Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Update: Just a quick update to say that the deadline for questions is Monday, 8am BST. And we'll be talking about Sony's statement on the end of physical media, so by all means comment on that and feel free to pose any questions on... well, anything!

Original post: Hi there, a mega late call for questions, but here we go! For this week's Direct, it'll Rich, Oliver and John at the mics and these are the topics we're considering.

First up, John reckons that this is one of the strongest performing console generations, with pretty much every game supporting 60fps - but at the same time, more users than ever believe that PC performance is in a very bad place. How can this be when PCs are effectively consoles? We'd love your input. By extension, we'll be zooming in on Halo Campaign Evolved directly after that - were we too positive about it? Are we growing immune to UE5's issues?

Other topics? A dynamite story from Jez Corden on Windows Central reveals that Microsoft is losing $150 per unit on Xbox Series consoles. Meanwhile, there's another remarkable statistic: 75% of Xbox Ally users are on Game Pass, but at the same time, for those who don't have an Xbox console, only 2% of purchases are on the Xbox Store. Does this end the "Helix running Steam" dream?

Other potential topics: what's happening with PS5 emulation and how come it's rapidly getting games into playable states? And Xbox takes full responsibility for the recent outage but what have we learned about the potential all-digital future?

As usual, we'd love your comments, questions and topic selections! Thanks in advance!

Files

Comments

Bad-News-Everyone

Hi DF dudes, just wondering if there’s any news about Alex -hope he’s doing okay!

Mario Rosa

Hello, Foundry Dudes. After seeing Sony sunsetting the PS3/Vita store and the PS6 all but confirmed to not have disks, should we be worried of Sony terminating backwards compatibility support for older platforms like the PS4 and eventually the PS5? With physical media production being terminated, the possibility that entire game libraries will be inaccessible without emulation is not something I'd be particularly fond of.

WrongGPU

Was wondering what you guys think about AMD’s approach to ml rt denoising, and what games you want to see nrc in!

Douglas Fowler

Hello Digital Foundrymen, I’m fairly new to FPGA gaming and recently picked up a SuperStation One. I’ve been having an absolute blast replaying Vagrant Story and Conker’s Bad Fur Day. Playing on a 240Hz OLED with proper integer scaling, low latency, and CRT-style video processing (the Trinitron filters) has honestly been the closest I’ve ever felt to playing the original hardware. It surprised me because I’d always assumed software emulation was “close enough.” With the recent release of the ModRetro M64 alongside products like the Analogue 3D and SuperStation One, I’m wondering where you see FPGA fitting into the industry’s future. Are we reaching the limits of what this hardware can deliver or do you expect FPGA hardware to continue evolving toward 6th-gen consoles like the Dreamcast, GameCube, PS2, and Xbox? And finally, if someone today wants the best possible FPGA retro gaming setup without owning a CRT, what would your ideal modern display and FPGA hardware configuration look like? Are there any displays, refresh rates, or video processing features you’d recommend to get as close as possible to the original experience on a modern screen? Thanks for all the incredible work you do!

NobleHeroine

Hi DF! Hope none of you have melted in the heat recently. Appreciate it if you could remain solid. On your note of PC performance, I think part of the problem is just that PC tech has not advanced as far as it had at the same point relative to most prior generations. Don't get me wrong, Zen 2 and RDNA 2 have aged significantly in the last six years, and compared to Zen 5 and Blackwell, they're meaningfully less capable. But compare Pascal or Turing to the GCN and Jaguar designs of the PS4, and, well, it's atomic bomb vs coughing baby all over again. So, on one part, people expect PC to vastly outperform consoles, even without spending halo-tier upgrade money. But beyond expectations, I think the Xbox Series consoles and especially PS5 were just very smartly designed, and have features pc has never been able to replicate, or at least not in full. For example, dedicated decompression hardware does a lot more than people realize, I suspect.

NobleHeroine

Also, secondary question. Is there plans to cover Splatoon Raiders? I'd really be curious to see your thoughts on the game. Splatoon 3 on Switch 2 already looks good, but there's some really cool water rendering and materials in Raiders that I'd love to see your opinion on. Some of it almost looks kinda PBR like?

Mario Rosa

Just being paranoid, I guess. Not sure how much trouble it'd be for Sony to keep implementing BC on future consoles since I know jack about programming.

Someguyperson

Why is there the perception that PC games don't have great performance? John has to look no further than his own household. John's son's eyes start to bleed if a game runs at 60 FPS. He needs 120 FPS at a minimum, which is difficult for most CPUs of today. I think people were too accustomed to PC having far superior CPU horsepower compared to consoles all the way from Conroe/Core 2 Duo until this generation of consoles came out. (~14 years) The perception was that you could buy a cheap CPU & cheap memory and as long as you had the beefiest GPU you could afford, you would have good performance. That's simply not the case anymore and the bigger YouTube channels don't preach the value of a good CPU to overall performance as much as you do Rich. You can't just double the framerate of a console with a budget CPU like you used to anymore. Another issue might be games like Elden Ring; lots of the biggest games have extremely questionable choices made and general performance. We've had so many bad PC ports that Alex had to make several videos a year covering how bad all of them are. Why cap a PC game to 60 FPS? Why not include all the various upscalers? Why do lower quality textures look like we're back on the N64, but memory usage is still too high for an 8 GB GPU? Even when you generally do the right things, you can still have issues like you saw on 007 where the upscalers weren't working correctly. Finally, PC users up the resolution too high, generally speaking. If a PC user is going to turn something down, they'll lower settings down before adjusting resolution down, even though that's not how the games were designed to scale in the first place. More support for full-resolution 2D elements and lower resolution 3D elements could help resolve that, alongside better variable resolution support, but PC ports don't really have those things either. Even then, a lot of PC users don't use any upscaling whatsoever and complain when the game designed for upscaling doesn't work when you disable an upscaler.

狐のケイ - Cae the Kitsune

Your original wording sounds like you're imagining they'd remove PS4 backwards compatibility from people's PS5s via an update, which would be slightly dystopian.

Mario Rosa

Oh, not at all. I had mentioned the PS6 previously and thought it was clear I was talking about PS6 and/or future consoles getting BC removed. I should've been more clear on that.

RAVE_DAM0S

Hola Foundry Folk! Between Jez Corden’s reports that an open 'Project Helix' forces $1,000+ prices, Asha Sharma’s focus on engineering cheaper hardware alternatives, and the return of XBOX exclusives, everything points toward a pivot back to a traditional closed subsidized console (no Steam). With PC Backwards Compatibility unveiled, could Microsoft achieve a cheaper box by selling one closed, subsidized XBOX (~$800), while leaving open $1,000+ PC/console hybrids entirely to OEMs like ASUS or Lenovo? Would offloading open PC hardware to third parties protect baseline spec parity for developers while keeping Gen 10 Xbox entry costs down and avoiding a repeated Series S bottleneck. Best!

Anthony

Hello Non-Analogue Smelter Masters, The number of remasters seems to be increasing but many don’t allow save data to transfer. Any insights you can share into why? It seems like most game save files would easy to transfer over and would not require much if any engineering.

bizzytrax

Helix will probably have more Microsoft storefront sales than the Ally by the nature of it being the main console created by Microsoft, not a project with a third party. I don’t know how many casual gamers are buying pc handhelds, then again with rumored pricing of helix maybe it’s not a casual machine. I do also think it may depend on the availability of bringing your existing Xbox library with you. Maybe it will still work regardless as an unsubsidized game pass machine? Maybe Microsoft just buys Valve

Pie Studios

Hello gents! When it comes to game performance on PC vs Console, I believe PC ports get a bad rep due to outliers that have performance problems. Games like TLOU Part 1, Spider-Man 2, Jedi Survivor showcase the worst behaviors of the PC platform, at least when they first launched. Even if there are hundreds of other PC games that run excellent on a toaster, the bad games write the narrative. Also, I believe the shift to high refresh rate monitors has morphed people’s expectations, while their budgets have not changed to accommodate. If you want 120+ FPS in Expedition 33, you can’t reasonably get that without upgrading from your RTX 3050 or whatever. Standards need to be realistic.

ZeeYoGlade

Salutation. Listener for a while, first time putting in a question. John once said, “it is possible to create games at a faster clip with lower investment and still be successful.” While not talking about the one company that’s been doing that consistently. From March to July, Nintendo had the following output of games: Pokopia, Tomodachi Life: Living the Dream, Yoshi and the Mysterious Book, Star Fox, Rhythm Heaven Groove, and Splatoon Raiders. Most of these games also fall outside of John’s (and Digital Foundry’s) radar, as evidenced that you guys only showed interest of talking about Star Fox and briefly Yoshi. And even though a majority of these don’t show the potential of the Switch 2 hardware necessarily (apart from Star Fox), they all showcase the power of a catalogue with variation in different styles and gameplay. And found success in their sales. This is a method Nintendo has been doing and found success in. Experimenting on ideas for unique gameplay, and diversifying their library with different IPs of various development cycles. Especially when they are a 100% gaming company, they need to have this diversity to sell their hardware even it is less powerful and the games have questionable performances. But this strategy is what made the Switch 1 their most successful console. Do you think Sony have dug themselves too deep in chasing high-end type games, or can they pivot in a direction akin to Nintendo’s methods? And if it also meant putting out more games outside the Digital Foundry radar (i.e., less focused on the tech, specs)?

NobleHeroine

You can't realistically get that with a 5060 though either. Like you have a point, but there is an issue where lower end and midrange hardware is scaling poorer than high end hardware.

狐のケイ - Cae the Kitsune

Way back in DF Direct Weekly #231, you all reported on a rumor that the PlayStation 6 would feature an optional add-on disc drive similar to the PS5 Slim and Pro. Given the current state of things, what are the chances that Sony offers the disc drive as a separate purchase solely for backwards compatibility a la the Power Base Converter? If they can't implement a disc-to-digital program comparable to what Microsoft is supposedly doing due to PlayStation discs lacking the same type of unique IDs, perhaps a disc drive add-on is the next best solution. At the same time, it wouldn't be a first for them if the PS6 simply offered digital-only backwards compatibility. *coughvitacough*

Pol Arbequina

Hello gents! I've been looking at people's experience on Halo CE with the Steam Machine. And while I can't confirm this myself without one, I have the feeling that it's underperforming very noticeably compared to the PS5 footage Oliver showed in your review. Do you this has something to do with the poor PC port or is there something else at play there? Thanks and have a great day!

MattGPT

Hello Gents. Your recent reviews of Halo Campaign Evolved demonstrated that once again, UE5 games running on PC at equivalent or lower settings than console seems to be much less CPU efficient. I think the current gen console are equivalent to something like a 3700X, yet on PC even 9800X3D sometimes has CPU issues with UE5 games when the consoles do not, do you have any ideas why there is such an difference? Cheers!

MattGPT

Hello gents. I have recently played through Stellar Blade and really enjoyed it, I had previously tried and given up on release having not got into it, but thought I would give it another go. I remember finding this with with different games over the years, the same with Death Stranding and even going all the way back to the original Final Fantasy 7. Sometimes the games that I just did not gel with on the first attempt end up being brilliant and some of my all time favourites. Have you found the same and do you have any insight into why certain games can feel this way, or is it a me thing? Cheers!

Pol Arbequina

Greetings! Regarding the perceived PC performance woes in this generation. I have the feeling that the introduction of an ever growing stack of technologies is getting too confusing for people. It used to be that you'd only need to read what the optimised settings for a game were. But now you have upscaling, frame generation, ray tracing, RR, etc. And they are all different experiences on different vendors. So I think people don't know how to set up their game in order to get a good experience. I've noticed even Youtubers that regularly post tech content make some questionable choices with their settings. So I can't imagine most people are making reasonable decisions. For the consoles this is never an issue because these decisions are always made for you. Any thoughts?

Magnumstache

If Rich's guest room is to become his new office, does this mean subsequent guests will have to sleep within the cone of respectability, terrified to roll over lest they be jagged by an errant GTX 1080 or stick of DDR3 RAM?

MattGPT

The perception is probably there because of UE5, because even the best CPUs money can buy, the 9800X3D, 9950X3D2 or even the top of the range Threadripper (not directly for gaming but still absurd), delidded, with direct die water-cooling and hugely overclocked will still have CPU related issues compared to a console running the equivalent of a 3700X. There are plenty of games that have issues on PC at equivalent or lower settings than console even when running on vastly more powerful hardware. With regard to the turning resolution down I think one of the big reasons some people do not do that is related to UI elements, personally I think the UI should always be a separate layer running at full native resolution, with the graphics doing the scaling, for most games that would barely hit a 1% difference but it really makes a presentation difference. As for the resistance to upscaling I do not understand it, DLSS and FSR4 are great, during gameplay very few people can tell the difference in quality between native and sensible upscaling and as you point out often upscaled looks better than native, usually due to enhanced subpixel detail and better AA.

Marcus

Hiya foundrymen! Halo: Campaign Evolved can look extremely noisy, and forcing Ray Reconstruction through Ultra Plus produces a much cleaner image. However, it only appears stable with Ultra RT. Lower settings become extremely flickery, supporting the idea that Ray Reconstruction needs RT effects traced at the game’s native internal resolution. This would also fit Star Wars Outlaws and Crimson Desert, where Ray Reconstruction is tied to the highest RT setting. As you highlighted in the video, it is not artifact-free, with some small particles smearing across frames, possibly because they lack reliable motion-vector data. Even so, the overall image-quality improvement is substantial. Its official absence makes some sense, since Ultra RT is already extremely heavy and Ray Reconstruction adds further cost. But if developers are already implementing such demanding Ultra RT modes, is Ray Reconstruction not worth the additional implementation time as a future-facing option, even if current hardware cannot run it particularly well? I hope you have a great week!

Teasing Hilarity

Hi Gentlemen. I’d be interested to see if the data backs up the claim PC performance is generally in a poor place (anyone remember .bat and .sys files in MS-DOS?). Nevertheless, to the claim: PCs /aren’t/ consoles, of course. They’re a different architecture notably lacking unified RAM; with a multitude of different component, spec, and driver combinations; all running on different OS(s). While it mightn’t be friendly to PC users it’s certainly easier — and likely more profitable — to optimise for the clearly-defined console platforms first and leave PC users to twiddle the engine settings to get an experience they’re happy with until there’s time (if ever) to do more optimisation. While it’s fair to question if such an approach is reasonable, I don’t see much incentive for a different one from publishers at present. Am I missing something?

Gareth H

Hey DF Crew, with the never ending RAM price saga will Sony cut back the RAM for PS6? Could we see a 24Gb PS6 and what would it mean for games? How low could they go?

MittenFacedLass

Unless there's some crazy architecture differences, which I can't imagine happening considering the way consoles have gone in the last decade or so, PS6 will most definitely be able to play PS4 and PS5 games. As far as further BC beyond that? I'd say up in the air, but Sony does seem pretty dedicated to PS1/PS2/PSP ports via emulation as well. PS3 they offer via cloud, and PS Vita currently not at all. I think they could theoretically broaden support to include those two platforms, but it would definitely require R&D investment in emulation or recompilation. If they were smart, it would be a good move to win some reputation back among gamers, but who knows. Predicting the way companies move in the industry (and in some ways the economy in general) has little to do with goodwill anymore, unfortunately, whether or not it might be good for them long-term.

MittenFacedLass

Highly case dependent. Definitely some cases where they definitely could but don't, though. At the end of the day, I would guess the most valid reason it doesn't happen is due to QA challenges. It adds a lot of additional testing possibilities and avenues, if you want to make sure everything works right. If the game is a fairly straightforward port, that may not be too much of a problem, but still takes time and money, but the more changes made, the more those factors increase. IF you want to ship something where importing saves doesn't completely break things. Which is generally a good goal if you're committing to that feature.

MittenFacedLass

God, I hope so, but I don't have much hope at this point. :(

MittenFacedLass

Valve would never take that offer. Not while they're still a private company and the people that are there, are there.

MittenFacedLass

It's kind of getting back to the 90s PC era where what hardware you had, and how you used it, could result in wildly different experiences in games, based on hardware/software support. Was messy then. Is increasingly messy now.

Kris Graney

Hello DF, With proposed prices of over $1000/£1000/€1000, these are becoming luxury items that not everyone can afford. Even the current Gen consoles have had their sales tank because of recent price increases. Nintendo's differing approach to chip selection for their consoles - going for the lower end of cost/performance - compared to Microsoft and Sony, do you foresee PS6 and Helix to sell far less than the much more affordable Switch 2? Has Nintendo already won the next generation? Thanks!

DaJaCo (Dan)

Happy Half-Fortnight Lads - Proposal for a little DF project here - There's a guy on youtube who normally provides GPU Repair Services, who is now offering GPU Memory upgrades, which seem to be fairly comprehensive in their implementation. Are there any "Ideal Candidate" GPUs, perhaps one at the low end, and one at the high end, that could be sent off to him to see what the impact of such an upgrade can be? It could be a very interesting experiment, and fitting amid the bloodbath of RAMageddon.. ? https://www.youtube.com/@GraphicsCardRepairs-tk7ql

mrtnptrs

Halo Campaign Evolved's usage of Chromatic Aberration seems to be used very heavily, essentially blurring most of the image, according to the opinions of many. Besides a toggle still being missing to disable this effect, might "Halo Studios" have implemented this effect the wrong way? Should they reconsider a different implementation of this effect? What would your suggestions be for Halo Studios to possibly improve the implementation of this effect?

mrtnptrs

From studying Campaign Evolved's credits, it can be seen that even some core Halo Studios personnel was gathered through recruitment agencies. Most importantly, the credits seem to indicate that this remake was actually developed like 80 to 90% by talented outsourced personnel from many subsidiaries of both Keywords Studios and Virtuos. What do you guys at DF think about the long-term consequences this might have and what they might entail? What does "Halo Studios" actually mean? Personnel that manages the work done through outsourcing?

mrtnptrs

I see more and more games getting delisted, while their Denuvo Anti-Tamper DRM implementation doesn't get removed at or after delisting. Examples are Codemaster's F1 games, EA's Sports games, F1 Manager games, NBA 2K games etc. Why would publishers/developers not patch it out at or after delisting? Doesn't this risk these games's preservation for existing owners if their implementation of Denuvo would ever cease functioning?

mrtnptrs

Yeah, same here. Even if there is no news, an update now and then would be nice. Even if it would be literally "He is still recovering, no news" haha. It must be frustrating for both Alex himself and the DF team. A team that close and dynamic is missing one of their comrades. Hope that Alex will be medically ok again soon as he really seems to love his job. Being away from it for this long, might also then have a negative mental impact. That might make his situation even worse as pain gets more difficult to deal with when you are struggling.

Zombiedude101

On this; I think Nintendo realised a long time ago that trying to compete with Microsoft & Sony on "AAA" games was never going to pan out. I think they had that phase in the 00s experimenting with stuff like the Twin Snakes MGS1 remake & Resident evil exclusivity and it just didn't shift the systems they wanted. So instead they cast a wider net with a philosophy of appealing to multiple audiences and focusing on what works for them rather than chasing trends.

Zombiedude101

Ayup folks. Kind of poetic to see the PS5 emulation scene gaining more attention in light of Sony's plans to end disc production. Is it fair to say the similarity of PS5 to x86 architecture are making the likelihood of a performant emulator more realistic, at least within the next few years? It does make me wonder if Sony might feel threatened by this considering their shift away from porting exclusives to PC. On another note, even though we do see disparity between PC and console ports, I think there's a good argument that modern games will often at least run at a playable level (albeit with lower graphic fidelity) on older hardware, compared to the situation we were in 10-15 years ago. Hardware from the early-mid 10s is still performant on non-RT games, but I could not imagine hardware from the early-mid 00s running games from the next decade.

Never Ready Eddie

Hi DF chaps. So, CHROMATIC ABERRATION, there I said it. There is much internet chatter around this long hated effect and its affect on game visuals following the recent Halo Campaign Evolved release. I am not going to ask your opinion on it as it is subjective, but I would like to know if there is any truth to the rumour that UE5 has this and film grain enabled by default, and that devs just don’t bother disabling it. That last part is conjecture and I am more interested in the "enabled by default" truth. Oh, and if it is true, given your close working relationship with Epic on their "kill the hitch", perhaps give them a call and ask nicely that they change it to "disabled by default". I know we would prefer a toggle, but if its not enabled by default, surely that is a better starting point for devs to add the option? Thanks!

Yannis Panagiotidis

Dear foundrylads. On the topic of how expensive it is to manufacture consoles nowadays, do you imagine that we will ever go back to the days of cheaper consoles? And I'm not specifically talking about the launch price, but the days that by the end of the lifecycle a console could cost 1/2 all the way down to 1/3rd of its launch price. I'm just afraid that with how inaccessible console gaming is to families and especially kids, that console gaming will slowly go down the way of arcade gaming and become a niche.

JL

Hi DF Team, Things are not looking great for PS5 discs or physical video game media in general. What if the compromise was a bespoke edition of certain games that included a physical disc? They could even include a paper manual to really appeal to collectors. Price it as a premium version and make it made to order, so publishers would not be left with unneeded stock sitting in warehouses or on store shelves. This would give Sony another reason to offer an optional disc drive for the PS6 beyond backwards compatibility. Physical media fans would still have an option, digital would remain the main version most people buy, and Sony could make more money from a premium product.

RAVE_DAM0S

Such a cool conversation. Has @john ever talked about FPGA gaming on the DF Retro show?

TheMightyEthan

Hey DF! If the OG Xbox PC "backwards compatibility" is an OG Xbox emulator running inside a 360 emulator, does that mean it represents a foundation towards "BC" for native 360 games too? Lots of 360 games have native PC versions but that was an era where lots of PC ports of console games were "interesting" to say the least, so playing the console versions on PC could be a game changer, not to mention all the games that never got ported. I'd love to hear your thoughts. Cheers!

Spencer M.

Hello DF, It turns out that there are "Very Low" settings for Halo Campaign Evolved, but it's only available for handheld PCs. What do you think the rationale is behind preventing desktop PCs from accessing those settings?

Skyrimfest 26 FPS Edition

With consoles we used to see a steady progression of graphical improvements over their lifecycle. Is that still true and do you think there is there much left in the tank for the PS5 and Switch 2? And could you see console-like optimisations being pursued more on the PC, now we are entering a period of relative stability in people's specs (stagnation really) and some fixed-hardware targets like Steam Deck and Steam Machine.

Chromatic Abomination

Hi DF Crew. Do you have any insight into why the AAA space almost unanimously uses effects such as film grain and chromatic aberration? I find that these effects do nothing but destroy image quality, and in the case of chromatic aberration, can be a literal eye sore when excessive. When booting up Halo: Campaign Evolved for the first time it was the first thing I noticed and it is ruining the experience since it can't be turned off. What gives? Games are not films and these effects make no sense in the gaming space to me.

Someguyperson

Complete freedom to work within a limited budget is exactly how you make money in this industry. Forcing a dev to check off a bunch of boxes and giving them an unlimited budget in order to do so leads to complete failure.

Someguyperson

Well, what do you exactly define as "CPU issues" then? People on PC aren't running the console performance mode settings and expecting 120 FPS, they're using the quality mode settings and expecting 120+ FPS. A ton of settings nowadays demolish the CPU and the actual impact of that might not be conveyed in the best way, which leads people to believe there are CPU issues.

Douglas Fowler

He did a DF Retro video on an FPGA wall-mounted arcade setup about 6 years ago that I liked. And I’m sure he’s talked about it here and there but before I was really paying attention to the space.

Someguyperson

In Sony's latest earnings, they doubled down on ditching the discs, but there were also some very interesting numbers to prove that point. $0.781 billion in physical sales, $6.5 billion in digital game sales and a staggering $8.4 billion in in-game purchases. Here's the rub though; if Sony prevents a marketplace for games outside of it's own store, a lot of governments will force 3rd party stores as alternative digital storefronts. If Steam comes in and promises purchases that transfer across to PC, a substantial percentage of those DLC purchases might go through Steam instead of the PlayStation store. Is Sony potentially winning the battle, but losing the war in the long run here? Keeping disc sales gives the illusion of a competitive marketplace, but shutting that down opens them up for a far more costly legal fight than it would be to just keep the small amounts of discs flowing.

DieH@rd

Hello DF! Do you think adoption of the next-gen Xbox Helix console will be impacted in any way because it will only support "base" BC versions of Xbox Series games? This time around, they elected not to release a mid-gen upgrade, and their games will remain "locked" to often sub-1080p resolutions and subpar upscalers "forever". On the other hand, the PlayStation 5 library already has over 200 games with Pro enhancements (boosted resolution, PSSR upscaling, enhanced RT effects), ensuring that its software can be reproduced with better visuals on future hardware.

Kaveh PG

If the PS6 is going to be ballpark 4080, what do you think the PS6 Pro will offer? When will Moore's Law die?

Someguyperson

I'll push back on Rich's comments that a PC doesn't last 10 years a little bit (from #274 Q&A). While almost everything inside a PC won't last 10 years, you could keep the same motherboard & memory and upgrade everything else. I built my current PC in 2019. I have since updated the CPU, GPU, CPU cooler, case, PSU, storage, and added 2 more sticks of the same memory. Is it a bit of the whole "ship of Theseus" thing? Sure, but that's also a huge, integral part to the PC experience. You don't really build a PC and not tinker with it over time. That's a huge part of the fun and value in it. I took all the old parts and made a NAS out of it, so it's not really wasted either.

NobleHeroine

Keep in mind, the news might be "Alex does not want the entire world to be informed of his medical situation."

Sam Ecorners

Hello my dearest DF friends. How do you feel about the following dream of a situation: Asha goes all in on exclusivity and kills other storefronts on Helix. Sony, seeing as there's no more chance of an Xbox running Sony games reverts their no ports on PC policy and finally starts PC releases again. PC gamers win. So could Asha actually preserve PC as a unique platform while doing whatever it is she thinks she's gonna do(1 bil minecraft) with the Xbox?

Sam Ecorners

Just want to use this opportunity to send Alex love. Whatever his situation is he is still loved and appreciated.

HarryB

Enjoyed Oli’s XC2 review but disappointed that he didn’t offer a view on the fact that XC canon is that the main character goes on to father children with (!) of the blades in the game. Would love to get Oli and John’s thoughts on this weirdness.

MattGPT

Hello gents. With the recent musings around the PS6 and PS6 handheld, what if the reason Sony made their awful blog post about ending disc production was they knew it would leak anyway and they are not ready to announce the PS6 and it's handheld will move to cartridges, so it offers full cross play? With the add on that the PS6 will support any USB Blu-ray drive or the PS5 drive via an adapter, allowing the PS6 to have backwards compatibility and even allowing it to hold the disc as a license to run the game on the handheld. Possible, or should I have drunk more coffee this morning? Cheers!

J Heron

Greetings. The biggest sore point of PC gaming for me is CPU-bound frame time inconsistency and dropped frames. Why is it so common for games that run at a flat 60fps with clean frame pacing on consoles to have CPU-bound stutter (not shader compilation or traversal stutter) on Windows? Alan Wake 2 is a perfect example, with scenes inside the police station dropping frames on even a 7800X3D + RTX5090 when targeting 60fps and using RTSS to limit frame rates. You frequently point to VRR mitigating this problem, but that’s not the case on OLED displays, where VRR flicker in dark scenes is as disruptive and immersion-breaking as stutter. Is it simply a matter of investment priorities, or is it fundamentally harder for developers to get right on Windows? Doom the Dark Ages shows what can be done with the right priorities and talent.

RagingWhisky

What might be the tech and 'secret sauce' feature-sets that will be there for the PS6/Helix releases that will set them out as 'justifying' to the public at large consumerbase l, a potential $1000 pricepoint? Each generation has usually done something to distinguish, whether 16bit 32bit, cdrom, dvd, bkuray, internal drives - hdd and now nvme, advancing from SD to HD to 4K (mostly-ish). When thinking about the 'what comes next' cant help but think machine learning/inference and squeezing more from less might be the result, making it seem a lot to ask in the current climate. Thoughts?

ozgoz

Salutations DFers! Sony's disc statement is disingenuous in a way worth naming precisely. "Strong opinions" recasts the substance of an objection as mere intensity of expression, and the vocabulary of "feelings" marks users as emotional. Both are sleights of hand, and both sidestep objections that are economic and rational: resale, library permanence, delisting risk, and pricing power on a storefront with no competing sellers. Dressing that up as listening to the community is shameful. Which raises a question about game reviewing generally. The standing principle is that you assess the game, not the publisher's distribution decision. But that separation isn't neutral — it's why ownership terms sit in the one zone no evaluative pressure ever reaches, which is precisely the arrangement that suits Sony. Publishers, not developers, decide whether there's a complete physical release, and publishers are the ones who care how a game is received. So should distribution model be reviewable? Whether that's a score at outlets that use them, or a version recommendation at outlets that don't — is "complete disc release" a legitimate thing to weigh, or does that break something important about what a review is for?

Craig.wtf

Howdy to the Messrs of Graphical Measurements. Long-time YouTube lurker, first-time Patroniser. As with, seemingly, the majority of the world, I’m frustrated with the abominable all-digital future of both Xbox and PlayStation. Not because I specifically like discs but because of the closed nature of consoles. Without doubt the biggest concern of a lot of people is the loss of cheaper access to games via the used market. Nintendo has teased a future for this via the use of key carts but I feel that’s likely to go the way of the digital dodo as soon as Microsoft and Sony push the self-destruct button on their disc facilities. Hopefully, the EU or another heavyweight authority will step in and offer some hope for us mortals in the form of at least one of the following: A) Minimum guaranteed time that a digital product must remain available for download after purchase (at least a year from the last date that it was available to buy). B) A digital product must remain indefinitely functional after it is removed from sale without the need to call home for a licence check or continue to provide licence checking after a product is removed from digital shelves. C) Digital purchases must be transferable both after their owner’s death and also as a second-hand commodity . Obviously no company wants to lose out on their cut when games are sold used so I have a suggestion that I’d like to hear your thoughts on: Why not monetise selling used games? E.g. - I go into my PlayStation account and select a game I want to sell. - Sony then charge me a rate commensurate with the current sale value of the game (like 15%) to create a single-use, time-limited code that I can provide to the buyer to transfer the licence. - The game will then be locked in my account until either the time limit runs out or it’s transferred to another user. This way they profit just as much as they did before and could even include a cut for the developers. Would love to hear your thoughts on this. Craig.wtf

Eric Benoit

I remember when DF Direct Q&A was just starting i had asked about the possibility of Sony giving up the console and just being an operating System. This was during the pandemic where there was a parts shortage, but do you think Sony and Microsoft are eventually heading in that direction?

MattGPT

Ok, well that aged well. I have not bought physical since the early PS4 era, but for Sony to let the first comment since the blog announcement be a soulless comment from the CFO a month later is absolutely awful. Does no one within Sony understand how public relations work, even if they are just managing the inevitable?

MattGPT

Hello gents. Was the first statement to come from Sony about physical media since the blog post being a tone dead comment from the CFO a month later a PR blunder on the scale usually reserved for Microsoft? Regardless of one's views on the end of physical media it just seems like a total PR blunder, with no strategy on how to handle the fallout or plan to deflect the conversation to something more positive. Sony used to be great at playing the PR game, there seemed to be a specific Japanese pride in the way they handled those messages, what went wrong? Cheers!

Chicken Point

Isn't $800 far-fetched (even subsidised)? Consider: 1) Xbox loses $100+ on each Series X that they sell 2) Memory prices are expected increasing until late 2027 3) Helix is expected to have *at least* double the RAM of the Series X (i.e., 32GB+) 4) The digital Series X RRP is currently $750 (with another price increase expected in 2027) Given those points, why would we expect a subsidised Helix RRP of $800? The Series X is already subsidised, and it's $800. Costs are going to get worse. Helix has more memory. Conclusion: the $800 prediction doesn't seem to make any sense. Please correct me if there's something you think I'm misunderstanding. My opinion is that Sony and Xbox both delay out of 2027. All the major commentators (including DF) say this is unlikely, but when it is announced, I don't think anyone will be the least bit surprised.

Alan

Hi guys, So the Xbox price rises have now gone live, the sales of Xbox's was already low, has it not reached the point where they need to just announce the next gen and kill the XSS and XSX because surely nobody is going to invest in a current gen Xbox now, a 5pro is only about £120 more (no disc drive) but 2tb storage and can buy a disc drive, than an XSX.

Magnumstache

You have discussed that the PS6/NeXtbox may struggle for traction since the gaming masses feel that graphics have plateaued while AAA game design hasn't evolved much from the templates laid down in the Xbox 360/PS3 era. Do you think it's time for game developers (and developers of game engines like Unreal) to pivot away from prioritising improved graphical fidelity towards things like more performant physics simulations or destructible environments that could enable new gameplay systems to emerge? In my opinion the most innovative game of the last decade is Breath of the Wild, which ran on a Wii U and yet had an exciting and coherent game world. I feel like taking inspiration from that approach would be a bigger next-gen draw than individually rendered horse follicles or whatever Rockstar offer.

Alan

Hi guys, Grand Theft Auto: Vice City VR has gone live for Quest on PC, people seem to like it, should Sony and R* team up and get GTA6 on PSVR2, surely it wouldn't take that much maybe Sony could just money hat it? It would send VR2 sales soaring, playing GTA6 in VR would be next level!

SirToby

DF Weekly - Bad thing happen DF Q&A - Why did bad thing happen?

DaJaCo (Dan)

LADS - Patent Alert!! So, with all the usual patent caveats and a big bucket of salt, Mike Odyssey has uncovered a recently published Nintendo patent which describes a novel way of "fixing" the problems with screen space reflections by dynamically calculating an offset reflection angle which keeps a reflection on-screen, instead of clipping or fading away as reflected objects go off screen. I feel like there was a similar one a year or two ago, and this does add weight to idea that they have some new performant reflection system brewing. Could you take a look and see if sounds like it would be promising were it ever to see the (reflected) light of day..?

Teasing Hilarity

Hi Gentlemen. With Sony’s recent comments on ending physical media production, they seem supremely confident that the market is with them here. I don’t have any visibility of the data they’re using to make their decisions, and much less whether they’re interpreting it reasonably, but I do wonder whether the likes of us in the enthusiast community are really a very small part of the pie these days. Could it be that our concerns around ownership and internet requirements really don’t feature for the vast majority of consumers who typically play PS games these days? Put another way, could it be that for those who don’t choose a digital purchase in the first place, code in a box is as good as disc in a box for the vast majority of them, who just want to play the game? Thanks and best wishes for the week!

RAVE_DAM0S

I don't think your opinion is wrong. What I've heard after listening to MLID is that the BOM for Gen 10 may not be as high with XBOX possibly able to offer Magnus for 900-1000. A second part, where my opinion comes in, is that if XBOX or Sony are going to subsidize a console, the price needs to be like a console price (e.g. 700-800, but to your point increasing all the time). If you're correct and a subsidized console still comes in at 900-1000, well (my opinion) at that point why even subsidize at all. Just sell me the open PC Helix for 1200-1500. There's a threshold where I'm just going to go straight to PC. Reference July 26th: Tom calculated the core component costs (raw BOM) at approximately ~$900: https://youtu.be/8unDLejaXRU?t=972&is=ToMVSpRwXYh1faRf

lbb12

Hello DF crew! When speaking about upgrades and people buying now as opposed to later due to the industry's self-induced memory and storage crisis thanks to AI, would this article I came across the other day help anyone "upgrade" their GPU to give it increased longevity? An outfit called GPU Solutions is doing just that: https://youtu.be/nJ97nUr1G-g?si=wNA0JyKgqrwYWhyU

lbb12

Hello again DF gents! This one's for John: considering the gaming industry's total and utter lack of care for the consumers that actually buy the products that are making them money (i.e. XBOX reset and Sony ending discs), do you think there will be an even BIGGER resurgence for retro? A younger brother of mine got the wife and I a Saturn with a SAROO cart, and we've been having an absolute BLAST playing games from my teens again on our 32" Toshiba CRT from 2004, and even discovering fan translated gems like BAROQUE or DARKSEED, Wachenroeder and even Grandia!

lbb12

My good DF sirs, my conclusion about poor PC performance as opposed to more widespread 60FPS adoption on current console gen is this: more devs are finding it easier to optimize for a fixed spec console (ex. PS5, XBOX series X, Switch 2, etc.), as opposed to the open ended spec PC that's forever changing with a zillion hardware configs to account for. As Tom pointed out in a past video (which I can't remember which it was, and I paraphrase), after a long hard day you don't want to have to fiddle with game settings for hours/troubleshoot just to get your game to work. Games *generally* just work on consoles and perform relatively well without any of that hassle. I seriously lament the amount of trouble I'd have to go through just to get PSVR2 support for F1 24 or 25 on PC, whereas on PS5 it would just WORK if they'd implement it.

Peter

Good day digital foundrymen! I have seen the conversations online these past few days around PC graphics and performance and also your own conversation on the matter on the latest DF Direct. I too think that expectations are misaligned in some cases around what performance and settings should be expected on various tiers of hardware. I actually think that for the most part, PC games have been just fine and performed largely on par with console on like for like hardware. On console, you "get what you're given" for lack of a better term, with settings curated to hit that 60fps target. Do you think, on those games that are on console and PC, a "console setting" preset would be of benefit? Applying all those same tweaks and adjustments that the developers deemed worth the compromise. Thus removing the agonising over settings and mismanaged expectations that I feel some may be inflicting upon themselves. Have a great day and keep up the great work. Hope Alex is doing well

Digital Foundry

Haha well here's the funny thing. The fibre coming into the house goes into my office, so I actually had to clear most of the junk so the electrician could feed network cables into the new office. So, amazingly, outside of the cone of respectability, things look 100x better now.

Digital Foundry

We tried to do a "good thing happened this gen" in Direct #275 to be fair

Digital Foundry

Yup, I make exactly the same point at the end of the first segment in DF Direct #275.

Digital Foundry

Thing is that per my comments at the end of the first segment of DF Direct #275, developers could lock in their console equivalent specs and then simply apply a resolution change to accommodate lower/higher spec GPUs.

Digital Foundry

Switch 2 will sell more unless there are some truly "innovative" pricing strategies. But nobody is interested in winning console wars any more. They're more interested in higher profit margins. If that means fewer consoles, they likely don't care.

Peter

My apologies Rich! I (somewhat ambitiously) started listening late last night and made it about 15 mins in before falling asleep! Just caught up and yes, you have said exactly that!

Kris Graney

If they don't sell many then it doesn't matter how big their profit margin is, it's still a high % of a small amount. I really enjoyed the discussion you all had last week. Great stuff!

lbb12

Fair enough, and sorry for delay in my being up to date with DF directs. I tend to be a few behind b/c of IRL stuff, but I sincerely appreciate your reply! <3 I'm thinking maybe your idea might be hampered by Windows then, as the consoles don't have a buggy OS to tend with to compete for FPS and performance. God knows Rich laments Windows and Alex hates UE5 stutter, which consoles seem to not have to deal with most of the time :)

Kris Graney

I think you were absolutely right in the Q&A saying it is up to MS and Sony to make the software to justify the purchase but given MSv record on that part - other than Halo and Xbox, have they ever had a killer launch? 360 they had the market to themselves for a year so not really a need for one as the tithes came out over that 12 month period, Xbone they were launched with the PS4 and they had what? Knack (🤭)? Same for the series consoles with nothing that springs to mind and ps5 had a Spiderman game at least. I have more hope in Sony at least bringing something to justify $1000+ console purchase but u really doubt it. A $1000 pc upgrade is very different to a $1000 console. I do wonder if the EU will have anything to say about opening the consoles up to other market places especially if the only way to purchases games - codes in boxes aren't the same as going in to any so and buying a disc. Nintendo and it's keycards does frustratingly make some sense now at least.