Crypto Update - July 4, 2022 (Patreon)
Content
Crypto market prices were mostly flat over the past two weeks with a lot of intraweek volatility. At one point, ETH was up 40% from the bottom before falling back down to the 1000 support level with similar price action mirrored by the other assets. As we mentioned in the last note, we saw a major capitulation over the weekend of the 18th-19th which was a temporary exhaustion point for sellers. This led to the subsequent bounce as selling power was weakened and shorts was squeezed, but it’s too early to call for global bottom just yet with more macro headwinds on the way.
- BTC dropped around 3% over the past two weeks and is trading a bit below 20k
- ETH flat over the past two weeks is now trading around 1k
- Total Crypto market cap is flat with total market cap at around only $900bn
Contagion
In the last note, we talked about contagion from the major CeFi protocols which led to the forced selling of major tokens like BTC and ETH which underperformed major markets as those are the tokens where there were still liquidity to sell.
Despite some stabilization, contagion is still working it’s way throughout the ecosystem. From price action, we can see that BTC continued to underperform the overall crypto market over the past two weeks, indicating continued selling pressure. In addition, in the post-capitulation rally, BTC also underperformed in the bounce. It is possible that firms are still under pressure to liquidate BTC to raise capital.
Indeed, we have heard of more CeFi firms in trouble beyond Celsius, 3AC and Babel. The latest casualties are the exchanges, albeit perhaps names that you have never heard of. We now know of two exchanges that went beyond simple exchange business and instead made loans to parties that’s defaulting on their obligations.
- An exchange called Voyager, incredibly, made a US$675mn loan to Three Arrow Capital with ZERO collateral. Unfortunately 3AC is not in a position to pay leading to Voyager suspending operations and exchange withdraws, and initiating legal actions against 3AC.
- Another exchange called CoinFLEX also suspended operations and withdraws. The reason is because it made a unsecured loan of US$47m to Roger Ver, who’s vehemently denied the charges. Unfortunately, users are again left in the dark in terms of how to access their funds.
- A more popular exchange, called KuCoin, have recently came under allegation that it too will start to suspend operations and withdraws. It is all rumor at this point and the CEO have denied this publicly. But the problem is that a rumor could cause a bank run and create a self-fulfilling prophecy. The market is continuing to monitor the situation.
Given that there are hundreds of exchanges, it’s inevitable that we will see more trouble coming out of the woodworks. Exchanges should never take principal risk with their funds; but without adequate regulation preventing risk taking, they of course did it anyways and made quite a bit of money in the bull market.
Even for the players who were supposed to be in the business of lending is of course all in trouble like Celsius and BlockFi. But there seems to be value in these businesses as suitors are starting to line up for distressed assets…
Bailouts
Contagion is often deadly in the financial markets because of the danger of failed confidence and the interdependency between firms, hence there is often a lender of last resort, such as the IMF or the FED, to intervene and inject some confidence back into the markets. Crypto does not have a central bank. The closest proxy, it appears, are the largest exchanges such as FTX and Binance.
FTX’s SBF have been vocal in particular about committing capital to arrest the contagion and bailout firms to stop the carnage.
BlockFi was a target that’s been circulating around the market in recent weeks. BlockFi hasn’t suspended withdraws and is not imminently insolvent but it is visibily weakened by market volatility. Apparently BlockFi made a 1bn dollar collateralized loan to 3AC, which was prudent as it was overcollateralized by 130%. But unfortunately the value of the collateral fell too quickly and liquidity dried up leading to losses on the position. BlockFI has been searching for a white knight to inject more liquidity and the the rumored acquisition of BlockFi by FTX was finally confirmed by the BlockFi CEO yesterday.
BlockFi represented this as a win but it is actually a complete destruction of value for equity holders. The actual selling price of BlockFi’s equity is now rumored to be between $25mn to $250mn versus the last round’s valuation pricing BlockFi at close to US$5 billion, wiping out basically >90% of the equity value.
The silver lining here is that FTX will step in and provide credit lines and backstop client funds hence stop the risk of confidence, which is the first stop to stop contagion. But unfortunately this is the only case of bailout so far. Rumor has it that FTX was also approached by Celsius, but had one look at Celsius’s balance sheet and refused to invest. So if BlockFi is valued only at $25mn, then Celsius must be valued at negative equity, which is bad news for its clients.
Unfortunately, it seems that contagion will still need some more time to work itself out.
Macro risks
Besides the bottoms-up problems in the crypto ecosystem, macro headwinds continues. The final Q1 GDP was at -1.6% with Q2 looking no better, with recession risk front and center. FOMC and CPI numbers will likely continue hawkish data points in July. As we continue to raise rates while the economy enters into recession, we will see stagflation for the first time in decades. The problem with stagflation is the twin whammy of both earnings cuts and multiple compressions. The further problem of crypto is that earnings are priced in crypto itself, thereby multiple compressions in crypto actually leads to earning cuts, which can lead back into multiple compression, starting a vicious cycle.
The significant growth in global money supply started in 2020 post covid when total crypto market cap was only around $US300-500mn. Assuming no fundamental growth, a total unwind of central bank liquidity would see crypto markets potentially fall another 50% from here. Of course, that’s the bearish scenario. Crypto made significant fundamental leaps through this time in technology and user growth. Unfortunately, macro is still hawkish and needs monitoring.
Near Term To Watch
- Need to continue to monitor spreads in stETH, USDT, GBTC for systematic risk
- ETH merger would alleviate pressure on stETH
- While GBTC suing SEC, if successful (unlikely), would alleviate pressure on GBTC
Chart: USDT market cap continues to fall