Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Files

Previews only

The Beatles- Good Night REACTION & REVIEW

This is "The Beatles- Good Night REACTION & REVIEW" by J P on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

Sylvan

This song is in some way a microcosm of the post-Revolver Beatles. As you say, in some theatrical sense it's a perfect closer to the album, but it sure ain't a perfect rock 'n' roll song, which up until recently had been this band's specialty. Personally, while I acknowledge the charms of this little lullaby, I prefer a perfect rock 'n' roll song to a perfect album closer.

Patti Crichton

I agree with everything you said JP, about "GOODNIGHT" It is such a lovely song and I actually played it at times when my children were very very small, at bedtime as a way to "calm them down" after I tucked them in. I have 3 boys and they were all close in age (one born in the early '70s, and the other two in the late '70s. It actually worked. I also did used it when they were infants, and were either crying and particularly fussy when ever I would put them down for a nap, or to soothe them, and actually helped to stop their crying. I really love this song and it also is calming to me as well. THANK YOU JP for going through this entire album. PLEASE PLEASE do any other BEATLES albums that you haven't already done, AND/OR their singles.. HOPE you will do more of their SOLO ALBUMS as well.!

David Imiri

Just awesome. There are no words for how awesome this album is. Now you have to do Revolver or Magical Mystery Tour...

Jeremy B

Lovely summing up of the album there, JP. Glad you've enjoyed it. I've loved going on the journey again with you. I wonder what you think about that age-old question - should the Beatles have edited these recordings down to two sides and left off the more experimental / whimsical stuff as George Martin suggested, or not. For me, part of what gives the White Album its character is the eclecticism. I’ve tried putting together a single album version in a Spotify playlist and it’s impossible! I wonder how you rate the White Album alongside ‘Revolver’, ‘Sgt Pepper’ and ‘Abbey Road’. Those four regularly end up in the top 10 list of greatest albums ever made. ‘Goodnight’ is a lovely closer. John felt unable to sing it due to his Liverpool rocker image, although 12 years later, he’d sing a gorgeous lullaby for his second son Sean called simply ‘Beautiful Boy’ with the unbearably poignant line ‘life is what happens to you / when you’re busy making other plans’. As you say Ringo does a super job and it’s a nice comedown after the madness of ‘Revolution 9’ to send us to sleep. The reason there’s lots of alternate versions is, in 2018, they released a deluxe boxset of the ‘White Album’ with new mixes and lots and lots of alternate takes, unreleased tracks, etc. It’s a great collection with a hardback book about the making of the album including many of Linda McCartney’s photographs from the sessions. A few outtakes also appeared on the Beatles Anthology trilogy of albums which appeared in the mid ‘90s to accompany a major multi-part documentary series about the band with new interviews with Paul, George and Ringo. The albums included a limited selection of outtakes, unreleased songs and live cuts from across their career. The more recent boxsets are giving us far more material though! The Anthology CDs also gave us two ‘new’ Beatles songs which went top 10 in the singles charts – ‘Free As A Bird’ and ‘Real Love’. Built around two John Lennon demos from the late ‘70s, they featured additional instrumentation, vocals and lyrics from McCartney, Harrison and Starr, recorded in 1994/5 and produced by Jeff Lynne (ELO).

Maruad

Sounds like it should have come off a Disney soundtrack in the 1940s. I like it. edited to add that I hadn't listened to your review when I made this comment. Hah! Great minds and all that.

Maruad

I think he has done Revolver but Magical Mystery Tour would be a good choice (assuming he manages to sneak in the b-side version of Revolution first).

George Davis-Stewart

A soothing balm. A foretaste of the orchestral passages on the Yellow Submarine soundtrack, George Martin takes a basic Beatle melody and embroiders it warmly, while Ringo's vocal range and delivery are finely suited to the mood of the song. Thank you, JP, for leading many of us on a tour of an outstanding album, not merely for nostalgia but also reunion and re-examination of its finer detail and subtleties. Hope you had a good time too.

Gary Arnett

You notice that the last 3 tracks on the album are all Lennon compositions? And each one so very different from each other.

Christian Staebler

I always felt this song like a sign to the previous generation. We are doing Rock'n roll but we don't reject your music, all our lovely elders. It's, for me, not a song for the children but for the parents.

JustJP

Thanks JB! I don't really see a reason to cut any of the material here tbh; it all feels pretty relevant to me and worthy of being on the album :D

Maruad

btw, I am looking forward to the Halloween tracks if there any. For Xmas I hope you consider Jane Siberry's "Above the treeline". Also, Loreena Mckennit has a 4 song EP of Xmas songs.

Rydell Downward

I always felt that “Goodnight” was a pleasant comedown from the intense acid trip of “Revolution 9”. Recently they’ve released “The Esher Demos” which is a collection of demos of the White Album materials and a few tracks that they didn’t have room for. It’s pretty illuminating to hear where a lot of the tracks started. What I find funny is that Paul’s numbers came completely finished, but John’s were sort if half-baked outlines.

Patti Crichton

THANKS JP so nice to get a reply from you. I just love your analyses of the Beatles music. You are my FAVORITE "Beatles reactor" You always make my day. Keep on what you are doing! Cheers!