Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Something about this new spell, created for Adventures Great and Glorious, has me worried, and I wanted to get your opinion.

Do you think this is too powerful?

It was written with mass combat (one of the elements of the AGG book) in mind. The problem is, I'm afraid this could completely overwhelm a typical dungeon game. Bearing in mind that it's a 6th level spell (and castable by 12th level illusionists), so it would only show up in a pretty high-powered game to begin with, but I'm afraid it might be open to abuse in situations other than mass combat.

What do you think?

Files

Previews only

Comments

Greyhawk_Grognard

I should add that the soldiers created will only have 1d2 hit points, and be 0 level.

Anonymous

You could put in verbiage that said it was created from the enemies shadows, so you could only create as many as the force it was facing to begin with?

Anonymous

Sorry I only know 5e, but the mental image people have today of wizards is of one who casts fireballs and lightning bolts, and one who focuses on illusions is almost a failed caster. In reality spells like phantasmal force and hypnotic pattern are very strong in their own way, so it's always nice to see some illusion spells that have some punch.

Anonymous

I think it's too much. I can see its utility for a war-game but I guarantee it would get used in dungeons all the time, provoking endless DM headaches. Either add some language to prevent its use in small-scale environments or make this a higher level shadow army and create a weaker demi-shadow variant. I think you should assume it'll get used in dungeons and find a way to keep everyone sane.

Anonymous

I agree. Mind you, if they only have 1d2hp and be 0 level, that almost wraps it up for me. But undoubtedly it will get used in dungeons. In the context of a 1E/AD&D/AGG rules frame, I'd go with the environmental limitations (open areas, etc, yes, small-scale verboten), rather than making it even higher level.

Christopher Bishop

Make it a ritual type spell. Something that either requires another illusionist or a prolonged cast and then maintain concentration period. Something like that would not be practical in a dungeon but in a tent on the cusp of the battlefield or perched upon a tower or battlements surrounded by shields or walls, it works.