Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Let's talk about the confidence mechanic

  • I dislike the current confidence mechanic 189
  • I am indifferent 214
  • I like how confidence is right now 129
  • 2023-02-01
  • 532 votes
{'title': "Let's talk about the confidence mechanic", 'choices': [{'text': 'I dislike the current confidence mechanic', 'votes': 189}, {'text': 'I am indifferent', 'votes': 214}, {'text': 'I like how confidence is right now', 'votes': 129}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 2, 1, 16, 50, 29, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 532}

Content

Since the first release of The Fixer, the most common complaint about it has in some way to do with the confidence mechanic. This post is about gathering peoples thoughts, presenting an idea I have and generally to start a conversation on the subject to hear as much as I can before doing anything about it.

The purpose of this mechanic of to add a small sense of progression to the game so that Sammy doesn't start a new game and is whoring from day one. Other smaller aspects are to add a sense of realism to the game, some sense of character to Sammy and a bit of gameplay stat balancing. It is also meant to act as a bit of a punishment if Sammy is too bold or crazy and suffers consequences, then she is less likely for a while to repeat her crazy behaviour.

At first I thought these complaints would let up as I balanced things a bit better, but they have not. And if anything, have gotten worse since I added stat numbers to the main top ribbon. So it has become quite clear that a large portion of players do not like this feature, and even if balanced and tweaked, it would still be fairly unpopular.

The main complaint about it seems to be two fold:

1, It blocks players from the porn. Being that this is a porn game, blocking players from viewing said porn is obviously not good.

2, It takes control away from the player. Players want to guide Sammy in their own direction and are fairly hostile towards the idea of game mechanics making choices for them.

I have thought about quite a few different solutions to this topic, but so many of them end up as a different flavour of the same problem. It blocks access to porn or takes control away. With that in mind, the only workable solution I can come up with that solves the issue without introducing new ones is to basically nerf the confidence mechanic into oblivion...

My thoughts are to keep confidence as it is, but only to change dialogue or Sammy's thoughts. Regardless of a passing or failing will roll, you will still get the chance to push through it and pick the option you want anyway. Possibly at the cost of some mood. So, a small example below.

A low confidence Sammy is invited to an orgy. This is way too extreme for her and in the current design she will auto refuse and end the chain. With the proposed idea there will be some internal dialogue asking herself why she would agree to such a thing and how stupid an idea it is, but the choice will display anyway and allow the player to make her say yes (possibly costing mood). Upon saying yes, Sammy will grumble and ask herself why in the world she agreed, but will go anyway. Of course a slutty Sammy will pass the check and happily agree to the orgy.

Other solutions thought of and rejected:

Nerf a bit. Or somewhere in the middle of the above proposal and it's current implementation. Issue with this idea is it still keeps the problems of the current implementation while also losing the pacing/progression. So ends up worse than just keeping it as is.

Confidence as a currency. This will lose the pacing while also introducing some wacky behaviour where Sammy agrees to an orgy because she had the willpower cost, but then later can't muster the will to have a beer with a pub patron.

Corruption/experience mechanic. This was something I was favouring for a while. It would be something you build over time and it doesn't drop. It would still allow progression in the early game while not hampering players later game. It was mostly rejected because it would effectively eliminate meek/broken/unconfident playstyles.

Comments

bigEZH

The biggest issue with the mechanic is how hidden what adds and subtracts confidence. Like with fitness, going to the gym etc. Affects it positively and not doing it takes away. With confidence, other than getting bullied, it's largely mysterious. I'm in support of it as a mechanic but the player has to know how to gain or lose confidence. Otherwise we feel the lack of control more strongly

Frigid Fox

I like the confidence as a currency idea.

Elder God's Minion

I like the idea of confidence, as it fits in very well with the whole story of the game. But in the current system, it just feels like there really isn't any progression to the confidence stat. Just asa general spitball, I think the whole thing would feel better if there are clearer mechanics on how this stat is raised and lowered, so that we as the players can make better decisions on how we want to guide Sammy's story and how her confidence plays into that.

Des InviS

To be honest, I chose "I dislike the current confidence mechanic", but it is not quite right. I kinda like it, but I really don't understand the way it works. Like there are many ways for losing the confidence, and I understand them and I am sympathetic with them. I mean, losing self-esteem after being groped or bullied seems like a fair choice. It adds the immersion and that I approve. But what annoys me is the fact that I hardly know how to boost it. It does not really come naturally (although it may come as a result of my own lack of understanding of the mechanics). Once I tried to act pretty social, i.e. talk with people, drink beer in the pub and be rather open-minded and that sorta worked for some time, but the confidence stat pretty soon plummeted or something and I could not restore it to the decend level again. I get it that you cannot turn from a super shy geek into the most people-person in the world overnight or even over a week, but still. All in all, I am personally a fan of explaining the mechanics of confidence a bit more clearly while adding more options for boosting it, e.g. hanging out with npcs in school or any other place, socialising in the pub or even the bus station or really anywhere it would make sense to. It would require from players to actually live in the world, interact with it and to get to know it better thus increasing the confidence (kinda like real life). Or so I reckon. The mood additionally affecting confidence to a certain degree is not a bad idea either. Same I struggle with the "excitement" mechanic, but that is for another time.

Zodiarch

Little introduction: I came for the porn and stayed for... well, everything else. So absolutely yes, I like this mechanic. The fixer itself reminds me a lot of Degrees of Lewdity, which imo is a masterpiece. In DOL it was exactly the same thought process.... you came for the porn and stayed for the story, characters, game mechanics, etc. Although I agree that the way it works now is a bit frustrating. -For example: I spent an hour grinding on confidence, not knowing what events to look for. Finally got it to "confident", slept in the game and boom... it drops back to the level before.- The basic concept of confidence is necessary to give The Fixer what makes it unique, I think. But it should be more accessible. My idea would go one step further; let me explain: First: I would have the confidence rise gradually each day, e.g. just living in this harsh world without getting hit by a bus or shot, and the sight of friendly faces here and there is enough to make it rise (like growing up in the real world) Maybe 0.5 each time you sleep. Second: events are modifiers that pile up throughout the day.... Being groped -0.25, going for a jog in the park +0.25, meeting friends +2 being harassed on the bus -3 and so on and so forth. Maybe big events modifiers like "all good events are multiplied by 1.5 because you make your first kiss with a person you like a lot, and vice versa for big bad events. This would reinforce the idea that a day can have good and bad situations that you process while you sleep. Third: add little prompts like in Crusader Kings 3 for events that indicate what might rise and fall.... "Running in the park"; that might help relieve your stress; that might lift your mood; running helps you stay fit; has a chance to let you feel the new world around you and getting comfortable with it; but watch out, even here it's possible to experience some of the harsh world you live in. I hope you understand what I mean. I really love this game and wish you only the best!

Squideater McGruff

Hot take from somebody who also makes games: Players only -think- they know what they want when it comes to balancing and limiting factors. A gradual but steady progression helps contribute to a game's "addictive" factor and keeps them playing, whereas if every possible option is available from minute one -- a player says "whoa, sounds great!" -- but then they'll be bored with the whole thing in an hour. In conclusion I say sure, listen to and consider the criticism, because maybe things do need tweaking, but ultimately you should follow your own instincts.

Dirk

Well, I would say that the current confidence system could be better, I like the idea of having the confidence mechanics mixed with an corruption stat, where the corruption builds over time and can't drop, and the confidence alters the possible random events like with the bully's in school etc. Those are just my thoughts

Iji

While I voted "I like ..", the availability of the debug / cheat menu skewed my perception. If I remember correctly, confidence was the stat I had to cheat the least, if at all. But I am ok with a "corruption" solution or "confidence light", where options get recommend based on your confidence but not blocked by it. Adding the fluffy inner monologue about why Sammy would even do this, it would be my preferred compromise.

Ex Caseus Fortis

I wish the confidence system was more transparent. My happy, smart, fit character is always losing confidence for apparently no reason. What is so terrifying as to lose confidence when you are walking from your bedroom to your dining room? Ironically, the only thing that reliably raised my characters confidence was to offer oral whenever possible and refuse to go any further.

LynxJune

The general concept of confidence is good, in my opinion. So that, as you said, you gotta put some work in to get Sammy where you want her. But I do find myself adjusting my confidence up and down quite often, to get Sammy to react to certain events the way I like. For example, be confident enough to be slutty with the soccer boys, but still unable to oppose the bullies. So maybe the best way would not be to give the player all the options right away, even with the monolog and mood hit. But rather make it, that you kind of have a range of confidence, in which you can choose either the higher or lower confidence option. Also, I don't really like the rolling mechanic, as I find myself reloading to make it go the way I want 😅

Kawn

I agree with the idea of confidence as it is, but like others I find it difficult at times because as players there isn't much info on how to raise your confidence. I kind of like the idea of leaving it to player choice with a possible mood drop. One idea I had while reading the email that I think could solve some issues is perhaps allowing players to choose a few perks at the beginning that unlock certain things. After all Sammy is technically 30ish? Or at least an adult so it seems logical that they may have kinks or fetishes before they ended up in a young nubile body. Perhaps Sammy was into exhibition, group sex, lesbian, Bdsm, bully kink, Etc. I think the main problem is the game is treating Sammy like an innocent girl just entering high school instead of an adult, who already knows a few things.

Stephen

Maybe it’s because I’m one of those players who has no problem cheating like a bandit, but I don’t really have a problem with confidence as it is.

Völundr's Forge & Metalworks

I don't have an issue with the confidence system, but what I do have issue with is how janky it seems to raise. A better way is to have it something that can be improved much like the rest of the stats, or at least a better explination and guide on the improvement. Some actions I take one time seem to raise it and the next it seems to tank it and it really doesn't seem to have rhyme or reason to it.

Chuc Smith

Having a choice is a nice idea. Letting the player choose it go or not at any level. Someone will low confidence could gain it by going. Fake it till you make it, does work a little with getting more confident

J3J

In my experience, I couldn't figure out how to raise it without the gamine origin perk. It seemed impossible with every other interaction lowering it so it felt like one step forward, two steps back. Maybe make it more clear how the mechanic works in-game and offer a way to raise it consistently?

Norfe

As most people said, the confidence mechanic is a good one. Of course, many people will say that it blocks progression and in some ways, it does. But that's the whole logic of it. However, I do think balance would be good. I really liked Des InviS and Zodiarch's comment. It is a bit hard to manage right now and could be explained a bit better. It makes for diverse runs and really adds to the replayability of the game. I think making it raise everyday instead of losing some could help. In the game's universe, I feel like it would however be harder to stay pure, especially when you consider the whole culture around the gamines. Maybe the passives could eventually help balance this out. Like getting a "cocky" passive that helps you stay confident over time. Maybe some specific passives like "Likes being groped" or more passives toward exhibitionnism that would be rewarded if you always put yourself in the same situation time after time. Not sure how people would like this other idea to use a system like disco elysium to simply hide things you're not conspicious enough to do maybe? In the end, I think the confidence mechanic was well thought and that you should trust your instinct but I thank you for your consideration. I think it's a great mechanic but it might just need a bit more love before it can shine completely :) Take care and don't worry, i'm sure all will agree when I say we always enjoy your game and are thankful for your efforts! :D

ChocolaSan

I think for those who want to get right to the action maybe a sort of "easy mode" would be a good addition, essentially just start with an already corrupted/confident sammy and she'll agree to anything. Then you could balance the confidence mechanic for those who actually want the gameplay, without ruining the game portion of the game to appease those who just want to see a slideshow of porn, essentially.

GrunchGames

I think the mechanics is good the way it is. If necessary, there is the cheat menu.

Kevin Anstee

I voted don't like, but for the way it works now. In the past it seemed to work differently (I had more control on raisnling the stat), and therefore I would have voted yes. I would not vote indifferent, as I like the idea of confidence, but it drives me crazy. As others have implied, raising confidence can at times feel like a grind, especially as it falls so easily. Trying to understand how it works, or fits with Sammy's character is the main cause of confusion. For example, Sammy has the whore perk but she will lose confidence being a whore? Sammy loses confidence on the bus seemingly all the time, implying that she never enjoys the attention she receives. Her flatmate questions Sammy about the bus giving the impression she hates it, but we learn she likes the groping. This implies a confusion in confidence. For me the current confidence mechanic is attempting to do too much, a jack of all trades if you will. Splitting the current implementation into two stats may be the answer. One stat for 'Confidence' and another for 'Attention'. Each mechanic could have weightings applied using the perk system. We could therefore see combinations where Sammy could like attention on the bus, but is not confident catching the bus. Sammy is confident dancing but dislikes the attention it brings. Sammy is confident being out late at night, but is concerned about attracting attention. A Sammy with high confidence and attention stats would actively seek/enjoy a late night out for the sense of danger. Its late here, so coherency may be a bit wild, but I hope I managed to convey my ideas.

killverin

If there is a change, which I'm not in favor of exactly, I really hope it doesn't eliminate meek/broken/unconfident playstyles. That would suck so much.

Kromar

I like your idea of corruption. The part that I don't like about the confidence as it is, is the fact that you lose some for small things like having an npc hit on you, even if you're playing a whore

Jay Emerson

Maybe I am misunderstanding but it seems like confidence & corruption are 2 sides of the same coin? Is there a distinction between them that I don't get? BTW I voted indifferent because I have confidence that no matter how you work this out, the game will still be great. Maybe this is a crazy idea but, would it be possible to satisfy both play styles by allowing the player to configure a personality setting or 2 on the starting screens? Perhaps that appears like an RPG mechanic but it could take the form of a simple Difficulty setting. (Easy = slutty Sammy = Start with extra confidence or corruption?)

Steve Sombdy

My problem with confidence, and with all the stats, is that they seem to constantly drop way to fast. The intelligence and fitness stat at least have a way to farm, but again they drop constantly so they're hard to maintain. I chose the 'academic' background, which ends up peaking the fitness in 40's even if I work out half of each day. Confidence especially seems to get into a death spiral, where less confidence makes it harder to gain confidence and easier to lose it. What I would like to see: 1. What clothing level Sammy is comfortable wearing for a given confidence. Dressing slutty should give a confidence penalty if she's not ready for it, and a bonus if she's dressing appropriately for her confidence. In fact tying how she dresses to how confidence is raised feels like a fun mechanic - giving Sammy confidence experience for slightly pushing the boundaries of what she's comfortable with. 2. A simpler mechanic for raising stats would be nice. Practice once every other day to maintain the current level, 1/day to gradually increase, 2/day to more quickly increase, but no returns after that. Double the effects for the focused stat, halve it for the weak stat (must practice 1/day to maintain, 2/day for slow increase). 3. The effects of negative modifiers from bad events should be mostly temporary, resetting after a night's sleep. Regardless, I love your game. I really enjoyed playing through what you have so far, I just felt like the stat system wasn't quite fleshed out yet.

Mena R.

I don't know if this would be feasible or not. But maybe tweak it a bit. Like maybe "Confidence check failed, proceed anyway? Y/N". It just got kind of annoying when I could have enough confidence to copulate with strangers in the bar, but not having enough confidence to sell one's underwear. So maybe something that would give a bit more control to the player. Don't know how much more work that would be for you. But it's just my 2 cents worth.

finder

I like the confidence machanics as it is. It's make Sammy look like she has her own mind and not a mindless doll.

Jeno

For me, progression and corruption are absolutely key mechanics. You have got to have some process to get to the stuff. Maybe you could put in a cheat or something, to disable Will checks? Getting through everything super quickly ruins the flow of the game for me, so I hope you don't just get rid of confidence altogether

Soul

i like the idea of keeping it as is, but changing the dialog and giving the choice to the player anyway,

Mortalis

I‘m a fan of progression but not too happy with the confidence system because it was hard to figure out how to affect it. So I would prefer a corruption system, affected by experience and temporary effects like alcohol. I would even raise the bar for some of the clothes, like in the beginning wearing a skirt only to school because it is mandatory.

JustAnOldDude

I like the 'idea' of the confidence checks. I personally am okay with some things happening (or not) because of low confidence, but blocking the porn part is problematic. I think confidence should guide Sammy in the 'right direction' somehow. In my mind, I have always viewed confidence as shyness. Sammy is too shy to wear or try something, or she is too scared to try it. Over time, she learns to adapt. At low confidence, Sammy is not going to want to wear micro-bikinis, thongs, and short skirts (maybe no strapless pieces?), and she may have issues doing other things involving sex, flirting, etc. Drugs and alcohol could help her overcome that, but maybe with a chance of addiction (that maybe can get worse over time?). This could potentially be expanded on with 'bad endings' later, depending on how the story goes. Maybe make it optional? If the player wants it fine, if not, disable confidence checks completely.

Darkon Turas

The only real issue I had with confidence is that it can be nuked by a random event. When she gains the confidence to dress a certain way, it shouldn't get suddenly reversed by the stat suddenly tanking. There should be a hidden sub-stat that acts like a permanent tier level for her wardrobe choices. Once you get so high enough to dress like this, then the clothing choice should always be available despite the stat tanking.

Xcritu (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-06 04:00 Confidence should be both a currency and a stat. Your "max confidence" increases like leveling up and the "max" confidence is used for certain rolls, meanwhile, you have runtime confidence points which fluctuate depending on things. For example, Sammy's confidence level is 50. And she has no confidence penalties, so her runtime confidence is 1 to 1 and so she has 50 confidence points. So on a certain day, she has 50/50 confidence points. For sex scenes and clothes and whatnot, she uses the confidence level 50. But there will be situations where she would use confidence points. These situations would be situations where there could be negative consequences. So if she succeeds in the confidence check then all is good, if she fails then the confidence points decrease. Different actions will have different confidence point costs. Maybe she tries to hook up with a bar patron but she is rejected. The cost was 5 confidence points, then she only has 45 points left. So after getting rejected 10 times she would not have any confidence left to try anything new. Shy characters would have a penalty for the confidence points. Maybe the ratio is 1 to 0.5, so if the confidence level is 50 then the confidence points are 25. This allows for greater control over the risk you want to take with confidence events. In addition, the loss of confidence points ONLY happens when Sammy is the one taking action. If she is asked to do something and fails a confidence throw she losses no confidence points.
2023-02-02 19:15

Rhin Forti

My beef with the confidence mechanic is that it is way unbalanced. First, it is too difficult to build or maintain. Second, it is far too easy to lose. Without cheating, penalties she receives to confidence far outweigh any gains she receives because only 2 or 3 things raise her confidence 1 point at a time while multiple things can happen to her throughout EVERY day, EVERYwhere she goes and each happen multiple times per day with each taking away 2 or 3 points on average. It is extremely easy to have a broken Sammy and extremely difficult to have a confident Sammy that can be a whore. There have been many days where the only thing that happened to Sammy in my playthrough is that she wakes up, goes to school, plays soccer, and by the time school ends she has lost 4 points on confidence but has high stats in everything else. Currently, the only thing in game that gives a solid increase to her confidence is to be absolutely wasted, which gives penalties in other things and tanks other stats after she recovers. I think a good fix for confidence should be a rework to have some things that currently affect confidence (getting bumped into, felt up against your will, etc) should affect mood instead of confidence and have more successes be a positive boost for Sammy (Someone compliments her physique, guys hire her for sex and cooperate with her during the event while she is a wh ore, she lost her virginity to someone she chose and wasn't forced into it, etc). Gamine and some other traits need to affect this as well. If Sammy "knows the way the world works and is unaffected by it" then she should not take hits to confidence by getting a guy rubbing himself on her in the bus. Also, the idea you put forward is good as well about doing a confidence check and if she didn't have the confidence, let the player choose whether to do it or not. If the player chooses to do it but with low confidence, it affects mood.

Stephen

After fiddling around for a bit without cheating, I've ultimately concluded that I agree with the sentiment that, the way it is now, confidence is too hard to gain, and too easy to lose. Having more confidence boosting events will probably do wonders to get players to like it more. BTW, on the specific points mentioned of punishments for being too bold/crazy, and people who feel blocked off from porn, I have some ideas. I agree in principle that there should be consequences for getting into trouble, but as it stands, it reinforces the "hard to gain, easy to lose" problem that confidence has. However, if you were to make it easier to gain confidence, that would admittedly make confidence drops kinda just a slap on the wrist. So I propose the punishment come in the form of a new temporary trait. Shaken: Due to a rough event, confidence gain is temporarily halved. As for the people getting blocked off from porn, that admittedly isn't strictly tied to confidence. It's also tied to the fact Sammy's desire is maxed at 50 as a Virgin, unless she has the Bimbo or Gamine origin. Perhaps some way around that for people who desire a shorter path? Perhaps making it possible for Sammy to either start as a pervert, or as only a technical virgin? (As in, she has had sex in her old life, with the institute's magic being the only reason she has hymen now. Meaning she doesn't really consider herself a virgin.) Either way, choosing this option would have Sammy avoid the malus to desire that she normally has from being a virgin.

Anderen

I was going to sleep on this answer, but I can't stop thinking about it. I may revise this in the morning so I apologize in advance. This is my idea for it. Split confidence into two stats. I'll say sex confidence and willpower for this example. Sex Confidence determines what Sam is willing to do. It goes up when you have Sam do things near (or beyond, see below) what she's comfortable with. This does limit the player early on but they are at least working towards more and more content. Basically a progression system. It can decay over time like athletics and academics if Sam stops doing sexual stuff. The second, willpower, would be a currency stat. Sam gains it by doing things that are fun. Sports, hanging out with friends, etc... The more she builds a relationship with other characters, the more willpower gained from time spent with them. Perks can also add new ways to gain willpower. Nerd would get it by studying, gym bunny would get more playing sports, etc... Willpower would be spent to push Sam even further. If she's just under the sex confidence to do something you can spend willpower to do it. Also other checks could be made a little harder (like fending off a mugger), but willpower could add a second attempt, or perhaps a bonus to the attempt. All checks that are pure willpower now would be replaced with the appropriate stat. Fending off the bullies for example would be athletics, with the option to spend willpower to retry a failure. Trauma of various kinds would hamper willpower gains, or increase willpower costs, or temporarily lower sexual confidence.

diego

I like the current confidence mechanic but i do think that sometimes it can be restrictive. however, i like that as you said, it makes it more realistic and gives sammy more character. well at least to me, if sammy just goes into full whore mode from day one, i think you can just leave a "Mode" or cheat for that. kinda like a difficulty system. where players wanting to go straight for porn can select it, and players opting for the story can keep the current confidence system.

K Nakajima

All about choice... tweak the mechanic you want, we'll stick to it, but leave in the option to take the succubus pill if we want an all out slut since the beginning for no checks

Ivellios

I liked the idea of it being a mechanism for internal monologue, but if the player really wants it, can push Sammy to go through with it.

Cyryos

I like the mechanic as it is the only issue I have is with the values. It seems that confidence drops quite fast and is hard to boost quickly. It's a good mechanic to have a confident Sammy being more assertive and comfortable in sexual scenarios, where a rattled Sammy is more vulnerable and docile. It also plays into her Fixer role where future jobs might call for a "shy girl" and others need a bolder approach.

David Gaston

I like that it exists, in theory. But I don’t like games forcing me into a decision. You should be able to bypass it if that’s the kind of playthrough you’re doing

Draconspy

I would say giving the player a choice is always preferable... especially when trying to trigger random events which require a certain level of confidence, if something triggers to damage or sometimes, boost, confidence, it can be frustrating.

Jasmeria

I myself would prefer the experience/corruption mechanism. The infinite confidence option would be my second choice. Just my personal opinion ofc, but here FYI. In fact, I usually use the cheat menu anyways to keep her confidence high at any time. I just like her better that way. Part of the confidence mechanics could be taken over by the mood trait, I think.

Jasmeria

Things that require building up stats are more for games where people want to climb up stairs. In a game like this one, which is more about living the story, it should be less prominent, I think. If there are ever to be combat mechanics in TF, it would be sensible to introduce stuff like that for those occasions.

BinaryGuy85

I’ll start with, I think the confidence system is a good idea and like having it in the game. While I’m sure there are a lot of players unhappy it blocks access to some of the porn scenes, my view is if I just wanted to see porn I’d go look at some, it isn’t hard to find. I want to play a porn game, where yes I will be treated to seeing porn, but there are also game mechanics I need to learn and utilize. That said, it does need work, but don’t think just re-balancing it is out of the question. Playing through the current release, the biggest problem I thought was it is far to easy to lose confidence when it doesn’t necessarily make sense. To fix the problem I think you need to tie it into the other other systems that exist more. So two situations I came across I think would help demonstrate. The big one for me was just getting cummed on during bus events. It happens fairly frequently and seemed to be a 5 point hit to confidence each time. Given the other dialog in school around buses, it seems like girls would just have to expect that and only the most sensitive would be affected by it. As and example then tying in the perk system, the bambi origin could be expected to take this hit, others probably wouldn’t take any at all, and if the player was a slut get a confidence boost. Similarly getting punched without being further assaulted is fairly common early game and is a hit to confidence. This makes sense, but not if the player raised their fitness quickly. Seems like at high fitness the player should see these coming and avoid them or be able to brush of the effects easily. Those are just a couple examples, but I think there is a lot of possibilities in pairing the systems. For instance you could get branded a slut without being a slut and have that be a hit to confidence, causing a small period of extra shyness. It could be fun to experiment with different combinations. Then to you have an in game way of controlling how easy it is to get to the porn. Easy difficultly would basically be choose the bimbo origin and hard mode would be bambi. Anyway just my thoughts. I would be sad to see it done away with or nerfed into oblivion, but you’ve been doing any amazing job so far and am confident you’ll figure it out.

Cyryos

Just a thought, why not add confidence gain to the dance training. The sweet girls thread is already pushing Sammy to be more confident with her body and performing in public, so it seems like a logical way to boost that stat.

Cyryos

It would also be nice if confidence checks were affected by your perks. Maybe a Slut Sammy would like getting attention the bus, but takes a big hit if she askes for sex and is rejected (like with the soccer boys). Likewise a Bimbo Sammy could gain confidence from guys noticing her body or clothes, but takes a big hit from Body fails or getting called smelly.

possgamer

I believe like many who complain about the mechanic it's not the mechanic itself but not knowing how to manage or navigate along with proper knowledge or tools in how to do so. all other stats have a way to manage them . but Confidences dose not and there is a feeling of it dropping on a whim. this makes Pure playthrough unnecessarily difficult with rng being the worst with the bullies being a annoying out come. and choosing to do a slut rout with confidence hiting low while being a bimbo seems to take away the choic of having a easier(for some) or more fun(for some) playthrough. this mechanic dosent need to be expunged but it needs to be given and explanation in how to mange it. as not knowing how it works takes away the ability for the player to focus or solidify there choices. as it is it can lead to an inconsistent Sammy. As Cyryos above me suggested having it change depending on perks is not a bad idea and depending on the type of sammy, a pure one or sluty one, doing diffirent thing rasies and main tains confidence. looking nice and descent and managing sates can improve confidences slowly over time for a pure viregn play through, in this case confidence hits are harder but there are known ways to avoid those hits. A sluty Sammy wouldn't be hit as hard(or would gain confidence) but then there is more hits if thy aren't up to par in there eyes needing more sultry clothing or actions. P.S tying out comes to confidence dpending on states would be a good idea as well. Being a bimbo making the hit less or go up are obvious examples but fitness for example could lead into instead of outright falling sammy saves herself from the fall. this would need a stat check of course to balance it like you said. being horny, fit, intelagent, Looking decent/Stunning(this would depend on a Pure/Slut Sammy), mood and fatigue. all these thing would be factors, whether by themselves or in conjunction, in being able to reasonably manage Confidence but still have that risk factor.

Kaiko

I think a good option would be to give the player more control over the confidence stat itself. ways to lower/train it intentionally. I mostly dislike that first the stat ruins the porn part of the game entirely if you choose the scared archetype und second that even if I play a Sammy that is shy but not super innocent, the stat sometimes goes up uncontrollably even though I want her to be bullied in school etc in those runs. I think reworking the effects the archetype has on Confidence plus giving an option to influence the stat more directly would make it a great game mechanic.

Daniel

My problem with the confidence mechanic is not that it exists, but that the changes seem too arbitrary and it seems too difficult to raise confidence. The changes to athleticism and intellect stats, in contrast, are easy to understand. If confidence was tied to things I understand and can control, it wouldn't bother me.