Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

My Dungeon Master Rated Attack on Titan (Patreon)

Published:
2025-10-03 11:51:36
Edited:
2025-10-03 11:51:53
Imported:
2026-06

Content

Hes a FANTASTIC DM, but he just finished and rated AOT a 7/10. Can i ever trust his judgement again?

Comments

Æther Paradox

The only real flaw of AOT is you kinda have to be a masochist to rewatch it. This channel is literally the only reason I rewatched it from the beginning. 9.8/10

StorytellerDave

My kind of guy. I found AoT deeply mediocre. I didn't really get the hype. PS - Banger of an opening in S1 tho.

Daran Tung

I bumped my rating of AOT by a lot after my first rewatch the amount of foreshadowing in just the first season makes to realize just how much planning must have gone into the series as a whole. I wouldnt give the series a 10/10 but 7 feels too low IMO.

Molly McDougal (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-19 15:00 I agree, 7/10 is outrageously high.
2025-10-03 12:32

Babybear47

I'd say it's a 8.5 or 9

Limini

thats a reasonable score

Riley Olsson

Like as a whole id give it an 8/10. season 3 part 1, parts of season 1, and how long the specials took lowered it for me

Shay

I'd give benefit of the doubt (I know I tend to rate violent things lower than they deserve because I don't personally like graphic shows, maybe he's the same), but personally I'd rate it at LEAST 8.5

StorytellerDave

See, that is actually one of my gripes with the show. I am all for a show where re-watching it gives you a ton of cool little details, but AoT I think is like too far gone, where the plot and world building feel disconnected and it feels like they don't really explain things very well throughout the episodes so you kinda have to go back to actually comprehend what they're trying to do, and some things just come out of nowhere, and meanwhile they waste time on things that they really didn't need to waste time on. I think this is a field where Frieren kinda sets the bar much higher. You get a perfectly understandable plot and story, but there's tons of little things you can pick up on when you rewatch it. It's a great balance there. AoT is way outta balance. Even the notoriously fast paced Lord of the Mysteries did a better job than AoT in my opinion. People say it's confusing and you have to lock in to understand it, but really, they struck a decent balance between letting the viewer figure things out, and eventually revealing things in a straightforward way. While it definitely does not hold anybody's hands, if you're paying attention everything is shown at the right time and there's no BS pulls out of nowhere. Obviously, it's a mystery show, so you're not meant to get everything at the start, but it does a great job at presenting to the audience exactly what they mean to, and showing a focused, crisp storyline.

Chris Collier

He should give you a magic item for that tbh

Eiríkur Eiríksson

First I'd ask why the hell he gave it a 7/10 because the show is a pretty solid 9/10 and sets the bar pretty high for any anime you'd watch after- if it was your first anime anyways.

HBelmont67

I have tried getting into it multiple times and it just hasn't stuck. Some things just don't jive with some people. Though, my reason is that I already know too much to get invested.

HBelmont67

I think you're a teeny bit biased, Kenny lol

MaSeshield9277

He is right unfortunately. It's maybe an 8.5 at best tbh.

HBelmont67

Kenny should be petty and ask for an Enlarge potion. 🤣🤣

Cyan_Sky9135

There was a time, long long ago, when I almost joined a party in DnD. It consisted of a few of my irl friends but I did not know the DM. I created a monk character. The DM killed him off before my first session. In hindsight, probably because they were in the middle of a campaign. Best to start from the beginning😅. Anyway the one thing my friend told me before I play is to never question what the DM says.

HBelmont67

Thank you for your honesty. I, too, think Attack on Titan's writing and plot is a bit . . . overwhelming.

Phoenix_mercury

Depends on how they rate other shows of a similar nature, if they're not usually a fan of such then fair otherwise 👀👀

Jinchuriki87

I mean, depending on who you ask they may have a solid feeling of wanting to give AoT that rating. I get why many would easily rate it higher...but I can also see why some may not rate it quite as high. If you'd told me the score was 5 or below...then I'd say it's time to question things. But a 7 is still an understandable score.