Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Malcolm X (1992) First Time Watching! Full Movie Reaction!!

Comments

Steve Mercier

"My father used to say that: you can't make a rooster stop crowing once the sun has come up. Well, the sun is up."

Paul Cox

You guys are really good at making sure your ages remain a secret, but I'm guessing somewhere smack in the middle of millennial territory, which means you were either too young or weren't even born when the Nation of Islam had a significant and still controversial resurgence in the 90s (perhaps the name Louis Farrahkan might ring a bell?). I can say that we were barely taught about Malcolm X when I was in high school as well, but that happened to be the same time this film came out. My perception of the man has always been shaped by the way Spike told his story, and from what I've read, it's more or less accurate (with some cinematic liberties taken the same as any other biopic). I suppose the day will come when even Martin Luther King, Jr. barely receives any time in high school history classes either, and that's pretty effed up imo.

TBR Schmitt

After googling the age of a middle millennial… how dare you Just kidding lmao but we are a little younger than that and it sounds like would have been before/too early for us. Crazy how much changes in terms of what gets taught in schools over the years -Sam

Paul Cox

Ha, I just googled it myself. I didn't realize middle millennials were knocking on the door of 40 now! Yeah, y'all are younger than that for sure.

Shehab Dawoud

I was starting to worry this reaction would never drop!

Tim McKnight

That’s my Friday sorted!! 🙌🏾

Tyler Foster

My read of the movie is that while Elijah Muhammad is corrupt, I tend to feel like he is off having his own arc in tandem with Malcolm's. When Malcolm and Baines first meet in prison, Baines feels genuinely committed to me, and while the Muhammad's teachings are retrograde, he also seems a bit less "above it all" and a little more like a true believer. I've always assumed that Muhammad and Baines become increasingly corrupt as Malcolm turns them into rockstars. In any case, I do think it's important to distinguish Malcolm's faith with his specific church. The underlying teachings that Malcolm gets from Baines in jail are separate from what he does for Elijah Muhammad, which is of course why he goes to Mecca right after he sets out on his own. He's getting a purer version of what his faith was and still is now that he's away from Elijah. (The film was the first non-documentary and first American film to shoot inside of the actual Mecca, and Lee wasn't allowed to go in himself because he wasn't Muslim.) It felt like Sam came close to saying this in the outro but one part I really like is the editing in the scene where Malcolm first eats lunch with Betty and they're talking about women's role in the faith, and Lee cuts it so you can basically see Elijah puppeting the words out of Malcolm's mouth. Although I do not understand the nature of the betting numbers that Malcolm is collecting for West Indian Archie, he does bet the number 821 while they're all high, based on the time that Sophia reads for him. The implication seems to be that Archie reacts the way he does because he becomes afraid being wrong will upend his entire business. During the scene where Malcolm plays Russian roulette to maintain control of the gang, although Malcolm later says he palmed the bullet, during the scene itself, you can actually see the round in the chamber. When he first pulls the trigger, you can see it move from being one chamber away into firing position. The same thing happens again when he's pointing at the driver who tells them about the rich guy; you can see the tip of it in the one-round-away position. It took me more than one viewing to put this together, but I believe Spike is playing around with the notion that the whole audience knows he'll be assassinated. Those random gunshots that scared Dan early on and the guy screaming "get your hand outta my pocket!" are like premonitions of Malcolm's eventual assassination. The shot of a character floating through space is a Lee signature. He uses it in Inside Man as well, after Denzel has a particularly pointed epiphany or moment about what's going on inside the bank. Lee had to fight quite a bit to get his vision on screen. When they wouldn't give him the $30m+ he felt he needed, he took Francis Ford Coppola's advice to "get the movie pregnant": make enough of it so that the studio has to acquiesce and up the budget. Lee ended up kicking in $2m of his own $3m directing fee. By the time the film reached the editing stage, a bond company had taken over, and there was an attempt to insist that the movie not run longer than 2 hours and 15 minutes. It was only after the intervention of several prominent Black celebrities (Oprah, Michael Jordan, Janet Jackson, Prince) that Lee was allowed to finish the movie as he intended. I think the film is kind of a miracle. It covers so much ground so effortlessly. 25 minutes after we last see Malcolm, the young wannabe gangster, it's almost hard to believe that version of him existed in the same movie as the new Malcolm. The sequence leading up to his assassination, set to Sam Cooke's "A Change is Gonna Come," is transcendent. It is not on the level of Malcolm X, but for a fun secondary story about Malcolm X, which also features that beautiful Sam Cooke song, check out Regina King's directorial debut One Night in Miami... (2020), adapted by Kemp Powers from his stage play. It is about a fictionalized night in which Malcolm X, professional football player-turned-actor Jim Brown, Sam Cooke, and Muhammad Ali spend a night together following Ali's defeat of Sonny Liston. A charming movie, and very entertaining.

Extraordinary Productions

The assassination of Malcolm X actually happened in real life! The movie did a great portrayal of how it happened. Also since you guys are having conspiracy theories, the bodyguard who shot one of the shooters and was giving Malcolm mouth to mouth was an undercover cop for the NYPD!! And told them who were the shooters and buried the evidence even when the shooter who got shot admitted to the whole thing and had a written confession. The police actually arrested two Muslims who had nothing to do with the assassination. It’s a whole documentary on Netflix about this that explains the whole story more than the movie. It’s called “Who shot Malcolm X?” I think you guys would have a better understanding of this Malcolm X. Because in our black community he always be a cultural icon.

Shehab Dawoud

I do love this film, but I also have critiques. I thought the film could've done a better job of distributing the time for the 3 periods of Malcolm's life. I felt that too much time was spent on his life pre-prison compared to his life after leaving the Nation of Islam. Of course, he only lived a little over a year after leaving the NOI, so it makes sense. But I felt like they could've put in a few more scenes of Malcolm and his message after coming back from Mecca, as that is the final message he preached. But to fit a whole man's life into a movie that's just over 3 hours is difficult, and I felt like Spike Lee did a damn good job. I would say 90% of it is accurate, as it is based on Malcolm's autobiography. It's probably the book I've read the most and I recommend everyone to read it. The story of Malcolm's life is the story of change and transformation and the film portrayed that as well as it could. Some things that weren't accurate: Shorty was not a real person. Baines was not a real person. Baines was supposed to represent some version of a man named Louis Farrakhan, a NOI member who for certain played a part in the assassination. He didn't want to be portrayed in this film, so they took him out and created the Baines character. Malcolm also didn't learn about the NOI from anyone in prison, but from his siblings who wrote letters to him while he was in prison. But you can expect some creative liberties. While some of Malcom's preachings on behalf of Elijah Muhammad were horrible and racist, they did serve one purpose: It helped change the mentality of black people at the time. It gave them the bravery to stand up for themselves, and Malcolm led by example. I mean, for him to do what he did at that police station... that requires balls of steel, even today, so imagine back then for a black man. So, if it wasn't for the NOI, we most likely would've never had Malcolm X. He might've got out of prison and continued as Red the criminal. So, it's like most things, the good comes with the bad. And the FBI absolutely played a part in his assasination, whether they were active participants or not. They had him under surveillance ever since that night at the police station. They knew he was marked for death and did nothing to stop it. They didn't want a unifying figure. To answer 2 of your questions: Why did the NOI still want Malcolm dead afterwards? Because he knew about Elijah's indiscretions and were afraid he'd go public with them and that a lot of the followers would leave the NOI and follow Malcolm. Those things did end up happening. What did the FBI mean when they said: "Compared to King, this guy is a monk"? Well, MLK, as great as he was, did have one flaw. He was a known philanderer, unfortunately... As great as Denzel is in this, there is nothing like listening to the real Malcolm X speak. The intelligence, the eloquence, the confidence, and the conviction. So I was happy to hear that you wanted to listen to his speeches. Whether it was as a criminal, under the orders of Elijah Muhammad, or as his own man towards the end, he was not afraid of dying. He knew he was going at the end, but still went out there to preach his message. I can't think of many people more brave in history than Malcolm X. After this, I would recommend the film Ali (2001) by Michael Mann. It is about Muhammad Ali and his story is closely connected to Malcolm X who also appears in the film. As for other Spike Lee joints: Jungle Fever, Het Got Game, and 25th Hour is at the top of my list. But most of his films are worh watching.

Shehab Dawoud

I thought Kingsley Ben-Adir did a better job of portraying Malcolm when it came to the voice, accent, cadence, speech pattern and mannerisms. There is actually no comparison between him and Denzel in that aspect. But Denzel did have a clear edge when it came to showing Malcolm's charisma and fire, which Kingsley did not have a chance to do. Both great, but different performances. Unfortunately, I think most people have not even heard of One Night in Miami.

sb

The running of numbers was started in black communities, specifically Harlem, Chicago and Detroit, involving betting on the last 3 digits of verifiable systems like the daily bank clearinghouse. This underground system was a means of survival for the oppressed and the direct blueprint for the American lottery today being that the government launched their own legal system to capture billions of untaxed revenue that was generated for decades by black communities and used these funds to build businesses including banks and hospitals that were eventually subject to destruction by oppressive forces that were allowed to do so with complete impunity.

Shehab Dawoud

I also find it fascinating how so many people living in America know very little about Malcolm X, yet people from other continents, such as myself, have learned about him in school and outside, since we were kids. I guess in some parts of America he is taught more than others, but from what I've heard from some people, they haven't learned anything about him in school. That is a big surprise because you can't talk about the civil rights movement without talking about him.

Norman

I'm not a fan of the Rodney King beating opening. It kind of puts you in 1991. Malcolm X was released 6 months after the LA Riots over the Rodney King verdicts, by the way. The colorfulness of Spike Lee's films is due to cinematographer Ernest Dickerson, Spike Lee's Tisch School of the Arts classmates, who shot his films up to Malcolm X. Michael Imperioli (Christopher from The Sopranos) has appeared in 6 Spike Lee films and he co-wrote and appeared in Lee's 1999 film Summer of Sam, which was filmed before The Sopranos was released.

Tyler Foster

Oh, one other thing I was going to point out: When it's revealed for certain that Malcolm is being recorded by some sort of agents, with the slow pan across the wall full of photos over to two guys at a tape machine listening, the guy that cracks that joke that Malcolm lives like a monk compared to Martin Luther King Jr. is Lone Star writer/director John Sayles.

Tim McKnight

RE: “Compared to MLK this guys a saint” was based on the idea that it later came out MLK was cheating on his wife. Pretty sure there’s FBI materials proving this (don’t quote me on that). Meanwhile, the dude at the end who was doing the voice over talking about Malcolm, that was actually Malcolm’s eulogy. The dude reading it was the guy who played Demayer in “Do the right thing” (Ossie Davis) AND he did the ACTUAL eulogy at Malcolm X’s funeral.

Tim McKnight

Shorty was a real person and if he wasn’t, then there’s some blatant lies in Malcolm X’s autobiography (which I doubt). Shorty’s real name was Malcolm Jarvis. Pretty sure Baines was real too. I agree that Farrakhan most likely had something to do with Malcolm’s assassination though.

Shehab Dawoud

From everything I remember reading, Shorty was a composite character, based on a different people in Malcolm's life. The same thing with Baines, with Farrakhan being the biggest inspiration. But Malcolm did not learn about the NOI by someone approaching him in the prison shower.

Tim McKnight

Ahhh! So (quick verification/research) Shorty WAS real, brother baines was the composite character… it was letters from his brother that let him know about the nation. I absolutely need to read the autobiography again though! I seem to have forgotten a bunch! 🫣 Salaam bro. 🙏🏾

Jason Dolan

I’m excited to do this one with you guys!

Backlog Andy M.

I remember him. And the parody they did on In Living Color. Star Trek The Wrath Of Farrahkan 😅

Backlog Andy M.

Denzel wrote his name on the academy award that year. But nah he didnt get it!