Hidden downside of voluntourism — when good intentions fall short. (Patreon)
Content
Hey there, fellow travellers!
Today, in episode 1 of the tourism article series, I'd love to share some of my thoughts about voluntourism - maybe you've come across it?
As the name suggests, it's a practice that combines travel and volunteering, which has become really popular in recent years. Often, it involves a well-intentioned person from the Global North wanting to help out in some way and paying money to an organisation which gets them involved in building a school, teaching English, or helping out on some projects abroad.
According to Save the Children, voluntourism is the fastest-growing 'trend' in travel, with 1.6 million people volunteering overseas yearly, motivated by good intentions. But here's the thing: despite its good intentions, voluntourism can harm the communities we aim to help.
There are serious pitfalls within voluntourism, and here's a summary of one of the most profound ones:
In Cambodia, for example, orphanage tourism is a damaging form of voluntourism where foreign volunteers teach or spend time with orphans. It sounds caring and well-intentioned, but it's a form of aid that poses serious child protection risks and has a lifelong impact on children's psychological and emotional development.
As orphanage voluntourism has grown in popularity, the number of Cambodian orphanages has increased by more than 75% since 2005. However, over 80% of the children in these orphanages are not actually orphans but come from low-income families.
Some operators of orphanages resort to buying or leasing children from their parents by making false promises of a brighter future and better education. They do this to meet the high demand for orphans, which will attract more donations and payments from tourists who want to volunteer, thereby increasing the profitability of the orphanage.
100% of the orphanages in Cambodia are foreign-funded, and almost all are in tourist hotspots. The increase in donations from tourists, volunteers and philanthropists has caused more orphanages to open and more children to be separated from their families to fill their beds. This trauma in childhood has lifelong consequences. If demand for voluntourism dries up, so will the orphanage industry across the developing world.
Another problem within the problem is that voluntourism can cause dependency on foreign aid. By providing short-term aid, we may be hindering long-term development efforts and creating a cycle of dependence on foreign resources.
Are you familiar with the Cambodian Children's Trust?
The story of Cambodian Children's Trust (CCT), an NGO in Cambodia, is an inspiring example of how they transitioned from relying on foreign aid and operating as an orphanage to becoming a Khmer-led organisation focusing on community-run child protection.
Tara Winkler and Jedtha Pon established the trust shortly after visiting several orphanages in Cambodia. Initially, the trust rescued children from abusive orphanages and sought donor support from Australia. However, after learning the local language, the founders realised that all the rescued children had families already and orphanage care was causing harm to their development. They then concentrated efforts to reunite the children with their families and communities. The founders understood the harms of foreign-aid dependency on long-term local development. So, they focused on transitioning CCT to a family-based care approach that promotes local agency, community empowerment, and independence.
At present, the trust has a leadership team in Cambodia that is entirely composed of Khmer individuals, many of whom have gone through the lived experience of Cambodian orphanage tourism. Their approach of shifting towards local leadership has positively impacted the community, as it has helped empower them, strengthen families, and ensure the safety of children.
As in the examples I shared above, unskilled - though well-intentioned - aid can create a whole host of new, unexpected problems.
So, what can we do to address these issues and make voluntourism a sustainable, mindful practice?
First of all, approach our voluntourism work with cultural sensitivity and respect for local knowledge and expertise. That means listening to and working with the local community to understand their needs and priorities rather than imposing our foreign values and solutions.
Another great tip is prioritising long-term development goals over short-term aid. Sure, building a single school in Kenya feels rewarding, as we get to see the actual building rise within a few weeks, a symbol of our contribution. But did we really achieve much beyond that feel-good feeling if the local economy cannot fund teachers to work in that same school over the coming years?
Long-term goals include but are not limited to supporting local organisations and investing in sustainable development projects that address systemic issues rather than providing band-aid solutions. To continue with the school example: rather than building a new school, a long-term project might fund teacher training, sponsor teacher salaries for decades, and create programmes for local children to attend the school regularly.
Finally, we must be mindful of our voluntourism activities' impact on the local environment and economy by seeking programs prioritising responsible and sustainable tourism practices and knowing how our actions may affect local ecosystems and communities.
Good intentions are great, and it's wonderful to go out there and help the world - but it's important to remember that not all volunteering opportunities are created equal.
What are your thoughts on voluntourism? Can you think of examples where foreign volunteers can create a truly positive, sustainable impact on the local community?