Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello there and welcome to your regularly scheduled weekly post which informs you of the plans for the next edition of DF Direct Weekly and humbly requests your input! It'll be Rich (ie me), John and Oliver on the panel this week and the deadline for questions is 8am BST Friday.

We'll be discussing the new 6nm revision of the Xbox Series X APU, and the surprise reveal of Analogue's N64 box. We'll also be talking about the Dragon Age: The Veilguard PC specs recommendations and the Tomb Raider 4/5/6 remasters announcement. The news of 3GB GDDR7 memory modules has also caught our attention, meaning that GPUs with 128-bit/256-bit memory interfaces can now ship with 12GB or 24GB of memory, instead of just 8GB or 16GB. The cancelled Halo battle royale? The Xbox partner showcase? Maybe we'll talk about that too.

But of course, it's not DF Direct Weekly without your contributions so please feel free to pose your questions, suggest your topics and react to the topic points above. Thanks in advance!

Files

Comments

videotechuk_

Do you have plans to visit Life is Strange: Double Exposure? The new game uses UE5 and features impressive facial animations, alongside use of Lumen.

carrotsauce

Hi DF team! Given the very recent announcement from Analogue about the Analogue 3D, would you guys (John most likely) be covering the release for it and all the features that it has? And what’s everyone’s initial thoughts about it? It’s pretty exciting that we’re finally getting an N64 FPGA console that runs at 4k!

Michael Pearn

Hey DF crew, with now an announced 60+ games officially supporting the PS5 Pro (and the hundreds of titles with “boost” support) have you considered bite sized, 1 min or less DF reviews of the differences? Would play well to all of the attention deficit Gen Z tik tok crowd

RustyGames

Hi DF Team. More than a week has passed and there is still no patch for the PC-Version of "Silent Hill 2" available. Also there is no official communication from Bloober about when a patch is comming or on which issues they're working on. There's complete silence. I understand that fixing sometimes takes time but at least some info would be nice. Especially if there are such severe problems like in this case. I really hope that this will not be another "Dead Space"-PC-situation. Maybe the DF Team has more info about a upcomming patch? What are you thinking about the situation? Thank you and keep up the good work. Cheers.

sj33 (Jake)

Hi all, 5800X3D the GOAT! Going to go down as a classic. Do you think AMD regret making it? I still don't feel a need to upgrade from my 5800X3D even with the 9800X3D around the corner. Nobody should built an AM4 machine right now, but there's still not a huge reason to upgrade from AM4 to AM5 unless you absolutely have to have the best. Feels like it'll keep chugging along for at least another generation or so.

Ryan Seymour

Gentlemen. Your recent Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart PS5 Pro vs PS5 head to head has only put fuel on the fire that PS5 Pro is a pointless upgrade. I have preordered one but I was watching, honestly struggling to see any difference. Sometimes base PS5 looked better! If Insomniac can’t put that extra horsepower to good use it doesn’t bode well. Do you think this initial slate of PS5 Pro enhanced games are not using the hardware to its full potential? Cheers!

Kruax

Hey guys, with the recent announcement of the Analogue 3D, it made me wonder why there hasn't been a small company pop up that produces/sells new CRTs. Is it impossible? Or is it just so niche and financially unviable that making FPGA consoles are the only real solution for retro consoles moving forward.

[PLACEHOLDER]

Rich and Dem Bois, long time listener, first time caller. With development time and cost growing to such crazy proportions, and games also similarly getting overly stuffed with 100's of hours of content, what's the argument against chunking them up and releasing at a more frequent cadence? If you could sell me one 150 hour game for $70 or three 50 hour games for $40 apiece, aren't you coming out ahead financially, even with the inevitable drops in price? Additionally, while the "sequels" to the first game might be largely derivative from a graphics and basic gameplay standpoint, the year or two between releases would at least allow for some basic tweaking and implementation of lessons learned each time. What am I missing here? I'll hang up and listen.

elboobio

Hello DF crew. Could you ask Alex if he has ever played Train Sim World? As I believe it to be a candidate for the game with the worst shader compilation stutter on the planet. The developers there, who I'm sure work incredibly hard, have zero solution for the UE4 infliction and we're now on to the 5th iteration of Train Sim World with no attempt at a fix. Can you see a reason why they couldn't include a shader compilation step? Are there limitations with some games in the way they are designed to at least limit the amount of stutter? Please help them, please 😂

Kris Graney

Hi DF Crew. Do you think Nintendo’s online test that you discussed last week could be a way to do “forwards compatibility”? You have a huge installed user base with Switch consoles and you aren’t going to immediately be able to sell a huge quantity of Switch 2, would it be cheaper yet still allow more money to line their pockets for new Switch 2 games to be directly playable in new hardware but then also sell a streamed copy people still on old hardware. Nvidia has market leading streaming capability so they can provide this ability to Nintendo, and modern games cost a huge amount to develop, do you agree that it makes more financial sense to not lock out your last gen hardware whilst also not requiring developers to build multiple versions of a game if they want to go cross-gen? They can build for switch 2 and then that build is run directly on switch 2 hardware or streamed to last gen hardware. They seem to be sticking with the same number of controller buttons and sticks so different controllers didn’t really need to be accounted for either. Thanks!

Having an AI-neurysm

Any idea why it took Microsoft almost 4 years to do a die shrink for the Series X compared to the ~2 years it took Sony? I’d have thought it would’ve been a higher priority for them given they had the more expensive die to start with

Leftisthominid

How is Will doing? What is he up to? When will he be on DF Direct again?

StrugglingShader

Hello gents! In the early days of DLSS, the base recommendation was performance mode for 4K, balanced at 1440p and quality for 1080p. But the base resolution for DLSS quality at 1080p is the same for performance mode at 1440p and ultra performance at 4K, with a very noticeable frame rate difference. And if you equalize by fps, 4K ultra performance performs similarly to 1440p DLSS Quality, which IMO looks better, even in a 4K TV. How do you fell about the tradeoff between the bluriness from non-native output resolution and upscaling artifacts?

Peter Karadimas

Hello DF team! With so much of the industry moving to Unreal engine, I was wondering if you could give a general overview of what the engine is good at and bad at. What are some example games that would represent a worst case scenario and a best case scenario for the engine? Thanks for everything!

Sirbobalot21

Hi guys, love your videos keep up the great work. This is half question, half thought experiment. Backwards compatibility seems to be kinda niche nowadays compared to before 360 gen with exception of the Xbox systems, I was wondering why don't the console manufacturers make a "Pro" model of their console at launch that has built in hardware to be backwards compatible with all past systems. I know this will cost alot to manufacture and to purchase for the consumer but I feel like it will sell a decent amount. For example for the PS6 why not have the base PS6 plus a PS6 Pro that has built in parts of a PS3, 2 and 1 so we don't have to rely on software emulation where not ever game is available. I think this would open up a new market to especially with PC players who might consider getting the next Xbox or Playstation if they can play old gen games more efficiently without running it through an emulator. I would love to hear your thoughts on this and how feasible it actually is.

DaJaCo (Dan)

There's a rumour going around that Sony has put a line in the sand for developers when it comes to PS5 Pro - Apparently all games published after September 16th will need to offer PS5 Pro Support. The big question is what exactly this will mean as a minimum requirement versus what it will likely mean as a typical level of support. Personally I would like to see the PS5 Pro bring about 2 additional modes. 1- 60FPS / PSSR - That seeks to achieve the best of both base PS5 Modes 2- 40 FPS / PSSR - PRO Fidelity Mode. Don't you think a 40FPS "Pro Fidelity Mode" is a much more legitimate approach on PS5 PRO - because "Professionals" are much more likely to have a HDMI 2.1 Display?

Perfect_Organism

I can’t say I’m super familiar with FPGA and the technical wizardry behind it, but is there anything you see from stopping Analogue or anyone else (god forbid, Sony) from releasing a HDMI PS1 with an FPGA chip inside?

Thomas the Jank Engine

With Analogue’s new N64 machine, what are the odds it combats the infamous N64 blur issue, and allows for better framerates albeit at original resolution? I’d be curious to see it compare to an N64 with the Tink4K! Cheers.

DaJaCo (Dan)

Have you guys seen the generative AI startup "Tales" which is creating a game development environment that can allow game creation entirely with natural language text prompts - is this an early sign of things to come.. and how long until Epic buys them..?

Daniel Bross

Hi guys! I recently read an article on PC Gamer titled "There's a future where you and your graphics card decide what a game looks like, not the developers", talking about how AI would be able to change the graphical style in a game to your liking instead of keeping the developer's vision. This way of thinking really worries me as a devloper and I was wondering what your thoughts are about this? Is this really what the players want?

Jonny_5a

Didn’t think we’d see FPGA based 3D consoles anytime soon. Do you think this increases the chances we’ll see an Analogue ‘Ringed Planet’ or Analogue CD in the mid term?

Tyrus1235

I saw the Dragon Age: The Veilguard specs sheet and it left me a bit confused, as they mentioned that upscaling "could" be used in some of those metrics. It felt way too vague. For example, even my meager RTX 3060 can run ARK Survival Ascended with everything maxed out, so long as I put it on DLSS Ultra Performance and use a 1080p display and 30 fps cap. I understand that using a 30 fps cap on PC (and running the game at essentially 360p internally) isn't something most developers would want to showcase, but it is a reality. At any rate, thanks for the show and hope you all have a good week and weekend!

filreed

Hi DF-arenos. Long time first time... Whilst awaiting for my PS5 Pro to be delivered and as currently not owning any of the latest consoles I decided to dig out my old PS3. Playing Motorstorm, Infamous, Resistance, MGS4 and Killzone 2 again made me wonder what with all of the remakes out there, why none of these has seen a re-release of any kind, even if it's not a complete rework like Demons Souls. Is it licencing, perceived lack of interest, or are PS3 games just too much work to update for the latest consoles? Was the cell processor that different to code for? Would be great to hear your opinions and if you think any of them would ever be re-released in an upgraded format. Cheers!

Mark

Hi Gents, In the PS5 Pro presentation, Mark Cerny mentioned that when given the choice, the majority of players consistently chose performance over graphical fidelity and yet they've built a 700 pound machine to make games prettier. While previous generations brought about giant leaps in graphics, these days the improvements from last generation to the next are more subtle, and I've been more impressed with current-gen feats such as the 3D audio in Returnal or the near instantaneous portals in Ratchet and Clank. Are there any features or emerging technologies, not related to graphics, that you want to see more of? Thank you for shining a light on how games are built and the people that make them.

Skyrimfest 26 FPS Edition

Upscaling has been the saviour of console and GPU manufacturers who skimped on VRAM this generation, but with those upscaling RAM savings now 'baked in' and requirements beginning to head upwards, what is more the more likely focus: further measures to economise on VRAM usage or more and bigger VRAM chips? RAM is getting faster but the prices generally don't seem to be falling at the speed they once did.

Meatdreams

I have a pocket and I love it dearly, especially now that they support display emulation modes on the OpenFPGA side. It looks like the 3D will come with its own spiffy set of CRT emulation modes, which made me think about John’s musings on how HDR might eventually let us emulate the specific look of glowing phosphors. I took a look at their new FAQ page for any mention of HDR, and lo and behold: “Are Original Display Modes supported on TVs without 4K? A modern 4K TV with HDR offers the best experience with Analogue3D and Original Display Modes. Other TVs are still supported.” Have you heard anything specific about how they’re implementing these modes? If they’re designed to take full advantage of 1000+ nit displays, then wowee. Excited to see what these look like.

Rich

Any interest in the new ModRetro Chromatic for GameBoy games? It apparently plays original carts!

1040STF

How much more powerful is the Cyclone FPGA chip in the Analogue 64 compared to the MiSTer? What possibilities could it open in your opinion? I know openFPGA is unfortunately off the table but in theory what cores could that chip handle, especially on the arcade side?

DT1878

What are Johns thoughts on Silent Hill 2? I know he was a bit apprehensive on whether Bloober could deliver a faithful remake. Has he had a chance to play it? and if so, does he think they pulled it off? I personally think it is excellent.

goregutz

Hi DF mates! Given another disaster unreal engine 5 game launch (silent hill 2 remake) being added to an already long list of abysmal unreal 5 engine based game launches, why do Dec's even bother with UE5 anymore? Clearly it's doing more harm than good. What are other options they have available? In fact, this would be a great time for companies with their own bespoke engines to market them and make them available for Devs to use. We need more competition in the game engine space. My personal favourite, cry engine needs a resurgence. Thoughts?

Wez OOSH! (WOOSH)

Hi DF team. I know you're all extremely busy, just wanted to know if you're going to do any more shenanigan play sessions of games together? Possibly quake 2 RTX or even DOOM RTX? Love the content and would be a nice change of pace from all the professionalism content (eventhough I love that content too) :)

Leftisthominid

What is the full, bespoke story about why Richard hates the Master System?

Kaepora

I mean, what's the point of getting the Analogue's N64 box when the original experience is only enjoyed by purchasing a real N64 (which is cheaper on Ebay) and plug it into a CRT? Why the heck would I want to play N64 games at "10 times the resolution of most of the N64 games"? Those games weren't created for that resolution at all.

Leftisthominid

Do you think the Switch 2 could fix Echoes of Wisdom. I started the game and the frame rate issues instantly bummed me out and I switched games.

Eduardo Alves

Hi digitalfoundrypeople, so, considering ps5 Pro ML hardware, could the former be used for other things in the future like frame generation? Currently Sony emphasis is in image reconstruction but I bet a form of bespoke frame gen would also be greatly beneficial due to the CPU situation. Or maybe Sony is holding the frame gen tech as a ps6 selling point... those evil corps... thanks for the attention! :)

minty-hippo

Hi Rich Foundry! As you’re going to test Strix Point by way of a miniPC (‘puter), is there any chance you could test Bazzite to give the Steam Machine dream another go-around?

lbb12

Hello Rich and DF Team! At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I don't know anyone else who can answer this question more reliably than you guys, so that is why I won't give up in my question being answered... I was hoping by the time a game like Metro Exodus and NVIDIA's open sourcing PhysX awhile ago (as well as continual extinction of dev support for it) that an AMD GPU user/based console would allow the use of its features by now, or am I wrong? Will we ever see a PhysX enhanced title run with those features turned ON for AMD someday (patched-in/updated to run)? Maybe a 'PhysX wrapper' (remember 3DFx Glide Wrappers for non-3DFx card owners?) As mentioned previously, the Batman Arkham series of games are a great example of a title that just seems lacking without the PhysX features, but complete with it (lookup 'Zogrim' on Youtube for best examples). I sincerely appreciate your input 😄👍

Wotans Cry

Hey DF Crew ! With the PS5 Pro release imminent ( and therefore first comparisons of it's Games with Series X) will you stay with the established pattern of PS5 vs Series X / S and include the PS5 Pro comparison on Sony Side? In that case, iam afraid, Xbox Series X will be hopelessly outmatched in all comparisons with PS5 Pro no questions asked. Would it not be more fair to not let Xbox Series X try to compete with PS5 Pro and have the latter fight it out with a comparable PC and DLSS? Keep up the good work Lads!

Samdenn

Hey folks! This question is for Rich, although it's really more of a request - to show us your dog!!

Mr Bespoke

Hi DF! Ive just read that somebody has manged to get Metaphor: ReFantazio to run on a 3DS and was wondering if John or Oliver will be taking a look/covering it at some point in the future to see how well its stacks up against the console counter parts? Thanks and keep up the awesome work!!

Zero

Hey Gents! Off the wall theory I had this week with the existence of Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered: What if the PS6 isn't backwards compatible with the PS4? Beyond just padding out their release windows, what if Sony is engaging in future proofing of their big hits because the PS6 won't handle PS4 era titles natively? It could possibly explain some of their odd choices in titles to remaster. Love to hear your thoughts, thanks for the stellar work!

Mike Saint-Jules

Hello Gents! Long time viewer and recent Patreon member. Thank you for the content all these years. My question is for everyone on the panel. Back in 2019 during the Computer Entertainment Developers Conference, there were articles highlighting Japanese Journalist Zenji Nishikawa where he heard that a PS5 Pro would release alongside the base model as there were rumors of a second Console being released. It ended up being the digital model SKU, but I thought at the time it would have been a cool thing to see. In today's day and age with how Phones and GPUs are released in Family lineups, there's a choice for people. Do you think this is something that Consoles will do in the future where you will see a base model and a "Pro" model being released together, or do you think that would be unwise because of possible limitations in hardware or small gains in performance forcing a V2 Pro in a mid-gen refresh?

Timothy Long

Hey guys, I happened to notice that all the PS5 Pro coverage is absent VRR frame rate data for 120hz displays. Are the Pro modes allowing for this? Or is there a different these aren't being covered? Thanks guys looking forward to November content

Crashpad

Hello DF Team, with the still surprising amount of PS4 games coming out from bigger studios is the series S really the problem or is the existence of the series S hardware making it easier to Backport otherwise "Next Gen" games to last gen?, I would love to hear what you guys think about it anyways cheers!

Lil Gohan

The Ratchet 1,2,3 experience. Hell, many series from PS2 did just that

[PLACEHOLDER]

Exactly, my message was already feeling overly long so I left it out but you're 100% saying what I was thinking, PS1/PS2 era iteration.

Mike Saint-Jules

I suspect it's because they don't have the actual hardware yet and Sony is providing B-Roll footage to use meanwhile. I suspect they will touch on that with games they haven't covered yet.

Question Generated By JensenGPT

Good morning, DF Crew, exclamation point. There have been a lot of conversations about what a new PlayStation or Xbox console would be like if it used a Nvidia GPU instead of an AMD GPU. What is the likelihood of something like that even happening? Nvidia doesn't have an x86 license, and game consoles moved away from separate CPU and GPU dies two console generations ago for cost and power savings. In addition, both Microsoft and Sony have used Nvidia GPUs in their consoles at some point in the past but seem to show no interest in doing so again. What would need to change for a theoretical Nvidia-powered PlayStation or Xbox to happen?

Peter

Hi DF Crew! As far as you are aware, does the PS5 Pro offer anything akin to fps boost where a framerate cap can be overcome without dev intervention? My assumption is no and that any framerate boosts mentioned are related to those games that could not previously hold a lock on fps target, or of course where devs do indeed unlock fps thus allowing the extra GPU grunt room to improve frametimes. Thanks and have a great week

LittleMac

With Sony porting their game to PC, it has me wondering why they haven ported Demon Souls Remake. It was a launch title Afterall. With Bloodborne missing in action it has me wondering if there's something going on with FromSoftware that prevents Sony from bringing Demon Souls to PC.

Jonathan Thomassen

Would you agree that the methods of anti-aliasing used today often produce an overly blurry image? What do you think are some examples of games or game engines that deliver a good anti-aliasing solution while still providing a sharp and clean image? Is there hope for the future for us that appreciate a good sharp image?

Phazonmasher

Hey DF crew, I recently played Silent Hill 2 Remake, Callisto Protocol and Jedi Survivor on PC and these are all games unified by being made by super talented teams hobbled by their underlying technology. This keeps happening and I can't just believe it's entirely on these teams. Epic clearly wants to be the de facto technology that powers the majority of the games industry but seemingly doesn't want to deliver a competent engine in favor of letting their licensees take on the brunt of the criticism. What will it take for Epic to take Unreal's performance on PC seriously?

Rigor88

Greetings Digital Foundry, About traversal stutters in PC games. What do you consider to be the primary cause? Is it possible that PCIe speed(assets streaming to GPU) plays a more significant role than CPU performance? If so is this one area where consoles have advantage due to unified memory. Additionally, I've noticed a lack of CPU benchmarks that specifically measure stutter duration. I recall Rich emphasizing this metric in his CPU reviews. Don't you think such data would be far more valuable than the abundance of benchmarks showing high FPS numbers? Thanks for your consistently great work!

Perfect_Organism

“Rich and dem bois” is 100% the best way that anyone has ever started a question.

Timothy Long

I suspected that was part of it but Rich had a developer kit for the analysis on The Last of Us II. It also seemed like Oliver might have during the Ratchet and Clank analysis but I don't know that for sure.

CrashOverride

I've shortened this question from 3 weeks ago in hopes of an answer: Given the dominance Xbox Series S in Microsoft's share of console sales along with the increasingly long time to produce a game, do we now have a recipe for disaster in keeping the development cost for games (at least those one console) under control? The Series S has proven to cost developers quite a bit of time and resources to deliver the experience they want on the mandatory offering while development times regardless of hardware are now beyond 5 years for many games. The life cycle of a console used to be roughly 5 years plus a cross-gen lag period in phasing it out! In light of the exploding budgets of games like Concord and other AAA titles, where do devs go from here?

Mike Saint-Jules

Ah if that's the case for the Kit, then that's a possibility. In their beginning sentence for R&C on the last Patreon post it said "We've had an extended look at a preview build" which I was under the impression they were given uncompressed video footage.

Levander Davis

I would counter that this was exactly Xbox’s strategy.

AfreemTheDream

Greetings, Foundrymen! Who is the Analogue 64 for? Thanks!

Levander Davis

FYI, Silent Hill sold a million copies in 3 days and has reviewed very favorably. I don’t think publishers are going to care about the UE 5 engine being a problem.

Julián Oroza

You guys covering DBZ Sparking Zero?

Abandoned Walnut

Nvidia always seem to stay one step ahead of the competition in terms of new gpu features. First we had dlss, then frame generation, with amd & Intel constantly playing catch up. What are your thoughts / speculations on new features the 50 series might bring?

Macky Dee

Following on from John's video earlier this year, the Ys X Nordics western release is finally imminent. Have you any info or experience with the PC version to add to the console analysis, or is it something you hope to revisit? Definitely keen to play as a fan of the series, so interested in hearing which version is recommended.

Someguyperson

I completely agree with this theory. GeForce Now could easily play Switch 2 games and stream them to OG Switch consoles. I find this particularly poignant as the new mainline Pokemon games were designed for Switch 2 first and need to be back ported to Switch 1. I feel streaming them to OG Switch customers would be the right call there.

Someguyperson

With the announcement that Craig Duncan from Rare is being promoted to the Xbox Games Studio lead, do you have greater or lower expectations for future Xbox titles? Rare seems to have a good culture that should help clean up the Activision Blizzard King mess among other issues at Microsoft. Or do you think the issues are too deep to resolve?

Someguyperson

Why does DF contributor Audi Sorlie look like Al Pachino at the ripe age of 84?

Someguyperson

The Analogue3D is finally fully announced! What do you think of the 4K mode? How well do you think it will emulate a CRT? How will it work with BFI and apparently no 4K 120Hz support? Will the games run at the original framerates, or will there be enough horsepower to actually hit 20/30 FPS in most games? Will the VRR support have LFC for the 17 FPS games? Will the console essentially be a MiSTer+ considering how powerful the FPGA is (220k LEs vs 110k LEs in the MiSTer)? I'm eagerly awaiting the DF Retro breakdown between an original N64 with a RetroTINK 4K vs the Analogue3D!

Someguyperson

Next year we are due for a new mainline Pokemon game and the GameFreak leak, unfortunate as it is, shines some light on that effort. If the Switch 2 was supposed to actually come out in Spring 2024, the Pokemon gen 10 games would have a fairly large amount of Switch 2 consoles to target. However, that's not what happened and now the new Pokemon games will arrive in the launch year of the Switch 2. Considering all Pokemon games sell 25+ million copies every generation, GameFreak really needs to somehow port the game to OG Switch now. Do you think they'll just put out a streaming only version? How ugly do you think the OG Switch port will be considering the poor visuals & performance of Scarlet & Violet? Do you think this would be an easier port if the game was in Unreal Engine as opposed to GameFreak's own internal engine? Can you just run the game at a pitiful internal resolution to compensate?

HerrJac

Hello gents, with the upcoming release of Dragon Age the Veilguard, I was wondering if there is any plans to look back at Dragon Age Inquisition? Would love to see a performance comparison across the generations. I’ve been replaying Inquisition and it’s crazy to believe this game was GOTY.

I love the Habs

Hi guys! I am curious how you guys generally know so much about gaming tech? Are you software engineers that moved into journalism? Being a dev (not game) myself, I get the impression Alex can code, feel free to correct me if I'm wrong. Even if you guys are not engineers, it doesn't make your in depth knowledge any less impressive, I'm just curious about your own technical skills. I think part of your appeal is that you guys get so technical on software. There's so many channels that go over gaming hardware, but very few go over the software. If you had unlimited time, could just the DF team and only the DF team build an indie game?

Abhi

Did you notice any changes to performance or visuals with the day one patch for Metaphor Refantazio? Patch 1.003 on PS5

Diego ElRey

Hello DF, This question is for John. As a fellow Japan enjoyer, Mikado Takadanobaba is usually my first stop as an avid fighting game player. I also recently learned about the Ikebukuro location. Does it also have fighting games, and also with the talk of overtourism in Japan this year, did you feel that was the case?

Nolasco

Evening my DF Compadres. With the new Ps5 pro around the corner and the upcoming title Kingdom come Deliverance 2 that if I'm not mistaken is heavy on the CPU and not so much on the GPU is it fair to say that we can definitely not expect a smooth 60fps experience when only the GPU have been upgraded? And just of curiosity, what current gen games would you guys love to see as a PS1 title, a demake in other words. Take care and thank for your hard work.

Diego ElRey

Hello DF, Would it be fair to say that Sony has done more for AMD graphics than AMD has done for AMD graphics? Do you think AMD is going to take their break from the high end to at least try to bring the feature parity closer to Nvidia or even Intel? What do you think of the move? It seems like Nvidia is going to be able to run away with the whole market, and even those who bought 6900XT and 7900 series, will have to go Nvidia to keep that general level of performance for this upcoming generation, and possibly further. I don't believe there is an upside, but I also don't make graphics cards!

Diego ElRey

Hello DF, Does your profession hinder your enjoyment of gaming? Like when you know the ins and outs of techniques, and the various pros and cons of using them, when you see a choice that you don't agree with, does it affect your time with the game?

Octolimar

Unreal Engine 5 has been out for quite a few years now, and I was thinking about how while it is definitely flawed, it has certain features that other developers could definitely consider adopting. I think by far the most significant is Nanite. The feature is somewhat contested online due to allegations that it is allowing developers to not optimize their art thanks to its infinite culling capabilities. Regardless of whether that may be true or not, I think its more important aspect is that it removes LOD transitions. I dont think users necessarily care about how detailed an asset is, but seeing LODs visibly changing creates visual inconsistency, and nanite removing that transition is what makes it valuable in my opinion. I hope other developers adopt virtualized geometry, curious to here your thoughts on the matter. Do you agree? Am i missing any caveats?

Pol Kallamata

Looking at the Analogue 3D and how convenient it stands to make playing original N64 games I realized that A) the only "retro" gaming library and console hardware I've held on to is the that of the Wii and B) it's unlikely that Analogue will get to producing a modernized version of that platform in the near future. Outside of the solution that Analogue has created for the GameBoy / N64 are there any devices that you guys would recommend that we can connect to original hardware to deliver the same scaling / HDMI compatibility that Analogue is pitching. I know there are multiple solutions out there. Would just like your thoughts regarding the quality of them.

DudleyTheGentleman

Hi DF crew, what is the likelyhood of Analogue creating a Dreamcast? What are the potential roadblocks to such a device being developed?

Anxiously Chrono Triggered

Hey DF Team, Contrary to my question from last week (about numerous remasters coming out) what old game you really wish they remade these days with all RT glory or just contemporary graphics? Something you think would please both old timers and the new(er) audience? For some reason Hexen, Prehistorik and Ape Escape come first to my mind and I don’t know why. Cheers!

Anxiously Chrono Triggered

Hi DF, Quick CRT question for John: have you got all three main kinds of tubes at home: shadow mask, slot mask and aperture grille? Which one do you prefer? Or does it perhaps vary depending on the type of game you’re playing? I find slot mask to be the sweet spot but I know there’s lot of Trinitron fans out there who wouldn’t trade their AGs for anything else. Cheers!

Jonathan Hamilton

These videos are available to supporters in the DF Petro tier.

Jonathan Hamilton

Sony already released a console with HDMI and hardware support for playing PS1 games. It's called the PlayStation 3!

Nice Marmot

Will we see Boost Mode before PS5 Pro's general release? The total silence around Elden Ring in particular and From Software in general is deafening.

Colin Robinson

Do you think that Sony should take a lesson from Astro Bot and start making more games like it? Games that are just fun and look great but don't cost multimillions of dollars and many years to make? Nintendo's games don't push any graphical boundaries or even gameplay ones and they sell like gangbusters. Could both Sony and MS learn from this that tentpoles are fine but aren't the end all and be all?

Ildar Nurislamov

Kind of curious about discussions that PS5 CPU won't be enough for 60fps for certain games. PS5 CPU is more than 2 times faster in single-threaded load, and more than 5 times faster in multi-threaded than its PS4 counterpart. Yes, half of that goes to 30->60fps jump, but nonetheless. And honestly i don't see games that do hell lot more than they used to in PS4 era. More or less the same. Good physics, AI, fluid or cloth simulation are rare guests this days. I wonder what modern games you can name that can justify, lets say 2x CPU consumption? Another example is Zelda on Switch reaches 30fps doing physics and stuff on a joke of a CPU. I think that every game that can't reach 60fps on PS5 could potentially do so if developers were willing to optimize as hard as they did on PS4 times. I guess vast availability of high single-core performance in PC CPUs spoiled developers.

Alan

Hi John, Oliver & Richard, On last week's DF Direct John and Richard spoke about robot pets, I have a Petit Qoobo myself (it is a sort of robot pet cat) just wondering the teams views and thoughts on the actual robots being built now by the likes of Boston Dynamics, Engineered Arts, Figure and Tesla etc, are you excited at the prospect of mingling with artificial persons in the future or do you fear a Terminator'esq takeover!

Soundwave GI

Greetings Gents! I've searched high and low to find concrete evidence of the VRR range situation for the PS5 pro. Will it be capable of a 40-120hz range on unsupported titles like that of XBSX? I mainly play games on Xbox when they fall into that situation, with Elden Ring being a great example. I always get both consoles, so now that my preferred will be the ps5 pro, I'm hoping it can compete in this arena. I fear that we'll still deal with plenty of games that would drop under the inadequate 48 range and be left with a less than stellar experience. Thanks, and keep up the great work!

Stuart Hart

Hello!! So, Tomb Raider 4, 5 and 6 are getting the remaster treatment. While I feel it was admirable to bring the first three games to modern platforms, warts and all, I felt porting the games over as a near 1:1 replica was a missed opportunity. Considering Angel of Darkness is considered a (very) low point for the series, would you feel it acceptable if the game was remastered without fixing any of its glaring gameplay bugs? If they even fix all the bugs, is it a worthy endeavour at all, considering it’s, quite frankly, a poor game?

rave2noon

This is what I came to suggest

Michael Pearn

Great idea, I’m all for the 40 fps fidelity mode idea in certain games

Rich

Ue5 doesn't remove LOD transitions, it removes the need for developers to make LODs. There are still dithered LOD transitions.

tod weitzel

Is Microsoft turning the ship around on losing third party developers?

James Prendergast

I think the question is a little backwards in the framing. For one, Zelda uses its own custom engine - which will always have benefits for being designed specifically around one mechanic compared to an engine designed for general usage. Secondly, 30 - 60 fps (33.3 - 16.6 ms) is not only half the time - it's half the time for /all/ aspects of the frame being rendered. If a game has been designed to target 30 fps (regardless of the merits of that in my opinion) it's not only all of the CPU operations which need to fit within that 16.6 ms frametime but also the GPU operations. Just like with the recent Dragon's Dogma update, if you can get that all down to around 20 ms (50 fps) then most developers would probably choose to keep a solid 30 fps than have screen tearing and inconsistent frame delivery and whatnot... Each engine and game are different and have different technical requirements/bottlenecks. Just because you don't specifically see cloth simulation or what you may term "good" AI, doesn't mean that they're not heavy on the CPU. Remember that one of the big limitations on the console CPUs is the very small L2 and L3 caches compared to their equivalent desktop parts. My testing has shown a LOT of limitations are due to this. But, finally, there are also limits on the budget of each game - not to mention the technical skill of each team. Not every team has a John Carmack. Not every game has the budget or time to allocate to heavily customising a general engine. As Rich and the team often start out in their answers to this type of question - if the targets that the development starts with are not to achieve 60 or 120 fps, it's seems difficult to retroactively achieve that without serious re-architecting of not only the game's logic but also assets. So, your closing statement is mostly correct - with *enough* optimisation, most games could probably get to 60 fps. But the time for that has already passed for most of those games or the effort to do so for games already far into development could mean doubling the development time. The only caveat is that a lot of games on PS4 were *not* 60 fps and had much /less/ going on. You may feel like they are similar, but they're probably not, behind the scenes...

James Prendergast

Regarding the 6 nm Xbox Series APUs, I'm looking at the power savings and they appear similar to the 10 - 15 % that was seen for the PS5 1200 (?) model. I'm a little surprised the power savings are so similar. I would expect that a larger chip (with a wider GPU) would have greater savings than the PS5's APU. I know that this change allows cost savings on each unit manufactured for Microsoft but it's a little sad to think that they couldn't have instead boosted the CPU frequency by 100 - 200 MHz or something similar...

WarpTHUMP

Morning Gents, What do you think of Valve bringing back 'the demo' across steam's next fest over the last few years... Should a game demo be a tease? Should it be a chunk of the full experience? Should it only be available for a limited time ? Are the risks of releasing a buggy Alpha worse than not having a demo at all during these promotional events?

StfA

Hi DF Team. Gen5 NVMe SSD have been available since beginning of 2023 now but reading all the reviews and feedbacks, everybody seem to agree that they offer zero benefits when it comes to gaming. Such SSD cost a lot and are supposed to be 2 times faster than Gen 4 but in reality they aren't faster than Gen 4 SSD that are way cheaper. In the end does this mean that Gen 4 is the fastest we can get so far? What's holding everything back: is it the hardware (motherboard, CPU) or the software (Windows OS)? Thanks a lot for your work.

VeryProfessionalDodo

If you look at the “Road to PS5”, Mark Cerny gives a detailed explanation why 20x faster SSDs do not equate to 20x IO throughput. To resolve this, they had to implement A LOT of custom tech throughout the whole data accessing pipeline, including custom decompression hardware, just to ease the strain on the CPU

VeryProfessionalDodo

Playing through it again, and even though I enjoy it, technically it’s all over the place. 1080p30 still on PS5 with horrendous image quality, and uneven frame pacing for animations in both PS5 and PC

Meme

I sometimes question the digital foundry business sense, for example why make 50 videos on Cyberpunk and 15 videos on Starfield but not a single PC video for Hogwarts Legacy which is one of the best-selling video games of all time? Nothing against you guys, i just question the choice of which games you choose not to cover sometimes.

Darth Plaguies the unwise

Hello DF team. Do you think it possible we see amd's 3d cache technology make it's way into future generation consoles? Seems like a current technology that we know is effective at improving performance. Or is cost too high to imagine something like a 5800x3d being slapped into a ps6 in 4 years?

domstole

Hey DF with UE5 maturing and with more developers utilizing the engine, we continue to see the same stutters and performance overhead which affects even the beefiest of hardware. Moving forward would a refinement of the engine or more time in the oven when it comes to game optimization be better?

Shawn Farsai

Hey all. As you guys have mentioned before, 30fps can feel fine for some games. But with OLED monitors, this might not always feel great. Any advice on how to make lower frame rates (30 or 40) feel acceptable on OLED like they do on LED?

trayracer

Richard did a video on the potential performance gain in Elden Ring that may be had from the increased GPU power of the PS5 Pro. LFC may not be necessary if I recall. Also, John mentioned in DF Direct 183(?) during his segment on the PS5 Pro that there will be no change to the VRR situation. It's likely that if any change will come it will apply to both consoles.

Soundwave GI

True, but there are hardware changes, so it’s not inconceivable that it may be different. And if added horsepower ups resolution, then maybe frame rate still dips to 45. Crude example, but if the added HP isn’t used to address frame rate by the developer as it can be used for multiple purposes, then dips could be similar on the Pro.

Stop the Spread

I’ve got a question regarding PS5 Pro. What improvements, if any, would it give to psvr2 games?

Samson

Hey DF Boyz! (yes! "boyz" with a "z", Richard!) I'm wondering if anyone else has this problem. I love PC gaming! So naturally I invested a pretty penny on my rig but I also own a PS5. However, on PC, I find myself constantly adjusting settings and constantly switching on my performance overlay to make sure that I'm squeezing out every bit of performance out of my 4090. This obsession sometimes distracts me from actually enjoying the game. In contrast, on my PS5 I just turn it on and play. Mind you! in my opinion most of the time the experience on PC is better but when you add that obsession with the too many bad PC ports, it just sours it. Other than just no buying bad PC ports, got any advice?