my replay to a more convenient date. ^^

Lamsey

No need to apologise - I have great respect for those who take the time and effort to speak other languages, especially one so complicated as English :-)

genericname12345

Hey, Sierra, did 0.40.3 change anything from the first half of the Gaunfall Council? I replayed it - again, from the second state and I was wondering if I missed anything by starting halfway through.

Lamsey

I'm trying to cover as many paths as possible to look for issues, so this is taking me longer than I'd hoped. I've just finished exploring the new denomination route, so I'll post what I've written up so far. I'll report back later after investigating the alternative routes (new religion / disunity). General feedback: The extra conversations with various High Priestesses at the end are good. I really like Bertricia's thoughtful, open-minded approach, and it's great to see her and Orcent getting to philosophise. Esmera's revelation during the dance is surprising and actually quite touching - it certainly made me see her in a more sympathetic light. Sarai's conversation after a successful purity vote is similarly touching, which is remarkable given that it includes the phrase "cunt-blasting". It'd be interesting to know the denominations of all the High Priestesses. We know that Annah and Kerannii are hard and soft Desecrationists respectively, while Sarai is a Subsecrationist; I'm guessing Esmera is too, given her support for the Inquisition. Hester and Bertricia strike me as Consecrationists, but I can't remember if that's ever confirmed. I'm unsure about Nabith, but she seems pretty concerned with balance and unity, so if I had to guess, I'd say Subsecrationist. Herin's innocent optimism makes me think she's a Consecrationist, and I suspect Kaskia changes her position depending on who she's talking to, ideological slut that she is. And we all know that Yelarel is a Cumsecretionist at heart, of course :-) Alonon's statement about the increase in monster strength is an interesting throwaway. I guess Stenai must be fairly insignificant in Tower terms, since its monsters are still so weak. I've also been thinking more about what Alonon says about the nature of reality. Simon's "fundamental dust" theory is a nice analogy for atomic physics, but we know that physical matter is only part of the equation in the world of TLS; magic is also a significant factor. Perhaps the lust/purity duality is a property analogous to positive/electric atomic charges, where lust is chaotic and purity is stable. This additional property could explain the different forms of magical power in this reality, where sexual and divine magics make more use of their respective charges and arcane is a balance of the two, and it also explains the difference in fallout production from the different forms; the more chaotic lust energy in the mix, the more fallout is produced. This also explains why sexual magic is good at manipulating and altering things, while divine magic is good at strengthening and healing; again, chaos and order respectively. Also, since magic is fundamental to the lifecycle of living beings (we know this from Robin's previous statement about it being difficult to conceive a living being stripped of arcane magic), that also explains the differences between races. Where it gets really interesting is the idea of a unified or raw form of magic that's neither sexual (chaotic), divine (ordered), nor arcane (balanced). Some kind of missing link, like dark matter/energy in our reality? It's going to be interesting finding out. Balance: It feels like the succubus denomination is the best path through overall, so long as you're able to get them fully accepted, but it's riskier. The other scenarios have their own strengths, but seem to involve more tradeoffs. After a lot of experimentation, I've managed to work out a path where I get the succubus denomination accepted and I don't get any bad results in the main votes, and the final-day issues have a range from partial to significant successes. My save is heavily optimised towards succeeding in this section, so I think that's about right; I certainly needed to work hard to get to such a good outcome, and I think it's inconceivable that anyone could get such a near-perfect result on their first attempt(s) without some Alonon-tier foresight. Final influence values after day 5 (i.e. at start of Iris section): Sarai 11 / Bertricia 5 / Nabith 11 / Hester 4 / Esmera 12 / Kerannii 10 / Annah 7 Feedback for other paths pending, as mentioned in my preamble. Typos/suggestions (0.40.3): There doesn't seem to be any difference between Yelarel's light and strong speeches on the Unpeople? has Ardoheim has -> has Ardoheim (Tak'Kan vote): <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/j2ui5beugevr1nl/Screenshot%202018-12-09%2023.03.23.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/j2ui5beugevr1nl/Screenshot%202018-12-09%2023.03.23.png?dl=0</a> 'your way through' could be misinterpreted as referring to Herin specifically here - maybe "the right way through"? <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/95kr4ype7h9suhv/Screenshot%202018-12-09%2023.58.47.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/95kr4ype7h9suhv/Screenshot%202018-12-09%2023.58.47.png?dl=0</a> 'to optimum balance' -> 'the optimum balance'? ('to' works OK, just unusual, so just checking if intentional) <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/hdp8dc3m5rnjcnk/Screenshot%202018-12-10%2000.09.50.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/hdp8dc3m5rnjcnk/Screenshot%202018-12-10%2000.09.50.png?dl=0</a> Overflow (Succubus denomination accepted, purity standards vote, 'support softening'): <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/6tyda3yggbwaff3/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2018.31.07.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/6tyda3yggbwaff3/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2018.31.07.png?dl=0</a> Pains me to say this, but I believe 'benefited' is the accepted American spelling? (High Priestess vote) <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/9v7wsm7boe5mas5/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2019.09.27.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/9v7wsm7boe5mas5/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2019.09.27.png?dl=0</a> 'had' -> 'has' and/or 'this council' -> 'during this council'? (High Priestess vote) <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/uy4ksjyxcrcxuqi/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2019.10.50.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/uy4ksjyxcrcxuqi/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2019.10.50.png?dl=0</a> Slight dissonance between these consecutive lines from Nabith, if Simon takes the subtle 'softening' option with succubus denomination, and Qum demos her Healing Hug ability: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/mhg1x1zyf5lbicf/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.06.41.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/mhg1x1zyf5lbicf/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.06.41.png?dl=0</a> <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/dscm7hyeix185zj/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.06.55.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/dscm7hyeix185zj/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.06.55.png?dl=0</a> <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/meyib0mp5twivj5/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.07.06.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/meyib0mp5twivj5/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.07.06.png?dl=0</a> Repeat of 'strong position overall' in consecutive lines (before final issues section): <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/vw8mmnn48oqx4xf/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.47.17.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/vw8mmnn48oqx4xf/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.47.17.png?dl=0</a> <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/2lc4p0h7eexuhs5/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.47.21.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/2lc4p0h7eexuhs5/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2017.47.21.png?dl=0</a> hips hips -> his hips: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/lep3sktxme4i2ih/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2018.23.50.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/lep3sktxme4i2ih/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2018.23.50.png?dl=0</a>

Sierra Lee

No, essentially all of the changes are focused on the second half.

Lamsey

Feedback from New Religion path: If the succubus denomination fails, Bertricia and Esmera always say they'll support division, even after you persuade them to change to support the new religion: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/4sv97dxyno5g4u0/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2020.03.34.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/4sv97dxyno5g4u0/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2020.03.34.png?dl=0</a> <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/oe9701jflhjk8pd/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2020.02.51.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/oe9701jflhjk8pd/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2020.02.51.png?dl=0</a> Overflow (purity vote, new religion, church competitiveness): <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/jfmw2mimo2onefn/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2022.59.54.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/jfmw2mimo2onefn/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2022.59.54.png?dl=0</a> I'm not sure what Orilise means by "Originals": <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/c42mewnlxue4551/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2023.45.23.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/c42mewnlxue4551/Screenshot%202018-12-11%2023.45.23.png?dl=0</a> Yelarel says this even if the dance isn't happening, (i.e. there's no-one outside). Change 'outside' to 'at the bar' or similar? <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/n50nt4jitecozo2/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2021.37.30.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/n50nt4jitecozo2/Screenshot%202018-12-12%2021.37.30.png?dl=0</a> New Religion scores: I didn't do as well in the Fucklord and Tak'Kan votes, but I could probably fix that by burning a bit more Sarai influence and sacrificing a little from the final votes. Otherwise, pretty similar to my optimised run on the new denomination.

Lamsey

Feedback from Division path: The "Factors" option for the Inquisition task doesn't do anything if there's no support yet. Balance: broadly similar to the New Religion path, but with according tweaks to the strategy to get similar results. I ended up with more Sarai influence at the end votes (15), but I also ended up needing more of it to get the same level of favourable results. I didn't find anything else new. All of the above is predicated on a pretty optimal first half. I'll try playing around with some suboptimal / everything-is-on-fire scenarios tomorrow, but what's really hitting home for me is just how many possibilities and corner cases there are. There's no way any one person is ever going be able to see all the content for this summit, especially when you consider the way that historical decisions affect things. I hope other folks have had their typo-spotting hats on too!

onepot

Well, I managed to replay about first half of the council and didn't run into major issues anymore, assuming something along the lines of Lamsey's idea will be implemented. Just wanna repeat and clarify two minor issues from my first post: - After meeting the Aram priestesses in the guest chambers on the first evening, I feel Simon should say something like 'Let's get back to the priestess chambers and meet them right now.' or something like that, because as it is now, it feels counterintuitive to me to go back to the HP chambers where you just came from. Especially as you'll most likely first talk to the other NPCs in the guest chambers, and lastly Carina says in her Chat option, 'Unfortunately, there's nothing we can do to change the decisions made on the first day. I suggest getting yourself settled and resting with Yarra.' So that's what I did on my first try of the section, and then had to reload when I realized next day that I must have missed my window to talk to them. - Having reloaded, I talked to Esmera, but then missed Kerannii even though I was actively looking for her. She's standing half in the shadow of the wall, gets somewhat obscured by the candlesticks on the desk, and her hair colour blends in with the furniture. Even more so at later occasions actually, when it's night. So I missed her there the first time and had to reload again once I later found out where she's supposed to be, which was a bit frustrating. Maybe you could put her more towards the center of the room, or just let her look southwards, as her face will probably provide more contrast to the background than her hair. Sorry if this seems nitpicky, and I won't rule out that I'm just stupid, but I think those are easy fixes that would have prevented some confusion and frustration for me at the start of the section.

Lamsey

"Everything is on fire" attempt: To mitigate the positive effects of my past decisions, I tried a playthrough where I just didn't participate at all. Didn't talk to anyone, didn't use Sarai's influence, no deals, nothing. I only used Sarai's last-resort option on the unity vote, and purged all influence with Nabith to get a new religion through (I was also able to persuade Kerannii for free, due to Riala having started on purity research). The results were predictably pretty awful - bad results on pretty much everything (although it seems I'm literally unable to fail the excommunication vote). On the loading screen, I have: Sarai 22 / Bertricia 0 / Nabith -2 / Hester 1 / Esmera 0 / Kerannii 0 / Annah -1 It seems that Hester at least approved of my non-interventionist policy :-P Bugs and typos: During the Unperson vote, Esmera was still offering her 'purge influence to convince' options from the previous day: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/9uapt6c0a2owc4c/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.08.27.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/9uapt6c0a2owc4c/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.08.27.png?dl=0</a> Orcent and Bertricia's conversation still plays even though she's hiding in her room: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/6znt37gys15dcyt/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.19.15.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/6znt37gys15dcyt/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.19.15.png?dl=0</a> Sarai's conversation about the purity vote plays during the Iris section, even though Simon and Yarra are in the Tower. I'd have thought that there would be a pretty hefty RP penalty if Simon didn't have that conversation with her, and instead left her to suffer alone. <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/qw7820bh8swo0zx/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.22.02.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/qw7820bh8swo0zx/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.22.02.png?dl=0</a> Regrettable -> Regrettably (bad Kaskia result): <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/uro7axahkh93fvl/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.23.02.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/uro7axahkh93fvl/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.23.02.png?dl=0</a> Sadl -> Sadly (bad magical standards result): <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/pp8d3fb2cwqa6au/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.23.20.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/pp8d3fb2cwqa6au/Screenshot%202018-12-13%2016.23.20.png?dl=0</a>

Sierra Lee

Okay, heeere we go! Sorry not to comment on more of your subjective feedback - I appreciate it very much, I'm just scrambling to prepare for Friday. >Sarai's conversation after a successful purity vote is similarly touching, which is remarkable given that it includes the phrase "cunt-blasting". My work as an author is complete. >It'd be interesting to know the denominations of all the High Priestesses. Your guesses are correct except that Nabith stands somewhat between denominations. >It feels like the succubus denomination is the best path through overall, so long as you're able to get them fully accepted, but it's riskier. The other scenarios have their own strengths, but seem to involve more tradeoffs. I intended the other main paths to be valid options, but since getting the succubi accepted is the most difficult to obtain, I did try to give it some solid advantages. >There doesn't seem to be any difference between Yelarel's light and strong speeches on the Unpeople? It was purely mechanical before, but I added changed dialogue. >has Ardoheim has -> has Ardoheim (Tak'Kan vote): <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/j2ui5beugevr1nl/Screenshot%202018-12-09%2023.03.23.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/j2ui5beugevr1nl/Screenshot%202018-12-09%2023.03.23.png?dl=0</a> Sorry, which vote is this? >Pains me to say this, but I believe 'benefited' is the accepted American spelling? (High Priestess vote) Yeah, it is. I mistype this one a lot. >I'm not sure what Orilise means by "Originals": It's a reference to the part where the party is joking about being replacements for other party members. >Yelarel says this even if the dance isn't happening, (i.e. there's no-one outside). Change 'outside' to 'at the bar' or similar? Or... another conditional branch. We must have conditionals for ALL THE DIALOGUE. >I'll try playing around with some suboptimal / everything-is-on-fire scenarios tomorrow, but what's really hitting home for me is just how many possibilities and corner cases there are. There's no way any one person is ever going be able to see all the content for this summit, especially when you consider the way that historical decisions affect things. I hope other folks have had their typo-spotting hats on too! We'll just do our best in the meantime and hope all the branching is appreciated. X| >Sarai's conversation about the purity vote plays during the Iris section, even though Simon and Yarra are in the Tower. I'd have thought that there would be a pretty hefty RP penalty if Simon didn't have that conversation with her, and instead left her to suffer alone. Oh, I missed turning off a self-switch! Good catch. While there's no RP penalty, you were meant to miss that conversation and the bonus it gives if you didn't do it before. Whew, I think I got everything! Thank you very much for your extensive checking during this update and forgive me if I missed anything going into 0.40.4.

Quiet Stranger

It's a testament to what you've accomplished as a writer that there are so many eager to voice act for you. One of my friends, who does this for a living, has complained of how loathsome it is to read for a book that he finds boring. I'm glad that I was able to renew my patronage in time to listen. Depending on the quality of the narration, I may choose the audiobook for my first experience.

Sierra Lee

Hello, great to see you back! ^-^ I've actually set things up for the narrator post already, but I'm focused on TLS first.

WaxerRed

I liked what you wrote and have to agree with you on curiosity on the absence of any chosen discussions and the disappearance of the two high priestesses on the last day. Well I mean I can guess where Hester went, I wouldn't be surprised if she knew about the demon disturbance in Ardford but Nabith? Where did she head off too? I even checked the outhouse for her.

Lamsey

I'm still checking different paths on 0.40.4, but in case you're preparing to upload a final version, the only thing I've noticed so far is that the Sierraface warning at the very start of the summit (the one about bugs and balance) is still present.

Sierra Lee

Thanks for all your thoughts! I believe I have things fixed for the public release except for the screen panning issues, which I will leave as it is. Nabith being gone is an error, so I'll give her another event page.

Sierra Lee

Thanks for checking! I'll replace that warning with a simpler one - I still can't be sure this is the final balance.

Rachnera

This may have been already answered in the myriad of (well-earned) comments, but is it on purpose that Carina's men show up on day one to say that they probably won't have any influence on political issues, but might still be of help later, then never interfere at all for the rest of the summit, including on military issues (Fucklord for example)? Note that I may simply have overlooked their testimony (a lot of people are there after all). Or I guess this could be foreshadowing for the soon-to-be war with Estaven.

Lamsey

Probably too late for the cut, but I've finished and I've got a couple more minor suggestions. I didn't find any new issues. First, 'their' makes it sounds like the Unpeople are starting a new religion here - change to 'the new succubus religion'? <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/cm8i6728bfwrdkx/Screenshot%202018-12-14%2017.32.14.png?dl=0" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.dropbox.com/s/cm8i6728bfwrdkx/Screenshot%202018-12-14%2017.32.14.png?dl=0</a> Secondly, I noticed there's minimal involvement from other non-Synod contributors in the second half of the summit compared to the first - it makes it feel like Simon and his allies are getting a disproportionate amount of airtime. I'm not suggesting any balance-altering stuff or more complicated conditional branches, but I think it'd add more flavour to get some dissent or alternate views from the sidelines, similar to the brief one-liners at the end of the public contributions in the first half. Some ideas: * Unperson vote - one of the Aramite unpeople could bemoan their lack of resources and crumbling HQ. * Tak'Kan vote - a priestess could point out that this might cause a snowball effect with Zirantia and Feroholm also requesting aid, on top of Aram and New Givini. * Purity vote - an older, prudish priestess could argue for the status quo and/or a younger Lay priestess could complain about her lack of career options. * Fucklord vote - Zirantia and/or whichever Elven nation was hit (or the Mother's Guard) could demand that more should be done, while Aram could argue it's better not to provoke the Fucklord. * High Priestess vote - Herin and Kaskia could have allies of their own making supporting statements.

Sierra Lee

Got the change in time, thanks! >Secondly, I noticed there's minimal involvement from other non-Synod contributors in the second half of the summit compared to the first Yeah, this is something that should change, and your suggestions are appreciated, but it's going to have to come in a later version.

Sierra Lee

The intention was that they show up for flavor but not have any influence at all on the summit.