Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks! I really don't like talking about stuff like difficulties in production, and personal life sorts of things online, but this is something that directly affects the future of OOPs, and it affects you as my patrons.

Patreon has been wanting to kill off the pay-per-post method for a while now, and came close to doing so last year, but the backlash caused them to step back on that. But it looks like they're going through with it, now. Starting in October, all Patreons that use the pay-per-post method, like mine, will be forcibly converted to a flat monthly amount. This is devastating to several types of Patreons, such as ones that put out content sporadically or big project posts every few months, and while that doesn't quite describe this Patreon's setup, it's definitely still in danger.

I chose the pay-per-post method because back when I started, I wasn't able to reliably put out the same number of pages per month, and I didn't want to charge anyone the full price if I didn't deliver on my end. Also, to keep myself from getting lazy with page releases; if I don't produce what people have paid for, I don't eat, or pay rent. And it's worked wonderfully in both regards over all these years!

And while I've developed enough discipline that I don't worry about getting lazy and getting behind on page postings, there's one major issue that makes me unsure if I can continue to do this full-time.

THE MAIN ISSUE: Instead of each tier displaying what the charge is for each page I post, it adds the expected amount up and displays that amount instead.

What's the big deal about that, right?

Because those numbers are incredibly important in the moment when someone decides to make a purchase or not. It's why something listed at $5.99 will sell incredibly better than the same product listed at $6.00. And it would change the $1 of the first tier of this Patreon to $4, and almost no comic Patreon has its first tier at anything but $1. The $3 tier will change to be listed as $12, and so on. And seeing those prices would personally make me really hesitate to sign up for a Patreon, even if i knew it was the same as "$1 for each page posted, at an average of 4 posts a month."

It's the same number, mathematically. But psychologically, it's devastating.

I've tried working out solutions like dropping the prices per page, but if I even dropped the $4 base tier to $3, that alone removes so much that I'd need to take a second job and not be able to work on the comic fulltime anymore. And that leads to a downward spiral, because a comic that doesn't update as often will get less Patreon subscribers, which means I'd have to increase the hours I work the 2nd job, which means further less comics, and less subscriptions, and so on.

But overall, I've looked at everything the Patreon support team has suggested, but none of the suggested solutions apply to this Patreon, so it looks like I'm going to have to just wait and see how bad the damage is, when the changes are forced. The last thing the support rep suggested was "reach out to your community," so here we are.

I'm not sure what that could accomplish though, unless The Community is able to stop Patreon from killing the per-post method, which is definitely not gonna happen. But regardless, I wanted to let you all know about the upcoming change before it happens next month, so that it doesn't come as a surprise.

Thanks for everything over these past years; I'll strive to continue to provide stories worth your support.

Comments

Super Shanko

Flat rate monthly fee? Pfft! Not a big deal for me. That’s how all my other subscriptions are as is. 👌😃 Edit: A flat fee is perfectly fine. Anyone used to Patreon should be used to this already, so hopefully it won’t be an issue if it comes down to this basic model.

BiasMushroom721

I'll be here one way or the other. And I dont mind waiting. Hell, i'm still a patreon of aimkid and dont see myself canceling that anytime soon (even if they hadnt suspended payments lol) I like feeling like some rich aristocrat who goes into his garden and tosses money at an artist

Rejax

Patreon really hates creators it feels like sometimes. I'll definitely upgrade how much I pay to at least match my current amount!

Christopher Cook

I’m going to be honest: I think you’re overthinking this. Your Patrons are here for a reason.

Paracosmic Productions

I may only be on the $1 tier, and I may be crazily behind on reading, but if that $1 changes to $4 I’m still here. I know it’s not much but I just wanted to say that, and I encourage anyone else in your community reading this comment that will stay subscribed in some way regardless to do so, and they seem to be doing just that. I know everything looks bleak atm, but if nothing else, your community is loyal and here for you 🫂🩵

Shiny Umbreon

5 a month for comic access is how so many artists do it. I certainly wouldn't mind seeing that here, even if I have to pay more.

Connor

For what it's worth, I'd initially been hesitant to join precisely because I'd never used the per-post rate before, and I had a lingering worry about seeing an abnormally large bill if many pages came out at once. I probably don't represent the majority, but it's completely possible there's people out there with similar reasoning. That aside, I love the work you do and want to keep supporting it. And if that means prices need to increase, I'll be sticking through for it.

Vet

To see and read good stuff it's worth the cost to me.

JRedWolf

There are a few comics I follow with a starting tier price of $5/mo. Personally, I prefer a fixed cost over a mild uncertainty anyway. I see it as I'm contributing to the artist's ability to make the thing I like, rather than a specific number of pages. With my limited budget I have to pick and choose carefully, but quality and story matter (to me, anyway - can't speak for other potential subscribers), so even if your base rate went to 5/month, I'd be fine with it (as soon as I free up that bit of the budget). I think (hope springs eternal...) that with your well established community, you will probably weather the change much better than someone just starting out, too.

Lucas

Repliers tend to be a more invested component in these things, so grain of salt, but have you considered moving? Patreon's done enough shenanigans that somebody has to have made competition. Subscribestar is the one I knew about, but a google search shows Podia, Selfy & 'Buy Me A Coffee.'

Russet

Uhhhhh, I don't brain.

ZealotDKD

Flat is better than per page. just set the minimum at 5$ and mention its because of fees

lChronosl

Enshittification is here.

Alex Krastel

A lot of people in the comments here don't seem to realize that the issue is that patreon is taking control away from you, not just that people might not want a specific schedule. They brand themselves as being Creator friendly but if they are making decisions for you on how you want to get paid then they are completely failing at that.

JIngle

Well you kind of already have a ballpark number of what people are willing to spend. Start on your extremes, make a tier covering the cost of what someone will spend when you have hit all monthly goals. Make a tier at the least amount someone has paid when you hit your minimum goals. Hypothetically 25 and 5 respectively. Then flush out the middle with say 10 and 15. Finally keep a 1,2 or 3 dollar a month one for people who just want to throw you a tip to support your work. Then it's just about spreading what each level gets to see. You could make a poll to see how many are comfortable with each level and adjust, based off of that you should get enough data to project what you'll make. Based on how things go for the first three months you can then adjust the values. Someone who is better at math and economics can probably explain it better.

Ozy Lellowen

Thats a shame that you've had to deal with that. Gonna up my pledge to make you feel better.

ComicTF

$5/month seems pretty typical to me. I think even if it's a bit more you are allowed to increase your prices to account for cost of living increases. How many years have you kept it at $1?

The Lonely Sand Person

Well, I'll still be here to support you either way. I pay because this comic should exist, not because I get X pages a month!

kurogetsui

I have several patreons that I support but sometimes dip out of when the money is tight and back into when i can afford it, yours is one of the very few that no matter what I keep going and this won't change that.

Simon Signal

Chat with other creators about how they share their content under their monthly tiers. AFAIK you never really locked anything aside from sketch votes to the higher tiers. Be sure to rethink your tier names(you may want to add more in between levels and note that for the most part it's still a tip jar. Don't be afraid of suggesting that folks can feel free to add a little more. Help keep the rats-zhings fed.

Avi Brandier

I might be wrong, but I feel like notifying your fanbase of upcoming billing changes and encouraging us not to lower or drop pledges when new tiers are rolled out should be enough to avoid significant/lasting damage to your current subscriber base. Folks who've been here should already have a good idea what you're all about, what Out-of-Placers' Patreon offers, and so on. It might be true most comics don't offer a first regular-billing tier above $1, but (and yeh, superfan saying zhis, guilty as charged) your comics aren't "most comics". You've worked hard to get here, built up major cachet using a consistent update schedule, and your storytelling and character work cultivates attachment I'd be surprised to see shaken off so easily. If Patreon's shift does end up making it tough to pay rent, it might be a good idea to create more (sustainable) ways for more dedicated members of your existing community to compensate. You might be surprised at what you find!

AnamorRabbit

I'll follow you to any platform you land on, m'man, and fine with whatever pay structure you come up with. Also, it's Apple. Apple is forcing these changes on Patreon.

Val Salia

I definitely have! Unfortunately it looks like Patreon was the last holdout when it came to having a pay-per-post model : /

Val Salia

Maaan thank you so much! I'll do all I can to make it worth it.

Val Salia

Yeahhhh, these prices were set almost a decade ago so I was probably due to overhaul the tier list; and you're right, the best way to do this is to wait for a couple months' worth of activity to develop so I can compare the pre-and-post payment methods, to figure out what to do from there.

Val Salia

Whaaat thank you so much! I'll keep on keepin' it good

Val Salia

That's what I thought! From some digging by other Patreon users who are gonna get absolutely blasted by this change, it looks like Patreon was gunning for the pay-per-post method for a while now, and was using "Apple made us, our hands are tied" as an excuse; but the reasons they're giving turned out to be pretty flimsy; specifically because this might cause issues for users using the Patreon App (on mobile iOS devices only), which somewhere around less than 4% of all Patreon subscriptions are handled.

Val Salia

True! From what I'm seeing, I'm not incredibly worried about current subscribers jumping ship when they see the prices displayed differently; it's the growth of new patrons afterwards I'm concerned about. With that said though, I -do- feel like what I'm making is something that has a bit more pull than a porn Patreon or the like, so hopefully people will feel the differently listed prices are worth it.

Val Salia

Indeed! I've been doing some calculations and it was probably past time I reshuffled the tier list anyway, after all this time.

Val Salia

It's peeps like you that keep me goin, truly

Val Salia

Ah man that's a relief to hear : D

Val Salia

I'm really hoping most people feel that way! If so, I might not have much to worry about at all. : D

Val Salia

Yeahhhh it was about 8 years ago, so cost of living has definitely shot up since then

Val Salia

Oh really! None of the ones I subscribe to or have looked at recently have anything other than a $1 first-step tier, so I was thinking it was something of an established unspoken rule. But if you've got a handful of them, hopefully a $4 base tier isn't too crazily rare.

Val Salia

That really does reassure me, seeing comments like yours. I appreciate it so much!

Val Salia

Yeahhhh any company of any sort seems to eventually succumb to carnivorous business practices when they get big enough.

Val Salia

Oh interesting! I hadn't considered that perspective.

Val Salia

Whaaat I really appreciate that! : D

Val Salia

Really! I hadn't seen any myself, so I kinda assumed it wasn't A Thing. But you're not the only one saying that, so hopefully it's not as uncommon as I thought

Val Salia

Haha; the world could use more aristocrats like you, then

Flora P-Stylianides

Frankly I'd pay almost any amount to see you keep working on your comics, I love your art and I love your storytelling

Simon Signal

Screw Apple! Weren't they the ones that other creators have had to ask patrons to avoid paying through their stores app? All cause they were scraping a percent off of those payments?

Finvaara

I'll be honest, the pay per post model is the number one reason I've ever considered leaving this Patreon. I'll be glad to see the back of it. I'm the type of person that gets easily surprised by things like that and when times were hard, that lead me to budgeting problems exactly once. If it had been twice, I'd have been gone.

Finvaara

For context, this is one medium sized chunk of about $200/month in artists of various types I patronize between here and kofi. I don't feel like a miser, but that's a lot to keep track of.

Thorin N. Tatge

If it changes for everyone, surely other comics will have bottom tiers above a dollar too, right? And it seems to me like the psychological aspect is more likely to keep more people from signing up than to incite anyone to stop patronizing you, given that we know the value we're getting. If you just keep the patrons you have, that should be enough to keep doing what you're doing, right? Aside from the effect of inflation, that is, and in time you can raise your base rate to account for that. To look at it more cynically, if your business model relies on tricking people into thinking they're only spending a dollar when they're actually spending four, that's not great, is it? So this move by Patreon, crummy though it is, could be (sort of sideways) seen as forcing you and other creators to be more honest.

Thorin N. Tatge

You need to put out 100 pages out of nowhere and then say "Hey, sorry about that $100 blitz, just for you I'll change to $4 a month so it won't happen again!"

Kagetsume

Either way I'm staying around. It's an amusing story and makes for a fun night when they come out. And if things aren't consistent in amount of stuff published in a month? Eh. You're creating something, and that's the most important thing in an age when it feels like there's an active attempt to devalue those who are creative and replace them with cheap auto generated crap. The reason Patreon is doing this is pretty simple, it makes it easier for THEM to manage their profit and loss statements, doing monthly bills means they have a consistent, predictable, ledger they get to report to their owners/shareholders. Having the pay when produced approach makes their income statements harder to predict and if it's one thing accountants hate, is unpredictable finance levels. It has nothing to do with helping creators or supporters, it's all about a cleaner balance sheet for them.

Hope Amyver

We'll< be here for you through this as well. We enjoy your work immensely.

Little_me

1$ is nice "I want to help but cannot afford much" tier, which is why it exists for most creators. I'm also on it, not because I cannot afford more but because I have tens of "I set it and forgot about it" creators. many old enough to predate EU VAT addition (and patreon adds that tax only to new/changed pledges) so.. I've been kind of evading taxes for years. (Patreon has too since collecting it is their responsibility) Also I've noticed that creator changing tiers does NOT change patreon pledge amounts, it does bump pledgers into kind of "nowhere" level even if pledge amount is high enough for higher tiers. Not sure how it works for each post things though, I lack data on that. you are worth more than 3/month though, trust me. well, at least to me. if/once you update, I'll try to remember to change it.

Lymed

I’ll be honest, I’m not a paying patron at the moment and have been kinda keeping tabs just in case I ever could be, and while it absolutely sucks that they’re getting rid of the method, and no longer keeping it as an option, it might make it easier for me to sign up. For some reason, flat fees are easier to swallow. Might not be much but, you can probably count on at least me and a few others joining up after the change to help ease the pain. I really hope the damage isn’t too steep and you’re able to keep creating comics

D

Honestly as a "customer" I really have never liked the "pay per post" model; I really prefer a fixed monthly cost and I had forgotten "pay per post" even existed until people started complaining that patreon was taking it away. Every time I see "pay per post" I just set an amount I wanna pay per month and put the per-post limit to 1. As "a person supporting your work", though, I wouldn't mind a different payment model if you feel that works best for you. But if patreon is making this go away, just saying for me as a "customer" it does feel better, just being honest. I'm raising my support a lil to try to help out; one downside of having been here so long is I never remember to raise it every so often; I usually don't remember or even think about what I set it to

ZealotDKD

having a minimum of 5 instead of 3 can be a hard sell, but if its what you need to actually get a cut it is what is. MORE IMPORTANTLY: anyone in thier right mind appreciates the same amount coming out of thier wallet every month, and the sheer fact that a patreon owner could just post several things and drain the accounts of thier users is pretty unreal to me. monthly is better.

Mr. BIG THINK

ill keep supporting regardless of changes to the payment. its all monthly subs now anyway, and your work is well worth the effort

Shyster

A flat fee is fine with me. And every other comic I support on here is at least $5 per month.

Caerdwyn

I don’t know what’s going on at Patreon but it’s not good. Between things like this, crappy redesigns of the web pages and stuffing 5 or 6 “join this creator too!” spams for each post from creators I actually support, they’re acting like some fresh-out-of-school know-nothing MBA has taken over and is filled with delusions of their own genius. Consider maybe also having a Kofi? The bulk of your support is here but if even a portion goes to Kofi and is pay per post, that might take care of the nudge-to-go aspect.

John C Butler

I don't plan on going anywhere. I also think most people who get invested in a comic about weird little stilt rat creatures is going to be fine with a flat rate. Admittedly that's only my opinion, gain of salt and all that.

BrowserCat

My impression is that your comic is pretty niche, in the good way. The higher price might deter casual comic readers looking for something new, who are maybe unsure about furry TF stuff. But for folks who LOVE that stuff, or who love the deep exploration of alien cultures, conflicting identity, and personal growth that you do so well, this comic is AMAZING. Those readers aren't going anywhere (no matter what BS Patreon pulls), they spread the word on social media to others in that niche community (which is not even that small, actually), and I hope that can keep you solvent for a long, long time. ❤️

Raan

It's difficult to see just how this will affect creators, but you can at least know that many of us will keep supporting you no matter what form patreon takes

Leasoncre

Setup new monthly tiers as you decide they need to be, and when the per-post system goes away, users have to choose the new tier they want(early preferred) or (sadly) loose access. I'd assume this would make the most sense as a consumer, rather than corporate always just shoving a new payment tier on you. most folks don't notice until their money is missing, not when they're notified of upcoming changes -Insert meme here: TAKE MY MONEY!-

Little Napoleon

I'm really sorry they're railroading you like this :( Patreon nowadays wants to cater to only specific types of creators, and crowdfunded projects like ours fit their legacy model more than the type they're aspiring to now. One thing I'll mention to consider when you make the transition: Setting up a discounted annual rate for lower tiers can work out for all parties, since the lump sum triggers fewer individual processing fees-- meaning the patron pays less *and* the creator earns more. Something to look into when you switch over!

kristian Kubar

It sucks that Patreon is removing certain payment options, but for me this won't matter as I'm already paying 90 Norwegian krones which translate to 9,45 American Dollars for each post. But I'll happily pay for a $25 tier a month cause i genuinely love the art and characters that you've created.

Val Salia

I'd thought about that angle! It's more that I wanted to post the price per page, so that if I ever got behind, I wouldn't charge people for that missed page. Like, if I listed the price as $1 per page, at an average of 4 per month, I'd feel kinda like I was ripping people off by charging a flat monthly rate even if I don't deliver on my end. Listing the price as a number easier to accept is a lot like listing an item as "Buy one get one free," when technically it's "With a bundle of two, each item is sold at 50% price." Same thing in effect, but phrasing it the first way is hugely more appealing, sales-wise.

Val Salia

Oh yeah heyyyy, I hadn't considered the "less individual payments, less micro-charges" angle, in terms of my own cut. I'll definitely look into that!

Val Salia

Patreon: NOW HOLD IT RIGHT THERE.

Val Salia

Yeahhhh I've always known that OOPs' success is mostly due to it hitting an under-represented niche! So rest assured it's never going to get "generalized" for mass audiences as the story goes on :V

Val Salia

I've been looking at other platforms to catch some people who are already signed up on em and don't want to open a Patreon account, yesh!

Val Salia

You're not the only one saying that! I really thought that $5 1st-tiers were rare cryptids : O

Val Salia

That's true, one reason Patreon's been wanting to axe the per-post model is that they haven't offered it for new signups for years, but a smallish portion of old users are still holding out

Val Salia

Oh thank you so much! To be honest the model is probably more customer-friendly, so hopefully that'll counteract the less appealing-looking new prices

Val Salia

Interesting! Hoping that the flat fee method might pull some watchers over the line, in that case

Val Salia

And I immensely enjoy you enjoying my work immensely!

Val Salia

Yeahhh, that and I think splitting payments up causes more credit card transfer fees to accrue, however small each one is

Val Salia

Oh interesting! I appreciate you making note of that way of looking at it

Evogelion

We are here fir you Val

Leasoncre

I'm holding... for???

Beefloaf

I’m going to keep throwing money at you either way.

WB101

A fixed monthly amount seems easier to budget for, but yeah, options are always a good thing. That said, I wouldn't have any issues with paying the cost of an average take out meal per month to support this creator. I jus needs to knowz how many more clammies ta mines... :)