NFT Update - Aug 28, 2022 (Patreon)
Content
Past week, Opensea’s volume was US$100M, down 30% from our last update. Magic Eden volume is doing slightly better, up from US$12M.
While Bitcoin and Ethereum are blue chips, NFTs are like the penny stocks of the crypto universe. Until the cryptocurrency market rebounds and people switch from risk adverse to risk seeking mode. This pocket of the market will remain quieter than before but in this period we will also see new developments. When the NFT market returns (if it does), it will be different from what we saw in 2021.
SudoAMM
Sudoswap’s volume skyrocketed. In Jul, it launched sudoAMM, an automated market maker platform for NFTs, . A seller can create his own “Pool” (which functions like a liquidity pool), and deposit his NFTs to sell with a starting price and a “Delta” so if the starting price NFT is sold, the next is priced with the Delta.
Here is an example of CloneX collection:
The first row is a buyer wanting to buy Clones starting from 4ETH, and each time this pool buys an NFT, the price will be lowered by 4% (Delta).
The second row is a seller with 22 clones wanting to sell from 7.247ETH. Clicking into box gives more details (see image below), the user sets a Delta at 4%, meaning after the first one sells, the next will be 4% higher. The Pool Owner also placed a buy order starting at 6.49664ETH. By supplying both ETH and CloneX, the Pool owner can specify a “Swap Fee” to take on each trade.
The volume on SudoAMM is impressive, it accumulated US$10M trading volume 35days from launch while Coinbase NFT marketplace only did US$6.7M in 100 days from their launch on May 4.
A few features contributed to the popularity - 1) efficient pricing allowing buyers and sellers to programmatically buy or sell NFT at a given price like limit orders; 2) no royalty fees (royalty fees are commonly between 5-10%); 3) Gem.xyz an NFT aggregator added support for SudoAMM.
Image below shows that for Azuki, the floor price listings are all from Sudoswap and experienced buyers usually visit Gem to see the lowest price across platforms.
The removal of royalty fee is what we saw with YAWWW on Solana previously that sparked debates as some are concerned that the incentive for project owners to continue to build is removed. But, noting that this is the trend and project owners likely cannot control enforcing royalty fees, X2Y2 announced on 26 Aug that they are making royalties optional for buyers.
Liquidity crisis in NFT
BendDAO is a platform for NFT holders to borrow ETH against their NFTs as collateral. Most NFTs are collateralized at 30-40% of floor value. During the bull market, many people deposited their blue-chip NFTs to receive ETH to buy more NFTs.
During this bear with NFTs’ floor price dropping, more and more of these loans are being liquidated (similar to how liquidation works in margin trading).
As of now, 15000 ETH has been lent out by BendDAO, but the contract reserves dropped from about 10000 ETH to less than 5 ETH over the past weekend due to a bank run.
BendDAO underestimated how illiquid NFTS could be in a bear market and proposed a protocol change to adjust the liquidation threshold from 90% down to 70%, changing the auction period from 48 to 4 hours and adjusting interest base rate from 100% to 20%.
This means more NFTs will be put up for auction and according to @cirrusNFT, there will be 600 combined BAYC, MAYC, Doodles, Clone X and Azuki up for auction.
This situation could lead to a 'death spiral' for the NFT market, but it could also a great buying opportunity. This proposal has passed quorum and if NFT prices don’t recover, we will see more NFTs up for auction in the coming month.
Pudgy Penguins
I guess winter is when penguins thrive. In this bear where all collections’ floor price are down, Pudgy Penguins (P.P.) did a come back and brought its floor from 1.78ETH early this month to 4ETH on 20 Aug. P.P. is an OG pfp project but they had problems with the founder Cole so their blue chip status was lost.
Only in Apr 2022, @lucanetz who was huge in the ecommerce space bought P.P. for 750ETH, which was US$2.5M at that time. Luca’s team did a complete rebrand and shipped a ton of utility within 4 months. This includes making Pudgy Toys and children books licensed from the community, using ; a clothing line; a marketplace etc. The rarest penguin sold for 400ETH (US$630k) on 23 Aug, pulling even more eyes back to P.P.
There are also some notable events worth highlighting:
- Adrian Cheng (鄭志剛) the CEO of New World Development announced that he owns the account @LastKnightEth. This account accumulated 101 Azukis and with this announcement, Adrian shared that he is working with Azuki team to showcase Azukis at K11 and bring the masses into the PHYGITAL world
- Nike is the biggest web2 in NFTs - Nike reportedly made US$185M in revenue, making it the top Web2 earning brand by far.
- y00tsNFT minting on 2 Sep - y00ts which is the second collection from DeGods on Solana has announced a mint date of 2 Sep. DeGods pumped from just under 300 SOL floor to now 400 SOL floor showed a high confidence in the project continuing to deliver value.