Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Holiday Film Poll!

  • A Christmas Carol (1951) 48
  • The Family Man (2000) 63
  • The Holiday (2006)* 35
  • Love Actually (2003) 91
  • Miracle on 34th St (1994)* 19
  • The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993)* 89
  • The Polar Express (2004)* 26
  • The Ref (1994) 49
  • The Shop Around the Corner (1940) 39
  • Silent Night (2002) 9
  • 2026-11-11
  • —2026-11-21
  • 468 votes
{'title': 'Holiday Film Poll! ', 'choices': [{'text': 'A Christmas Carol (1951)', 'votes': 48}, {'text': 'The Family Man (2000)', 'votes': 63}, {'text': 'The Holiday (2006)*', 'votes': 35}, {'text': 'Love Actually (2003)', 'votes': 91}, {'text': 'Miracle on 34th St (1994)*', 'votes': 19}, {'text': 'The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993)*', 'votes': 89}, {'text': 'The Polar Express (2004)*', 'votes': 26}, {'text': 'The Ref (1994)', 'votes': 49}, {'text': 'The Shop Around the Corner (1940)', 'votes': 39}, {'text': 'Silent Night (2002)', 'votes': 9}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 21, 5, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 11, 23, 22, 54, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 468}

Content

Help us pick the film we will react to!

NOTE: Sam has seen Miracle on 34th Street, TNBC, TPE, The Holiday, so these would only be Daniel's first time watching.

Please feel free to suggest other options in the comments for future polls!

Comments

Roy Wright

My wife made me vote for Love Actually

Santiago Hardy

Not listed: "The Family Stone"(2005) It's such an underrated/forgotten lost gem of a Holiday/Christmas movie. I hope you consider it. It's so GOOD.

OddThomas

The Family Stone, Happiest Season

Backlog Andy M.

Love actually. Its become a xmas tradition in the UK. And one scene reminds me of being on a pub crawl in boston. With some very nice american ladies. My accent. 😉😁

Paul Cox

I mentioned this one when you reacted to Double Indemnity, but MacMurray and Stanwyck starred together in a film four years prior named Remember The Night that is a completely different spin on their chemistry and a genuinely lovely Christmas movie.

Dan Holmes

You should watch the Patrick Stewart Christmas Carol! ♥️ Also pls rewatch Die Hard 1&3 when you’re done with LotR 😂

Matt

The Family Man sooooo good

aarswft

If Love Actually wins, I hope everyone who voted for it uses this an opportunity to analyze how problematic the movie is.

Mario

Here's hoping it wins.

Tyler Foster

My allegiances lie with The Shop Around the Corner and The Holiday, but I am willing to vote for The Nightmare Before Christmas (a fine movie I simply don't have that much passion for) in order to defeat the evil that is Love Actually. In a just and fair world, About a Boy (2002) would be the UK holiday rom-com featuring a star-studded ensemble of both adults and children led by Hugh Grant, featuring a pivotal scene at a school stage performance.

Jon

Not listed: Just Friends (2005)

Tyler Foster

My guess is that The Family Stone will have more momentum on holiday reactor polls next year when the sequel they've just started filming comes out.

Duncan

💗

Wormtongue

No The Muppet Xmas Carol 😭

Tyler Foster

Also...are we confusing Silent Night (2002) with some other Silent Night? Perhaps John Woo's Silent Night (2023)? Just seems like an oddly obscure pick...but I haven't seen it! Maybe it's good. Also, speaking of John Woo, I'm still hoping the lost-by-one-vote Face/Off (1997) is still in the cards somewhere.

Santiago Hardy

Omg!😳🥰 I had no idea a sequel was in development! Thank you for that information.🙏

Jason Mangen

Classic; Santa Claus is coming to town, Frosty the Snowman, Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer

Smooticus

For future consideration - the Lion in Winter (1968) with Katherine Hepburn and Peter O'Tool. Excellent movie and the original dysfunctional family Christmas movie

jjkcharlie

What about The Muppets Christmas Carol? Or, if possible, Mickey's Christmas Carol. Of course there is George C. Scott's version, and Albert Finney's too.

Birdie Num Num

The Silent Partner (1978), Christmas Holiday (1944) with Gene Kelly - its a fairly bleak noir, maybe the most most misleading title ever, It Happened on 5th Avenue (1947), Remember the Night (I recommend this every year)

Birdie Num Num

Holiday Affair - great Xmas movie with Robert Mitchum and Janet Leigh

Mike the Ginger

The Ref (1994) and The Family Man (2000)

PIG

lol

Brownie Win

I think you would love The Holiday, it is an excellent RomCom.

Roy Wright

Watched that today great one

Santiago Hardy

Nice! Glad to know you appreciate it. I'm long overdue for a re-watch.

Eric

I just rewatched Nightmare Before Christmas for the first time in like 25 years (the kids that were fans of it in HS went so overboard it pushed me away), and it’s kinda incredible still. The art direction is so good. Virtually every frame can be saved as a PC wallpaper.

Jason Dolan

I only want THE FAMILY MAN to win

penoyer79

If you aren't voting for The Ref then you've never seen The Ref.

Vincent Hollow

If they haven't seen it prior to the channel, I would love for them to see the Muppets Christmas Carol

Vincent Hollow

I've never seen it, but Ive also never heard Love, Actually referred to in that way. Not that I had any interest in it, but this is new to me.

Bob Bittner

It really is a highly enjoyable movie. We watch it every year.

Bob Bittner

We love a lot of Christmas movies—particularly “The Family Man” on this list— but I voted for “Love Actually,” since it’s such a warm-hearted hug…with some truly surprising storylines (especially for American audiences…who probably don’t expect a Christmas movie to come with an R rating!). And it’s laugh-out-loud funny as well.

Tyler Foster

I'm mostly just not a fan of Richard Curtis. Among the films he directed, I can tolerate Four Weddings and a Funeral, but I do not like Love Actually or About Time, both of which just have a weird retrograde sexism running through them, IMO.

Bob Bittner

Would you like that gift wrapped? With or without the lavender…?

Bob Bittner

I do enjoy “It Happened on 5th Avenue,” but I put it in a second tier of holiday movies, where “Christmas in Connecticut,” “Holiday Affair,” and “Remember the Night” live.

Bob Bittner

Just rewatched it last night…and I still love it.

Bob Bittner

For me, this is a pleasant but second-tier holiday movie. I think the focus on drama and the (for me) annoying way Gordon Gebert plays “Timmy” lessen its appeal.

Backlog Andy M.

They were a gift. As in my line. Hey ladies this is my last night in boston. Can i buy you a drink. They all looked at one another and they said no. 😬 then one of them said. No we want to buy you a drink 😃 i was in. 😉

Max Rinaldi

"Polar Express" is going to bring some discussion about uncanny valley.

Shehab Dawoud

Bad Santa (2003) Better Watch Out (2016) Nosferatu (2024) Three different kinds of Christmas movies. Not your typical kinds, but nevertheless. For Thanksgiving I would love a reaction to... Thanksgiving (2023)

fire12wife

Most people don't know that Miracle on 34th Street (1994) is a John Hughes movie! It's actually a great film that stars the little girl from Matilda! I urge everyone to give it a chance. I love the original, too, but this version is great as well!!!

fire12wife

Jean Smart is playing Kelly Stone's new girlfriend!

Brandon Meng

I will be so geeked out if you guys do Love Actually.

James

Family man and the shop around the corner the two best on here

Mario

So much for hope lol.

Richard Maurer

What, no Krampus? No Violent Night? What kind of Christmas poll is this?

TBR Schmitt

We’ve done both of those already lol -Sam

Richard Maurer

lol, after I posted this I literally had the thought “I wonder if they did those already” and was looking at your watch list when I got the notification of your reply. Well that gives me something to watch next month!

Richard Maurer

Next time I’ll check before I write a comment.

TBR Schmitt

You guys are cracking me up with these TIES!!!!! -Sam

Vincent Hollow

Gotta admit, it's a pretty clever way to get two movies for the price of one 😂😂😂