Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Please take a few minutes to watch this month's Patreon-only video before answering the poll below. There's a fuller explanation there.

What do you think about doing a Greyhawk-specific RPG? Bear in mind that all the specifics (system, format, etc.) are up in the air. 

Comments

Anonymous

How would this be any different than Adventures Dark & Deep?

Greyhawk_Grognard

Adventures Dark and Deep is a generic RPG that can be used in any setting. I'm thinking of something that specifically ties the setting into the mechanics somehow. Just an example, there might be no generic clerics; every cleric is a specialty priest of a GH deity. Monsters descriptions specifically tie them to locations in the Flanaess. Stuff like that. (There's a fuller description of the concept in the video, be sure to watch it.)

Rich Spainhour

Heck yeah. I'm in if it flies w/the rest of the patrons.

Anonymous

I don't really see the need, as I tend to dislike setting-specific RPG's. I find genre-specific works very well, but setting-specific tends to be less useful. Having said that, if the community says they want it, I'd love to be involved. So, I said "no" above, but the answer is really "yes, if the community wants it."

Anonymous

My first thought was "this is a great idea!" but then I thought "what game mechanic do I really need to be Greyhawk-specific?" and I couldn't find any. For now AD&D 1e has everything I need to run my Greyhawk games. What's more, I think AD&D 1e was made for Greyhawk. For now, I'll stand on the sidelines supporting but ready to jump in if there's anything that catches my eye.

Anonymous

I think the already available material is more than adequate. Most people who even know the name "Greyhawk" will be people familiar with some edition or editions of D&D, and will have the materials necessary to run games, or be happy to make use of the great new material being produced by many enthusiasts (including you!)

Anonymous

I hesitate in suggesting that the rule mechanics (1sr edition) are for the most part sufficient in my estimation only because I love the the roll for initiative mechanic you employed with the use of a D10 dice with modifiers and I have little doubt that there would be a variety of worthy pursuits with this project. That being said, I know you are likely not interested in another supplement, but there is a lot to digest with respect to the World of Greyhawk, well beyond fighting monsters and bandits. If there was guide to all things Greyhawk that included a timeline of events and captured how a variety of factions interact or look to dominate one another along with the political intr it might go a long way in enabling DM's and players a way to influence the greater world around them and how might certain modules could play out in the larger context. I know much material exists with respect to these topics but you do an excellent job of capturing how factions interact and how those interactions could impact the greater world around players/DM's. In the end I say do as you will I have little doubt it will be excellent.

Greyhawk_Grognard

I do have something else in mind as a "Plan B" that is more in line with what you're suggesting in terms of timeline. I want to give the other patrons a chance to weigh in before I go too far on it, though.

Anonymous

makes perfect sense

Anonymous

I think it is a brilliant idea but I would want it to be more descriptive than rules based. One of the biggest problems is that there is so many rules and not enough descriptions.

Anonymous

I second the timeline and in-depth guide to lore, etc. plan B. I would much prefer that to a setting specific RPG.

Anonymous

I ‘third’ the the timeline and in-depth guide to Greyhawk lore idea (i.e., plan B). I would much prefer that to a Greyhawk-specific RPG. I’m already quite stressed about the fact that various Greyhawk publications over the years are couched within different rules editions. In order for me to use any given publication (like a module, for example), I need to decide whether to convert it to whatever rules edition I’d prefer to play in, or else switch to playing the rules system that that module was originally written for. Yet another rules system seems like it would sink us further into that quagmire. Then again, I may not have the correct understanding of what’s being envisioned here ;) On the flip side, I’ve been slowly cataloguing various Greyhawk resources (mainly modules, so far), based on the Greyhawk timeline. In other words, I’m trying to track what year (or within what window of years) each adventure was understood to have taken place within the published flow of history. I’m also trying to track what regions (or possible regions) each adventure takes place in. Another detail to include would be: which adventures are dependent on which earlier adventures. So the plan B idea seems like it would be immensely helpful, and something that I could throw my 2 or 3 cents into ;) But as others have said, I’m open to what the rest of the community thinks is best :)