Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's that time again! There's certainly no shortage of discussion points for the latest edition of the show. We'll be talking - of course - about the crazy happenings at Microsoft and its unfathomable decision to close down two highly respected developers. We'll also be discussing Nintendo's confirmation that Switch 2 actually exists (!) along with the latest tech specs rumours to emerge, and if there's anything interesting with the ROG Ally reveal, we'll definitely be discussing that.

Other topics in line for discussion? We're considering talking about the Helldivers 2 PSN debacle (which seems like a million years ago now, right?), PC Hellblade 2 recommended specs and - if I can find the time - I'll take a quick look at the latest Lossless Scaling update with its new frame generation upgrade.

But, of course, the show is nothing without Supporter input, so please feel free to share your comments on the topics above, suggestions for further topics and... well, just any other questions you'd like to put to the team.

Thanks in advance and have a good day!

Files

Comments

GetFisher

With studio closures rife at the moment, what do you think prospects will be like for future game development graduates as they are now competing for fewer jobs with a market flooded by laid off devs

Macky Dee

Like everyone, I’m baffled and angry about the MS studio closures - especially after Tango delivered an all-timer with Hi-Fi Rush. Thoughts with all those impacted. Do you think all this represents an admission of the failure or unsustainablity of the Game Pass model? The only reason I think the profound compromises of Game Pass (lack of ownership, monthly cost) were worth it is if it was funding interesting games outside the “Triple A” model. Hi-Fi Rush was very much the ideal of that model, but now its studio is unceremoniously shuttered despite apparent success. The beginning of the end, or at least the beginning of a major watering down of Game Pass?

Hank D.

Hello DF team, Not too long ago we were celebrating the success of xbox lineup for the current year, I guess this must be devastating for all developers being shutdown as well for all gamers across the board. I wanted to ask if we are still having any upside to all of this in the future? Are we expecting more studios closures across Activision Blizzard? Thanks for the wonderful work everyone.

Perfect_Organism

I know you lads clearly have connections within the gaming world, and probably know things before they become public knowledge. I’ve seen a couple news outlets reporting about last weeks direct and the PS5 Pro news you shared around its CPU. Are you able to give any insider insight into how you decide when to share information you’re privy to and when not to?

GreenSwede

As more depressing layoffs continue to happen in this industry at an alarming rate, is it realistic to expect to see some actual responsibility for the people in charge? I understand that this issue is a lot bigger and isn't just exclusive to video game development but it feels soulcrushing to see the artists who actually make the games happen get axed whereas top leading management oftentimes get out scot-free with yearly bonuses to boot. In my view this approach of business isn't and *shouldn't* be feasible in the slightest.

ConcreteLlama

I've been invested in Xbox since the very original, and while I also game on other platforms, I've always been an Xbox fan at heart. I want to see them do well and offer a strong alternative to PlayStation. They've made some missteps for sure but I've still stuck by them, excited by their potential - and it seemed like things were finally starting to come together. But after the recent news about the closures of Arkane Austin and Tango Gameworks, all I can think right now is... "fuck Microsoft". I had hoped that the acquisitions in combination with Game Pass would mean that they could take more risks on games that may not have otherwise been comercially successful. HiFi Rush seemed to be an example of that and I was quite excited that we'd see more original content like it. But apparently Microsoft is just a big, rich black hole where good studios go to die. I know that Microsoft aren't the only company doing this but buying a developer, praising their output then shutting them down despite the fact they clearly have money to throw around? It just feels so callous. I sincerely hope they don't buy any more studios. I just don't trust them any more.

1040STF

It's an awful week for the victims of the Xbox layoffs but as of today, I can't help thinking it might go deeper than that. Xbox closed two studios dear to the heart of their players base, to reviewers, to everyone in fact, based on what we can assume is just "money". Last week Rich, you were still reporting how Xbox business seemed very "healthy". Well, that aged quickly and badly. First, I think they broke the trust. Especially Phil Spencer. And that's a big issue for the future of Xbox. Secondly, it underlines how wrong the biggest part of the industry is going. Most decisions of growth are not made around creative ideas now it seems, decisions are just made to create growth of money. It might have worked for some years - namely the PS2, PS3 and PS4 eras - but the amount of money in jeopardy are becoming an issue it seems. Even Nintendo's board seems to be forced to explain and defend Nintendo's model to their shareholders every time their growth is lower - remember when their shareholders asked them to put Mario and Zelda on other plateformes during the dark years of the Wii U. And I wonder how long Nintendo will be able to handle this as their productions costs will obviously rise with new technologies (4K, Ray Tracing, etc). Only Valve seems healthy as a big plateforme. They don't have shareholders so they grow only when they have a new creative idea, like the Steam Deck. Imagine if Valve had shareholders: the SteamDeck would have been just one idea among multiple ideas for growth and it might have gone differently. I think more and more the industry needs to be more healthier. Independent developers are showing the way I think as their creative ambitions grow, as for exemple we went from Super Meat Boy to No Rest for the Wicked in 14 years. But even indies should be careful as I think a company like Tango GameWorks or Arkane would have enjoyed the success of their games if they stayed independent. It would have been harder, sure. But more healthier in the end as we can witness today.

Adam (TDM)

Regardless of what they said in Feb about future hardware, a lot seems to be changing quickly, and Xbox as platform and a software ecosystem feels like it's trapped in a death spiral. The idea of OeMs making boxes for them seems reminiscent of the last ditch "Dreamcast on a chip in DVD players" cope that we saw on message boards at the turn of the millennium. Do you think they will even try to fight their way out given how much of a hole they seem to be digging themselves into, or just ride this into the sunset while reducing investments and pivoting to being a pure 3p publisher?

Gentlemonster Jones

Given Microsoft's OS-focus, how viable would it be for them to offer an 'Xbox OS' for 3rd party manufacturers to use in their own handhelds/consoles/PCs/TVs and so on? Something a bit like Android or Chrome OS as a platform, where devices able to deliver a minimum level of performance certified as a Xbox-compatible (with access to Game Pass, profiles, digital libraries, etc. ) Could it help Microsoft deliver a scalable range of devices for every price-point or would it create too many variations for Developers to manage and too much testing/support for Microsoft to cope with?

Mevlud Sabashvili

Hi DF Crew! Question about Microsoft closing those studios: WTF?

Diecou

It's been a while since the first and only DF Indirect. I fear I might miss it as I don't trust the instant notifications to be instant. Will there be another episode or it'll be stuck in development hell to never see the light of day like Star Wars 1313?

Mr Codders

Hi team, continuing on with the Nintendo switch 2 roumer train, what software changes would you like to see added/modified. Personally I think achievements and voice chat should be included. What are your thoughts?

AshesBoomstick

Hello DF team, I hope you're having a lovely day! With the overwhelming backlash of the Hell Divers 2 PSN kerfuffle, it seems like Sony doesn't quote GET unquote that there are distinct differences with the PC gaming community, both with its users, and the infrastructure as a whole, compared to consoles. It's hard to imagine that the money-grubbing execs responsible for the PSN login rule weren't thinking about how many countries can use Steam, yet cannot legally create a PSN account due to geographic location. Does this send out another warning to gamers about the precarious nature of digital gaming non-ownership? In what ways will this influence Sony's decisions for future PC game releases, and their relationship with Steam in general?

GreenSwede

Alleged Switch "2" leaks from manufacturing is starting to pop up online, and it alleges that it will have 12 GB of LPDDR5 RAM. Assuming that this information is accurate, does 12 GB sound like a good enough amount of RAM for developers considering that Xbox Series X and PS5 is using 16 GB? Would developers have to make more obvious development sacrifices for multiplatform Switch "2" releases?

Mekagnome

At the time, I felt that Microsoft’s purchase of Activision was good for both companies. Microsoft would have a big addition to their Game Pass catalog and would hopefully revive other non-COD franchises. I feel these recent studio closures are a knock on effect of Microsoft spending so much money on the acquisition, and they now seem to only care about the largest titles. I see now that all this consolidation is wrong, and I’m afraid for all of Microsoft’s smaller studios.

Piotr Bakiewicz

Following on from your discussion last week on the state of the console industry, I wondered whether this situation was by chance caused by a short-sighted business decision to extend cross gen. If you think about it, previously you had to buy new hardware to play new games almost instantly, but we are almost 4 years into this generation and only now are things starting to appear that are exclusive to the next generation. So why bother with new hardware when I can use my current one? Pro consoles have made things even more complicated. On the other hand just look at Nintendo - no cross-gen and almost 140 million Switches sold. Makes you think. On a side note - I have just bought my first PVM, thus joining the CRT Legion! I hope John's proud of me! Love you all, keep up the good work!

Pol Kallamata

With the unravelling of the GamePass model and Microsoft's mega acquisition gambit, as seen through the recent sales decline and studio closures, which of the two paths do you see as more likely? A) Xbox finally starts to "copy how to get gud gaymes" from the quintuple. B) Phil Spencer just cooks up some new hair brained scheme.

alexrdavies

Microsoft say they will look for some talented studios who could produce more content in the Fallout and Elder Scrolls universes. It's so hard to find effective dev teams at the moment. Can you think of any great studios at a loose end they could have used for this?

DaJaCo (Dan)

In the wake of further devastating lay-offs and studio closures from Microsoft, I have to wonder whether the Game Pass model itself is flawed. It certainly seems that way to me - for example - assuming I'm not going to use some Xbox Live code conversion deal, or buy a code from a different country in a cheaper currency - I can pay just £12.99 - complete a brand new AAA £60 game in a month, and then end my membership until the next one comes along. Even if I take a leisurely 2 months, I've played it for less than half price. Why would I stay signed up indefinitely between games I'm interested in, and how is this financially sustainable? PS - which Xbox wordsmith's baby earns the highest accolade - "adorably all digital" or "feel the burn" ?

Leftisthominid

When will we see Will once again on DF Direct? I enjoy seeing all the random tech boxes in his background and trying to guess what they are.

Leftisthominid

A while back, you did a video comparing streaming quality on xCloud and PS Plus. I was wondering if you had any plans to do a comparison of in-home streaming on these devices. Late last year, I used to the Backbone with my Galaxy S22 Ultra to stream from my Xbox. I was only doing an NG+ of Persona 5R this way, but I did not notice any major issues. I am curious if either machine is better at in-home streaming. (My Xbox and PS5 are hardwired into my network).

sj33 (Jake)

Hi all, With the appalling news from Microsoft this week, we’re faced with an unfathomable situation where the company with the biggest market cap on the planet somehow can’t find the spare change to keep open relatively small studios like Tango Gameworks and Arkane Austin. This is clearly a nonsense, and really suggests that we need to be paying more attention to the most bloodsucking, venomous stain on our industry - shareholders. For too long, gamers have gotten the blame for the industry’s woes - it’s all our fault because we like big AAA games, it’s all our fault because we struggle to justify £70 for a non-essential luxury, it’s all our fault because we like to buy things on sale. It’s all because we aren’t giving enough of our money, apparently. Yet look at the destruction being wrought by shareholders across the industry- be it at Microsoft or Embracer. It doesn’t matter how successful a studio is, how many copies they sell, how many awards they win, if you’re not achieving perpetual growth, growth, growth, you’re for the chop. Why isn’t it enough for a studio to simply be self-sustaining, achieving their creative goals and keeping the lights on? They just don’t care as long as they’re getting perpetual return on their ‘investment’. Just think - it could be id Software next! That would be a crime of cultural vandalism against our hobby, but they wouldn’t care one bit. I’m so thankful that Valve is a private company so doesn’t have this issue, though fear the day that Gabe passes. Sorry for the emotive rant, but for too long gamers have gotten the brunt of the criticism when it is leeching shareholders causing the creative death of our (our, not their) industry.

andre surles

Gentle Gents, If you all were actually cats, what kind of cat food would you prefer?

SirLankyIII

Hi All, You've probably got enough xbox questions this week so instead here's a repost from a couple weeks ago! It's becoming increasingly obvious that proper CPU utilisation is a major problem, Dragon's Dogma 2 being the most recent culprit. We most often think about it in terms of gaming in this community, but commercial software isn't immune. I use Solidworks extensively in my day job and it's notoriously (frustratingly) single threaded in almost all aspects. We often put the blame for these issues down to the software developer, but i've been wondering, how much of this is just a limitation of CPU architecture in general and are CPUs themselves holding us back? Do we need new hardware architectures to save us from CPU limitations. Maybe NPUs are our saviours? Or will they be too specialised like GPUs?

Jiruuino

Hey DF crew, are you familiar with the compression techniques used by cloud gaming services like xCloud and GeForce Now? If so, how is the 48 Gb/s bandwidth of a raw 4k120Hz video signal compressed to a 400 Mb/s stream in real-time? What kind of artefacts are commonly the result of this compression? Could some of these compression techniques be used in a way to further improve the quality of the upscaling algorithm like dlss and fsr as well? Thanks and keep up the great work!

VeryProfessionalDodo

Can’t agree more, I’m still infuriated by this decision. How has this not been a wake up call that there is something completely rotten at the core of Microsoft’s strategy? Is this a Game Pass fault? Surely making all these acquisition to drive subscriber growth was never a sustainable proposition, right? Or the expectation that all these games should be on the service Day 1? There is no way that Game Pass did not cannibalise sales of Starfield, for example. And to have all of this happen after a 70 billion dollar acquisition? This is more than absolutely preposterous, this should be illegal. I worry for all those smaller studios that find even less success than these.

VeryProfessionalDodo

Absolutely, there is no way that all these AAA releases at launch on a subscription don’t cannibalise sales. In my mind it’s impossible that they do the same stunt with Call of Duty. They generate too much reliable, consistent revenue to even test out it would pan out to have it day 1 on Game Pass. And if they do putting it there on Day 1, will the lost revenue put other smaller companies on the chopping block?

MGsubbie

What the heck is going on at Xbox?! Spends billions on acquiring developers and publishers because 1st party is lacking.... Plans on staying multiplatform anyway. Shuts down studios and doesn't seem to want to do anything with their IP's. What was the point of spending that many billions of dollars?

DaJaCo (Dan)

Sadly I think there needs to be some kind of compromise - like if you want Day 1 releases - you are tied to the subscription for a few months minimum.

VeryProfessionalDodo

Another Xbox related rant. I think that Day 1 Game Pass additions are a net negative for the entire industry (including indie), and catastrophic for Microsoft Studios, and I'm almost certain we're going to see the living proof of it in the next month. How can Microsoft think that spending at least over 75 billion (!!!) dollars, and then put their games on a subscription immediately is not going to be a disaster? They have the statistics, they KNOW that subscriber growth is plateauing, so they're not making more money than they already did. If Call of Duty does not go to Game Pass Day 1 (which it absolutely SHOULD NOT GO), it's evidence they know this. What pisses me off is that so many good studios are caught in the crossfire of these fucking business decisions. If you're that strapped for cash to justify SHUTTING DOWN STUDIOS, not even laying off part of the staff, how did you think spending 70 billions on ABK was sustainable? I'm just infuriated with this decision, and I worry for all the smaller studios that might not make mega sales. Who's next, Turn 10? Double Fine?

Some Guy

I've been a fan of Xbox for a long time - it's been my preferred ecosystem for two decades and even when they've stumbled I've always found myself rooting for them. This week's news has really crushed that. It seems clear Gamepass is failing. Between the lack of disclosure on subscriber numbers, rumors some previously expected games may not be "Day 1", and layoffs a few months ago, this week, and talk of more to come, it seems the model just isn't sustainable. In and of itself that's something I'd have mixed feelings about. I don't love the subscription model, but it was innovative and Xbox invested heavily in it. However, this week's studio closures point to a more profound issue. It feels as though Xbox's lack of first party content isn't because these things take time and investment, but rather because Xbox just doesn't get it. It seems Xbox leadership is plagued by the same ailment that befalls a number of tech executives: they've become so focused on pursuit of a particular type of product and a particular operating model they've lost sight of the foundation of their business. They've lost the North Star of "making good games is how you be a good game making company." One would think Arkane would be trusted to return to form based on their track record, but at least in the most cutthroat sense they have a recent failure to point to. But Tango? This was a relatively small studio fresh off a critically acclaimed game that, in Xbox's own words, "was a breakout hit for us in every key metric", and did so without marketing expenses or physical distribution costs. If they can't figure out how to make money to fund that, I'm not sure how they make a compelling case they should get any more of mine or anyone else's. I'm finding it exceedingly difficult to articulate an actual question here, but... your thoughts?

Austin Cade

What are your favorite immsims are why is it Prey (2017)?

(Don’t be a) Richard

With all the negative press surrounding Xbox and what appears to be an increasing erosion of their customer bases trust and support, is it time for a leadership change over at Xbox? It feels like Phil’s tenure has been a story of two halves. One where the first five years he built a lot of good will following the Don Matrick period (retiring Kinect, GamePass, BC, One X etc) but the last five years has represented nothing but squandered opportunity. Around 2017 MS didn’t have the market share, but it had the enthusiasm of many gamers. Now they seem to be lacking both. How can they get back the excitement and identity that surrounded the team when they defied the market and shipped the 360 to acclaim, silencing everyone that had written them off with the previous Xbox release. They need another lightning in a bottle moment, and I’m not sure the current leadership can provide that.

VeryProfessionalDodo

Don't forget Arkane did Prey as well as Dishonored, both critically acclaimed games. But yeah, Tango is THE reason this is particularly brutal. They could have justified Arkane Austin with Redfall, but Tango just released Hi-Fi Rush, which they themselves claimed a success. And it just now hit the PS5, so who knows how much that would have changed the argument.

Zero

Hi DF Team! Gaming community question for you all, what do you make of the fact that gaming enthusiasts seem so unknowledgeable about how games work (both technically and creatively/from a business standpoint) compared to enthusiasts in other areas? For example, you wouldn't catch a car enthusiast not knowing how an engine works! You all see it all the time with your coverage being taken out of context and conclusions shared with little understanding of their real meaning. Would love to hear your thoughts and keep up the great work!

Eric Benoit

If I controlled Microsoft and fired Phil Spencer on day one, and on day two I filled his position with a member of DF direct, what would be your first moves to halt and reverse the tsunami of bad press?

VeryProfessionalDodo

Late-stage capitalism of perpetual growth should be abolished at this point. However, by law, a company is forced to make as much money to share holders as they can once they go public, so now we live with the consequences of that

VeryProfessionalDodo

I feel like the true end of Game Pass as we know it will be if they do not release Call of Duty day 1 on GP. I'm hoping they abandon the idea of Day 1 releases, and if it has to start with Call of Duty for them to see this, so be it

VeryProfessionalDodo

I agree, and the way it is currently is unsustainable, we're seeing proof of that time and time again

lbb12

I was hoping by the time a game like Metro Exodus and NVIDIA's open sourcing PhysX awhile ago (as well as continual extinction of dev support for it) that an AMD GPU user/based console would allow the use of its features by now, or am I wrong? Will we ever see a PhysX enhanced title run with those features turned ON for AMD someday (patched-in/updated to run)? I sincerely appreciate your input 😄👍

wildwildwesty

Hello founders, I often observe a recurring argument among gamers that video cards with less than 16GB of VRAM will soon become obsolete. This viewpoint is particularly aimed at cards with 8-10GB of VRAM, with many advising against their purchase to avoid a lack of future-proofing and redundancy in just a couple of years. However, with current PC games like Hellblade 2 recommending 8GB of VRAM for high settings 1440p gaming, there appears to be little evidence supporting this claim. Moreover, with technologies such as DLSS, we're seeing more value from lower VRAM capacities than ever before. NVIDIA in particular has demonstrated that it’s not how much VRAM you have but what you do with it that counts. What’s your take on the longevity of these types of video cards?

Thomas Trala

Hey DF Team - I know we are all wondering which studio is next on the MS chopping block. Do you think Doublefine is safe? Their documentary showed MS coming in and saving the day when they were out of money so that would definitely be awful if they decided to shut them down.

Tamerator

Hi DF gentlemen, do you think the recent Microsoft game studio closures mark the end of medium size developers? Do studios like Ninja Theory, Obsidian, Double Fine, id, and Machine-Games have a chance of survival as Microsoft focuses on maximizing its revenue? Can some of these studios survive by going indie and attempt a similar route as Toys for Bob?

Kellan Sandifer

Should the next gen consoles focus more on RAM pool size ( 40GB or 64GB of memory) and Memory bandwidth. As that seems to be the big issue with Series S instead of the latest greatest GPU and CPU

DaJaCo (Dan)

In CPU terms, pretty much - but in GPU terms, no - the jump from RDNA 2 to RDNA 3, along with additional compute units - takes the floating point performance to 32.5 TF vs Series X's 12TF. Couple this with more memory bandwidth, faster SSD, a better API and a hardware supported bespoke upscaler (PSSR), along with ray-tracing features likely borrowed from RDNA 4 - and it'll produce games that look significantly better (especially in terms of image clarity and ray tracing features) with very little additional work from developers.

DaJaCo (Dan)

Nevermind the optics, sort the business model first!

Rich

I think it's highly likely many of these studios would have closed down with or without Microsoft. At least Arkane Austin.

MGsubbie

Fitting in that much memory at such memory bandwidth is going to be extremely challenging. Larger memory controller taking up more die space, as well as the amount of traces that need to run between memory chips and the SoC, will be limiting factors. 30-36GB would be more doable, 10-12 3GB modules. Unless they want to go clamshell, but that would be so many chips.

Rich

I don't see any evidence of the unravelling of the game pass model per se. Game Pass apparently makes Microsoft billions per year.

Rich

Game development isn't a charity or a jobs program. Just has to be said.

DudleyTheGentleman

With recent discussions on Nvidia's technologies such as NRC and SHARC, I'm wondering if RTX Remix will eventually become the premier way to showcase Nvidia specific, non-vendor agnostic, technologies? Though SHARC specifically is vendor agnostic, NRC looks like a very interesting technology that I'm wondering if Nvidia will have trouble convincing devs to implement? Their true showcase title, CP2077, is no longer under active development. A separate question, what does DF think about the upcoming release of REDkit for the Witcher 3? Do you think that CDPR will go tht extra mile and provide the same level of modding SDK for CP2077?

Rich

I don't see any evidence that Game Pass itself is hurting Microsoft or developers. Game Pass generates billions of dollars for both the platform and Developers on it (Microsoft pays huge money to Developers for each game on Game Pass on top of everything else). I see lots of people jumping to this conclusion, but with no real evidence. It's more likely that consoles in general are shrinking relative to PC, while Xbox's share of the console market is shrinking within that - with or without Game Pass.

Rich

Games are a business. Game development is not a charity or a jobs program. It's likely that some of these studios were simply not profitable and would have been shut down regardless of ownership. Every other industry operates with shareholders, they aren't mere parasites, shareholders are INVESTORS too! It isn't unreasonable to expect growth when GAMING IS ACTUALLY GROWING. It's just that consoles aren't keeping pace with PC and Xbox isn't keeping pace with Sony within that. The need of a company to actually make money isn't a conspiracy, it's how life works and has always worked.

Rich

I don't think Microsoft is strapped for cash, it's literally the richest company on Earth. Studios are getting shut down because they aren't profitable. I don't think Game Pass has much to do with it either, and there's no evidence that Game Pass is a "disaster."

Rich

The Arkane that did Prey is essentially a completely different studio than the Arkane Austin that was just shut down. There was a 70% turnover rate internally.

Travesty Stutter

Hi DF team (exclamation mark). While the human impact of the Xbox studio closures cannot be understated, there is another line in Matt Booty's statement which I find even more troubling (as a gamer).  Matt describes the closures as part of their strategy of "...prioritizing high-impact titles ... and further investing in Bethesda's portfolio of blockbuster games...". These words - which seem to indicate an increased focus on big AAA games with big budgets and development timelines - echo sentiments from execs throughout the industry, such as Square Enix who said something similar while writing-off $140,000,000 in "content abandonment" losses a couple weeks ago.  Meanwhile, indie devs have taken up the slogan "survive till '25" as they face a drought of funding for their relatively tiny games.  Do you think these facts indicate a new, even more risk-averse direction of travel for the industry as a whole, or is this all simply a "phase" that will pass when the economic situation in the industry and economy as a whole is in better shape?

Rich

There was never any evidence for this claim. In my opinion this was a cope from AMD users to justify their purchase over an Nvidia product. No one is requiring you to play on max settings anyway.

Diego ElRey

Hello all, I've been wondering about the proposed XBOX handheld. How could it not be another streaming device? If this is a dedicated machine, then XBOX games (if there are any after this week's news) will have to target 3 different versions, with the handheld version being lesser than even the Series S version. The Series S is already known to hamstring devs, so how much worse could it be to have to target that mobile platform? Also, if Series consoles aren't doing that great, what chance does this device have in the market, compared to the Steamdeck, ROG Ally and such? I understand it would likely have well integrated UI, with a closer to 'plug-and-play' experience, but you're then stuck on XBOX, which those other handhelds can do, plus they have access to Steam, and other stores. The final question begs, what's the point?

AGSMA

Hi DF. Given this week's news, I sense an eruption of the Wrath of Linneman in this episode. If I was invested in the industry as much as you guys do, I would probably snap out and wish misery to the usual suspects in order to avenge their victims. That being said, I encourage John to rip out the proverbial shirt and express his most primal outcry so that Phil Spencer, Matt Booty, Jim Ryan and the like, can feel complete shivers down their spines at a distance. Thanks, and have a nice weekend.

M

Dear DF Gentlefolk, Given all of the rumors and hype of 4K switch with ray tracing, 60fps gaming as powerful as an Xbox Series S in your pocket, and all the other overblown craziness out there, is it possible that we're actually underestimating the potential power of the Switch 2 and the impact it will have on the industry? Stay with me. Let's say that the Switch 2 is, at best, as powerful as a Steam Deck. Even with some rudimentary form of DLSS added, on its face that doesn't sound particularly overwhelming especially in light of the rumors we've heard and the ever increasing availability of PC handhelds. They generally tend to be large and very power hungry, and in the grand scheme not anywhere near as successful as the Switch. So when the talk turns to Switch 2, we're comparing the state of gaming to what currently exists in PC handhelds and saying there's really not much of anything Nintendo can do to produce meaningful mobile hardware for Switch 2, especially because it's Nintendo who haven't really gone for anything resembling cutting edge ever since the GameCube. So with all of that said, the advantage, AND difference, that Nintendo has is that game companies (Nintendo first and foremost) actually optimize for the hardware. That's how we've received so many truly "impossible" ports on the switch over the years, as well as game engines that had no business looking as good for what is now, effectively, 10 year old hardware. So even if Switch 2 is barely as powerful as a Steam Deck and has some rudimentary ray tracing and DLSS available, is it not that native optimization that, just like the original switch, is what will actually make an enormous difference and allow games to approach visual fidelity and/or quality far in excess of the underlying hardware, ala, the first Switch? If this is ends up being the case, Nintendo would for the first time have a situation where they have generationally appropriate hardware which would allow for a significant influx of PC games, PS4 cross-gen level games, and maybe even some "impossible" ports of XBox Series X and PS5 because of that optimization and featureset availability. Developers are not really incentivized to optimize for Steam Deck, Rog Ally, and others by default. But Nintendo is different in this case as they've proven the model and the power of that optimization for the Switch. I'm really curious to hear your musings on this front, as I think we may very well be underestimating, just like the original Switch, just what a Switch successor can do with hardware even as powerful as the "aging" Steam Deck. So those are my thoughts, thanks for reading, and I hope this finds you well! Keep on delivering the all around banger content!

Saskira

Microsoft has form for this and has done this a few times in the past, poor Rare and Lionhead Studios. I think what it shows is that the industry really needs a rebalancing of power and can’t be left in the hands of good old Phil and the rest of the corporate gang. How do we get development studios to have a bigger voice and reach..?

Diego ElRey

Hello all, in the Discord, I am known as the two 4090's guy. That said, my stance on RT and DLSS are not favorable, and personally I have that level of GPU because it is still by far and away the fastest raster card. This is why I have worries about the 5090. It could be like comparing the 1080 Ti to the 2080, where actual gains are minimal, but you paid for extra features, such as RT and tensor cores, but you got nothing out of it unless you wanted to Control at that time. I've recently come to realize that I don't care for RT is simply because none of the heavy games, or 'tech showcase' titles are in genres that I particularly care for. There are no "You NEED a 4090/80 to try this" in the 3rd person open world, racing, or fighting genres, and the latter two need a locked 60 minimum. I understand that these are probably going to be the hardest to run with full RT, and path tracing, which is why they don't yet exist, but will foregoing a another massive performance leap like the 3090 to 4090 to focus on RT/AI make it possible? Or How long does Alex in particular believe it would take before those genres can be shipped with heavy or full RT modes? Also, how much do the consoles and AMD's generally lower RT ceiling play into the decisions of RT implementation of PC games? It seems at least Forza was supposed to have much more RT than it shipped with, and you'd think that PCs of a certain level should support the level of RT that they initially wanted to put in the game? Does it need to be an Nvidia sponsored game to be a tech showcase title?

Someguyperson

Golly gee willikers! Did you guys see that Nintendo announced they will announce a new Nintendo console sometime in the next 12 months?! Who could have seen that one coming? I sure didn't. Also, who was that Someguyperson guy who asked you several questions about the Switch 2? Never heard of him.

Someguyperson

One thing I noticed with Oliver's handheld ray tracing coverage is that the footage of Path Traced Alan Wake 2 looked fairly similar to FMV footage played by a Sega Saturn. Do you think it will take 30 years for a gaming handheld to play games at the same fidelity as FMV footage in games today? How much better do you think a gaming handheld will be in 30 years? (If Moore's Law slows to doubling performance every 3-4 years, the performance of a 4090 will be <1 watt in 2054)

Someguyperson

I know you guys talk about how the #stutterstruggle is a new phenomenon, but I want to counter that with PC games of the 90's. I vividly remember as a kid that Lego Island (1997) stuttered horribly on my family's mediocre Windows 95 PC. In those times, if you didn't have a GPU or CPU from the same year a PC game came out, you would almost always run into huge performance issues and giant stutters as the CPU fails to keep up. Do you guys have other vivid memories of stuttering 90's PC games?

Someguyperson

Regarding Alex's video about RE Engine Path Tracing, how difficult would it be to add in denoising? Does the DLSS 3.5+ .DLL file always contain the Ray Reconstruction feature? If so, how difficult would it be to add that in, since the game already supports DLSS upscaling? Would that allow for the 1 ray/pixel & 2 bounce scenario to work a lot better?

Someguyperson

If the graphics of a current game can be scaled down, it will almost assuredly work on the Switch 2, but the real question is CPU performance. It's completely unknown if something like Dragon's Dogma would be able to run at ~27 FPS with the Switch 2 CPU and there's basically nothing they can scale there to get that working. As the generation goes on, only more and more games will be CPU limited, making it more difficult for a Switch 2 port.

Someguyperson

The era of 0% interest rates has gone now, which is why you're seeing undies struggle to get funding. I would say indies are in as good of a position as it gets this year though. The number of indie titles that have sold this year is absolutely astronomical compared to most other years and it's the AAA games that are struggling most and laying everyone off.

Someguyperson

Yes, memory bandwidth is the main issue with the Series S, but that's also a design decision. Microsoft could have given the Series S a better memory subsystem, but deliberately choose not to to save money. Any future console will face the same issue if someone wants to reduce the cost as much as possible. There will always be a bottleneck in the cheapest device and devs will just have to work around that limitation, whatever it may be.

Someguyperson

I would also add that developers not scaling textures well for lower RAM limits is an issue on the developers and not a hardware issue.

zephyr

Are the recent closings a warning from Microsoft to their other studios? Does Double Fine need to create the latest greatest looter extraction shooter or else?

Diego ElRey

I understand that shareholders are a (bad) thing, but what do these companies really expect? These consoles are almost 4 years out, it makes sense to me that most people that want them, have them by now, so in my possible smooth brain take, sales should be waning. How can you expect infinite growth, especially in that business? The sales aren't there, they can't cost-reduce these machines, all they can do is cut positions and jobs. It's a wonder that anyone wants to be in this industry. I'd love to make games, but I also like eating, and doing so under my own roof. Thank you to everyone who puts up with being in the games industry.

Archibald “Moonlight” Graham

With Valve developers getting Gamescope running on NVidia hardware, does this indicate anything regarding a general release of SteamOS? Of note, this was done on the open source NVK driver, not the proprietary NVidaia driver.

Someguyperson

It's also a similar case for Tango. Shinji Mikami left last year and took a bunch of talent with him.

Diego ElRey

Hello all, quick question about the Switch 2. Being based on Ampere, shouldn't this machine theoretically have better RT performance than the PS5 and XSX? Or will the chip size be a deterrent, or could there be other reasons, such as Nintendo simply not supporting it in their API, or could the RT cores possibly be fused off for price savings? Ray Traced Rainbow Road? Need.

Someguyperson

No, these issues are entirely on the developers not wanting to put the work in to make multithreaded code. It's more complicated and takes trained developers and architects to do well, but ultimately everyone is on a hard deadline and a single threaded software pipeline is what was typically used before and typically the easiest thing to make initially. Inexperienced devs think "oh, I can just move a bunch of the work to another thread later", but the more senior and experienced devs know that's not how things work.

M

I'm not really sure about that honestly. If you had said back in the day that some company would get Doom 2016, Doom Eternal, Witcher 3, etc on the Switch, you'd have been branded a heretic off your rocker.

Someguyperson

You don't think that this is Microsoft cleaning up after ABK's mess they left? It seems to me that Microsoft took careful stock of exactly what they had and didn't have in terms of development resources, and let go of the developers that seemed to be on the wrong path going forward. We heard all last year that the Arkane Austin that released Redfall was a completely different company than the one that made Prey. There's also been huge turnover at Tango. Microsoft clearly felt the remains of the studios weren't all performing to the best of their abilities and took action accordingly.

Travesty Stutter

Indies are indeed selling well, but as we've seen time and again this year, that isn't necessarily a thraight line to more funding. Danny O'Dwyer over at NoClip painted a pretty grim picture recently when summarizing his converstaions this year with indie devs scrambling for funding and coming up empty handed. The same thing seems to be happening with his own little game dev project. Lots of talk among indie devs about Epic grants and Game Pass funding being "thin on the ground" (tm). I fear we may see the delayed results from this in a couple years (akin to the dearth of AAA games in 2022 after the initial effects of covid took effect).

FrametimeSommelier

Hi DF Direct Team! In one of the last Directs you talked about the newly announced Kingdom Come Deliverance 2. I'm a big fan of the first and I cannot wait to get my hands on the new one. Earlier this week Warhouse founder Daniel Vávra posted a Youtube video showing off his new gaming PC powered by an AMD Ryzen 7950x3d CPU and RTX 4080 Super GPU. In his video he is mentioning that the current build of the game runs at 4K, 60 frames per second at very high settings, and 40 FPS at epic settings on this new build. He also mentioned that the game will have DLSS and FSR 2 upscaling by launch. What do those numbers tell you about the current state of the game considering it is scheduled to launch later this year and it is using cry engine. I know that the first game was/still is really hard on CPUs.

Someguyperson

The Series S only has 10 GB, so the Switch 2 could easily manage with 12 GB.

Mechajin

Hi and grüssle dear DFlers! Since Microsoft is now cosplaying as Embracer group and buying up studios to shut them down if they don't make billions by yesterday, wouldn't it make more sense for Microsoft to become a holder of IP's and license these out to studios that want to actually make games? Exit the hardware business and be a platform agnostic service platform that doesn't actually develop anything themselves? Thanks for your insights and stay awesome!

Leftisthominid

How are you all doing? What game(s) are you all currently playing for fun? Do you consider them to be "Next Level Stuff"?

FrametimeSommelier

Hi DF Team. I have a question about Shader Compilation stutters which plague PC gaming a lot recently. Why can developers not implement an option during install that precompiles the shaders completely for the system it is installed on? We could have an option like "normal quick install - fast install, but possible compilation stutters during first playthrough" and one "long install, but no shader compilation stutters". The heck, I wouldn't even care if it would take 10 hours. Would just let the install run over night. Would this be technical possible? Console games come with precompiled shaders. Why can't we do this during install (even if it takes very long) on PC. As long as there is still a quick install option for the impatient gamer, I don't see why this wouldn't work.

Diego ElRey

Hello all, I was wondering if there is a reason that the PS5/XSX don't have bespoke 1440p modes with higher graphics settings, or higher framerates, or a combination of both? Currently when these consoles output 1440p, or other lower res, it's usually within the bounds of a DRS window, but the original target is 4K, meaning all the cuts needed still apply. Would a 1440p targeting mode be different than 4K targeting using 1440p as an downscale or DRS window, or have I got it wrong? Sounds like they'd get extra headway. PC owners commonly have GPUs more powerful than 9th gen consoles connected to 1440p displays. There seems to be no downsides, and the consoles are not usually at 2160p often anyway. What gives?

MGsubbie

I think the answer is quite simple and obvious : Because consoles are designed with the idea of it being used with a TV, and there are no 1440p TV's. Of course there are TV's that can do 1440p, but those are all 4k TV's to begin with. And the amount of TV's that can do 1440p 120Hz but not 4k 120Hz is quite small.

Perfect_Organism

An idea perhaps - not totally your usual thing but Animal Well released today to seemingly critical acclaim, by a solo dev, and the binary size clocks in at ~30mb. Could be worth a deep dive to see how that was achieved? Seems very impressive on first glance.

FrametimeSommelier

Yeah, I want to know too. What games are you guys playing for fun, which is not work related. What games have you currently hooked?

zurce

What do you consider has been Microsoft biggest contribution or innovation in the industry ? Seems that all the bad trends (always online , charging for online, ads , physical media abandoned ) always start with them , yet gamers treat them as a great partner in the industry Besides bringing hardware ? What have they done to enrich the industry ? Is it time to treat Microsoft back like we did in the bill gates era ?

StrugglingShader

Given the perspective of next gen Xbox being closer to PC, I think they should still be a fixed spec hardware platform. Look at Steam Deck, it launched over 2 years ago, and the specs for the OLED revision are the same. This is what allowed them to be so good at pre-compiling shaders and deck verified titles. Valve is not even allowing other companies to use the OS. I think Xbox should follow a similar path, keeping the Xbox OS exclusive to the console, while allowing other PC games to run from competing stores. My point is, I don't think we should expect Xbox software to run on regular PCs. Thoughts?

MGsubbie

Yes, this can be done. But it requires effort from the developer.

Lil Gohan

First 720p HD console in the Xbox, first console of the generation X360, popularized console online play with Xbox live. Once the Kinect came out it was mostly downhill from there.

Joe Esposito

Hello DF Crew! You were talking in the last direct about ominous signs around the console market in due to layoffs, revenue drops, and sagging sales numbers. In my view, the gaming industry in general may be in for a harsh reckoning because it feels like we’ve had a flood of awful moves by the big names in the space. Let's just review a few shall we? Games continually launched in broken states, publishers dumping IPs after ill advised buying sprees, unsustainably high budgets, vaguely defined sales expectations and exceptional studios being shuttered even after delivering fantastic games. Can anyone look at what’s happening and not expect some really dark days ahead, if not an outright crash of the industry? The reality is that we’ve been dazzled by ray tracing and lush graphics while a foundational rot has been spreading all around us. We may be way overdue for a serious reset, and with any luck there are sunnier skies just past the thunderclouds but it may be a very rough ride to get there.

1040STF

This is Furukawa, President of Nintendo. I chose this random Patreon comment's reply as the official way to announce there will be a Switch 3. Stay tuned around I don't know, after 2030 I guess, for more information. PS: There will a Nintendo Direct in June 2029 but we won't talk about the Switch 3 in it. Please understand.

tod weitzel

Who do you think could use an infusion of imsim developer talent? Arkane Austin itself came about with talent that was shed by Ion Storm which itself had talent from Looking Glass. Shutting acclaimed studios as a cohesive team is a short term shock, but I've seen enough cycles of renewal to be kind of excited about what the Dishonored and Prey creators will do next in a green field environment.

Alan

Hi DF, Let's face it Micro$oft have gone back to the antitrust days with Xbox, buying up devs only to shut them down later, Sony are no better but they did take notice of small devs and give them few games to make and then buy them out, nurturing them basically onto bigger things, Xbox were never going to recoup $70 billion putting games on GamePass it's obvious! The ABK acquisition was always going to be bad for gaming and gamers. Phil portrayed himself as a gamer, but he's always been a corpo imo, his position is untenable surely as his words cannot be trusted anymore in gamers ears, does MS even care?

Alan

Hi DF, Let's try to focus on some positives in these current dark days of gaming, what games do you each want to hype up coming out in the next few months?

Ednamode

you keep talking about the t239 being a “cut-down” t234 and my understanding of the word “cut-down” that it was the same die with excess cores(and other parts?) disabled. But the recent direct suggested that the t239 is its own chip, derived from the t234, which makes me question if I misconstrued the word cutdown. Is t239 it’s own chips with a smaller die size that allows Nintendo to pump up the production? If so, what are changes are there now that Nintendo has designed its own “bespoke” chip compared to previously using off the shelf Terra. Also why do we look at the t239 to be it’s originator when there is an entire Orin line of chips.

zurce

Now that AFMF and Lossless Scaling have proved that generic motion interpolation is good enough for plenty of people, what's stopping us seeing it in consoles/mobile or in other applications? Maybe on demand motion interpolated NPCs at the distance can be possible to reduce load ?

Julian Shniter

John! How was your trip to the homeland of Ohio? Did you see everybody you wanted to see? What were some of your best retro pickups, how did you manage to brick the TV at best buy? And what was the greasiest, unhealthiest food you ate? Welcome back john!

MrBurns

What an abhorrent lack of accountability and responsibility towards their employees. Shocking. All hail the next quarter results! Is it fair to even lose all faith in Xbox as a platform holder when a studio that made their most critically acclaimed game in years (apart from Forza Horizon) is being shut down? If it wasn’t abundantly clear before this really hammers home the point that in the future they will only sell living room friendly PCs as a side gig where a diverse portfolio to attract customers isn’t needed anymore. The focus of their business will be Gamepass as well as publishing of only the most profitable games. Thoughts?

Raijin94

The original Xbox was the first console with an internal hard drive. Popularising indies with Xbox Live Arcade could be another good contribution.

Raijin94

Dear DF Team, Data such as that shown by Mat Piscatella suggests that the average age of the console buyer is getting older. Other analysts, managers and ex-managers also mention this and specifically talk about Gen Z being ‘to blame’ for this problem by preferring other forms of gaming (PC/mobile). What do you think are the factors behind Gen Z preferring such different forms of gaming to previous generations? To what extent do you think this could be a problem for traditional consoles?

Critically Wild

When it comes to optimisation, a lot of major publishers — but Microsoft portfolio in particular — have access to immense cloud computing resources... I haven't seen anything mentioning it being used for QA. Couldn't they use machine learning or even AI to run VMs of system configurations to find optimised settings, precompile shaders etc.?

FrametimeSommelier

So, today (Thursday) ASUS dropped the announcement video for the ROG Ally X June announcement (they must really think that the community likes announcement videos, since they're now doing announcement events for announcements). Anyway, we learned a few things, they enthusiast aimed Ally X will get a bigger battery, M2 2280 form factor support, and more RAM. The APU will still be Z1E. Here is my question: How much will more and faster RAM (in this case supposedly LPDDR5X-7500) help a bandwidth limited handheld device. How much performance can the extra faster RAM realistically offer?

FrametimeSommelier

After the latest Xbox Studio closure announcements someone nuked Phil Spencer's camp in Fallout 76 which prompted over 40000 reddit likes. Is this an indicator that the goodwill of the Xbox fans and community is reaching a tipping point when it comes to the new reorientation of Xbox's (non-existing) strategy?

Crashsune

Was Microsoft's shut down of two beloved development studios worse than their bafflingly terrible Xbox One launch when it comes to public perception of their brand? Personally, I thought it felt like there was at least a small glimmer of hope even in the Xbox One launch days that things would eventually improve or get better. However, these studio closures seem much more dire, as they seemingly prove that high quality software, the reason to own a console in the first place, simply doesn't matter as much to the suits in charge as "line go up". If their strategy isn't about making awesome award winning games, then seriously, what is the Xbox strategy at this point? Why be in this industry at all? Also, welcome back John!

Digital Foundry

It's more a spin-off than a cut-down chip. It has new/different CPU cores and a decompression block for faster loading - it's all in the T239 video I did a few months back.

ConcreteLlama

Is Microsoft actively trying to kill their own Xbox brand?

Chromatic Abomination

Hi DF crew, and welcome back John! Meta recently announced that they will be opening up the Quest platform to third party device makers using what is now being called "Horizon OS". What implications does this have for the future of the VR market, and what would you like to see from third party devices? This also got me thinking about Microsoft taking the Xbox platform in a more PC like direction. Could we see Microsoft take a similar approach and open the Xbox platform up to third party device makers as a way to offset hardware costs and broaden the market?

CCshoreditch

Hi guys 👋 my favourite "podcast", excellent work as always 👌🥰 Are there going to be any more InDirect episodes?

tomwinsagain

Hey gents, a fresh flood of Switch 2 rumours have come in this week. Including 12GB of LPDDR5X RAM at 7500 MT/s, 256GB of internal storage with read speeds of around 2GB/s, and a fan in the dock. There's even talk they may have ended up going for a last minute change to a 5nm process from Samsung. Would using that process dramatically change the manufacturing cost than the initially rumoured 8nm and 7nm processes? There's a lot of conflicting information out there now, but some of these specs seem too good to be true! Thoughts? It's certainly exciting to see that there's a decent chance this device will be a lot more advanced, but as a lifelong Nintendo fan, I am still expecting something with a very modest upgrade. Maybe the need to support easy ports of UE5 titles forced their hand...

StrugglingShader

Even in a 4K screen, if you have to lower internal resolution to 720p (DLSS Ultra Performance), it looks worse than a 1440p output with DLSS Quality (960p) at a similar performance level. At living room viewing distance the aggressive upscalling artifacts bothers more than the slightly softer image, and when you factor in that console use the inferior FSR…

Octolimar

The steam deck got a preview update (version 3.6) and with it comes official overclocking support in the bios! This isn't a new concept but it's nice to have it officially offered. Is it something one of you would be interested in covering I'm a future video? Also including the undervolting features

Niklas King

Hi DF Team! Can you guys maybe discuss how borderline criminal it is how Epic has neglected both Unreal and the UT franchise despite them working so hard on the Unreal Engine? I can't seem to get nearly as excited for "Fortnite" as I was back in the years leading up to the release of Unreal 2 or UT2k4 for example.