Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Update: Time to renew our Call for Questions! What do you make of Asha Sharma talking about an "economical" Xbox when the Magnus die is so huge? And what to make of the Helix "family of devices"...? Pose your questions below!

Original Post: Ah, hello there. Having finished the GTA 6 Extended Look Direct (coming very soon), we're now planning a new weekly Direct. We're taping tomorrow once John has returned from Cologne. It'll be just Rich (ie me) and him on this one, but we'll likely revert to a three-person panel for the standalone Q+A show.

We'll be discussing the shock reveal of The Witcher 3 remaster along with the perhaps not shocking but certainly surprising Switch 2 port. Xbox disc to digital? It's official, we've had some chats with Microsoft about it and we have thoughts.

John will be talking about some of the game demos he saw at the show. Fable! State of Decay 3! Ace Combat 8! Alien Isolation 2! Stranger Than Heaven! Silent Hill Townfall... and more!

Aaaaanyway, feel free to pose your questions, suggest further topics and comment on any of the above! Deadline is 8am BST Saturday morning with a Monday deadline for Q+A proper. Many thanks and have a great weekend.

Files

Comments

alchemistOfPrague2023

Hi DF. With all the talk about a Nintendo Switch 2 version of the remaster, how likely is it that Witcher 3 remastered will work well on the Steam Deck too? I know the builds are different, and Switch 2 has DLSS but surely they have more common elements with both being in the portable space. Thanks!

Pie Studios

Hello fellow disc enjoyers! Do you think that Microsoft may regret this disc-to-digital program long term? In the past, people who played a game on GamePass would buy it digitally on the Microsoft store once it was removed from the service (especially for PC players, where some games do not let you transfer the save file from MS store to the Steam version). But now, if a game you want to keep playing gets removed, you can buy a disc used off eBay for dirt cheap compared to digital options. Not to mention you could have a Series S, and instead of buying full price digital games, you can buy a dirt cheap Xbox One and effectively use it as an external disc drive. Do you think they may place restrictions on this feature in the future to combat this sort of usage?

Snorlax cat

if gta 6 is not 60 fps I would rather not play it. For real, even jedi stutter survivor cracked 60. Sorry not sorry. Rockstar you can take my Mario kart world tour by the head. Also, are you expecting MW4 to feature a good 120 fps mode on ps5 pro, or are we shorthanded by the move to still-current gen. Yours sincerely, a cat dubh

Chris Baxter

Hi DF. With the botched PC launch of Marvel Tōkon, major performance issues, and complete lack of Linux support, why is it that unauthorized versions without the aggressive DRM run at full speed even on the humble Steam Deck? Furthermore, Sony has completely clammed up about its stance on Linux and why it's blocked. Are publishers intentionally punishing legitimate buyers while ignoring community feedback?

Someguyperson

Does Oliver regret his big Mac purchase from earlier this year now that a newer, faster, and more expensive model is out?

TheMightyEthan

Hey DF! Last week you answered a question about developers renaming graphics presets to encourage gamers to make smarter choices about what settings to use, and it got me thinking. I have a 5090 and am admittedly guilty of just "whacking everything to ultra" not so much because I think that's a reasonable preset, but because it's often so difficult to determine what different settings do, what will and won't impact performance, etc, that I simply don't want to invest the time in figuring it out. I love y'all's optimized settings videos, but quite understandably you can't do every game that releases, so what general changes would you recommend to game settings menus to make that process better and more approachable for the user? Thanks as always for your thoughts. Cheers

Mullet2000

Hi DF Crew! Do you think there's a world where we will ever get the ability to implement a global framerate cap on Switch 2 or other console platforms? I recently bought Tales of Arise on Switch 2 and while I knew the game had a 30 FPS cap going in, the framepacing on the 30 FPS cap is absolutely abhorrent in handheld mode for the game. If I had bought in on Steam Deck I could likely solve it with a few clicks but as it stands and with Nintendo's strict refund policy, I'm basically screwed out of enjoying the game I purchased. If I could just do the same in the Switch 2 settings I'd have a lot more confidence in future purchases on the Eshop. Elden Ring looks to have a similar issue on Switch 2 where a 30 FPS cap would be most welcome judging by reviews. Thanks and keep up the stellar work!

DrianCel

Glad to see Witcher 3 remastered on switch 2. Do you think it will retain the RT features? Would it be wiser to use the existing versions visual settings and target higher output resolutions?

RAVE_DAM0S

Hola Friday Foundrymen, Coming out of gamescom is there any ability to glean Witcher 3 Remastered performance on Switch 2? Cheers!

DrianCel

I find my self underwhelmed from the GTA6 footage. Overall it hasn't fuelled me with hype to lift my siege on PS digital and pre-order it! (Physical discs!!!!! - William Wallace apparently!). The RDR2 gameplay overview was much better - what do you think??

DrianCel

Nice to see I'm not the only one with Witcher 3 switch on the mind.

Scully

Howdy foundry fellas So is John the retro gaming master sommelier? He’s trained all across the globe studying the craft and has the perfect display to pair with his games. On that note I’d love to hear the teams thoughts on some retro gaming ‘pairings’. For example, to play Super Mario World what display/platform is the perfect pairing to you? CRT on a SNES? For Half Life 2: is that on a PC CRT or a blazing fast QD OLED? If playing Killzone 3, is that rpcs3 connected to a 3d display? Truly the answer is the format that lets you have fun, but I’m curious if the team has any sort of philosophy for how they choose to play.

MrSirPaul

Hello gentlemen, Regarding Black Myth: Zhong Kui—with the release timeline likely being so far out, many are speculating whether this is being developed as a next-generation title. The visuals look incredible, though there are still a few rough edges that could use polish, such as hair rendering and simulation. Do you think this is targeting next-gen hardware, and is this representative of what we can expect visually from the PS6 era? On a related note, after seeing how amazing the GTA 6 footage looks on current hardware, how do you expect a game of that scale to evolve on next-gen systems? What specific technical leaps—like ray tracing, crowd density, or frame rates—do you think next-gen hardware like the PS6 will bring to GTA 6? Keep up the great work!

Someguyperson

I'm still trying to understand how a 13 year old game gets a complete tech overhaul for a remaster before the next game in the series comes out. Do you think CD Projekt Red are doing all these Witcher 3 things as a last hurrah for the REDengine?

NobleHeroine

Hi digital foundry. Hope you had a wonderful GTA reveal week. Not a holiday I celebrate but I'm glad for the joy it brought nonetheless. My question is more of a theoretical one. Do you think Nintendo might give VR another whack with the switch 2 generation? There's no real commercial reason for them to try, but Nintendo does need an outlet for their more inventive side, and the switch 2 has a lot already "VR ready". The wireless gameshare streaming could be repurposed for a wireless VR stream (with higher image quality than the current implementation, of course), or a custom dock could use the DisplayPort capabilities of the systems USB-c port to connect straight to a headset with a wire. The joycons already have most of what's needed to work as VR controllers. Just add a IR tracker with a magnet and they're basically ready to go. Surely, if the original ps4 could deliver a somewhat viable VR experience, then the switch 2 can do the same. Do you agree? And if Nintendo does do this, do you think they'll stick with their Labo theme and make the headset out of cardboard?

Ildar Nurislamov

Hi guys! My question is not about graphics tech, but about how modern games are made. I think you are an important platform to raise such a question, which a lot of people who actually make games listen to. I'm 42 yo and will become a father this December. I have 15–60m per day of free time to play PS5. But I actually don't play at all. Because so few games are actually suitable for 15m sessions of pure enjoyment. Mostly due to so-called "RPG elements" (character progression systems) - skill trees, gear upgrades, crafting. It feels like I have to invest time in all of that - otherwise, I feel like I'm missing something or will actually be underpowered. Playing games like SH2 Remake was a pure joy - because I could quickly submerge into its beautiful atmosphere even for just 20m. RE9 felt this way too. But most games these days are just not for me anymore. What I suggest: I don't suggest that devs must change games for grown-ups. Probably many people have a lot of time and enjoy these progression systems. But if games have difficulty levels where the easiest level changes gameplay dramatically, I ask devs to add a "Progression System" setting with options like Auto (Curated), Optimal, Fully Manual. And with Auto mode, I want my character to just get new skills based on the devs' choices, without requiring me to invest my time and thought into it. I just want to play the game - enjoy its atmosphere and gameplay mechanics - and not waste my time in the depths of UI screens and progression systems. Thank you!

ZeeYoGlade

Good day to you Digital Founders. And a happy 15th year anniversary for the Nintendo 3DS! You know what that means? The day of reckoning is coming for those cartridges as they are entering their estimated end of life. Start plugging them in and turning your ol’ system on like their life depends on it! With that PSA out of the way, with PlayStation discs going away and Asha Sharma’s lack of comment about the Helix having a disc drive: what will Nintendo do with their cartridges? On the one hand, if you look at Famitsu’s weekly charts, you see that Nintendo games dominate the physical market in Japan consistently. And Japan being a country that loves physical products of all forms, it would be ridiculous of an idea for Nintendo to cut off that domestic profitability. Not to mention, Nintendo fans being more likely to pay the premium cost for their games. On the other hand, there are also a lot of issues with modern Nintendo game cartridges: The obvious one being they are expensive to manufacture and sell as we have been seeing with many developers opting for Game Key Cards. And will likely be more expensive as the current climate of memory costs are going to be rising for the foreseeable future. Also makes me curious if third-party developers see GKCs as lost sales from people being deterred. But what concerns me the most is: as far as I know 3DS and Switch 1 cartridges use rewritable flash memory that result in them having shorter lifespan than the NES roms or discs. I can’t say for certain that also applies to Switch 2 cartridges. But I don't want to take the risk of it being possible. As much as I love physical games, I don’t want to have to worry about maintenance of a large collection when the time comes they reach their entropy. Do you see Nintendo eventually moving away from physical games perhaps in their next generation too?

Zombiedude101

Ayup Foundrymen, as an enjoyer of the original I'm eagerly hoping to see something of REV (Code Veronica remake) at Gamescom - what are your thoughts concerning recent physics and body tech in the RE Engine. RE2R seemed so promising with detailed viscera only for RE3 and 4R to downgrade thoss details. Even RE9R felt slightly disappointing. Perhaps this is my inner child yearning for the days of blowing OG resi zombies in half with the shotgun. The original Code Veronica was a particularly scary game at times and impressive for it's time with 3D environments and lighting effects. Maybe it's one for a retro showcase featuring the original DC port?

Fowler is God

Hi team. You guys have suggested that the new PlayStation portable won't be able to play PlayStation 5 games fully. But many of the current PC handhelds can play AAA games, albeit at a lower scale. They might be at low settings and they may even need upscaling, but I thought that was supposed to be one of the selling points. I'm not even talking about the Ryzen AI chips, but the likes of z2 extreme. Alongside a lower resolution 1080p screen with potential upscaling I would have thought they they should be able to meet the majority of games that are out today. I understand they may not be as high a quality and som may be limited to 30fps, but most outside the digital foundry circle of fans would barely notice! I'm sure people would buy and be more than satisfied they can 'play ps5 games on the go'

Nick

Hello there DF crew! Had a thought and wanted to get your opinion on it. With PlayStation ditching physical media altogether, and Xbox seemingly unsure of their own plans for disc support on Helix due to rising costs and shortages of critical drive components and discs themselves, do you think going full circle back to cartridges like Nintendo has would be the consumer friendly solution? While memory costs have made cartridges more expensive to produce than normal, there's no risk to the technology being discontinued any time soon, storage sizes can go higher than a blu-ray disc at additional cost, there are no downsides to the quality of what can be put on a cartridge, load times would be faster reducing the need to install the game to the internal storage, a cartridge slot would not take up as much internal space as a disc drive and reduce points of failure and the size of the console, and it would still give consumers something physical to purchase and own. To offset the perception of the increased cost to consumers, they could do what Nintendo is doing and offer digital versions cheaper, emphasizing that the more expensive physical versions are due to inflation of memory costs rather than an increase in prices of the games themselves. And for cheaper options to publishers they could of course also offer their own version of Game Key Cards, which are preferable to a code in a box since you still own something and can resell it if you choose.

CynthiaSizer

Good evening, I just finished listening to the portion of your GTA6 special about frame rate: Isn’t it very likely that Rockstar will leave it at 30 fps for strategic reasons, too? The game will sell like crazy regardless, no need to put in extra work and compromise on quality. They can save 60 fps as a selling point for the next gen version.

Jacob Godserv

In case you're able to see deleted comments, I removed my previous question about DF content, realizing the basis of the question itself was wrong.

Sam

Hi DF team, would love to hear your opinion on this. Modern Warfare 4's Switch 2 campaign runs at 30 FPS as well as Warzone. It suffers from *lot* of visual downgrade. Xbox Series S runs with better clarity at 70-90 FPS in 120hz mode. Do you think the Switch 2 version could of handled a 40 FPS lock in campaign with the right porting team?

Dan

This is probably a bad idea, but do you think that Rockstar should have used 60fps footage from a PC build in their Netflix reveal, instead of using 30fps footage from the PS5 build? Or would this have gotten people’s hopes up, and then made them disappointed with the launched product in November? The reason I ask is because:- (A) I remember seeing 60fps footage of GTA5 back in 2013 in Argos, even though the PC build had not yet been released (B) There is already fan-upscaled 60fps footage now available on YouTube anyway (C) The PC release is probably not too far away, and so it wouldn’t necessarily be all that dishonest!

Teasing Hilarity (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-06 16:00 Huzzah Foundrymen! With Gamescon now behind us at the point you record the Q&A, I’m wondering about the hidden side of it some more. How does the amount of embargoed content compare to normal this time round? Further, how long do these kinds of embargoes typically last? And to the heart of it — if you can’t share your impressions for some time, what’s the point of showing you and others embargoed content in this context at all? Thanks for your fine work and have a great weekend!
2026-08-29 01:31 Huzzah Foundrymen! With Gamescom now behind us at the point you record the Q&A, I’m wondering about the hidden side of it some more. How does the amount of embargoed content compare to normal this time round? Further, how long do these kinds of embargoes typically last? And to the heart of it — if you can’t share your impressions for some time, what’s the point of showing you and others embargoed content in this context at all? Thanks for your fine work and have a great weekend!

Huzzah Foundrymen! With Gamescom now behind us at the point you record the Q&A, I’m wondering about the hidden side of it some more. How does the amount of embargoed content compare to normal this time round? Further, how long do these kinds of embargoes typically last? And to the heart of it — if you can’t share your impressions for some time, what’s the point of showing you and others embargoed content in this context at all? Thanks for your fine work and have a great weekend!

Fractal Flow

Hey there DFFs! After 11 glorious years, my 1st gen IPS G-Sync monitor (with only a single DisplayPort!) is showing signs of failing. As I look for a worthy game-changing replacement, I wonder if John still uses his G-Sync Pulsar monitor as a permanent part of his setup. Did the incredible motion clarity manage to sway him away from the delectable HDR goodness of a larger OLED? Has anyone else on the team used one extensively? Give us a long term review please! As someone who hasn't experienced CRT-level motion clarity or proper blinding HDR yet (Steam Deck OLED doesn't quite cut it), Pulsar or OLED? Note that I am an 8700K/4070 Ti Super peasant, so 1440p at 80+fps is generally how I play my modern single-player games. Thanks in advance and for keeping us excited for new gaming tech!

Mike Hobson

Howdy! After yesterday's reveal, I feel like we're just now seeing what these consoles have always been capable of. Do you feel like maybe we would have seen this level of fidelity years ago if developers weren't "required" to always support a 60fps mode? Thoughts? On that note, I don't think Rockstar should even try to hit 60fps on this generation due to the sacrifices they'd have to make (maybe 40 is doable, but no more), but save 60 for PS6/Helix or the PC release.

Fractal Flow

It's called The Switcher 😛

Someguyperson

Did you guys see that DLSS 5 DLL that's floating around? It kind of just looks like an HDR & crunchy sharpening filter to me. It's not really the end of the world, or anything great from what I've seen. To me, it brings up questions of, "Why was this marketed as the next big thing?" and "If this setting is as lame as it seems, was the whole controversy a tempest in a teapot?"

Someguyperson

Do you like the best black levels you can find, or do you prefer motion clarity? Do you play more cinematic games, or fast paced games with a lot of action? Do you use a controller or a mouse + keyboard? If you lean towards the first set of options, I would say you should go OLED. If you prefer the second set of options, go with the Pulsar monitor. For me, personally, I would go OLED also because low framerate compensation is still a bit iffy on Pulsar monitors and with your setup, you might have performance below the LFC limit on a Pulsar monitor. Definitely look at that number and get whatever can accommodate the lowest framerate drops.

Salman

Shout out to "Showa American Story" for having one of the wackiest trailers on ONL, wondering if John had a chance to check it out. Sure the combat looks terrible, and some of the animations look like they're 20 years old. However, it's the only trailer where watching it felt like a weird dream.

MattGPT

Hello Gents. Having watched your GTA special it seems very clear that Rockstar have targeted 30fps on current gen from the start and built the graphics and game world with that in mind. Based on that decision is there any benefit to them offering an unlocked framerate in a 120hz container with VRR and in engine LFC? Cheers!

MattGPT

Hello Gents. Having watched your GTA video my personal opinion is that it looks great, with obvious easy improvements for PC when that releases. Higher frame rates will obviously be the one PC players will want most and you both talk about the rather low resolution RT reflections (the burgundy van). What do you think will be the easy win upgrades that Rockstar will have built into the engine for the eventual PC release? Cheers.

MattGPT

I have tested a Pulsar monitor and whilst the motion clarity was great I still prefer a 240hz 4k OLED. I have the MSI MPG 321URX and think it is really great.

Spodlude

Gents have you seen the MW4 beta on switch 2, why do the characters specifically appear to update at like 15 fps?!

1040STF

John, will you play a game whose trailer shows people throwing a CRT off a bridge? How crushed were you? Do you need a hug?

Succulent Chinese Meal

G'day gents. Why don't AMD/Intel/nVidia implement DRS into their upscalers? Instead of having fixed upscaling factors, like 66% for Quailty, why not just tell DLSS/FSR/XeSS that i want 216FPS and let it adjust the upscaling percentage to meet that?

wildwildwesty

Hello chaps. I’d love to hear John’s reaction to the GTA 6 extended look. And after years of feeling that there’s still more to squeeze out of the PS5 and Series consoles, is this finally the ceiling? It’s hard to imagine anything topping it on current hardware. Furthermore, if the Pro version is only going to improve some of the image quality but will not be capable of higher than 30fps due to CPU limitations - as was suggested in the special direct - do you think people will find this acceptable given the high cost of the console?

Magnumstache

If a plateau in graphics prompted developers to focus more on physics, simulation and interactivity as a differentiating factor, what hardware or architecture changes do you think would be required to enable this?

Stephen Brown

Hello DF, It appears that Microsoft, with its disc-to-digital initiative, is paving the way for a disc-less Helix which, given the previously discussed difficulties in sourcing optical disc drives, would help keep costs down. However, do you think it’s likely they could include some kind of card reader that would allow people to continue buying physical games, similar to Nintendo’s game-key cards? It seems like it could offer most of the benefits of digital while retaining many of the benefits of physical — particularly the ability to buy, sell and own a physical copy.

SL0MAR

My default load character didn't have eyebrows!

SL0MAR

How about how those uncanny valley renditions compare to the actual people? I'd love to see a comparison of DLSS5.0 generated Courtney Hope to real world Courtney Hope! Is the AI model smart enough to look at that? Is that why DLSS 5 seems to add 8 years?!

SL0MAR

I finally found a sale on the C5 42". 5 years late to the party, but OLED up close like that is really special in game. Text is a bit off, but not bad. My rig is a 5070 so 165hz is plenty of refresh, too. 850usd? There's a couple MSI monitors that do a nicer job with text, but LG OLED was quite an upgrade. LG companion for wake takes a second to set up, but very doable.

sj33 (Jake)

Hi all, Word that the cost of producing physical Switch 2 cartridges is increasing has me thinking. Hot take but I think it’s perfectly reasonable for Switch 2 games on full cartridges to cost more than key cards or digital. That said, I understand that publishers might be wary of increasing prices to accommodate them. Why not do both? We already have multiple game SKUs - it’s already pretty common to have both standard and deluxe versions of games, but the latter often just comes with unimportant in-game items, or pointless tat. Why not put the deluxe releases on full carts, and the standard edition on key carts? It’s the best of both worlds - people can choose to pay extra for the full cart if they value that, or not if they aren’t bothered.

SL0MAR

Check out the MP beta this weekend for yourself! I played the campaign on a series x, now I'm trying the same level in portable mode on the sw2. You can definitely see/feel the difference, but for some reason, it just seems like I'm playing CoD: WAW in the trenches again. Specular highlights, AA, intense lighting effects... same generic Asian dude jumping down a trench wall and shooting you dead in the face? See how I added a question mark to make it a question ;) San Diego?

SL0MAR

I've had really great responses from Nintendo when I send in my Joycons. Im wondering if Nintendo will make it right by replacing carts when we send them in the same way? Maybe they'll do a code exchange that somehow works even with the eshop offline?

SL0MAR

Ha! Same. I rarely play online. Family life and no pause button makes for some serious priority conflicts.

SL0MAR

I'm still surprised Doom 2016 hasn't been ported to the sw2 with the PS4 version. It seems like No Man's Sky did that in the first month! I'm super excited for the Witcher 3 on the SW2! Maybe they took their time to make it a little better on all systems. That begs the question... what games do you guys want on SW2 that have great potential for an upgrade?

SL0MAR

Has Oliver replaced his MSI 3080 laptop on the windows side? If so, why, with what?

SL0MAR

Dearest Digital Play Anywhere Foundry Founders, how far do you expect this Xbox disc to digital program to go? Will a disc translate to PC if play anywhere is enabled? What about cloud gaming? Do you think ebay/gamestop/uk/Germany resale shop prices will spike for supported titles?

Someguyperson

The current version of DLSS 5 doesn't really get closer or farther away from the model compared to the original art. It just adds sharpening and an HDR effect. It can somewhat bring out detail that wasn't there in the source art, but that's more of a general thing than being able to recognize a real person and make someone look more realistic. It really changes the art more than anything, so I don't know if anyone will really use it.

Someguyperson

Oliver edits on an M3 Mac Studio Ultra. He bought a new one before RAMageddon, but it took something like 3 months to fulfill the order.

SL0MAR

...also... if you're not willing to give up that G-Sync just yet, google how to use a solder gun and the specific capacitors that tend to fail on that monitor. An hour of your time and it'll be brand new. (assuming this is a power on flicker type issue)

Pol Arbequina

Good morning foundrymen! Xbox's Asha Sharma says Project Helix will be a "family of devices". Do you think this is just refering to the "premium device" plus the existing handhelds, or is there more to it? Asha wants to focus on affordability, and this might mean she wants to have a more "mainstream device" to compete with the other consoles (whether it's a good idea or not). It probably wouldn't have made it in time to be aligned with a PS6, since this is a recent pivot, but it looks like the PS6 is also delayed. Does this give them enough time to come up with something else?

Mr_Weis

Hi DF crew! I’m thinking about becoming an indie game developer myself, and it got me wondering: have any of you ever thought about becoming a game developer? Maybe one day we’ll get to see a game developed by DF

NobleHeroine

Decimated animations. On characters farther away from the camera they cut the animation rate in half in order to save CPU time. Indiana Jones did the same thing.

Spodlude

Bold move for an online shooter though!

DyeHardX86

Hello fellas, With Ashas affordable "Family" of Helix devices what are the chances they could simply offer lower power GPUs/CPUs in the RDNA5 line? isn't that the point of the bridge die and move away from the traditional Monolithic Chipset design? Question is, is that enough to offer a more affordable device(s), without also trimming bus width, memory and storage sizes/speeds? Thank you and have a good one.

Peter Vrba

Hi DF, now that Xbox is finally getting some goodwill for the Disc to Digital feature which is ironically possible only thanks to the disastrous decisions made for the Xbox One. Do you think that Don Mattrick might redeem himself one day as well? Anything seems possible at this point :)

Eric Benoit

Hi DF, will i be able to digitize my OG Xbox copies of Dino Crisis 3, Call of Cthulu, and Cold Fear? Sharma's tweet mentioned "supported titles" which i think means we're not going to be able to transfer great games locked in the OGXbox and 360. Having a cohesive library spanning 5 generations, and a disk drive, would be for me personally a game changer when considering XBOX HELIX VS playstation six. Im in a mind to buy neither right now.

Skyrimfest 26 FPS Edition

Even in its early and unrefined form DLSS 5 certainly changes the look of a game - to my eye it's seriously impressive, but I realise many hate it visually or on principle. Putting that aside, are we heading to a moment where the AMD powered consoles and the Nvidia powered PCs seriously diverge in how games will look on them? Mark Cerny may ultimately craft a PSDLSS5, but I bet that won't be quick or easy. Will we head back to the N64 vs PS1 days where you instantly knew which console the game was running on?

DrianCel

MW4 on the switch 2 is rough, but the standard console editions are not far behind. Why do I get the perception that it somehow looks worse than MW2?

goregutz

Yeeeeees DF gentlemen. Given the performance improvements of recent iterations of UE 5, which older UE5 games do you feel would benefit immensely from an engine update? My top pick would be Immortals of Avium. The older iterations of UE5 really didn't doo them any favours and I feel like if they had released their game on the current iterations of UE5, it would have been a much better game.

Sam

I've been playing the BETA on Switch 2 since it launched hence the question. The downgrades are quite intense honestly.

Magnumstache

Really enjoyed the Thief: The Dark Project DF Retro video. It got me wondering why "immersive sims" often garnered critical acclaim but rarely attracted the audience they deserved. Logical, physics-driven worlds (even in fantastical settings) and real player agency sound like things gamers should want. And yet the "wide as an ocean, deep as a puddle" style game tends to prevail. Hypothetically, if graphical advancements slow and developers attempt to differentiate by pursuing greater interactivity with their game worlds, do you think Joe Bloggs will be receptive to that or will they pine for the more linear experiences of yore...?

Eric Benoit

Has anyone on the DF crew besides Audi tried out MGS4? Any thoughts? I know it came out when everyone is busy.

Magnumstache

I think it's safe to say that PlayStation's live service push has failed (maybe it was actually supposed to be a "pull"? That happens to me sometimes, but I normally realise my mistake after the first try...) Their approach completely ignores some of the core tenets of product development, namely that you should test whether or not you have a desirable product before committing large sums of money towards it (the "fail fast" approach). Instead they have, multiple times, spent years developing fairly polished games only to seemingly be COMPLETELY SURPRISED by late-stage user feedback that the game is boring, or crap. It got me wondering why they haven't tried to use Steam Early Access (or to create their own equivalent) to trial ideas quicker, get lots of user feedback and see which games have legs before choosing which projects to throw their weight behind. Am I missing something, or would that not be a more logical approach?

CABBAC

Digi peeps, are you planning to work 24/7 through scary release September to cover all the games coming out, especially with Alex sadly out of action?

DaJaCo (Dan)

Happy-Half Fornight LADS! Is it conceivable that Sony had the foresight to widen the bus on the PS6 APU, to say 256-bit, so that they could disable channels down to 160-bit if they want a PCB with 10x3GB modules, OR enable all the channels for 256-bit, and build a PCB with 15x2GB modules.... It would mean that if they had a good price on one density, but the market dynamics changed or the contracted volumes ran out - they could utilise a board revision to switch to a different bus width and memory chip count. Presumably they could go with 15 x 2GB modules at much slower speeds, and save significantly in the current climate. The only downside would be having to do PCB revisions as needed, and building some redundancy into the APU bus width.. Or have i overlooked something obvious? (P.S. I recommend 20g a day of bovine collagen powder, with hot water and cordial - for Rich's Knees)

Ian

Is there any possibility Nintendo could allow for switch 2 to run in docked mode (clock speeds etc) when it is handheld but plugged in? 80% of my playtime is handheld and most of that I could be plugged in. It’s low enough wattage to not get too hot and isn’t close to as hot as many pc handhelds. So it’s safe, and if plugged in negates battery life concerns. Any reason why not? It would increase the utility of the console.

DaJaCo (Dan)

I think it's just possible that Sharma won't be able to resist the opening that Sony has created for Microsoft, especially as the new matriarch of an embattled Xbox division. Lets say that before the she appeared there was one $1000 "adorably all-digital" SKU.. I wouldnt be surprised if there are now 3 SKUs.. $500 (smaller chiplet) with disc $1000 (original digital) $1200 (original with disc added somehow) The chiplet design surely lends itself to this approach? Also, just going off the "vibes" from her on-camera BBC interview.. what do you lads think?

Alan

Hi guys Apparently, at Gamescom, third-party developers were avoiding Sony due to the ending of physical gaming, thus affecting marketing and third-party support. Surely it’s the same for Xbox with their recent layoffs. Developers can’t be happy in the PC space either, with Nvidia and the pivot to AI causing price rises. Is there any truth to this? The irony is that the most hyped and biggest game ever has seemingly killed physical gaming with the announcement that it is digital-only. Sony was in cahoots with Rockstar, given the timing of both announcing a digital-only approach going forward.

Molsen

Hello, DF! With the DLSS5 leak, we're finally seeing this new technology in the wild. Do you have any new thoughts on it now that we've been able to see it applied to more games? I still think there's something decidedly off about its presentation, especially in regard to human faces, but I have to admit, that it does intrigue me more now than it did at Nvidia's initial reveal. I'm still torn as to whether this really should be called DLSS at all, as it presents itself more like a filter, regardless of whether Nvidia would like us calling it that or not. Cheers!

Teasing Hilarity

Hiho Foundrymen! Regarding Asha Sharma’s comments on a Helix family, is this perhaps an acknowledgment that their original plans won’t result in an affordable device? Perhaps they are pivoting to have the original Magnus part as a halo device, and other less capable but cheaper devices in a similar vein to Series S? Cheers and best wishes for the week!

DrianCel

Shockingly so. To think MW2 ran decently on a PS4. I would say MW3 switch 2 is objectively much worse than the previous gen cod ports

Someguyperson

I fully understand you don't want to talk about the GTA VI leaks, but now there's a massive Steam leak too? What's going on right now? Why is everyone in gaming getting hacked?

regawdless

Hello Gents! With the DLSS 5 leak and the ongoing discussion about the impact on the artistic vision, loss of jobs and how it affects the development process, I'm a bit baffled. The feature can only be used by high-end Nvidia GPU users. Next gen consoles use AMD hardware and even if AMD wanted to copy the tech, realistically, we wouldn't see a mature version of it before the second half of next gen. Nvidia didn't even officially launch it and they'll need more years to iron out the issues, and AMD didn't even figure frame pacing in frame generation out yet. With all the AMD cards in the market, handheld, older GPUs and older consoles, developers still have to do all the non-DLSS 5 work either way. At least until next-next generation, meaning it will remain an optional, customer -adjustable nice to have for many years. Until then, there should be ways to match the rendering quality with "real" solutions across the different vendors. From my understanding, it isn't and won't be feasible for studios to make DLSS 5 only games. What are your views on this? Cheers

Someguyperson

Asha Sharma really doesn't sound like the answer Xbox needs in her recent interview with the BBC. She said that Halo "represents a very key memory structure" like a robot instead of saying "tons of our fans have great memories playing Halo". She also mentioned how "the Xbox business isn't healthy" but didn't actually say how it isn't healthy and any reasons why. She didn't really give a vote of confidence that the business is magically healthy now. She also mentioned how she "just learned" that good games take a long investment process from start to end. How on earth did she get this job? It's like the new CEO of Nabisco saying that they only recently learned that "the price of flour is incredibly linked to the overall cost structure of all the foods we create". This is basic business 101 stuff, not even the complicated issues that got Microsoft to this point in the first place.

Asterdahl

Hey DF crew! MS disc to digital: It’s quite clear how it’s intended to be used in the primary use case. However, I’m curious about the optionality of “claiming” the digital license. As someone who prioritizes preservation but would also not mind being able to claim PC versions via play anywhere by claiming some first party game licenses, I am torn. It’s been reiterated over and over that the “disc remains a disc that can be used physically.” I understand that if I sell it on someone “can” claim the key, and of course in this scenario is likely to do so. But is that “can” a “must?” Once a game is optionally digitized is it immediately claimed when placed into other hardware? And setting that aside, has there been any clarification if offline DRM is applied once a disc is digitally claimed? If MS is doing work to ensure subsequent physical uses are always pushing the key between accounts I wouldn’t put it past them to require a periodic “check if you can still play” needed. I certainly don’t want to optionally claim a digital entitlement if it could ever jeopardize offline play in the future on a machine that knows the license has been digitally claimed. I realize this question went a little long, feel free to paraphrase! I’m curious what John’s thoughts are on these edge cases as a fellow preservationist!

Digital Foundry

We're doing a video on this but suffice to say the key here is having proper artists in control of the technology rather than random bloke off the internet whacking everything to max.

trent howell

A very bespoke greeting to the DF fellas. Dragons Dogma 2 looks like it actually managed a substantive performance improvement with their latest patch. Just hopin to get your thoughts!

Fractal Flow

Thanks for your responses everyone! I don't know if I'd prefer motion clarity over black/HDR pop, as I've never experienced either. And I play all kinds of games, with a variety of input methods depending on the game. I ended up getting..... both! I initially ordered a Pulsar (honestly I've been dreaming of ULMB + G-Sync for years) to replace my main PC monitor. Then I stupidly dropped a statuette on the 28" 4K IPS connected to my XSX, which broke it :( So after a lot of research, I also ordered a 27" 4K QD-OLED (the smaller version of MattGPT's). Now I get to experience both :D And thanks SL0MAR, I'll look at what I can do to fix my old G-Sync monitor. It's not the issue you allude to, on mine the left half of the screen displays red vertical lines on black content, intermittently, mainly when I play Prime Video content??? It's a weird one!

PRATYUSH KUMAR

You are right. It's a deeply generic game and in my opinion the worst MW made bar MW3(2023). I was expecting a phenomenal graphics experience on my PS5 Pro as it is the first CoD to drop prev gen support and IW is known for fidelity. I was massively disappointed. Also, Ground War looked unplayable in 120hz mode due to very disturbing blurriness. Bad time to put out a technical mess like this with GTA 6 coming out? Time will tell.