Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Happy September my friends!

As promised, here is an exclusive Patron-only video for you all. Please let me know what you think in the comments, and any ideas/requests for future topics are more than welcome.

Thanks,

Joe

Files

Previews only

Patreon 2109 From the Ashes

Please visit my blog, which has a lot more and different content (including a bunch of free downloads): http://www.greyhawkgrognard.com If you like what you see, please consider supporting me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Greyhawk_Grognard And, finally, you can straight-up purchase RPG books I've written at the BRW Games online store: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/browse/pub/3728/BRW-Games "Maple Leaf Rag" used in the intro is licensed through Haven Sound, Inc. Proof available upon request.

Comments

Earl Rumburg

I find myself mostly agreeing with your assessment of 'From the Ashes'. I think it did indeed serve two purposes. One to alienate Gary from the setting and also to move toward the 'storytelling' aspect of the game.

Earl Rumburg

It seems iirc, that TSR/Wizards was trying to move more toward role-playing and less toward combat. The games I ran during this time were usually with players who preferred character development over combat. Not to say they didn't enjoy it, they just preferred the storytelling aspects. I found it a little discouraging that they decided to put out so many sourcebooks at the time. The massive amount of content is what soured me on the Realms at the time. I found I preferred the simplicity of the Gold Box, and settings such as Dragonlance, to the overload of material they came out with. There were a LOT of developments and changes to absorb and it could be quite overwhelming to players and DMs who were already adventuring in the world. A lot of that was my young self not realizing that I could 'throw out' things I didn't like. I tried to incorporate some changes, but, in the end, gave up in favor of a return to 576 cy. Still, there was a lot of good information there, and re-reading 'From the Ashes' years later softened my views of it considerably.

Greyhawk_Grognard

I'd probably say "exploration" rather than combat. Some of the FtA-era modules were very combat heavy; just look at something like Patriots of Ulek, or even Greyhawk Ruins, which even though it does have traps and puzzles, is quite a combat-centric adventure in a lot of places.

Earl Rumburg

True enough. I actually ran part of Greyhawk Ruins for my group at the time. I was excited for a dungeon crawl, but they quickly wanted more mission based play, so we moved on.

Anonymous

Great video! I appreciate the high-level perspective on the two boxed sets. The ‘exploration’ vs ‘plot-driven’ orientations is a helpful framework. I also like how you’re able to revisit your thoughts on things, especially as you do more research (like how the Dragon Magazine articles that advanced the timeline gave you a new appreciation for how From the Ashes advanced the timeline). I didn’t think I’d have a topic to suggest for a future video, but then something popped into my head: Valley of the Mage / Vale of the Mage The reason it came to mind was that the “Vale of the Mage” product came up a few times in the “Ask the Experts” Twitch discussion you were a part of at the end of Virtual Greyhawk Con 2021. I can’t recall if you chimed in on that topic during the discussion, but if not, I wondered what your take on it might be? For instance, how would you expand on (or do something cool with) the Valley of the Mage, if you were going to incorporate it into a campaign? And how might you leverage whatever material was published on it, without just tossing it aside? I searched your blog for “Valley of the Mage” and “Vale of the Mage” to make sure you hadn’t already covered the topic. In fact, on that search, I discovered that OJ #18 did a big Gazetteer entry on that area. I’m not sure how the OJ #18 article relates to the LG Gazetteer entry on the same topic. I haven’t researched any of this myself. Anyways, not a pressing topic. Just a random idea :)

Greyhawk_Grognard

You know, I haven't really delved into the Valley. There are three versions as far as I can tell; the Gygax version (in the Gazetteer and Gord the Rogue novels), the TSR version, and I might be misremembering, but I thought Rob Kuntz's Xaene adventures were also linked to it (although they're set in the Great Kingdom). Might well be worth a look. Thanks!