Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone,

Some offers hit like a knife to the heart.

Two companies we worked with, SourceAudio (our database solution provider) and another one - that I can't name because of earlier NDA contracts - offered us a deal totalling $100k to let generative AI audio companies train their models on our work, through them.

Naturally, both spoke at length in the usual corporate mumbo-jumbo about how much they value composers, sound designers, labels, and so on.

$100k is a gigantic amount for us. We may be the largest TTRPG audio label, but music is a niche, and TTRPG music is a niche within a niche. Compare us to the largest TTRPG map makers and it becomes obvious. This deal is basically twice what Patreon generates for us yearly.

And still, this feels like betrayal. From a moral standpoint, this is an absolute no.

I've thought about this a lot, and we can't just let it slide. Their offer is obviously perfectly legal - the law doesn't stop you from selling your soul, or from running an OnlyBards - but keeping ties to either of them is not acceptable.

To take matters at hand, I interrupted two ongoing contracts with the company I can't name.

More importantly, we are closing our SourceAudio database.

It's time to say hello to the TTRPG Audio Database!

If you've followed our 'quips' on Patreon, you've certainly seen I've been working for the past month on our own database service. It's live and working!

Also ...

... IT'S CONNECTED TO PATREON!

SourceAudio couldn't. We did it.

The features

This webapp comes with a ton of new features and new advantages for you. Here's what's new:

ALL the audio is now available in mp3, ogg and FLAC for everyone. SFX and ambiences used to only be available in ogg. Now, you choose your favorite.

ALL tracks come with their metadata automatically. They were missing from most tracks.

ALL tracks received a genre, era, sometimes a mood (or style).

Our Patreon content and albums are now perfectly referenced in a single "Source of Truth".

You can download your albums from the app directly, if you purchased them from our website.

You can view and purchase licenses from the app directly. Believe it or not, SourceAudio, which is a licensing solution at core, hid the licenses in several submenus. I received several emails per week, sometimes per day, to know where the hell the terms could be found.

A freaking THICK CLIENT APP ---->

Yep! You can (and should) install that on your computer.

A single button downloads EVERYTHING you have access to.

Perfectly organized in folders. The whole directory structure has been reworked. This genius idea that helped us for years was proposed by Atropos (the founder of FoundryVTT). It helped a lot for organization, but our library outgrew it. We needed that new system.

We had a genre called "Steampunk". Now it's an "Era", like Fantasy, Modern, Sci-Fi, Asianfantasy, etc. Each of these have the generic genres (Combat, Exploration, etc.) It's finally possible to have a combat steampunk track correctly organized in folders!!

If we update a track, change metadata, etc. you can update it on your side.

Play audio (it's not meant to replace your audio player or be the next ttrpg audio tool, it's merely to have the audio and the database on the same window for convenience)

Why this helps us too (you can skip this part)

No more lost tracks from messy manual organization. No more hours lost zipping files and uploading them across Dropbox and other services. One source of truth instead of scattered folders. I won't spend days sorting zips ever again. The control freak in me will be appeased.

The future

This is probably not perfect yet, and I'm waiting on your feedback to adapt or fix what needs to. It's possible that some tracks have not been correctly attributed to the right Patreon tiers.

To be frank, editing the metadata was extremely tiresome. Patreon's system isn't made to keep records, and their API is notoriously buggy, which meant I had to manually check the access rights for every single track individually, digging through 5+ years of posts. I tried automating it, but it didn't work.

On top of that, I renamed a few hundred tracks, especially SFX, to get rid of grammar mistakes and inconsistencies. Because of the overall chaos, hundreds of elements couldn't be tracked properly, so I set their access to "Guardian". I may have distributed a few hundred new SFX I composed in advance as a result. Consider it an early birthday gift.

I've tested it a lot, but it now requires your attention. Starting in September, we'll exclusively be sharing new audio through that tool.

Windows users: When you install the app, it will say it doesn't come from a trusted developer. You can ignore that, I won't be stealing your crypto. MGS is not known for their programs (yet). The warning will disappear over time.

Thanks for your attention. Please ask your questions. I'll gladly answer ASAP (GMT+1).

Michael & team

Try the app

Warning: 6k patrons will receive this message and try to download at the same time. Expect slow downloads in the immediate future.

Files

Comments

Spey

You have my utmost respect for this. Do not capitulate to the thieves destroying our art and our planet.

Sernard

The bards did not drop the based on this one. They amped it up

John

I am going to join patreon for a bit paid just to support this position, ai can help me with excel problems, leave art to artists

Brandon Kohn

$100k once. And then what? You sold your livelihood for a pittance and will soon be competing against slop-you.

Atila M

si on parle d'un côté purement économique, est-ce que ça ouvre pas la porte à des opportunistes qui prendrons 1 mois d'abonnement, télécharge tout ce qui est proposé en "3 cliques" et interrompe leur abonement ? Personnellement, je suis membre sur ce patreon en soutien et regarde de temps en temps si il y a des éléments sympa pour mes campagnes à intégrer avec moulinette sur Foundry.

Michael Ghelfi Studios

Hey Atila, C'est une bonne remarque, mais la réalité est que c'était déjà un problème avant. Je n'ai pas de chiffres exactes à avancer, mais il y a une proportion non négligeable d'utilisateurs (entre 5 et 15% ?) qui agissent déjà de cette manière et c'est un problème très connu des créateurs de contenu dans le JdR (et au sens large je suppose). Je pourrais modifier mon app pour ajouter une limite mensuelle de téléchargements assez facilement, mais je préfère me baser sur la confiance pour l'instant. Par contre, ça va attirer à nouveau ceux qui étaient ennuyés par le travail que nécessitait le téléchargements de milliers de fichiers à la main.

Maggie C

Congratulations on your spine, I hope that you used the actual F word.

Rane Zero

Hell yeah. Much respect to you for knowing what makes your work valuable. An AI could never do what you do. They could get the training data and churn out a bunch of souless garbage. It might even make them money in the long run, but it would never be "valuable"

Artimus

Thank you for this. You have my utmost respect and continued support. And the new database looks great!

FlipDescript

Thank you for standing by your values.

Sven

This is why I have so much respect for you and this company. Thank you for taking a stand and doing what's right

Michael Ghelfi Studios

Well said! Although I think they'd lose money eventually. TTRPG audio is a very very small niche and you guys value humanity and quality way too much. The cost of AI audio creation is higher than the money anyone can make in this industry, I think.

Sebastian Billmann

Thank you for your integrity! The DB looks great as well!

Edoardo fabbi

Stay strong! But a curiosity, dont you worry that they could still sample your works using your database?

Michael Ghelfi Studios

Thanks! They'd need to purchase all of it first, as the versions you hear on our webapp are very low quality (preview quality). And if they siphon it without our consent and we hear about it, we'll win in court (and I'll definitely sue).

OddSquirrel

I really want to dive in and support you for the app alone. Will you consider adding looping functionality within the app? And can it play music without downloading it first, like the web version can do?

Michael Ghelfi Studios

Hi! Thanks for your question. The client app only plays downloaded audio. It would make the job too easy to tech savvy pirates or simply vibe coders to steal all our audio, even though our streamed audio on the webapp is already in low quality. Some don't care. As for looping and other features, I didn't think about it. It's naturally excluded for the webapp, but I don't see any reason to restrict that on audio you own. Right now I'm working on two new webapps/tools and general improvements for the rest, but I'll try to design something!