Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Elemental Edit 2 (Patreon)

Published:
2019-07-16 20:37:56
Imported:
2026-06
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Contentious posting continues. Thank you everyone for the good itemized feedback last round. You were specific and numerous enough that I tallied those opinions and used them to guide my new version. However, that tally largely agreed with my personal willingness to apply the requested changes.

Shown here, my original on the left, the requested (demanded) edit on the right, and my compromise in the middle.

If you couldn't change/mix/match any more, which of the 3 would you want?

Files

Previews only

Comments

Paul Mabbott

Honestly I quite like the compromise version. I like your take on the toes more, but I do worry about them being so small and potentially breaking off. Please please keep up the good fight on the Bullet Bills and keeping them OUT! :D

James Bixby

Middle one is the best. retains your original vision while putting most of the needed visual identifiers there that scream "Toad" namely the belly plating

Jakob Fredensborg

The middle one works. The feet aren’t clunky, no full leg armor and no bullet missiles. It still looks like a suit of armor. It looks like something, someone would wear rather than something someone would get into. Does that make sense?

Anonymous

Middle one looks great.

Henning Boessler

As the guys have written before - the middle. Looks a good compromise and i like it. Especially without those bullet missiles.

MechaParade

I think the final design is the best except the missile warheads. They look out of place with the rest of the design.

Anonymous

Middle one, you hit the nail with your compromise.

Anonymous

Again you got another vote for the middle

Chris

I like the middle one the best.

David

Middle one, you nailed it.

Anonymous

The middle one is great, I’ll take it!

Anonymous

Compromise! So good!

Robert Schuster

Compromise is excellent. Keeps all the stuff I like from left but also brings in the chunkier legs, segmented panels, etc. I think it's a "best of both worlds" approach. Wonderful job!

Anonymous

I like the middle, but I think it would look cool with the missiles from the right... they would look good with some paint.

Anonymous

Middle one for me too

Danny

Middle option!

Anonymous

Middle is the winner.

Anonymous

The Middle one, hands down. Absolutely dead on!

Chris L

I love the middle, I'll still waffle about the missiles but overall excellent.

Anonymous

I still like the center torso on the right the best. I don't see a huge amount of difference between left and center, but maybe I'm just not observant enough!

Anonymous

I vote for the middle one. It's a good compromise.

Richard Jensen

Middle, but really I prefer the upper half on the right and legs on the middle.

Anonymous

Middle is the best looking

Anonymous

Definitely the middle!

Henning Boessler

We will get These Elementals! Jiipiiiieeee! 😁

Anonymous

Welp, elementals are in per the Kickstarter. Hope you got your drawing hand limbered up! :)

Anonymous

The middle looks the best!

Mark

I also like the middle, very much.

Damen DeLeenheer

I would also take the middle design, in my expansion and add-on boxes! Wahooooo!

wiski

I like the middle one.

BFenix

Yup, middle seems like the best of both worlds!

Anonymous

The middle is the best compromise. That being said, the design may need to be tweaked for production at 6 mm scale. Can you do 3d SLA test print?

James Doughty

I'm late to the discussion and I like the middle one but I like the chunkier feet on the third. Also chunkier feet on a plastic mini is more durable and less likely to break.

Anonymous

I like the right-most. Big missiles are important, same with the larger laser. They do the same damage as a Mech's SRM and small laser. They need to look like it. Feet and "abs" on the middle are a good compromise.

Roysan

Middle one for me

Joshua Bressel

I think the one in the middle is as close to perfect, as you're gonna get!

MacDhomnuill Games
>>24877122

SRMs weigh less than 20 lbs probably closer to 15 lbs after ammo handling system is accounted for and are similar in size to real world hydra 70 2.75 inch rockets (13 lbs and ~3 feet long) so the smaller missiles should be fine with canon. Not that Btechs misssile stats make a ton of sense.

Taylor Shead

Middle one with the left one's missile pods

Todd W

Concur= Middle. I like the original "toads" stomach thatch design and that one stays the closest.