Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Price Action/Macro

Unfortunately, the collapse in Luna and UST did indeed lead to capitulations in the crypto complex as all coins have fallen dramatically over the past 14 days. Price action have stabilized somewhat recently but we are clearly not out of the woods yet. Technically, BTC is hanging by a thread around the 30k level while ETH is struggling to hold the 2K level. Fundamentally, the market is watching for USDT as the next domino to potentially fall.

  • BTC dropped around 13% over the past two weeks and is now trading around 30k
  • ETH dropped around 20% over the past two weeks is now trading around 2k
  • Total Crypto market cap is also down around 19% with total market cap at around only $1.35 trillion

Apparently, the old adage of Sell-In-May also applies to crypto as the month-to-date drawdown of Total Crypto Market Cap is around 35%, contributing to the YTD performance of down around 43%. Overall drawdown from ATH is almost close to 60% now as can see from chart below.

Chart: Drawdown

The current drawdown is already worse than the drawdown back in May 2021. This makes sense as the May 2021 drawdown was similarly led by the unwinding of overleveraged crypto positions, but the macro conditions were still accommodative in 2021. However, macro conditions now are obviously much more restrictive than 2021, hence larger drawdown.

On the positive side, it is unlikely that we will hit a drawdown similar to 2018/2019 where crypto went down 80% and many thought that it could potentially go to zero. Fundamentally, the industry is in a much stronger position now versus 2018 where it was pre-smart contracts, barely had NFTs, no mentions of metaverse, and lacked of institutional interest. If I just put a finger in the air, I would say a total drawdown of 60-70% would make sense for this cycle, and the duration should be much shorter than the 2 years that we experienced back in 2018/2019.


After UST, is USDT next?

As mentioned in the last biweekly, the market was on death-watch for UST/LUNA. Market was shocked at how fast UST, a $19bn mkt cap algo stablecoin went to zero, also dragging down the $25bn mkt cap LUNA along with it, wiping out the entire Luna ecosystem along with its TVL. As you can see from the chart below, UST (yellow) quickly grew to account for 10% of the total stablecoin marketcap, which was close to $200bn dollars. But literally overnight, the 10% went back down to 0% causing chaos in the markets. However, there is a even larger risk potentially brewing right now.

Notice the big blue part of the graph? Arguably, the biggest fundamental risk to the entire crypto complex is now the status of USDT. UST may only accounted for 10% of stablecoin market cap and powered one single L1 Chain – Terra, but USDT is almost half of all stablecoin issuance and powers every single L1 Blockchain from Ethereum, to Binance, to every single blockchain except for Bitcoin.

USDT is literally too big to fail. And the recent numbers does not look good.

USDT claims to be backed by hard fiat assets stored in banks and other regulated institutions. So it should be much safer than UST which is backed by an algo that depends on the market’s faith in the backing currency LUNA, which can be argued to have questionable inherent value.

However, despite USDT’s claim that it’s backed dollar for dollar, it’s been a long running controversy in the crypto industry that no one actually believes USDT’s statements. There’s been a history of documented wrongdoings and obfuscations so it’s a known risk that USDT is not adequately collateralized. In fact, the industry has been trying to wean itself from USDT for a few years now as you can see in the chart that USDT market share of stablecoins has already declined from 80% just a few years ago.

But nonetheless, USDT still has 82.5bn dollars of market cap as of last week. And alarmingly, the market cap dropped by 10bn dollars in the span of one single week. Note that the price of USDT is still one, just that people are redeeming their USDTs for fiat USD at a alarming pace given the mistrust that USDT will hold up in the event of a bank run.


Are we already in a bank run? The UST drop was dramatic and quickly over as the peg broke in the first few days. But the USDT drop looks equally sharp but the peg is still holding at 1. This is because the redemption process is still working as normal, for now. How long will it hold?

For better or for worse, USDT discloses on a quarterly basis a relatively opaque snapshot of their reserves. The below snapshot is from end of 1Q. USDT has classified 85% of their reserves as “Cash and Cash Equivalents”. However only 5.8% of that is in Cash, which should already be depleted since USDT has already seen around 11% redemption so far. Next in terms of liquidity should be the 10% in money market funds along with 55% in US treasuries. The 28% in commercial papers is question since we don’t know who’s commercial paper. So roughly, USDT probably have another 50% buffer mainly powered by its holding in treasuries. In dollar terms, that’s about little more than 30bn USD. That sounds like a lot of money but at the current pace of 10bn dollars of redemption per week, USDT’s liquid reserves can only honour redemptions for another 3 weeks or so.

Of course, that is the worst-case scenario, but as investors we need to properly weight non-zero probability events. A massive run on USDT has always been talked about in the crypto community; and it appears to be underway now.

There are other signs that I’m watching on-chain as well. The Curve 3-pool is dangerously unbalanced right now. Curve is a exchange to trade stablecoins with low slippage and the 3 pool is one of the most popular products allowing users to trade between stablecoins USDT, DAI and USDC. However the problem is that the pool, which was supposed to be made up of equal proportions of the 3 tokens is now 75% dominated by USDT meaning that users are trading out of USDT (selling usdt to the pool) and receiving USDC or DAI. Given that Curve is the largest stablecoin exchange onchain, it’s important to track as this was also a warning sign leading to UST’s collapse


And speaking of Defi, the numbers there does not look good either. TVLs are down drastically due to users pulling out capital as well as capital depreciation. Defi is extremely reflexivity that volume follows price, and price follows volume. As seen in chart below, total TVL has dropped from around 250bn to close to 100bn now.

But not all is doom and gloom. A16z has released a extremely bullish presentation on the state crypto which it can be accessed here - https://a16z.com/tag/state-of-crypto-2022/

I agree with almost everything that A16z has mentioned including that web3 is inevitably the 3rd iteration of internet and that we are still extremely early in the journey. If I would steal one slide, it’s the below showing that overall trends for all metrics are on a positive slope. What we are witnessing in the markets today is just normal volatility in a hyper growth industry.


Nevertheless, for the near term, there are several glaring risks that we must overcome to continue the story. What we watching now is for USDT redemptions to stop or slowdown before the market can stabilize.

Some noteworthy headlines

· Instagram have announced that they will support creators and collectors by allowing NFTs to be showcased on IG

· Spotify is also testing various ways to support NFTs by artists on the platform. Currently in closed beta

· The band Chainsmokers have created a industry first by creating NFTs of their album and sharing album royalties with holders of the NFT

· And even the Vatican is preparing a gallery in the metaverse to showcase art through NFTs

· Current NFT projects like Doodles and Azuki are actually starting to hire professional management to take their project to the next level.

· And despite the market, a16z closed yet another 600mn dollar fund to invest into metaverse, gaming and web3




Comments

LoJ

Amazing analysis, thank you!

Lami

very deep analysis, thank arju!

Gary Liu

arju~ other than usdt, is usdc or busd preferable?

Vic Leong

英文理解能力較差,能否隔天有篇中文PDF供下載??

Suresh Chugani

Have loads of Harmony One. Bought quite a while ago, cashed out, and re-entered at 0.14-0.15. Kind of true for cryptos… “A bull market will climb a wall of worry, while a bear market will slide a slippery slope of hope”..

Cheuk Lam

So deep and so much things learn from you