Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

We're working on a video about the current state of the action figure industry and we're looking for some input.Let us know what you think of the current state of the industry with respect to distribution, convention exclusives, kickstarters, availability of product, pricing, "kid focused" vs "adult collector", the loss of Toys R Us and its potential impact on ALL of this.I know that's a lot to ask in one reply, but, you can boil it down to "does the model need to change or is this just the way things are and the consumer has to adapt?"Feel free to offer potential solutions as well like "perhaps the DVD/Videogame/Force Friday model should be the industry standard. The next wave of any brand should be rolled out on a specific street date. Not only can you NOT put it out before that date, you HAVE TO put it out that date."Thanks!

Files

Comments

Wilfredo Flores

That's a good idea about a set date! Because as you and I know, being based in New England, a lot of places tend to get stuff later and the supply is erratic. Sometimes they have a lot or nothing. They might just come out of nowhere. And I seen plenty of instances, especially on YT and IG of people who travel around great distances (like hundreds of miles) to find product. And it's not like the middle of nowhere, where such a journey is to be expected. We are talking like populated areas. So it's a 2 step process.... Define the problem ( which you have) then eliminate it!

Dean Jones

Looking at it through the lense of a teen from the 90's I've seen some people seeing figures as an investment and not as something to be used/apreciated in it's own right. We all saw how New Mutants 86/87 sky rocketed in value after only a few monthes becuase you know, CABLE and then started buying 2 or 3 of every hologram cover/new character/ sealed comic bag that we could find in the hope of using them to buy a house or girlfreind one day. Ofcuase the very act of ALL of us being LOTS and keeping them in pristine condition means they are now worthless, unless you bought them for thier intrinsict value, and enjoyment. I've seen too many peoiple buy figues with the intent of selling on more than just to enjoy them as things in thier own rights. THat's why I love Dan for being an "Opener" and for his sign off phrase.

Inhaled Farts

I don't know if the Industry is broken but my heart is. After failing to secure my holy grail figures of the NECA TMNT and trying to make light of it I really am disillusioned with the system. I blame us more than the companies. We feed into it by purchasing from scalpers and then trying to recoup our losses by reselling figures that we never intended to collect only profit from. I thank you both immensely for always pushing the "leave one for the next collector" creed and for hopefully bringing light to other areas that need attention with this post.

Anton Jensby

I think the industry is changing right now and that's why there's so many dissatisfied with the market. The shift of who the market is, is what's forcing the change. I would venture the bulk of people buying figures now are all adults and companies are trying to figure out what that means to their product. And the more detail, higher cost, and more limited availability is furthering to alienate the younger collector. I think we can look back at what the comic Industry went through and expect something similar for the action figure industry.

Yokai_Customs

We need way better direct to consumer purchasing options at affordable prices. Subscription models suck and exorbitant shipping sucks (looking at you NECA eBay/amazon). The "hunt" is irritating. I just want to sign up for what I want and have it show up when it's available. Amazon never has enough and then it's got 3rd party jacked up prices. Going to TRU was a pain as well. Why is ML pumping out so many figures? They're flooding the market it seems. Why doesn't the black series do BAFs? Why won't they refresh (or just re-release) the earliest figures? Kickstarters and small batches (Joe Amaro) are cool but don't seem useful for licensed products. Works great for Mythic Legion and Articulated Icons. Black Series convention exclusives have been great. Not gonna miss out on the figure, just cool packaging. The bump in price by impo4ts and Mezco is troubling. The market has been jacked up to $75-100. I bought 12" Sideshow Star Wars figures for less than that 10-15 years ago. The hobby seems out of control and unsustainable. But yet, here I am. Buying figs.

Geoff Arbuckle

Oh man... All the thoughts. I'll try to put them into proper perspective as well as make it all make sense to anyone who reads. So, first and foremost, I am not a toy collector. I'm a comic book collector and have been for over 30 years now. I had lots of cool toys - growing up in the 80s means I absolutely always had cool stuff around to play with. However, I still get "toys" (particularly Funko products because they are modeled around affordability and wide range of IPs). That said, and as I literally prepare to make my final trip ever to a Toys R Us today, I've had time to put into perspective what that closing and how the industry got here. So many people think that the daggers have been big box outlets like Amazon, Wal-Mart, etc. offering cheaper prices on everything. Some of the worst point of views have been wrapped around the idea that social-political reasons, like putting boys toys and girls toys together or Disney pushing female leads in Star Wars movies, that have acted as a nail in the coffin for boys to not be intrigued by what they see in toy aisles. I do not think that is it at all. I feel like the intended audience and market for toys have shifted as our generation got older and got cash to hand over in fistfuls. My first Millennium Falcon was like $30. The Solo Falcon released today is $100. The new one might be better made, but I don't think it is properly inflated for the quality. So who is that toy made for? It seems too "kiddie" to be for adult collectors, and it is too expensive for every parent to buy it for their kid along with a fair complement of other toys and figures to match it. So I think the biggest issue with the toy industry is that they no longer know who they are manufacturing for. People willing to spend lots of money are adult collectors but they are much fewer than the kids who will actually want and play with the item. The item is too expensive and fragile for the rigors of being played with by children, so parents, and collector parents in particular, aren't going to buy toys for their kids. Kiddie version of toys don't look as well made anymore. They either look like preschooler toys or they are flimsy in general for their price point. I just don't know if they have the legs and staying power as the toys from 25-35 years ago. I'm an adult who doesn't have kids and a collector, but I had to make my bed and lie in it with what I do want to collect in a single income home. There are plenty of toys from my youth or new collector's items that I would love to purchase, but they may be anywhere from $150-300 in range and that's just not gonna ever fit in my budget, and the secondary market is not an option without a winning lottery ticket. So let's circle all the way back around to my actual answer to your question - I think the toy industry has an identity crisis. It is clear that the action figure market is slanted toward older fans and the collectors. And that's fine, but I also agree that the release model does not at all fit that goal of appealing and delivering to collectors. I think a set release date is necessary to keep the industry alive. If you receive the product before street date, it must be on the shelves on the street date. Not before and not after. That's what the home media world does. Imagine if you find out that Avengers is gonna be out on a date, but no one in your town has it stocked - or your area of the country cannot get the digital version? That would be a disaster and potentially kill the movie industry. Street dates are so important for this type of pop culture thing. If you don't buy it on or around street date and you miss out, it's your fault, not Hasbro, Funko, or NECA or whoever. Couple that with who you want to market to, or increase the quality across the board so slightly older kids can get an affordable, good looking figure that doesn't look like a baby's toy, and this industry might have a chance appeal to a much wider audience. Sorry for the novella there... This post happened LITERALLY as I was thinking about all this in general and I had to let it all out because when I say these things to my cat, he doesn't seem all that interested in the topic.

Charles Paradis

I'll try to keep it short-ish. For me the biggest turn off and what's created a love-hate relationship with a manufacturer is how Mezco handles things. From PX Exclusives, to ones only available on their site, international (Canada I guess is international...) collectors regularly get screwed. Oddly enough, they don't do any international shipping form their site, which means that non-US collectors have to find other means, some of them not always the most reliable. This in turn creates an artificially (in my opinion) manufactured demand resulting in (again my opinion) insane prices on the open market. From eBay to collector groups, prices skyrocket and there doesn't seem to be a specific reason for why one might be more than another. One of the worst examples stemmed from the extremely limited Ascending Knight variant available at Toy Fair. It was gonzo stuff and has certainly made me shy away from this line as time goes on. It now seems to be more of a race of "I got it and you don't, so there." When I first started into figures, I was more into the higher end stuff, and now I've done a complete flip. I'd rather have something that works than not at all. I honestly don't know how viable this practice is for them. It certainly creates buzz, but also a great deal of frustration within a collecting community.

Eric Lutes

Whoa. Just whoa. This is a big can of worms. Personally- I think the toy market was (yes, was) killed by a combination of factors: poor distribution, bad case assortments targeting adult collectors, adult collectors cherry picking cases and leaving too many peg warmers. What kid is going to be interested by the kind of crap usually left on shelves? If I was 9 I can’t say I’d be too excited walking into a toy store and finding 20 General Hux figures and being terribly excited. I don’t remember having that difficulty finding a Luke, Han, or Chewie. I’m not sure who packs these cases but I think it’s a big part of it.

Anthony Caulfield

O God! I think you might need a 2 part video for this one, I'm not a doom and gloom person but I do see problems.

Anthony Caulfield

1 the prices are raising on everything and are getting out of control look at Play Arts Kai,Mafex, Mezco etc it to much.

Anthony Caulfield

2 it's a bubble that is getting bigger and bigger and is going to burst with God knows what consequences.

Adam Blue

The context in which you could use an action figure varies greatly. I think direct distribution is the future, once shipping processes have streamlined, in terms of technology (using drones). The video game industry found out direct-to-consumer is the way to go, made easy once the digital future arrived. But, action figures aren't digital (or are they?*). But the consumer could change. Are current children going to grow up and be adult collector's 20 years? *Also, I see a future of 3D printing. Smaller equipment, easier to obtain materials - indies or companies can sell you directly the instructions to 3D print (a digital connection to the printer, like redemption codes tied to user account) action figure parts, and put them together like modern toys seem to be built for. The only blindspot is the material factor - will we grow out of physical representation of the things we enjoy? My conclusion: the modern commercial structure for action figures: development, distribution, appeal - really requires leveraging modern technology to be able to grow even more, lower costs and increase production. Look at all the figures you can by off eBay! Some are knock-offs, but how soon until we can't tell? I don't think you need to grow up with toys to be future collectors, just easily get cool things in people's hands.

Anton Jensby

My wife has an interesting take on it. She thinks that the retailers like walmart, target, and Walgreens aren't taking the adult collector seriously. It's not kids or some mom shopping for figures but a discerning buyer with money. And the retailers hit or miss approach is driving the figure market more and more online. Every Walgreens employee I've ever talked to don't even know they carry exclusives. If the stores don't care about adult collector dollars, that adult is going to shop elsewhere. Probably online.

Laserpants81

There’s more quality, collector focused action figures being released now than ever before IMO. I just think the traditional Brick and mortar method of obtaining them is changing. The online market is the new way to collect.

David Chambers

I have wondered this myself many of times. I agree with Anthony you may have to do a 2-part episode Dan! Recently I was thinking this exact question while re-watching the Toys That Made Us series on Netflix for like the 20th time and wondered what the industry will look like 10 to 20 years from now. The industry has changed so much since Captain Action and GI Joe some for the good and some for the better. I think toys helped with cultivating imaginations and storytelling in children, which is a good thing. And I see that in the interviews and commercials in that documentary series. There are folks who went into the industry because of their 1978 Luke Skywalker figure or their He-Man toy. I think the industry is at crossroads but not broken. I think with the loss of Toys R Us (but the possible return of KB Toys) is signaling a watershed moment for the industry. But if the companies can zero in on their market and structure their brand around that consumer I think we will see the industry grow. When I think of companies that struggle with their market and identity I think of DC Collectibles. They have struggled to remain viable in this changing market. Are they a statue company or a toy company? Are they a high end product line or a mass produced toy line? All of that being said, one of the things I noticed in the box openings that happened on their Facebook live was Kevin mentioning adding story telling elements that toy photographers could use in their ACBA. I think Kevin knew his market and you can see that in the Superman/Doomsday pack. But I think the suits didn’t see that as a money making market which is unfortunate when it is the adult collector that can get to their product. Other companies like NECA understand their base market and create towards them. They capture nostalgia in plastic and it works. Look at the 1990 TMNT SDCC set. I still find myself looking at their Keaton and Reeve 7 inch figures amazed that I have those iconic representations on my shelf. I look at Hasbro and see that they are directly competing for the adult dollar with companies like Diamond Select and the import companies. They have stepped up their product in the last year and it shows. They are on par with the imports when it comes to their film lines with the game changer face printing tech. I would like to see more detailed paint apps on the bodies and hand options personally. But one thing I think could hurt them is the deluge of product in 2018. I know that Jay C asked this question last week regarding the amount of figures and I think as it stands there are at least 63 comic and 47 MCU Legend figures for 2018… that’s a lot! And for some who collect both lines that could create some wallet hurting issues. I’m afraid that this mountain of product will create a peg warming issue that not even the might Marvel brand can avoid. I remember collecting Legends in middle school back in the day and I relied on summer lawn mowing money and my parent’s kindness and I have to say, that if this was then, I don’t think I would have a complete MCU shelf due to the amount of product. Sometimes less is more and if less means greater product for my money I will take it.

Thom Mazak

Most kids I know are more interested in games like Fortnight than toys. Having the basic price be around 20 a figure isn't helping things either.

Secret Galaxy

Yeah I feel really bad for a friend of mine who has a 10 year old who is REALLY into Marvel Legends. Gotta save up those birthday and Christmas present requests.

Secret Galaxy

I am shocked by how much product Hasbro has released this year and keep asking myself "why?" Is it just a coincidence of all their individual brands being marketed at the same time (movies in particular)? Are they trying to choke out the import market? I really don't get it. And the weird thing is, even with this deluge of product, I have purchased FEWER figures this year than any year in recent memory.

Secret Galaxy

That is a GREAT point. I think fig-swapping speaks to that as well.

Secret Galaxy

Yeah there have a been a few Mezco that I might have gone for, definitely some SHF and Mafex but I have to draw a line somewhere even if they aren't.

Secret Galaxy

Totally agree. An outdated strategy that hasn't corrected for buyers habits.

David Chambers

I'm right there with you. I have only gotten 15 new Legend figures so far this year and out of that only 4 were comic based. There have been some that catch my eye but then I say to myself that if I'm patient I can get a deal on Amazon or in a trade with another collector.

Mikey 12

I guess my complain falls under distribution, but I just don’t understand how a brand new figure can be released but just impossible to find on a store shelf (99% never seen in the wild), realizing I have to preorder from a website that will charge me more than the MSRP, resorting to eBay and charged even higher, after all that I’m over it and discouraged from even buying. Maybe it’s me not hunting enough, but I don’t remember it being that bad years back.

Mikey 12

Sorry for the misspellings and run on sentence, lol.

Avery Mercer1st

"Look man! I only need to know one thing – where they are." -Vasquez, Aliens. i saw your video and understand the frustration of gripes of getting some of these figures. so many options, so many figures, short supplies, store exclusives, etc etc. i feel like we put ourselves in this mess when know too much about what's out there. i try to narrow my own options and use say only Amazon for online buying. if there is something i really want i'll seek it out to no ends. if not, i am toy hunting at my select stores around my area (Targets, Gamestop, Think Geek, Barnes & Noble, Ross, and Walgreens). i don't do Walmart because i don't have one that stocks good figures in my area. I have a couple routes to get home from work, so i'll stop by a Target, Ross, Think Geek, and Gamestop in North Seattle or go to the other Target and the multiple Walgreens along my drive home (which there are 4). i spend about an hour hunting after work nearly every night before going home. I am of the mind, if i can't find it in person, then i probably won't get it. but i do hunt on Amazon like its the stock market, if i can't find a figure i want in person, i wait for Amazon price to go to at least retail and it has to have Prime Shipping. sometimes if i am on the fence about a figure, i'll wait until it drops to nearly half the price of retail on Amazon and buy it then. now that TRU is gone it's just one more store(s) that i can't go to. I don't do Comic book stores to buy figures because the cost is normally a lot more than retail....comics yes, toys no. and i try not buy toys at cons because they normally hike prices as well. normally. i've rambled enough... good topic... good video.

Avery Mercer1st

oh and figure lines like Mezco, SH Figuarts, and Mafex i normally will buy off Amazon because its rare to see those out in the wild unless you go to a specialty store... but then i feel like i HAVE to buy something or talk to the shop guy. i see a figure that is like double the price from Amazon and i don't want to point that out. i feel bad for not supporting the small shops for toy buying, but hey I do live in Seattle, so i technically i am still supporting my local economy. HA!

Secret Galaxy

I just hate waiting. I have a Gundam SD Model kit that I paid for on AmiAmi yesterday. Preordered it like a month ago. Still going to be a week or two before I actually get it. At that point it feels like it's just some old thing that I was obviously able to live without.