Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I am dumbfounded by the response to the Man-Thing VS video in the comments. Absolutely dumbfounded.

And honestly, I'm not sure if it's more because people disagree with me, which I'll come back to in a moment, or because so many people seem to be so personally invested in MAN-THING. WTF?

I honestly, HONESTLY never expected even ONE person to take issue with the result of that video, heck, I wasn't even sure people were going to WATCH it.

To get as many people (even 2 would have been a surprise) being as disappointed with the outcome as they are I just don't know how to reconcile that.

When it comes to the VS structure I try to be impartial about the scoring. Sometimes, if I really like a figure, I might make a judge's call and award them a victory just because (I think Wolverine VS ended that way if I remember correctly). Usually, it's pretty clear which figure is better (any SHF vs any Black Series).

For this VS I stuck with the basic categories that everyone evaluates a figure with: sculpt/paint, price/availability, accessories, articulation and I threw in one non-standard category to TRY to give Hasbro a point and I couldn't even fully award that because it's such a subjective thing.

I THOUGHT those first 4 categories were pretty clear cut. You can't argue (I should say, you SHOULDN'T argue) that one is priced more or less than the other it's just a fact. One has more articulation than the other, that's a fact. One has a clearly more detailed sculpt. Fact.

It boggles my mind that people watched that video and interpreted it as me "hating" on a figure.

And these are time where Producer Greg has to remind me NOT to reply to the comments because, SHEESH, I just want to go in and go scorched Earth on everyone.

But that's counter-productive and adds nothing.

But what the heck?

Alright.

Vent over.

Thanks for listening.

Files

Versus #24 - Toybiz Man-Thing vs Hasbro Marvel Legends BAF Man-Thing

It's Toybiz original Marvel Legends Man-Thing from 2004 versus the 2017 Marvel Legends Netflix Wave BAF Man-Thing. When it comes to Man-Thing there aren't a ton of requirements for a good figure so is it worth it to spend all the money to build the Build-A-Figure Man-Thing or should you just hit eBay for the Toybiz Man-Thing? Help the channel continue to grow: https://www.patreon.com/toygalaxy Follow Dan on Instagram. He posts lots of toy photos: http://instagram.com/toygalaxy http://www.twitter.com/toygalaxytv https://www.facebook.com/toygalaxytv https://www.twitch.tv/toygalaxy https://shop.spreadshirt.com/toygalaxy/

Comments

Anton Jensby

Gee I liked the hasbro one a lot better but I thought all your points were totally valid. Sometimes the facts don't matter as much as visual presentation. After all people still buy Chrysler cars.

Frekki

Yeah idk man, I think this new Man-Thing isn't better per se, but I personally like it more. I like the size more. The sculpt is really good. Paint needs work but the articulation could be argued is better then the Toybiz one because the Toybiz had articulation that was kind of dumb (fingers and toes) that made those parts look goofy and broke up the sculpt. They're both great. It's a tie to me.

Laserpants81

It's part of becoming more... hmmm... "famous" on the Internet I think. You're reaching thousands of people now, people that grew up in a world much different than the one you and I grew up in(80s & 90s). This generation takes personal offense to a differing opinion. Even an opinion on plastic toys. It's a weird world we live in my friend. In the past couple years I've almost completely left 3 3/4" scale Star Wars collecting for the 6" line. You wouldn't believe(or maybe you would) the amount of vitriol I get from 3 3/4 purists.

Bryan and Laura

If I'm honest being angry about the contents of a YT video always annoys me. Even if you actively disagree with someone at least try to see their point of view before chalking it up to 'hating'. Also, what most people on the internet don't seem to get: "It's FINE to have a different opinion. It's NOT FINE if it's not up for discussion." Nobody's talking definitives ultimately just opinion and preference.

Toys with ‘Tude!

Look man, I am guessing you are in my age range (I'm 43, so late 30's/early 40s?) and things were just different when we grew up. You were allowed to disagree with people and not be a dick about it. Now, unless you come with swivel arm battle grip and righteous indignation, you may as well not show up. I know I tell everyone that will listen about your channel and I bet other people do, so you're kinda Internet/Youtube famous. I review action figures on my page and I am shocked over the few people who read my page and some of their reactions. An opinion is subjective. You didn't say anything crazy like "the earth isn't flat" or some other nonsensical fact, you gave a well thought out OPINION. But man, people stop short of wishing cancer on me for my opinions so I can't imagine you don't get both barrels from the scathing mediocrity that is the denizens of the internet. Eff em', you're doing great.

notaname

I was surprised by the result but I thought it was hilarious when I realized it would be so lopsided. I'm not invested in the character or either figure and perhaps that contributed to how much I enjoyed the vid. I wouldn't change a Thing about it.

Yokai_Customs

Preface: I don't own either figure and don't care about the character. I have plenty of Toy Biz figures. Watching the video I did get the impression it was strongly biased to the Toy Biz version. Looking at photos I didn't think the TB version should be such a shoe-in. This one seemed a bit anti-modern ML to me. I still love your channel though. Cheers!

Eric Ramirez

I agree that the Toy Biz one is better in all the ways you said, but I'll end up getting the Hasbro because I want the whole BAF wave that Man Thing comes in just because those individual figures are so good. While Toy Biz may actually be better, it's gonna be Hasbro for me just because of how strong this wave is and how strong this line is becoming. Toy Biz will always have the best Ghost Rider though, do any VS with any brand, Toy Biz wins every time.

Secret Galaxy

That's exactly it. These things are never about "this one is good and the other one is trash." I don't even like most Toybiz figures or Man-thing!

Secret Galaxy

I totally hear that. I really tried to even close the video on a point of "regardless of the scoreboard... they're both good!" Sometimes I wonder if I'm just crazy or people don't listen.

Secret Galaxy

The idea that there are even 3 3/4" purists (and there are, I too have seen the comments) is INSANE. What the actual hell?

Secret Galaxy

And hey, I also get that the whole reason we post Youtube videos publicly is to elicit discussion about things. That's where we make our youtube dollars. Interaction. We WANT people commenting. What I don't get is how MAN THING got those responses. I expect it on Deadpool or Wolverine. I was just shocked to see ANY push back on MAN THING.

Secret Galaxy

And I don't even care if people disagree with me when I state an opinion. I welcome differing opinions and I encourage discussion. None of this was opinion and, in the end, it's about MAN THING which just surprised me. I honestly was not expecting Hasbro ML Man Thing defenders on that video.

Secret Galaxy

I am 41, so right on! I get it. I get the comments. I get the "kids these days". I really didn't expect people to interpret things that I thought were pretty clear cut facts as opinion. I don't even care about EITHER figure. I don't even like Man Thing. It's more just a minor reminder that even when I think I'm being impartial... some people aren't seeing it that way.

Secret Galaxy

Exactly. It's the same categories as nearly every VS we've ever done. I don't care about either figure that much or Man Thing in general so I thought I was being pretty impartial. Guess it's just a reminder about the way that people perceive things that they care about.

Secret Galaxy

So, yeah, that's what seems to be the overall sentiment, but let me ask you: of those categories, would you change any of the scores? I thought they were all pretty basic, standard categories, pretty much the same categories we use almost every time. Which ones were too anti-modern? Which ones could have gone the other way?

Secret Galaxy

That's part of what's blowing my mind. It's just a scoreboard thing for a video. I even made the point in the video that "they're both good". It's not like the Hasbro one was a pool turd or anything. It's like Toybiz was a 96 and Hasbro was a 91. Those are both still A's.

Milo Magaña

these things come with the bigger audience, criticism is a sign of success man

Bryan and Laura

Of all the (Man) Things to get upset about... (Sorry, couldn't resist)

Toys with ‘Tude!

My best guess: people are dumb. I think it even says that in the bible. And I am like you... if man-Thing accidentally touched himself as he saw a lawn mower and burst into flames in front of me, chances are good I would maintain my urine for Jellyfish stings and such.

Toys with ‘Tude!

"Pool turd" was my mom's nickname for me. Mom was mean.

Yokai_Customs

All good questions and my comment was a bit off the cuff. If you're genuinely interested I'm happy to take another look at the video and give a more thoughtful response.

Jacob Sauve

I read the comments too, and I have to say people went overboard. I see this quite a few times in toy review youtube comment sections. People strongly disagree and act like really assholes about it. Maybe they were so invested because they spent ALL that money, and then to have someone tell them an older figure that was far less expensive was better in some objective categories? HOW DARE YOU! lol! It really is unbelievable. All I can say is, you guys do a fantastic job, don't let the brainless on Youtube get you down. Fans or not.

Jacob Sauve

Side note: I didn't even KNOW man thing existed. I honestly thought it was some version of Swamp thing. Didn't even know there was more than one plant based Superhero.

Secret Galaxy

I'm genuinely curious if there are things that seemed less than impartial. Sometimes I push the scoreboard one way or another for either personal preference or entertainment value... but this wasn't one of them.

This Deal Is Getting Better All The Time

Some people can't understand that preferring one thing isn't damning another. You made a video comparing two action figures and found that you liked one more than another based on your personal criteria. Anyone that can't handle that has problems they need to work out on their own.

Yokai_Customs

I've watched a quick recap video of the character for some better context and sat down to go over your review. Figured I'd break this down by each category as the review goes along and we'll see how this turns out at the end! For ease of typing I'll just refer to them as TB and ML. Sculpt: I like the ML face more (though the roots look like a glued on addition which I don't care for) but overall I have to agree that the TB sculpt is superior. The branches and other debris work well and the articulation is hidden a little bit better. ML looks more like a pile of grass clippings (partly influenced by the reduced brown wash). The ML joints are garishly obvious, especially around the knees. I'm not sure which size is more appropriate. In the recap video it was hard to get a sense of which size was more accurate. He's big but he's not a hulking giant...so I'm tentatively leaning towards TB on that aspect too. Articulation: Is the hand articulation on TB really necessary? The ML hands look better but have less articulation. If the winner is simply "this one has more" then this goes to TB but I think thoughtful articulation balanced with the overall sculpt should win out here. By thoughtful I mean judiciously chosen, useful, and integrated well into the figure. I'm sort of at a loss for this category to be honest. I prefer less articulation if it improves the aesthetic but I'm not sure the ML appearance is really improved much, other than the hands. I'm leaning towards TB I guess but it's a soft win. Feels like a technical win. Accessories: TB wins by default because it has a stand and comic (and a card no one cares about) while ML has nothing. He's a character that doesn't really need any accessories so this also feels like a technical win. ML would've been well served to include a tree branch as a weapon, or perhaps the chemical container that led to his creation - like the ooze canister the ninja turtles sometimes come with. As a fringe character I can accept the lack of accessories but there's no way I could give this to ML. Price: If we go simply by dollar amount then this goes to TB. I wonder if a supplemental category called "Value" would be worthwhile here. If, hypothetically, ML was vastly superior but ultimately more expensive it would lose on price but win in value. Based on your discussion in the video I'm kind of on the fence for value though I concede that price goes to TB without question. Fear factor: I think this category being awarded to both is spot on. The "vibe" each figure gives off is very different and the ML figure DOES have an overall quality I like but in the breakdown TB clearly dominates. Perhaps there needs to be a category like "greater than the sum of its parts" to account for this? At the end of the review, looking at the photo of both, I can see now why TB won but I think I like the ML more. Very subjective but obviously something is up here because ML is the clear loser but I like it and so do a lot of others. I'm 33 and started collecting Marvel figures back with Toybiz so I'm not some wet behind the ears collector who doesn't like the older stuff. A paint category might've been a useful addition here. That would also go to TB. The lack of better brown washes on ML is disappointing and annoying - especially after you pay so much to get him! Bonus points to you for Treebeard and Groot in the background.

Inhaled Farts

I liked the video, I think based on the fair judging criteria the Toybiz clearly one. The Hasbro Man-Thing wins in my book based on my personal taste which we've already discussed. I really hope you aren't losing any sleep over this remember we're all just nerds. By the way can you do an Instagram post of all of your tree themed figures that were at the end of the video. They looked awesome!

Shane-O

No one knows who ManThing is. I'm convinced that there was a matrix glitch and he just revently appeared in our universe. Crazy how people will argue with folks over things they don't care about. For what it's worth, I think it looks like a lot more time was spent creating the TB figure and that usually wins my money.

Secret Galaxy

He did recently appear in Marvel's S.T.A.K.E. a supernatural Avengers team. But I didn't get the impression that these were fans from that series just people who had been DYING (pun intended) for more Man-Thing content on Youtube. They were poised, ready and waiting.

Secret Galaxy

Nah, no sleep lost whatsoever. Just a few moments of "wtf?" The figures at the end of the video were just the BAF Groot, the old Toybiz 8" Treebeard and the larger 18 or 24" Treebeard (not sure off hand how tall he is).

Secret Galaxy

That's the thing. People are welcome to like whatever they want. These are the basic categories. It's the same categories I've used in nearly every VS we've produced. It's ok to be a fan of the one that lost on the scoreboard. It means absolutely nothing. I think I take exception more with people saying "you're wrong" and not saying why I'm wrong. I broke it down point by point. I can't be wrong if you can't say why I'm wrong. It doesn't make you wrong for liking something else. I appreciate you taking the time to rewatch and respond. I didn't expect every commenter to do that of course. But I feel better knowing that even you who admits that you like the Hasbro piece for [doesn't matter what] reason can see that I played it pretty neutral based on the criteria and was not, as accused in the comments, "sucking Toybiz's dick."

Secret Galaxy

It's not even that I "like" like. I don't care about either of them. There were 5 criteria, I looked at them objectively and rendered a judgement that I thought was pretty obvious. It by no means means that one is perfect and the other one sucks. Just struck me as such a weird character/video for people to accuse me of being impartial.

Yokai_Customs

To be fair, you absolutely could be wrong. The lack of a well articulated rebuttal in the comments doesn't inherently mean you are right. Some people did address your points in the YouTube comments. For instance, while TB had more articulation some could argue that it is sort of ugly and unnecessary articulation and the ML looks better. Subjective, of course, but it at least addresses one of your points. To play devil's advocate: Sculpt could really go to either one. Articulation leans to Toybiz but again, one could argue either way. Accessories: as I mentioned, this is a technical win. I don't have a lot of experience with BAF aside from Galactus. Do they tend to have accessories? Given the character I think accessories are largely unnecessary. I don't really use themed display stands ever so that's kind of worthless to someone like me. The frog looks a little goofy. One could really argue this point for either if they REALLY wanted to though this is probably a Toybiz win in all respects. Price: BAF are expensive but only if you didn't already plan to get all the figures. If you did then this is basically an extra free figure. This could be a draw, from a certain point of view. Fear: you gave this a draw, which seems fair. So, this could've swayed differently depending on the reviewer's preferences. I went over it and agreed with your review but the next guy could just as easily sit down and go over it and have the opposite opinion. The folks that do the drive-by comments and say "you suck! wronggg!!!" and keep going are the trolls and frankly I'm surprised you don't run into more of that given that 1) it's YouTube and 2) the subject matter. YouTube comments are a wretched hive of scum and villainy. I took a quick glance at your list of "Versus" videos and I noticed that many (certainly not all though) are often imports vs hasbro (expensive vs cheap) or something along those lines where we sort of all know going into it that the import is better and will probably win and it's understood why from the onset. Comparing Toybiz and Hasbro's Marvel figures is a lot more evenly matched in my opinion. I think, when comparing two figures to similar to each other, you are bound to have some issues. Have you done a video comparing Toybiz Deadpool to the recent Hasbro version that comes with the taco? I bet that would be pretty contentious, regardless of who won. Regardless, you have 380 videos and 22.5k subscribers. A few buttholes are bound to show up now and then. If you think it is bad now, wait until you hit 100k or 100m subscribers! For what its worth, I love your videos and that's why I chose to back you on patreon. We don't need to agree about everything but you produce thoughtful, high-quality content for a platform that I enjoy and I appreciate that.

Shane-O

Woe didn't know that, Marvel Universe so huge now! I need a hitch-hiker's guide to the MU. I also forgot to say thanks for all of the great videos! I'm upset I missed you guys in Cherry Hill (where I work). I had no idea that convention existed...Looks like I'm out of a very fun loop. I'll catch it next time. Speaking of NJ, there's a really really cool toy store in Richland NJ that's absolutely worth the drive. Very awesome and unique place, retro, recent retro, and modern alike. Check it out some time.

Shane-O

Just realized I didnt name the store... "It's a Toy Store" actual name

This Deal Is Getting Better All The Time

Haha yeah it's definitely strange. However, Dan, if you want to admit that you like Man-Thing, perhaps even more than than any other fictional character, it's okay. We'll still watch your videos. It'll just be weird for a little while…