Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello my patrons! I am pleased to present this month's exclusive video, in which I compare two wildly divergent novels set in the World of Greyhawk. As always, your feedback is more than welcome, and ideas for more videos too!

Files

Previews only

Patreon 2110 Comparing Two Greyhawk Novels

Want more Greyhawk and OSR content? Check out the links below. Free downloads on the blog! Blog: http://www.greyhawkgrognard.com Store: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/browse/pub/3728/BRW-Games Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Greyhawk_Grognard

Comments

Anonymous

I Couldn't agree more Joe! AtG was dog poop, WPM was amazing. In fact, of the 7 Greyhawk books from that era/series, in my opinion all 3 Paul Kidd books were great, and the rest were all horrible (though Tomb of Horrors was passable at least). Note for fans of the Paul Kidd novels/characters, there are two short stories with those characters in different issues of Dragon magazine. Both great stories. I forget the plot of one, but the other is how The Justicar meets Cinders.

Greyhawk_Grognard

One was in issue 271, and the other in 278. I had quite forgotten them; now I have to go back and re-read them. :-)

Anonymous

Thanks for the tip, Marc (and Joe), on those Dragon magazine short stories. Didn't realize there were related stories there :)

Anonymous

I have all those novels from that era. I don’t think I ever got around to reading the Against the Giants story. If I ever do, I will now go into it with appropriately low expectations ;) My wife and I did, however, read all those Paul Kidd novels, back in the day. My wife isn’t really a gamer — she likes the sword-and-sorcery genre and tried a bit of D&D with me for a stretch, but role-playing games are just not her thing ;) That being said, she absolutely loved those Paul Kidd novels. To this day, we’ll throw around references to “the Justicar” from time to time, though maybe more as a concept than the particular character – but it still always conjures images of the character in the back of our minds. He’s basically the picture next to the word “justicar” in our mind’s dictionary entry ;) Since Marc mentioned the “Tomb of Horrors” novel as passable, I’ll go ahead and throw in my own enthusiastic thumbs up for that one. That was my favorite of all those novels. Very different mood than the Justicar novels – a very moody, gritty atmosphere – and I loved the characterization of the main character and the arc of his journey. I have a terrible memory in general, but I’m pretty sure the main villain was pretty grim and gritty, as well — especially in the chapter that introduces him. Thanks, Joe, for the trip down memory lane ;)