Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

The Largest Poll We've Ever Done (Fifteen Anime) (Patreon)

Published:
2026-10-01 18:34:27
Imported:
2026-11
Tags:

Poll

The Largest Poll We've Ever Done (Fifteen Anime)

  • Blue Box 318
  • Daemons of the Shadow Realm 748
  • Elusive Samurai 440
  • Link Click Season 3 301
  • Love Unseen Beneath the Clear Night Sky 107
  • Marriage Toxin 453
  • New PANTY & STOCKING with GARTERBELT 242
  • The Ramparts of Ice 373
  • Sakamoto Days 380
  • Secrets of the Silent Witch 312
  • Sentenced to Be a Hero 748
  • Smoking with You Behind the Supermarket 496
  • Undead Unluck 614
  • Welcome to Demon School, Iruma-kun! 677
  • Wind Breaker 513
  • 2026-10-01
  • —2026-10-06
  • 6722 votes
{'title': "The Largest Poll We've Ever Done (Fifteen Anime)", 'choices': [{'text': 'Blue Box', 'votes': 318}, {'text': 'Daemons of the Shadow Realm', 'votes': 748}, {'text': 'Elusive Samurai', 'votes': 440}, {'text': 'Link Click Season 3', 'votes': 301}, {'text': 'Love Unseen Beneath the Clear Night Sky', 'votes': 107}, {'text': 'Marriage Toxin', 'votes': 453}, {'text': 'New PANTY & STOCKING with GARTERBELT', 'votes': 242}, {'text': 'The Ramparts of Ice', 'votes': 373}, {'text': 'Sakamoto Days', 'votes': 380}, {'text': 'Secrets of the Silent Witch', 'votes': 312}, {'text': 'Sentenced to Be a Hero', 'votes': 748}, {'text': 'Smoking with You Behind the Supermarket', 'votes': 496}, {'text': 'Undead Unluck', 'votes': 614}, {'text': 'Welcome to Demon School, Iruma-kun!', 'votes': 677}, {'text': 'Wind Breaker', 'votes': 513}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 6, 15, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 1, 17, 49, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 6722}

Content

We're doing another public poll! EVERYONE CAN VOTE!

We've got quite a few reaction slots opening up VERY soon! Some will be dedicated to seasonal releases coming soon and others will be taken by the top performers of this poll!

Vote for ANY AND ALL shows that you would like to see us react to! We always take note of which shows get plenty of votes, but don't win.

NOTE: Jacob and I have not seen any of these anime.

IMPORTANT! Any number of these shows could and probably WILL be reacted to soon! This is for garnering interest in which of these shows you'd like to see most! Don't worry, we still have plans in place for the upcoming seasonal anime ;)!

Thank you all so much for your continued generous support!

If you don't recognize a show, check out the AniList links below:

Ao no Hako (Blue Box) · AniList
Yomi no Tsugai (Daemons of the Shadow Realm) · AniList
Nige Jouzu no Wakagimi (The Elusive Samurai) · AniList
Shiguang Dailiren III (Link Click Season 3) · AniList
Toumei na Yoru ni Kakeru Kimi to, Me ni Mienai Koi wo Shita. (Love Unseen Beneath the Clear Night Sky) · AniList
MARRIAGETOXIN · AniList
New PANTY & STOCKING with GARTERBELT · AniList
Koori no Jouheki (The Ramparts of Ice) · AniList
SAKAMOTO DAYS · AniList
Silent Witch: Chinmoku no Majo no Kakushigoto (Secrets of the Silent Witch) · AniList
Yuusha Kei ni Shosu: Choubatsu Yuusha 9004-tai Keimu Kiroku (Sentenced to Be a Hero) · AniList
Super no Ura de Yani Suu Futari (Smoking Behind the Supermarket with You) · AniList
Undead Unluck · AniList
Mairimashita! Iruma-kun (Welcome to Demon School! Iruma-kun) · AniList
WIND BREAKER · AniList

Comments

Saleem Ali

No Shangri La Frontier 🥺

Crofo

Marriage Toxin was such a surprisingly fun watch, hope it makes it

Zawa

Love Unseen Please. Its sooo good. And Daemon

xNico

I gotta pick between Undead Unluck and Iruma?! This is impossible!

Jesse Vincente

Where's Chainsmoker Cat you cowards 🚬🐱🗿

DARKSNAKE

C'mon, guys, undead unluck is peak and needs more recognition

Lady lolz

Waiting for the day mo dao zushi comes back on a poll

Pheonifire

Undead Unluck pls pls pls

Sebastián

Nah, you can (and should) vote for both!

Kenju Storm

Sentenced To Be A Hero! Let's go guys!

Hibiki

I hope Kamiina Botan makes it to the next poll. It deserves to be on this list! It is one of the most beautiful anime I have watched

Sydney

Irumacchi Irumacchi Irumacchi

kingofshibainu

Shangrila frontier would be great! Though I'm surprised and excited to see Iruma-kun on the list!

Zawa

spoiler: caleb said there's a reason its not on the poll

Zawa

someday we'll get SLF, Isekai ojisan and Handyman saito reactions. Love unseen being last is so sad.

Zawa

TRUUUU

Specter177

Sad Silent Witch isn't getting much push, it's so good

JNES

The grassroots movement has finally got Iruma-kun on a poll!!! Sure it’s a public interest poll, but this is our moment to get it further recognition.

Sariel E

Looking good so far for Sentenced to be a Hero! 🤞🏻

Xemnas27

Ooou Sentenced will be interesting

Tzimisce Queen

I love when it comes up on the polls!!! Not many people react to it, but it's pretty great!!!

CaffieneKitty

NOTE THAT THIS IS AN INTEREST POLL. THERE ARE NO WINNERS, JUST LEVELS OF GENERAL INTEREST. VOTE FOR EVERYTHING YOU’D LIKE TO SEE A REACTION FOR. 😊

Duck Lad

confirmed on discord that they unfortunately cant do it due to copyright issues

Aio le

Iruma is here at long last!

BeastialMoon

Putting Iruma and Wind Breaker in the same poll is so mean. Why should peak compete with peak 😭

Hackz

Still no Makeine.... Isekai Ojisan would be another great one too.

Therion2816

I have seen so many people react to it though. Is it impossible even if they do only timer reactions? When and where did they talk about it?

Raza

They need to see love unseen man

Ltnorm

Chainsmoker cat where?

jessibipi

I'm so sad that link click season 3 isn't getting as much attention as the other seasons😔 it's still really good

Eternals Developing

I don't actually know most of the shows on this poll. As in, I haven't seen them not checked what they're about. Going only by the titles, though, a lot of them come off as comedy-focused, which I'm not a big fan of. So my votes will probably be limited this time. I do hope Sentenced will be among the chosen ones, though, and Yomi no Tsugai.

Cyber

How have I not seen any of these animes?! O.o

Saleem Ali

Caleb just said in discord that can't do cuz of copyright. Timer only should be possible. Idk I asked in discord server if they can

Kathryn Ryder

wish i could vote secrets of the silent witch 100000 times

S0ulSp4de

That's an unlucky list for me, only 1 I can vote for. XD

Chaos_Ryder

Iruma kun!!?!??! LETS GOOOOO

ahmeddiaa

i see no "Ao Ashi" or "Ace of the Diamond" HUH still underrated by the anime community as usual sad 😔

Paweł Kuś

Smoking with You Behind the Supermarket IS MADE FOR THEM

Zawa

It’s criminal how low that vote count is damn…wtf

Alec Hagen

I really liked Smoking Behind Supermarket. Hope it gets a reaction!

RandomThorn

I'm not typically a slice of life guy, but The Ramparts of Ice hit me in all the right ways. Please check it out of you haven't and please lend it a vote on this poll!

Greiciellen RM

Ramparts of ice is his have the second/ final season now. It's a masterpiece in the drama romance category and definitely top 3 best written show on this list. Of course the more action/fantasy shows are gonna have broad appeal but it's good to have some variety.

Valfalk

A lot of interesting discussions would be had for Sentenced to be a Hero

Chris

I hate to be a downer, but this is a weak poll. I have seen over half of these shows, and none are really tickling my rewatch interest. Good luck to those who are interested though

Lou Sassle

I watched the first 3 episodes of that season it seemed like all fair with absolutely zero substance.

Lou Sassle

That anime’s 3 episode test bored the crap outta me.

Sariel E

Ummm…k. 🤷‍♀️

Lou Sassle

For such a large list, i have almost no interest in any of these anime. Not much seinen/mature stuff on here.

Buchêlaruzit

I never understand why blue box never gets many votes, I would love to see their reactions to it and they would enjoy it

Emmanuel

Daemons of The Shadow Realm would genuinely tick all their boxes. It's not the flashiest or most popular anime on this poll but it has all the substance.

Waluigi

UNDEAD UNLUCK LETS GOOOO

Fenronin (Dorian Dubourg)

Iruma kun is so underrated, Undead Unluck too. Daemons of the shadow realm is alright and it's cool to see the designs of Arakawa again but it's way different and a weird vibe compared to FMA and not even close to being on it's level

GooeyEngineer

I love the genre love unsee is in, but dear god did that show piss me off with just how much it jumps off a cliff writing wise

That Guy

I didn't love it myself, but I want someone to react to it

That Guy

Def doesn't have zero substance, but the best episodes are FOR SURE the last episode. I just rewatched it, and it doesn't have the most interesting middle

Arz

Iruma outta left field woah

Fenronin (Dorian Dubourg)

I beg people seeing this to try Iruma-kun good mix of comedy, fantasy and school anime with actual good characters

Skyller

Lord of mysteries ?

Locke

I have to agree with some of the other sentiments here, unfortunately not really anything on here of interest to me which is kinda surprising with the big list lol. Happy for those who like these though!

Kim

I'd like to reccomend The Darwin Incident for future polls. Criminally slept on

simplegunner

the ratio of shows ive even heard of to watched is horribly lop-sided.

SLF needs more love

Already won a previous poll and will replace Nippon Sangoku when it will finish

Huy Nguyễn

Please, Blue Box. It’s been on these polls for too long

.korbitr

There will have to be warnings for Caleb for every Bug Master scene though, lol

Aizen

Iruma kun!!

Luis Arispe

The twin show of "You and I are polar opposites", "Ramparts of Ice" is a must.

Mat Kin

Honestly I kind of agree though I liked it anyway. It's pretty basic till like that last episode

CaffieneKitty

It's just an interest gauging poll, but LINK CLICK S3 and IRUMA are ON A POLL. I consider this inclusion alone an absolute win. :-)

Awoo

When will they react to lord of mysteries

vocal 200

SMOKING WITH YOUUU!!

Ionicawa

🟦,🧊,❤️❌👀🌙?

camel.d

Blue box for me with season 2 coming up its a very good time to start. Wish to see other options though like makeine.

Eris

Silent witch not getting voted is tragic but not unexpected. At least Iruma is getting votes

FE4 0536

Really hope they can react to Wind Breaker as they are the type of reactors who appreciate the storyline and character development rather than just hyping on the fight scenes... And Caleb will cry so hard 🥺

M-sama

Undead Unluck has to win eventually it would be such a perfect show for the bros to theorize about.

backseat

Undead unluck finally has a chance?

wellMega

Legend of the galactic heroes Gaiden

moala

IRUMA KUN OHHH MY GOSHHHHH PLEASEEEE!! a great comedy that's also heartfelt with memorable characters

BibidiBuu

how about Infinity Castle movie that's been out for over 2 months now

Madani

I was hoping for Needy Girl Overdose and Awajima :(

Kenju Storm

I would LOVE for more reactors to watch Awajima

Limini

Would love the elusive samurai! I read the manga to marriage toxin and loved it but I don't think the anime is a good adaption. UNDEAD UNLUCK is so fun but the amount of recaps and the pacing is killing me, it needs a one pace edit Here are some recs for next time! Kino no Tabi/Kino's Journey (2003)- 13 Ep - About kino and a trusty motorcycle who travel from country to country and each country has unique and special laws, more of an philosphy anthology, would make great discussion material, like "a country where murder is legal" or " a country where everyone can hear each others thoughts" , super stylish, has a modern reboot which also has its strengths and weaknesses, also cool to watch them back to back and see the differences in style and narrative, they have little overlap in terms of stories/countries. Kuutei Dragons/Drifting Dragons (2020) - 12 Ep - Dragon hunting! LOVED the manga, great and fresh take on dragons, Full CGI, the pacing is a bit slow at times, super worldbuilding Kowloon Generic Romance (2025) - 13 Ep - Sci-fi, mystery , really great atmosphere and existential questions Sonny Boy (2021) - 13 Ep - Mysteryyy, like what IS going on? Great directing, unconventional storytelling, you'd love it RE:CREATORS (2017) - 22 EP - Best reverse Isekai out there Darker than Black (2007) - 26 Ep - Supernatural with a kind of noir feeling, you'll have a blast with the characters and the power system. Sanda (2025) - 12 Ep - same author as beastars! Akane Banashi (2026) - 12 Ep - Rakugo in shonen format? loved the manga, haven't checked out the anime yet Ghost in the shell (2026) - 10 EP - don't think there's anything to add, very different from the other adaptions Vanitas no Carte (2021)- 2 Seasons, 24 EP - great atmosphere, vampires in an alternate victorian Paris, mystery, shonen

Limini

the show is so disgusting

Limini

SECOND SEASON OF TO YOUR ETERNITY and sparks of tomorrow (2026) - about the age of electricity? havent watched it but it caught my interest

Elle2128

Omg PLEASE do Sentenced to be a Hero I would be so excited. Not nearly enough people watching this show, its so good.

ナ アリ

I'm surprised Go For It, Nakamura-kun! isn't on the poll. I think you would've loved it. Unfortunately I'm not interested in any of these, but I did vote for some titles people asked for in the comments. I hope you haven't given up on older anime. You're one of the only reactors who give not-so-popular older shows a chance. If you haven't watched them already, I would've loved to see reactions to Natsume Yuujinchou, Hikaru no Go, Kono Oto Tomare, Nodame Cantabile, Seirei no Moribito, Kamisama Kiss, Ballroom e Youkoso, The Twelve Kingdoms, Mo Dao Zu Shi, Princess Tutu and Shiki. Anyway, hope you'll enjoy the new shows!

Nox

I'm absolutely PRAYING for Wind Breaker. I think you guys will love it. I'd also be partial to Secrets of the Silent Witch, very much a comfort show for me.

PatrThom

Is there a list somewhere of all the ones they have to keep refusing due to copyright, etc?

Ainne

3d season the apothecary diaries?

slobbers

Ramparts of ice I beg🙏

CaffieneKitty

The Discord has been ardently shilling It for months now. ^.^

CaffieneKitty

Per note from the Bros on discord, Shangri La Frontier is sadly a no-go. it attracts copyright strikes like a lightning rod. :-/

Empyreal

Yomi no Tsugai is absolute trash, far from the greatness that was FMAB. Really can’t recommend it. Has a ton of worldbuilding issues and the character writing of the MC is beyond terrible.

Fenronin (Dorian Dubourg)

Pretty sure the top 4 will easily be picked there's 8 anime that are finnishing right now or close (Tanya,grand blue, mushoku, re:zero,Nippon sangoku, beastars,hell's paradise, invincible)

nektar

Lord of the mysteries? Actually packed show that will be awesome to see your analysis and discussion on. Plenty of action, but the mystery/detective part of the show is truly reaction worthy for those who like to theorise.

Juicy Skittle

So many based iruma enjoyers, btw today is Irumas birthday lol

mae

what was the reason?

Chaos_Ryder

Oh really? That’s so sick! I guess it already is October! Also fitting for Iruma ngl…

Fawful Great

Sakamoto Days deserves more love, it probably won't win any polls but I do hope they get to it by the time s2 comes out

Apriyan Suhendar

Never comment on this platform or your Patreon for that matter, soni wonder did anyone ever suggested "Make heroine/too many losing heroine" to these guys?

groovy

Man, it hurts seeing PASWG towards the bottom... so few reactors do the show :(

Excel

iruma for sure!

Mx Lara

I NEED Iruma-kun reactions! Most underrated show OAT

Loken

Daemons of the shadow realm characters are so forgettable, I watched sentenced to be a hero ages ago and literally remember every character. As a first season sentenced to be hero is a much more interesting watch. I think Daemons has potential in the future but right now it feels pretty average.

Clappicus

No love for Clevatess? 😔 🥀

Brok3NJays

Broooo Sentenced to be a Hero..,. Why did Nick drop it all those months ago?😭 genuinely such a good anime

Lagking

Love Unseen Beneath the Clear Night Sky being last is criminal

C.N.Gentle*LegoNenen

I'm currently watching through your reactions to season one, and I hope to someday see *season two* of *Ancient Magus Bride* (which I like more then season one). - you have it as "completed" on anime-list but I think you only saw the first (24 eps). Also would like to recommend a few [that I didn't see on anime-list and/or patreon/youtube]: -Monster -Haibane Renmei -Ergo Proxy -To Your Eternity (also s2 + )

Danil

You're absolutely right. All lightshow, no substance. Everytime they said "Maou genshou" I was cringing. Trying to sell "dark fantasy" in large quotation to isekai crowd. Before was Clevatess selling to shounen crowd. Make dark fantasy for dark fantasy crowd please.

Danil

Sadly, I can't get behind Iruma-kun at all — I was filtered by the first episode. What it really did, though, was make me want to rewatch Hayate and Reborn!, and reread Rosario + Vampire. It's a premium nostalgia blend

Crimson

YOU GUYS SHOULD REACT TO UU PEAK. Like If One Piece and HxH were the gold medal of worldbuilding and power system respectively, I dare say that Undead Unluck was the silver medal of both.

Let's Talk K-Pop

Late to this but I definitely want reactions to Iruma-kun. In terms of shonen anime that has a school setting w/ abilities, Iruma-kun has to be in the top 5 (mha, wistoria, Mashle...). Problem is, Iruma-kun is so underrated (lack of typical shonen battles might play a huge part), but it's fun to bingewatch. Really pulling for Iruma-kun to be one of the next series to be reacted to!

A.M Seymour

their arent that many reactions too it because i already know 3 reactors that coiuldnt do for copyright

Fenronin (Dorian Dubourg)

So the Results are: 1. Sentenced to Be a Hero 748 votes > 1. (exaequo) Daemons of the Shadow Realm 748 votes > 3. Welcome to Demon School, Iruma-kun! 677 votes > 4. Undead Unluck 614 votes > 5. Wind Breaker 513 votes > 6. Smoking with You Behind the Supermarket 496 votes > 7. Marriage Toxin 453 votes > 8. Elusive Samurai 440 votes > 9. Sakamoto Days 380 votes > 10. The Ramparts of Ice 373 votes > 11. Blue Box 318 votes > 12. Secrets of the Silent Witch 312 votes > 13. Link Click Season 3 301 votes > 14. New PANTY & STOCKING with GARTERBELT 242 votes > 15. Love Unseen Beneath the Clear Night Sky 107 votes

Gerdi 86

Sad to see that Insomniacs after School seems to be out for good by now. I am sure you would like it, but i guess whats the point if no one watches the reaction ^^

.korbitr

They could do timer reactions for everyone like they did for Kaguya-sama Season 2. If it came down to it, they could poll Tier 3 patrons on it. I know I'd vote for it at least.

Mildly Anxious Arts

Marriage Toxin! "Though I am an inept villainess" would be fun too if it were an option

아아 아

Link Click season 3 part 1 ends next week😆

mobata

Do you guys think they will someday react to Danmachi series?